What sort of national anthems do you think the Ravenloft nations might have?
Discussion follows.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Sun Mar 31, 2013 11:55 am
by HuManBing
I'm toying around with the idea of composing anthems for Darkon and Falkovnia, and here's what I've come up with so far. The following is only for my own campaign - other gamers may have very different ideas, of course.
Most anthems either come from hymns (with a specific religious source, generally Christian hymns for European nations) or from military marches. Hymn-derived anthems will have a specific lyrical pattern to them, usually with a simple enough rhyme scheme and rhythm that a commoner or layperson could sing along. A significant number of Christian hymns feature fairly interchangeable lyrics because of the similarity of the underlying songs' structure: 4/4 time is most common, and rhyme schemes will generally cleave to an AABB or ABAB pattern. Occasional "loose lines" of CC at the end of a verse, or one C line appended across two verses can be found.
I'm thinking Darkon's anthem will likely be more stately, in the manner of a traditional European royal hymn or gentle march. Azalin probably has a much greater focus on internal peace and stability, so the anthem is unlikely to focus on "rallying the troops" and more on "make the listener happy". Or at the very least "let the listener know the king is coming".
Younger nations (or at least, those with more recently-formed nationwide governments) can have surprisingly poetic national anthems. Take, for example, the anthems of Mongolia, India, and the Republic of China (Taiwan):
These are anthems that seem less to focus on lauding a ruler or an army, and more to telling a story or developing a musical theme.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Sun Mar 31, 2013 11:55 am
by HuManBing
Marches, on the other hand, focus less on the lyrical qualities of the piece and much more on the rhythm. Before Napoleon, marches could feature time signatures as slow as 60 (often the case for solemn or funerary occasions), but Napoleonic marches took on a time signature of 120 - largely in order to facilitate rapid infantry marching. 2/4 and 4/4 time is the most common, with 3/4 time almost unheard of, given that the median infantry soldier has an even number of legs. Functionally, a march can serve as inspiration for friendly soldiers, remaining in an overall major tone - although a small number of marches serve to intimidate the opposing forces and may feature patches of minor tonality. Retrospective marches, such as those to commemorate solemn occasions, may also have both minor tonality and a much slower pace.
Some nations have a separate national anthem from their signature military march, for the exact reason outlined above - the national anthem speaks to pride in one's nation and is usually inspirational, and the military march speaks to trouncing your foes and can be much more combative. Falkovnia might have both - one specifically for use when you're staring down the battlefield at your enemies, and one for civilian circumstances.
Examples:
Dawn of a New Century (Secret Garden) - has a faintly-minor beginning, and progresses into a major key - a common enough pattern if the song emphasizes current sacrifice for future glories.
March of the Volunteers (Mainland Chinese anthem) - clearly a marching song, with a very clear drum-led rhythm. The tonality of this piece is unusual in that it preserves the pentatonic scale common to traditional Chinese music, although it can be hard to hear behind the Western-style orchestra.
And now for some songs which are clearly meant to intimidate the listener: minor tonalities, occasional double harmonics, strident bass and percussion all openly proclaim "we are bad guys...or at least, bad ass". Rarely will these be used by a government in real life - few governments would want to invite comparison to something with negative connotations. But they're common enough in fiction.
Innuendo (Queen) - the first segment seems like it's written with war machines (or a sinister version of Bolero) in mind.
The Imperial March - an implacable regime will find you, wherever you're hiding, and blast the planet out from under your feet.
King Koopa's Fleet - whenever Mario's adventures take him onto an airship, tank, or warship, this music plays. Clearly inspired by Gustav Holtz' "Mars The Bringer of War".
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Mon Apr 01, 2013 6:02 am
by Jimsolo
I think that Falkovnia almost certainly has a national anthem, which is all about how omnipotent and awesome Drakov is. Nova Vaasa is probably in the same boat, although it's probably more nationalistic and less personalized. Valachan seems like it might have one, too, which was probably chosen by von Karkov for how professional it sounds, given how much he seems to crave legitimacy. If Tepest has one at all, it's probably some kind of hymn.
Most of the others are not, I think, unified enough to have a national anthem. (With the exception of Kartakass, which probably has several! ) Many of them don't really see themselves as a nation, so much, and many more are ruled by a government which is either loose (Mordent), ambivalent (Barovia), or both (Lamordia).
Just my opinion, of course.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Mon Apr 01, 2013 6:05 am
by Manofevil
What is the oldest known national anthem? Did The Romans have one? Did Charlemagne? Vlad Tepes? I could see Drakov having one if he could conceive of such a thing. I guess the question is Would he? Would any Darklord have one about the nation instead of themselves?
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Mon Apr 01, 2013 8:49 am
by HuManBing
Apparently the earliest song still in use as a current national anthem is the Wilhelmus, for the Dutch. It was not used as a national anthem until 1923 though. For lyrics, the current anthem of Japan is based on a poem from the 8th Century.
The concept of a national anthem is relatively recent - it is very unlikely to have predated the Treaty of Westphalia (which set several important milestones in international law standards and sovereignty customs, but also set the stage for differentiating a nation from its monarch). Prior to that, you might have a specific hymn in church or temple praying for the wellbeing of the king (since king and country would then have been viewed as inseparable concepts) or possibly a popular march that started with the military forces but caught on with the general public.
Even in the absence of a separation of monarch and state, you could still have family hymns. In a state where one family gained autocratic power, a family hymn could become the nation's de facto anthem.
All the above, however, is just historical color. Ravenloft departs from history on creative tangents, and if something is fun or impressive or interesting, mere history on Earth shouldn't stop it.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Mon Apr 01, 2013 9:55 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Another possibility as a basis for a Falkovnian national anthem: Die Wacht am Rhein.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Mon Apr 01, 2013 5:01 pm
by herkles
I don't think that all realms have a national anthem. Barovia would not IMO. I am also not sure if Nova Vaasa would as it is a feudal kingdom that is in the midst of becoming a more centralized nation state. Though I can totally imagine a plot for nova vaasan bards to try and come up with a proper national song for their kingdom.
Also some may not have anthemes but songs that might be patriotic.
For instance Gundark, I think a poem like the Nemzeti dal work well. A song to try and rally for the rebels freedom and hope
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Sat Apr 06, 2013 11:24 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Even if they don't have established national anthems, it's likely that several Ravenloft nations have songs that are strongly associated with their ethnic or historical roots. In the more advanced domains, these might derive from operatic works about the domain's founding, while traditional ballads or folk songs could serve a similar purpose in the rustic ones. Think of how "Waltzing Matilda" is even more strongly associated with Australia than its actual national anthem.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Sun Apr 07, 2013 9:50 am
by HuManBing
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Think of how "Waltzing Matilda" is even more strongly associated with Australia than its actual national anthem.
Fun story: In Munchkin Cthulhu, there is a card that gives you a +2 bonus - but if you sing the song to the tune and add in lyrics to finish it, you get a +5.
The lyrics were "Munchkin Cthulhu, Munchkin Cthulhu, You'll play some Munchkin Cthulhu with me..." and the tune was Waltzing Mathilda. I finished it with the line "And he sang as he sighed and slid into the Shoggoth orifice: 'Who'll play some Munchkin Cthulhu with me?'"
The rest of the group collapsed into laughter and it ensured that I survived the 2.6 seconds and won the battle.
I've started working (slowly) on a religious Eternal Order style of hymn which might also turn out to be the national song of Darkon. In terms of lyrical meaning, it's a subversion of "God Save the King" - instead of pleading with a deity, the choir is denouncing the Grey Realm and supplicating itself before Darkonius Rex as their protector. The king and the church's savior-figure have become one and the same.
This song came up in my gaming session recently: the PCs met a controversial bard who did satirical parodies of church music. She takes church hymns and then adds an extra vocal line at the top, asking contrapuntal questions and making faux-naif observations about the religion's doctrines. I took The Divine Comedy's "Eye of the Needle" and added a lyrical choral line to the bass line. It's just simple and unadorned, for now - something similar to a psalm. I'll see if I can polish it up and maybe even get a recording of it uploaded somewhere.
If anybody has any suggestions for good, free music recording and mixing software, I'm definitely interested.
Re: On national anthems
Posted: Fri Apr 12, 2013 10:24 pm
by HuManBing
More random examples, mostly from video games:
Hell March (Red Alert marching theme) - much too modern for Ravenloft, but the minor tonalities and relentless marching drumbeat would make for a good intimidating song:
Call of Pripyat (STALKER end theme) - orchestral enough for adaptation to Ravenloft. A 1-6-1-3 minor chord progression in marching time (though the syncopation of the drums throws the 2nd step off a little bit). Modulates into 3 major. Much of the "voice" of the piece is around the 5 mark, occasionally reaching to a 6-7-8 resolution; this on its own should be easy enough for an army to sing along to as they march.
JFG character select - a short looped piece, possibly inspired by Williams' Imperial March, but unlike that piece, played at a brisk marching pace. Its opening theme also sets an anthem-like lyrical piece at a marching pace, although there is no simple pleb-friendly tune, being heavy on the brass and flourishes:
Legend of Zelda palace theme - perhaps more suitable for a noble house or a royal entrance. The section around 0m56s gives me chills up the spine.