Page 1 of 2
NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 12:49 pm
by vipera aspis
Okay so I've witnessed several domain revisions. What about useful NPC revisions? Less known ones that could really enrich a game. There are quite a few that could use a little work or even an update.
-Deiter Furschten(Adam's Wrath)
-Brothers Ruden, Jarvik and Pelov(The Heart's Final Beat)
-Chezna(The Awakening)
-The Krutzers(Mordenheim)
-Ratik Ubel(Realm of Terror)
-The Spider(Van Richten's Guide to Vampires)
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 1:06 pm
by Jimsolo
Do you mean revisions that we, the DMs, do? Or do you mean official (or semi-official) updates for the NPCs?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 1:37 pm
by vipera aspis
Any I of those would be great. We used to do a Domain of the Month(which was awesome) but all good things must come to an end and we ran out of domains!
I suppose just fleshing out the NPC's and filling in a few gaps would work to start.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 2:27 pm
by Zilfer
I for one am curious if anyone ever came up with who that "Yellow scarfed" person was that actually killed Ratik, and why? Was it for a bounty? Did he have a love live and it was some disgruntled lover? Was he in the wrong place at the wrong time?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 3:50 pm
by vipera aspis
We should establish if Radik is insane or not. That would give us more to go off of.
I like the idea of him being originally from an asylum. Make him in into a horrible and sadistic serial killer: who's memories are fragmented even more-so do to the awakening and violent shift into undeath.
He cannot remember: except in dreams and even then only flickering images quickly forgotten.
He's cursed to witness his murders, through the eyes of his victims; whenever he dreams.
The scarf was his own.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 8:25 pm
by Jimsolo
I have radically redesigned some of the NPCs in Ravenloft for my game.
I don't even use Godefroy as the Darklord of Mordent. Instead, I have Heather House as a whole serving as the Darklord. (Godefroy is just one of the victims of it.) If every domain can be summed up in a single word that encapsulates the themes of the domain and the kinds of stories that work best there, then for Mordent that word would be home. I choose to base my Mordent stories around the ideas of home-in-danger (being threatened, either by outside ideas or outside dangers) or of home-corrupted (corrupt law enforcement, abusive families, warped upbringings, that sort of thing). For my money, a haunted house that consumes those who dwell within it (à la Stephen King's Rose Red) fits the bill much better than Godefroy does.
My game is set five years after the publication of 3rd ed, so I had to advance the timeline somewhat. The PCs just finished a plot involving the clergy at Ste Mere de Larmes in Dementlieu. Since you can only be on your deathbed so long, in my campaign Bastion Secousse died two years previous. (This caused a minor rift in the church, with about half of the church feeling that her stated wishes should be followed, naming Pineau as the new bastion. A significant minority, however, felt that Leonie Caille was obviously Secousse's preference for the job, and left the church when they failed to gain support for her ascension.)
That the sort of thing you were talking about?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Mon Feb 04, 2013 10:50 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
vipera aspis wrote:He cannot remember: except in dreams and even then only flickering images quickly forgotten.
He's cursed to witness his murders, through the eyes of his victims; whenever he dreams.
The scarf was his own.
I've played around with the idea that Ratik will never find his killer by searching the demiplane, but only by coercing a Zarovan into taking him back in time to the night of his own murder. He'll get desperate enough to do that someday, and bring along a piece of yellow cloth to mockingly wave in his killer's face as he strikes him/her/it down, intent on ambushing the culprit immediately after his younger self is killed.
Unfortunately for Ratik, he'll realize once he gets close enough that his Craving is inexorably compelling
him to murder his younger self. Because the obsessive pursuit of revenge is self-destructive by its very nature, and he who threatens the Zarovan risks getting caught in a Stable Time Loop...

Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Tue Feb 05, 2013 10:26 am
by Zilfer
Wouldn't that mean at the point of death of Ratik that there would be two of him in the world?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Tue Feb 05, 2013 11:20 am
by vipera aspis
Thus the need for the reworking Zilfer. But as he's sort of one dimensional and difficult
And Mr. Jim Solo- that's fantastic. I always felt it was the house too. It even hints at it in GazIII. At least that's the way I took it. So then we could say, the HOUSE was ripped in and merely dragged the spirits with it? That the spirits are pulled towards the house and not Godfrey? What horror is the foundation of the house built upon?
I'm thinking we can make some of these darker. Their motives more villainous. Their actions more sadistic.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Tue Feb 05, 2013 5:16 pm
by Ryan Naylor
I think making Gryphon Manor the darklord rather than Godefroy needs to be handled thoughtfully to avoid too much overlap with the House of Lament.
Gryphon Manor is (canonically) a "bad house" like the Overlook Hotel in the Shining. There's an evil atmosphere and terrible things are drawn there, but it's not actually sentient.
The House of Lament is a sentient bad house like Hill House.
If you don't mind the overlap though, then go for it.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Tue Feb 05, 2013 7:07 pm
by Jimsolo
I, personally, don't mind the overlap too much. And I'm really enthused to see you here in this thread. If you had your druthers with some of the Ravenloft NPCs, what kind of changes would you like to make, Ryan? Do you run games in Ravenloft? If so, have you made any big breaks from canon?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Wed Feb 06, 2013 6:23 pm
by Ryan Naylor
I do still play Ravenloft. I tend to play short campaigns, so some are very different to the published world (as in, the map looks more like Europe, or there are no borders or whatever) while most are very similar.
I do multiply distances and populations by 10 though.
If I were to do things differently, I would have worked on Tepest a little more to make it clear that the domain is really all about the Hags and their personal foibles, rather than the Inquisition/shadow fey conflict. While I think Servants of Darkness was a really excellent adventure, it (and the Shadow Rift) really sent things off on a tangent. It's not insoluble, but the way Tepest has been portrayed since then seems to me to sideline the Hags a bit. I'd have to re-read the gazetteer to see whether that helped or not; it's been too long since I read it.
I'd also redo the Arak generally (which, in fact, I tried to do a little in the gazetteer). They don't work for me as I think gothic fey should. Unlike many people though, I have no problems with a faerie land in Ravenloft, or the Rift itself. Again, it's more about the portrayal of some of the Breeds. I don't think VRGttSF helped here either.
Of the NPCs - I've made Jack Bequick darklord of the House of Mirth because I like him and I like a bad carnival to go alongside the other one.
I spent a lot of time talking about Isolde in the transposition by good outsiders thread, so I'll summarise that here by saying I refocused her slightly as well to reduce her tarnish. I think the forces of good should be as powerful as the forces of evil (if more subtle), rather than collapsing into despair and corruption all the time.
I actually quite like Ratik, which is why he's in VRGttWD. I stopped Rucht from adding too much about his murderer too, because I wanted to leave that up to individual GMs to decide for their games. That's the fundamental tension in RPGs of course - you want good characters, but you need to be able to adapt them to individual needs and situations, so by necessity they're often only partially filled in.
Most other NPCs if they don't work, I don't use them, which means I don't think about them. Tara Kolyana for example does nothing for me.
I think there's something wrong with the way the Weathermay-Foxglove twins are portrayed, but I'm not sure what it is. They just don't work for me in the way that I think they should. That's why they spend a lot of time in VRGttWD teasing each other, and why Gennifer reads the Dead Travel Fast romances - to try to make them seem more alive.
The strength of Van Richten as a narrator was that he had an absolutely ripping backstory - stolen son, putting son out of his misery, avenging son, turning to the light to save others. And then Tales of Ravenloft and VRGttV came out and we realised we'd had it wrong the whole time - he was far more culpable than we'd previously thought, he was cursed, and his curse had left a trail of blood behind him. And over the course of VRGttV, he realises all this, realises how wrong he's been about the Vistani, and finally comes to peace at the end. I still think the end of VRGttV is a brilliant piece of writing.
The advantage of all this is that (a) Van Richten is an interesting character and (b) his curse keeps him alive, which makes it reasonable that he could spend his life hunting monsters.
I may have to come back to this after I've had more of a think actually. This is taking too long to work through for a work break.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2013 1:49 am
by Jimsolo
I've been playing around with doing something with the twins, actually. I was thinking about one of them (probably Gennifer) trying to deal with the increased pressure from family and friends to marry and carry on the family name (Lord Jules is dead in my game, so the issue is more pressing). In order to get rid of a particularly persistent foreign suitor, she offers to consider his proposal if he can spend one week in Heather House. He fails to do so, of course, and his servants hightail it out of the domain. (She presumes he went with them, although in reality the house killed him.) This pattern begins to repeat itself, with the beseiged woman using Heather House to drive off/dispose of her unwanted beaus. It makes for a nice slow spiral of corruption, as she begins to suspect more and more that the house is doing something far nastier, and that the men who go in might not be coming out at all. At first she just rationalizes it as the product of their own lust, but as time goes on she begins to care less and less...
Just a thought, anyhow. Like you, I thought the twins needed something else.
I never really thought of Isolde as corrupted, though. Maybe a little...unmerciful, perhaps, but I agree that she is better portrayed as a force of good as strong as the villainous darklords.
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2013 6:34 am
by Ryan Naylor
OK. The difference between Van Richten and the Twins is that Van Richten was protected by his curse - everyone around him died, but he kept going.
Unlike Van Richten, the Twins still have very strong family ties and obligations. While Van Richten cared deeply about his friends, his close family is all dead. In contrast, the Twins have parents, a grandfather, George Weathermay as their uncle, and a privileged place in their society. They are also attractive young women (under extreme pressure to get married - even Godefroy wants them to marry and have male heirs, because he's such a snob he doesn't want Mordent's last noble house to die out), whereas Van Richten was an old man. His story is behind him, whereas theirs is still ahead.
There's also the matter of Gennifer's lycanthropy.
I think the main themes here are the conflict between doing what is right, and obeying their obligations. Gennifer is a bit more conservative than Laurie, so there should be some conflict (which increases as time goes on) between where the line is for each of them. Is Laurie willing to turn her back on her family and ride out to fight evil? Is Gennifer prepared to say goodbye to her sister in order to fulfil her obligations? Can they do both, and for how long?
Another theme is coming of age and the loss of innocence. People have commented a lot on the Nancy Drew feel, which I think is perfectly valid for the first few books, because they have the arrogance of youth but little real experience. When they learn, they'd have to learn hard and fast. They do have to come to terms with the loss of Van Richten and George Weathermay, and the looming death of Jules Weathermay. So there should have been more about that - growing up, making hard decisions, and living with the consequences.
So, stories:
The framing fiction to the Book of Sorrows is about George Weathermay realising that Gennifer has been infected (even though she is yet to turn). This is middle-to-end of George's story - he grew up, he was a great ranger and champion of the common man, he met a girl, girl used him to get close to Van Richten, girl turned into a werewolf and mauled Gennifer, he spent the rest of his life trying to hunt her down in vengeance, gradually growing colder and harder with time. George's story is basically the fallen hero (and probably caused by Van Richten's curse). Stricken with guilt, he never returns to Mordent, and won't see the twins. There's not much left for him but the hunt and eventual (mutual?) destruction.
The twins, meanwhile, are putting Van Richten's library in order and waiting for him to come back from Bleak House. They've been doing some minor investigations on their own.
VRMHC is all about them coming to terms with the fact that Van Richten is not coming back. It's fundamentally a passage into adulthood for them - they go from just editing his books and making comments from their research (largely theoretical - if not, it should be) to deciding to actually take on his position and keep his work going.
With VRA, the twins are branching out into the world for their first research project. Because they're still novices, they're relying on the experience of Van Richten's friends to bring everything together. It's also their last attempt to reach out to George and convince him to come home. It fails, and the twins are forced to move on.
So by the time they're getting to VRGttWD, they've had to come to terms with Van Richten's death, and that George is never coming home either. I don't mind the personal anedote here (although it does contradict canon), but they become increasingly ludicrous as time goes on. Because the walking dead are relatively easy to beat, they've got some experience with them. It makes sense that they're out hunting them. We're still in the arrogance of youth phase. However, they're still forced to rely on contacts for information - Alanik Ray, Ratik, Toben - because they don't know enough about it. I wanted to have them make mistakes in the text to convey this lack of experience, but I'm not sure how clearly it comes through.
And they end up with Nikolas (their friend, whom Laurie appears to be a bit interested in) being mutilated by the Glutton.
For VRGttSF, I'd have the cracks starting to appear. Gaz III was released just before, and if there'd been better oversight from the developers, it would have been great to tie their concerns about Jules' health into the text. You'd convey this by making it clear that Laurie was out doing field research while Gennifer was back at home in the library while looking after Jules - instead of journal entries, they'd correspond via letter. And you have a bit more burgeoning romance between Laurie and Nikolas, drawing the twins apart even more. I'd still have other experts being brought in, albeit on a slightly more equal footing, and make sure they were human(oid) experts.
For VRGttMists (or, VRGttCreatures of the Deeps, as it should have been, to tie in with (a) sanity and (b) Gaz VI), the twins are now able to produce guides more or less by themselves. I've made no secret of the fact that I think Gennifer failing a Powers check was a mistake; instead, I think the twins' story should be one of maturation and hard truths on the rocky road of good, rather than failure and corruption (remember, George Weathermay's already got that covered). There's no real point in showing Richten Haus either, because the twins have accepted his death since VRMHC.
I think I'd probably kill Nikolas here. Or kill someone else we've grown accustomed to, and have Laurie turn to Nikolas for comfort rather than Gennifer. We leave it on a precipice - will the distance between the twins heal, or grow wider?
It's now 760 BC, by the way, leaving a gap of 3 VRGs before 3.5 ed finishes, the Gaz plot is over, and we hang up our boots and hand over to the next round of poor hacks. I have no idea what creatures we'd have looked at in 2 of those 3 guides.
However, Laurie and Gennifer's story progresses through them. Jules would be dead by 761ish BC, and Gennifer is having to deal with the sudden political complexities thrust upon her. She has political power, which she wants to use for good (furthering the work, really), but feels constrained by these obligations after resisting them for so long. Laurie is out doing direct good work, avoiding her responsibilities. By 761 BC (the second last VRG - something with mind control/deception abilities would suit, perhaps like the FoS's guide to dopplegangers), they're 31, and they finally bring this all to a head. We can lay a few seeds for the Time of Unparalleled Darkness and the Dying Days leading up to that through these books as well. Something about Gennifer's lycanthropy as well would be good - perhaps that is the cause of their falling out - Gennifer realises it earlier, but conceals it from Laurie, and Laurie can't handle what she takes as a lack of trust between them after everything they've been through.
Having Natalia the werewolf disguised as a guest expert would be a nice touch as well. She and Gennifer only meet at the end, which is when Gennifer makes her awful discovery.
The last one is VRGttEldritch Abomination (Lovecraft), which ties in with Our Hero reaching Bluetspur and sacrificing herself to finally gain her freedom from Azalin. The important thing here is that Lovecraftian horror is all about sweeping away the importance of human constructs and realising you're lost and alone in a meaningless, uncaring universe (see Matthew L Martin's ideas about cosmic horror and illithids in Ravenloft for further ideas). So, to wind it up here, and to end on a positive note, this is where the twins reconcile. Having studied creatures that want to sweep everything away and make their lives meaningless, they realise that the only thing that really means anything is each other. Which brings us nicely full circle to the sentiment of VRA, and echoes the end of VRGttV.
Of course, the real challenge is conveying all that clearly but subtly through the framing fiction and On the Hunt chapters, which is where most of this would come out. You also have to remember that the twins are actually publishing these books in their world, so outing herself as a werewolf to the real world reader but not to the Land of Mists reader would need to be artfully done.
The twins are also really Mangrum's babies, so he might have other ideas.
How does that work for you?
Re: NPC Revisions
Posted: Thu Feb 07, 2013 2:39 pm
by Jimsolo
Waa-a-a-a-ay better than the two bit plot I hammered out.
You make some good points (particularly in how to use Lovecraftian themes for positive rather than negative results). I'm not entirely sure, to be honest, that I am going to use the twins at all, but if I do, then I will almost certainly run with the story you've laid out.