Page 1 of 1

Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sat Jan 26, 2013 10:52 pm
by Jimsolo
So, for those who are not familiar with it, there is a prestige class called the Frenzied Berserker (Masters of the Wild) which is a barbarian derivative class. The primary ability of the prestige class is the Frenzy ability. Here's a quick rundown of the salient points:

1. Frenzy is similar to a barbarian rage in most respects. (No spells, you can still use class features and feats except ones requiring concentration, etc.)
2. While you can enter it willingly, you must also make a Will save whenever you receive damage or enter a Frenzy automatically.
3. When in a Frenzy, you must attack your enemies as best you are able. If you defeat all of your enemies, you must attack the nearest living being, regardless of health or relationship. (I do ammend this to 'nearest being,' in recognition of the undead and constructs.)
4. You may make a Will save to end the Frenzy early.

So, here's the question. If a Frenzied Berserker harms or kills a bystander or party member while in Frenzy, do they need to take a Dark Powers check? I can see several arguments in either direction. Personally, I lean towards a judgement of 'you're just as responsible as if you weren't Frenzying,' but what do you guys think?

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sat Jan 26, 2013 11:40 pm
by Ryan Naylor
If entered willingly, yes. If not, no. Also yes if they didn't try to escape the frenzy.

Think of it as like an Enchantment spell - if they tried to resist, they're not morally culpable. If they didn't, they can be held responsible for what they did.

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 12:16 am
by Jimsolo
I considered that as one possibility, but here's my question: if the berserker isn't responsible, then who is? Is the person who injured them (in the case of involuntary frenzy) the one responsible? (Assuming they knew what would happen.) My thought on it was that the character in question knew they would be endangering friends and bystanders when they began the prestige class. If they go bananas and butcher, say, a bunch of schoolchildren, I don't think they should just be able to shrug and say 'sorry.' By the same token, I don't think they should totally be held accountable either. Maybe a reduced chance of failure when the frenzy was involuntary.

Sorry, I'm not wanting to be argumentative, I just don't want to become a Powers-crazy DM. (One of my players is pretty far gone down that route, so I've begun to question myself...)

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 12:43 am
by Zilfer
I lean towards the side yes.... it's not fair but life isn't fair. If you can't control your anger you shouldn't be in situations that make you do that. I wouldn't mind actually RPing a barbarian that way now that I think of it..... o.o!!!!

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 12:45 am
by Zilfer
Jimsolo wrote:I considered that as one possibility, but here's my question: if the berserker isn't responsible, then who is? Is the person who injured them (in the case of involuntary frenzy) the one responsible? (Assuming they knew what would happen.) My thought on it was that the character in question knew they would be endangering friends and bystanders when they began the prestige class. If they go bananas and butcher, say, a bunch of schoolchildren, I don't think they should just be able to shrug and say 'sorry.' By the same token, I don't think they should totally be held accountable either. Maybe a reduced chance of failure when the frenzy was involuntary.

Sorry, I'm not wanting to be argumentative, I just don't want to become a Powers-crazy DM. (One of my players is pretty far gone down that route, so I've begun to question myself...)

Also you might want to remind them if they go much further they loose their character. Make sure they know that and maybe that's what they'd wanted the whole time?

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 3:56 am
by Jimsolo
They're aware that they lose their character if they fail another check. (The player in question was trying to work her way back from her third failed check when she failed the fourth one.) She's got a gigantic Will save, so I'm not too worried about her killing anyone in Frenzy, but I just wanted to be prepared.

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 12:38 pm
by Zilfer
Yeah I've had one person loose their character to dark powers checks and after loosing one character they seem to have calmed down quite a bit.

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Sun Jan 27, 2013 8:24 pm
by Ryan Naylor
Jimsolo wrote:I considered that as one possibility, but here's my question: if the berserker isn't responsible, then who is? Is the person who injured them (in the case of involuntary frenzy) the one responsible? (Assuming they knew what would happen.) My thought on it was that the character in question knew they would be endangering friends and bystanders when they began the prestige class. If they go bananas and butcher, say, a bunch of schoolchildren, I don't think they should just be able to shrug and say 'sorry.' By the same token, I don't think they should totally be held accountable either. Maybe a reduced chance of failure when the frenzy was involuntary.

Sorry, I'm not wanting to be argumentative, I just don't want to become a Powers-crazy DM. (One of my players is pretty far gone down that route, so I've begun to question myself...)
Sometimes, no one is responsible.

If you deliberately provoke a frenzied berserker locked in a room full of children, then you are responsible. If the berserker just goes nuts in combat, no one is.

Also, you need to separate the choices the player makes from the choices the character makes. The character doesn't choose to become a frenzied berserker (well, some might, but some might not); the player does. If they play it as borderline mental illness or a curse or possession or something, then the character is not responsible.

Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Mon Jan 28, 2013 4:57 pm
by kottakinge
One more failed Power check and he'll have to sing that song each time he enters frenzy:


Re: Frenzied Berserker question

Posted: Tue Jan 29, 2013 6:56 pm
by Jimsolo
You've got me convinced on not giving out checks for involuntary frenzies, Ryan. (Although the PC is still on the hook for any voluntary ones...)

And I would never hold the player responsible for actions of the PC. However, I would normally not allow a player to claim that their character had entered a prestige class involuntarily, and never in a Ravenloft game. (And it isn't the case here, the character in question did it willingly.) If a player tried to come at me with that story in this particular scenario, I would be unable to shake the feeling that they were just trying to get all the benefits of the class without having to take the Ravenloft specific negatives. Like I said, though, doesn't specifically apply here.