Page 1 of 3

Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 9:50 am
by kottakinge
Well, hello there.
I'm planning to run this excellent module to my player.
They'are 4 (like the fantastic 4) :
-A level 9 bard/storyteller
-A level 8 rogue
-A level 7 cleric of the Morning Lord
-A level 7 barbarian from Verbrek

I had the gazeeter 5 about Tepest, Keening and the shadow Rift so no problem for converting from 2nd edition to 3.5 (and eventually to PF)

I do not read the whole story for the moment but i'm wondering if i could run this adventure "as it" for my group.
I explain myself:
-Goblins a threat?REALLY?
-The plot seems lame (prove the innocence of a young girl), even if things get a bit more complicated than it seems in the future.
-The local powers (including the inquisition) couldn't do anything against them.

Well i'm wondering if Tepest is not too much a backwater for this high level characters?
If not what would you suggest me to adjust?

Thanks

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 1:19 pm
by The Lesser Evil
Well, first of all, even in 2e 7th-9th level is way high for the module (which is listed as 4-6 characters of 4-6th level). You'll have to do a fair bit of conversion work to scale it up. OTOH, your characters may get a charge out of being able to singlehandely crush Wyan and his little inquisition, but decide to take a more finessed approach. Remember power checks hit you regardless of your character level.

Now, thankfully a good bit of it is investigation and roleplaying opportunities (and dealing with a number of figures like the three hags and Tristessa that might be beyond even an average party level of 8 to tackle). There's a good skeletal structure there to work from, especially if you plan on going into the Shadow Rift.

If you wanted to elaborate the plot, you could set the adventure sequentially later, when the Inquisition has become more powerful (and thus several of its members more advanced in class levels) and has begun to get out of Wyan's hands (write up some stats for some sinister or fanatical inquisitors that have been doing some shadier things beyond Wyan's back). The issue with the falsely accused girl is merely the match that lit the powder keg. And the three hags may also be exacerbating the conflict. Which also makes enlisting their aid all the more complicated as well.

If you wanted to challenge your heroes a signifcant degree more, you might go with an alternate setting, like Nidala, which has a (more evil) inqusition backed up by a powerful blackguard (Nidala Faithhold). This would take a fair bit more work (since the powers that be in Nidala are outright evil instead of just paranoid bumpkins), but the setting is roughly similar (same god, atmosphere of paranoia, etc). As a compromise, perhaps a cadre of Faithhold's servants got displaced from Nidala to Tepest (IIRC there's a mistway in the lake/riverway) who are trying to reform the "backwards" inquisition into something more of a power player in Tepest (by exploiting the situation to get Wyan/the people to grant the inquisition more power) at least until they find away back home. The presence of Nidalan fanatics could explain higher level foes in the inquisition without taking away the backwater low-level feel of Tepest's natives.

Other random ideas... Goblins, well you could give them a few class levels (goblin fighters/rangers/cavaliers/barbarians riding worgs). Or make them goblyns (perhaps coming in from a mistway to Forlorn or some such). In any case, there is a 5 HD goblin vampire in the module the characters have to deal with (the book says goblin vampires can go up to 10 HD) The accused girl may have some secret special significance to her, which has another third party after her. Perhaps she is the girl that escapes the dungeons of Castle Forlorn, and this explains the presence of goblyns traipsing about the area (if you decide to go with goblyns instead of goblins). And of course if you've got a barbarian PC from Verbrek, maybe some hostile werewolves are chasing after him just to complicate things?

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 1:30 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Goblins can easily be a threat; they advance by character class. Don't ever underestimate the little guy. And Tepestani goblins have ties to the hags, not just the Minderfisk Sisters (the Three Hags). It's one thing to face a few goblin warriors and an adept to fighting a hag or two (or three, if they're in a coven). As for being a threat to the locals, most are commoners lvl 1-2 at best and in relatively small numbers compared to hundreds of gobs. Strength in numbers.

I can't comment on the plot since I agree, it is a little unimaginative. But the Tepestani Inquisition is an analogue of the various Inquisitions in real life Europe. Many used their power for political or personal gain as much as rooting out "enemies of Mother Church." Even then they were acting out of ignorance--sometimes willful ignorance--about what they were supposed to be hunting. "You're a Protestant? BURN! You're eccentric? BURN! You're a Jew?! BURNBURNBURN!" (Yes, the Inquisitions were very anti-Semitic.) The Tepestani Inquisitors are working from a fictional analogue of the Malleus Malleficarum, which itself was based more on conjecture and hearsay than anything even remotely factual. They're willfully ignorant, refusing to believe anything not already accepted as fact when most of it is just superstition and legend with no real fact behind it. Is it any wonder they're not getting anything useful done?

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 1:43 pm
by The Lesser Evil
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Goblins can easily be a threat; they advance by character class. Don't ever underestimate the little guy. And Tepestani goblins have ties to the hags, not just the Minderfisk Sisters (the Three Hags). It's one thing to face a few goblin warriors and an adept to fighting a hag or two (or three, if they're in a coven). As for being a threat to the locals, most are commoners lvl 1-2 at best and in relatively small numbers compared to hundreds of gobs. Strength in numbers.

I can't comment on the plot since I agree, it is a little unimaginative. But the Tepestani Inquisition is an analogue of the various Inquisitions in real life Europe. Many used their power for political or personal gain as much as rooting out "enemies of Mother Church." Even then they were acting out of ignorance--sometimes willful ignorance--about what they were supposed to be hunting. "You're a Protestant? BURN! You're eccentric? BURN! You're a Jew?! BURNBURNBURN!" (Yes, the Inquisitions were very anti-Semitic.) The Tepestani Inquisitors are working from a fictional analogue of the Malleus Malleficarum, which itself was based more on conjecture and hearsay than anything even remotely factual. They're willfully ignorant, refusing to believe anything not already accepted as fact when most of it is just superstition and legend with no real fact behind it. Is it any wonder they're not getting anything useful done?
Good idea about the hag idea... Perhaps a single or covey of rogue hags spawned by the Sisters is leading the goblins in the area.

And your ideas about the inquisition are spot on. A scenario like this also allows you to explore some of the twisted theology of the time. The use of burning at the stake was seen to be salvific (meaning that you were doing it to save the person's soul...) at the time, for example. Torture wasn't used so much for information but to get a person to confess to deeds the inquisitions already "knew" the person committed, for in doing so it was thought to be a purgative acknowledgement of wrongs (not to mention quelling further heresy with a person who redacts himself through self-criticism.)

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 3:01 pm
by Jimsolo
Don't go too overboard with your portrayal of the Inquisition, though. Gamers as a whole tend toward the anti-establishment side of the spectrum, and I can't count the number of otherwise good DMs who's games fall a little short because every authority figure, be they law enforcement, govermental, or religious, is corrupt. The Tepestani inquisition may have their bad side, the guys who are a little TOO eager to use the thumbscrews and the brands, but they have a good side too, with guys who really believe that they are doing the right thing.

And I always like to keep one thing in mind which, I think, changes the situation dramatically. The REAL inquisition only imagined/lied about the existence of secretive witches allied with dark forces for the covert corruption, torment, and/or destruction of the surrounding populace. The Tepestani says the same thing, but the difference is that they really ARE up against the dark forces. (Even if they have shot themselves in the foot with misinformation and ignorance.)

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 3:31 pm
by The Lesser Evil
Jimsolo wrote:Don't go too overboard with your portrayal of the Inquisition, though. Gamers as a whole tend toward the anti-establishment side of the spectrum, and I can't count the number of otherwise good DMs who's games fall a little short because every authority figure, be they law enforcement, govermental, or religious, is corrupt. The Tepestani inquisition may have their bad side, the guys who are a little TOO eager to use the thumbscrews and the brands, but they have a good side too, with guys who really believe that they are doing the right thing.

And I always like to keep one thing in mind which, I think, changes the situation dramatically. The REAL inquisition only imagined/lied about the existence of secretive witches allied with dark forces for the covert corruption, torment, and/or destruction of the surrounding populace. The Tepestani says the same thing, but the difference is that they really ARE up against the dark forces. (Even if they have shot themselves in the foot with misinformation and ignorance.)
Another good point. Unlike the Nidalans, most aren't malicious by nature, but just really paranoid and xenophobic about the pervasive fey presence in Tepest. Wyan, for his credit, is a good man and has managed to keep them from taking over politics too much thus far.

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:12 pm
by Ryan Naylor
Also, what's lame about stopping someone innocent from being horribly burnt to death?

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Sat Jan 19, 2013 2:41 pm
by vipera aspis
If you run wyan like Jim Gordon, it's way, way more fun. Keep most of.the others corrupt but make wyan the good guy. Makes for a great pc contact and you can always do a "internal affairs" side plot later or during. Goblins can be done well and horrifying. Quickly read Tapestry of Dark Souls. They are far more sinister then normally given credit for.

And if you're looking to really up the ante and swing the darkness at your players i have two words for you: Introduce Blackroot

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 5:26 am
by kottakinge
Once again plenty of good informations, thanks a lot fellow DM :D

My opinion on the ideas discused :
-I don't want to run Wyan's inquisition as a fanatic evil doers: as mentionned they believed to act for the good of the community, and Wyan is award that they lack knowledge about the hunt of the fey, that'is the reason why he decided to invent written language on the tepestani.
-You right about goblins, but even with levels they will be butchered to death, but goblins with adepts and hags it's another matter :twisted:
-In fact, my main concern about the adventure is to 'force' the players for follow the quest to prove that the accused girl is innocent, but i won't be able to use the inquisition as a threat nor i will be able to let them use their high level spell to find the truth (detect lies or the such). In the adventure the girl's lover help them during a gob attack and ask for their help rescuing her lover, i need to find better thant that to force them do to that :D
-I agree that in the middle and at the end of the adventure there are some hard encounters (trekking to keening IIRC), but the lady of the lake will be severly spanked.
-Blackroot? ahhh yes i remenber this undead ent, but where is he mentionned in 3.5 ed? he isn't in the Gaz about tepest.

Thanks

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 7:29 pm
by yaoihuntressearth
I think Blackroot was killed off in 3.5.

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 7:48 pm
by Manofevil
yaoihuntressearth wrote:I think Blackroot was killed off in 3.5.
This is Ravenloft. That doesn't mean much.

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 8:10 pm
by Ryan Naylor
yaoihuntressearth wrote:I think Blackroot was killed off in 3.5.
Really? I don't think so.

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:45 pm
by vipera aspis
Anyone have a 3.0 or 3.5 mention of Blackroot? I want to say it was at least hinted at in gazV. He was deadly and really sinister in 2nd ed. I think it had other undead ents serving it. Forlorn to Tepest?

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Tue Jan 22, 2013 3:43 am
by Ryan Naylor
No, Blackroot is definitely still around. There's a picture of him on p. 47 of Gaz V. And he's alluded to in the text on the same page.

Re: Servants of Darkness - feedback neeeded

Posted: Tue Jan 22, 2013 5:48 am
by kottakinge
Found it on http://community.wizards.com/go/thread/ ... cters?pg=3

Blackroot: Male Advanced Treant; CR 11; Huge Plant; HD 12d8+72; hp 126; Init –1; Spd 30 ft.; AC 20 (touch 7, flat-footed 20); Base Atk +9; Grp +27; Atk +17 melee (2d6+10, slam); Full Atk +17 melee (2d6+10, 2 slams); Face/Reach 15 ft./15 ft.; SA Animate trees, double damage aginst objects, spell-like abilities, trample 2d6+15; SQ DR 10/slashing, low-light vision, plant traits, vulnerability to fire; AL CE; SV Fort +14, Ref +3, Will +8; Str 30, Dex 8, Con 22, Int 11, Wis 14, Cha 12
Skills and Feats: Hide –9, Intimidate +6, Knowledge (nature) +7, Listen +7, Sense Motive +7, Speak Language (tepestani), Spot +7, Survival +7 (+9 aboveground); Awesome Blow, Improved Bull Rush, Improved Sunder, Iron Will, Power Attack
Special Qualities: Trample (Ref DC 26 half), +16 racial bonus on Hide checks made in forested areas.
Spell-like abilities (as 12th level caster): 1/day – animal growth, antilife shell, antiplant shell, charm animal, command plants, create water, detect animals or plants, entangle, hold animal, plant growth, repel vermin, snare, speak with animals, speak with plants, spike growth, summon nature’s ally I, summon nature’s ally II, summon nature’s ally III, summon swarm, tongues, wall of thorns, warp wood.
Possessions: None.
Description: Blackroot stands just over 18 feet tall and looks like an ancient oak. His bark is grooved and rough, providing excellent protection from physical attacks. His branches are long and gnarled, never sprouting leaves or showing even the faintest hints of bud or blossom. When he wishes to be seen for what he is, a gnarled face appears to form from the fissures and grooves of his bark. A great and terrible maw, shaped like an inverted “V,” opens up beneath two knotty eyes.
Sources: Ravenloft Monstrous Compendium II (2E), PHB 3.5, DMG 3.5, MM 3.5, and Ravenloft Campaign Setting (3E).