Page 1 of 1

Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 2:32 am
by The Lesser Evil
So I've found something of an interesting conundrum in the Lawgiver faith that might make for some interesting discussion. Gaz 5 tells us that with the First Judgement, the first people were given twisted forms to match their corrupt ways (p. 125). And yet also this judgement is said to me a "permanent one", meaning that those who overstep their bounds are marked by it (p. 127). This seems like something of a twisted recognition of the corruption caused by failing power checks. And yet the delicious irony is that it's coming from a religion that encourages such acts of evil!

So, I was wondering, how is the doctrine of the Second Judgement is dealt with in practice among the lawgiver clergy and faithful, particularly when deeds that naturally warrant power checks are encouraged with Lawgiver doctrine. Could this be fodder for some of the "permissive" (i.e. LN) Lawgiver theologians to base a more light-handed, rule with a velvet glove more than an iron fist? Would this be an way for those lower in the priesthood to strike out against their hierarchical superiors who have by proof of the Lawgiver's wrath shown they have overstepped their bounds or were never true to the faith to begin with?

What are your ideas about the ways in which this seeming paradox of doctrine and the dissonance Lawgiver faithful might have to deal with?

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 3:06 am
by Jimsolo
Because the Lawgiver is Bane of the Forgotten Realms, I don't see much "velvet glove" coming from his faithful or their people. He is, first and foremost, the god of tyranny. Dictatorships can be benevolent (in fantasy settings) but tyrannical dictatorships cannot.

The First Judgement is intended to represent a creation myth which we (as omniscient DMs) know to be false. It accomplishes several goals at once. The first message it gives is that the Lawgiver is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, and that he will punish those who violate his will immediately and without mercy. The second message it gives is the supremacy of Bane. If you believe this story, then by definition the dwarven belief in Moradin must be false, as must the religions of all these demi-humans who "delude themselves" into thinking they are anything more than the cursed offspring of the original heretics. Which brings us to the final point: it greenlights racism in Nova Vaasa (and anywhere that Bane is worshipped). If you believe Bane's version of this story, then as a human you must be descended from those who were the most pure, and must then be inherently "better" than those loathsome members of those other races.

Could a deformity caused by a failed Powers Check provide a Banite priest's enemies with an excuse to accuse him of having lost the Lawgiver's favor? Absolutely. By the same token, he could always twist that around and claim that Bane "gifted" him with the transformation. As a Lawful Evil religion, Bane worshippers have access to a great tool to overcome religious paradoxes: hypocrisy. I don't think any of them are going to get too hung up on doctrine if it gets in the way of their personal goals. (That ambition is mandated by the Lawgiver, after all...)

Hope that helps. If you want some more info on the Lawgiver, I would check out some of the extended information on Bane and Bane worshippers. There is some good stuff in the Forgotten Realms books, and a little more in some of the D&D supplements for that setting.

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 3:35 am
by The Lesser Evil
Yeah, you're right on the dot with the hypocrisy thing (a thematic element I enjoy exploring in games, which is why I asked for ideas). I'm not really bothered or hung up on it too much, just so much looking for ideas to explore it and the related hypocrisies and such in game (the counterarguement of the blessings of Bane is a good idea- thanks!). Makes for some power dynamics clever players can use against the Banites.

Ravenloft's Lawgiver of course is based on Bane, although in Ravenloft I think they did a much better job in making it more believable in masking the tyranny as necessary for order and stability within society rather than the openly unjustified malice that the FR Bane goes about extolling.

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 7:40 am
by Jimsolo
Prior to 3rd edition, he actually WAS Bane, wasn't he? (The second ed entry for Nova Vaasa says so, at any rate.) I always assumed the whole "Lawgiver" change was one of those copyright issues. For my game, I just have people call him Bane. (I'M not bound by those issues! :D ) I think you're right though, he's a little more subtle in Ravenloft. I think that's partially because that's more in line with the tone of Ravenloft, and partially because Forgotten Realms is supposed to be a little more over the top. I would hope that any good DM running a Forgotten Realms campaign would utilize some of the 'necessary for stability' shtick though.

It seems like religious corruption is one of the pillars of the Ravenloft setting. Most organized religions are corrupt as a whole, inherently corrupted by a flawed premise in their understanding/belief, headed by corrupt people, or subject to a significant amount of corruption in their clergy/worshippers. If you then start exploring a religion which is evil and corrupt even WITHOUT the influence of the Demiplane of Dread, you can wind up with some truly malignant theology!

Do you have a significant amount of activity going on with the Banites in your game?

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 7:14 pm
by Garudos Celestar
Jimsolo wrote:Prior to 3rd edition, he actually WAS Bane, wasn't he? (The second ed entry for Nova Vaasa says so, at any rate.) I always assumed the whole "Lawgiver" change was one of those copyright issues. For my game, I just have people call him Bane.
Yes, Bane is the Lawgiver (and I also treat "the Lawgiver" as a title of respect, as opposed to the deity's name), but even in 2nd Edition, the Church of Bane in Ravenloft was specifically described as a lawful neutral branch of Bane's worship. To quote VRMHC Volume III, pg 245: "The Church of Bane is generally of Lawful Neutral alignment, although strong streaks of Lawful Evil run through its teachings as well."

Because of the disconnect between the Demiplane of Dread and the rest of the cosmos (not to mention the traditional inability of the Realmsian deities to directly influence events within the Demiplane, so the Core's worshippers only have access to the scrptures that formed with the domains of Nova Vaasa and Hazlan), it has developed independently of the Church on Abeir-Toril.

The system inherent in the domain borders has also influenced its development: because conquest is almost-but-not-technically impossible in the Demiplane, the Church of Bane never developed the same aggressive ideal that the Realmsian faith pursues (so they neither try it nor endorse it). This helps shift the focus from the "Evil" aspect of Bane's alignment (attack and maim anyone who gets in the way of the ultimate tyrant's expansion) toward the "Lawful" aspect (maintain an ordered, smoothly running society). Bane the Lawgiver may reward ambition and expect harsh punishments for (many, many) transgressions, but he does not reward those who brutalize others to expand their dominions or find triumph in schadefreude (at least not in the teachings that have been revealed to the Demiplane's worshippers... and it's not as though they can summon an avatar to get new instructions).

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 8:31 pm
by Jimsolo
Hrmm...your interpretation seems to fit most of the facts, but I find one incongruity, which I have been unable to explain. I think he might be more open to forcible conquest than you think, since the War domain is still open to his clerics.

I think that part of the misconception people have about Bane is that he's all aggression all the time, when the reverse is largely true. His clergy is described as subtle in the 3rd ed campaign setting, and I think that the majority of their movements support that. It's only when they have all their ducks in a row and feel victory is assured that they make their attack, and a disproportionate number of encounters we see in games and fiction with Banites focus around these events. (Which only makes sense, since they are the exciting events, which is what people want to read about/see in play.) I think that the implication (especially in the 3rd ed Forgotten Realms campaign setting) is that for every blatant take-over-the-world scheme, there is hundreds of hours of subtle, underplayed work that takes place behind the scenes.

We could all benefit from running a Banite church that follows the perceived model of the Ravenloft faith (I didn't know that they used to be LN. That must be one of the changes that occurred in the edition transition. Damn that meddling Vecna...) from time to time. A reminder to players, both Forgotten Realms and Ravenloft-based, that Bane can be a quiet viper as well as a raging bull can add some definite distinction to the church.

Good discussion, Lesser Evil.

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 1:35 pm
by The Lesser Evil
Jimsolo wrote:
Do you have a significant amount of activity going on with the Banites in your game?
Yah, I do. I'm prepping up for a holy war between Banite and Ezra-worshipping countries (one of my players who is playing a paladin of Ezra has really gotten a hatred of Bane after one of his priests called Ezra "the Harlot"). The Black Duke is stoking the fires of war for his own purposes of funneling souls back to Hell and continuing the Blood War after a lengthy period of building false identities, etc. One of his servants is a tiefling cleric of Asmodeus pretending to be a Banite, so the concept of the First Judgement has some direct importance to me here.

The concept of the First Judgement also interests me with the possibility of the Duremkite Heresy (a LG heretical Banite sect of the from one of the Book of Ss), since it's one of the arguments they could make to back up their rather shaky take on the Lawgiver. I'm really looking forward to seeing my players thrown for a loop when they see an evil religion "corrupted" to good with this oddball bunch.

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 2:53 pm
by Jimsolo
Cool. Sounds like you've got an interesting take on the Ravenloft cosmology. It always interests me how people view Ravenloft within a planar cosmology, especially in relation to the afterlife. (The source material is pretty silent on the topic, so no two DMs see it the same way.)

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 3:41 pm
by The Lesser Evil
Jimsolo wrote:Cool. Sounds like you've got an interesting take on the Ravenloft cosmology. It always interests me how people view Ravenloft within a planar cosmology, especially in relation to the afterlife. (The source material is pretty silent on the topic, so no two DMs see it the same way.)
Thanks! I think for the most part the cosmology should be vague with a few dread hints of a possible great beyond.

Though to be fair, most of my ideas aren't my own but merely connecting the dots. The Black Duke's ultimate long term goals are based on what he's described in CotN: Demons, and the thing about the First Judgement just seems natural given the nature of ravenloft and putting it together with some of the settings fixtures (we know that the Darkonian Cult of the Overseer is a complete fabrication, but there's a dread possibility that enough belief might actually give the cult enough power to sponsor a cleric who can cast spells, for example). So to me that speaks that the Dark Powers are users of the Clap Your Hands if You Believe trope (using tvtropes terminology), usually for ill but on occasion for good.

Re: Lawgiver First Judgement and Power Checks Corruption

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:39 pm
by Jimsolo
Sorry, not familiar with your tv tropes reference. (I sincerely hate that website. I find it incrediby poorly put together.) Contextually, I am led to understand that you are saying that belief reshapes reality, (a theory which is absolutely true in Greyhawk and Faerun) even in Ravenloft? An interesting notion, if true. I think that the setting bears that out, kind of. It seems to me like the Dark Powers allow divine events (granting of spells and so forth) in order to foster the illusion that belief has power in their realm.

Are there gods in your version of Ravenloft? Personally, I go the route that there are no deities in the Demiplane of Dread, (with the possible exception of Ezra) and that any divine power is granted by the Dark Powers. Outlander divine casters are aware that something is wrong. At home, in Faerun, they can feel a very real connection to their deity when praying for spells, and after coming to Ravenloft, praying for spells becomes far more impersonal. They still get their abilities, but it's like sending in a requisition form at the office: your boss doesn't care and probably didn't even read it. That's how it feels to them, anyway.

If there is no hell attached to Ravenloft (And in mine, there is not. The Demiplane of Dread is cut off from the rest of the cosmos.) then it is interesting that the Black Duke is unaware of this. The only demon my PCs have encountered was very aware of the true nature of Ravenloft, but he was far from a run-of-the-mill demon of his type. I generally try to avoid using fiends of any stripe, because I think they provide too stark a contrast. (I like moral ambiguity. I'm not satisfied with a plot unless at least ONE party member isn't sure they're doing the right thing.) Do you like more of the black-and-white in your moral conflicts?