Page 1 of 2
Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 2:44 pm
by vipera aspis
So as enigmatic and deep as the dark powers are: I would imagine them ignoring characters who are evil for evils sake. As in lacking substance behind their motives. So your pc/npc who's doing things to be evil, wearing the black robes to alarm the normals yadda yadda; all round seeking attention and that juvenile evil sort of way. What do you folk think?
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 3:44 pm
by Dark Angel
vipera aspis wrote:So as enigmatic and deep as the dark powers are: I would imagine them ignoring characters who are evil for evils sake. As in lacking substance behind their motives. So your pc/npc who's doing things to be evil, wearing the black robes to alarm the normals yadda yadda; all round seeking attention and that juvenile evil sort of way. What do you folk think?
Well that person would be jailed and/or lynched before the Dark Powers could really take hold. In my little world, it's a person's (or monster or item or group) capacity for evil that really grabs the Dark Powers attention. Azalin and Vecna will set up and sacrifice millions if it meant they would get their goals of escape. Strahd would kill anyone or destroy anything to get close to Tatyana. Just running around and stabbing someone (Midnight Slasher for example) does not advance you to go. It is almost like it's not what you do to get to your goal, but what is expected of you when you get there. How many lords of Ravenloft really wanted to ascend to that level of power? Not just rule over everyone, but be trapped and the test subject for some twisted unknown power? If one of my player's really did bad things "for evil's sake" to get special powers, make an example of them by the natural consequences of their actions, drawing the attentions of bad people (even darklords), or have them stopped by the most powerful creatures a DM can throw at a group: a good aligned party of npcs. They won't kill them, but they will have them taken into the custody of a proper authority.
The best question you can ask yourself for who or what qualifies as a candidate for "lordship" is, Can I imagine a pocket domain, island of terror, cluster, or full domain for this person? If not, then they are not worth your time (consider yourself a proxy to the advocacy of evilness, always a growing business!) and should just be dealt with quickly as to set an example. One way is to attack their expectations. If they enjoy killing (see Lord of Verbrek or Paridon), have them weakened by it yet still need it. Or use/modify the Terror Tracks in the Book of Shadows pdf.
Sorry this went a bit longer than expected... [steps off soapbox]
Hope it helped.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Fri Oct 11, 2013 2:20 am
by order99
'Evil for evil's sake' is a poor motivation for a future Darklord. Even true sociopaths don't violate ethics for the heck of it-in all but the worst mad Lost One, there is a goal that the NPC wants to achieve, even if it's just 'lots of money, ale and women until I die'.
The most memorable 'Evil' character (especially in Gothic tropes) is someone the Hero can empathize with on some level. The underlying motivation can either be heroic or selfish yet human, then twisted into monstrosity. Consider:
-I want wealth and power, because I deserve it
-I want to be respected
-You will obey me because I am smarter and wiser, and know what is best for you/this town/this kingdom
-I want my family back
-I want your love, and deserve it
-Death and illness are abominations, and I will abolish them
-I will never hunger or starve again
-I wish to explore the boundaries of Art/Science/Sensation
-I know the One True Faith, and must show you so that you will also know the truth
-I want justice/vengeance on you/your government/your species
-I want to live, more/longer than the others I know
-I want all of the knowledge, the secrets of the universe
-You have something I want, and I deserve/want it more than you
-I have everything I need/want and fear losing it
-I want to escape persecution
-I have unnatural/immoral hungers and must satisfy them
-ThevoicesinmyheadmademedoitOHGODwhyistheresomuchBLOOD?
-I want my memories/old life back
-My tribe/ethos/race/gender is the equal of yours, and you will give us equal rights/respect
-Change/the Future is scary
-I will assist in finding my sibling a good mate
-My child shall have the opportunities I didn't
etc, etc etc.
Now take that well-meaning(or selfish) person and twist them up. Twist HARD. That notable perversion of ethics is what we know as 'Evil'. The compromises, self-delusions and lack of empathy that result enable the commission of truly bestial acts.
The Dark Powers hate motiveless persons and do not support them with Dark Gifts or a Realm.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Fri Oct 11, 2013 4:52 pm
by Dark Angel
Order99, I just read this post (obviously) and your concise bin Laden synopsis. I mean this with all honesty (and absolutely no sarcasm), you need to post more often! Love that little Darklord check list!
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2013 12:03 pm
by Zettaijin
The issue here is that seeing the DPs as "agents of justice and the greater good" is a silly one.
"Boring" characters/creatures acting in ways that could be described as "evil" (that is to say as purposefully dangerous to human life and disturbing their happiness directly or indirectly) are everywhere in the realms to the point of being a threat to the "human ecosystem" were it not for presumed interventions from the DP (forced immigration/kidnapping via the mists?).
Were the DPs to truly loathe these characters/creatures, they wouldn't be nearly so prolific.
That the DPs seem interested in certain types of individuals to the point of intervening in their existence through boons and curses suggests they love a good story and are quite happy to move things along a path of their choosing if needed.
Until a canon source describes the nature and purpose of the DP in detail, we are left with scant few clues as to the former. However, what we do know is that the DPs are not particularly concerned with anything but their own amusement and have the means to achieve just that.
I've posited the idea of super powered D&D characters having transcended the world of mere mortals thanks to the redonculous things one can do with higher level magics.
Given the social context and generally acceptable behavioural patterns/attitudes as suggested by the average D&D material, one would assume that the above super powers could easily act as the apparently unpredictable DPs.
Having multiple DPs means they might fight over who gets to do what with whom and when. Much like children fighting over toys. Some DPs might be more idealistic and see themselves as teaching lessons to humanity while others are just in it for kicks.
This could also explain the static views of the populace as the super powers are not likely to have sudden ideological shifts. And besides, when you have the power to create planets and snuff out stars, what's a few human lives for the sake of a good story?
Still, why have so many dangerous things and creatures around? Unless they derive entertainement from say werebeats ripping into the flesh of sentient beings... which they might...
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Wed Oct 16, 2013 11:12 pm
by vipera aspis
I like the idea of numerous dark powers. Some giving dark blessings to those in need; others sweeping plagues across cities. So you gave some interested in justice and some interested in malign breeding cycles.
And about having so many dangerous creatures in one small landmass?
Let's ask Australia
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Thu Oct 17, 2013 12:10 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
The Dark Powers aren't anything more than a DM tool, just like the Mists. Powers checks are also a DM tool. This is why so many evil NPCs exist who haven't failed any powers checks while others have. If it serves their character to have or have not failed a powers check or two (or three, or four, or even five, six is when they become darklords) then that's all that matters. Anything else the Dark Powers do is largely homebrew.
Admittedly the above is only for NPCs. PCs, because the players are responsible for their actions, risk the consequences every time. "Man is not punished for his sins but by them."
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Fri Oct 25, 2013 5:11 pm
by The Lesser Evil
vipera aspis wrote:So as enigmatic and deep as the dark powers are: I would imagine them ignoring characters who are evil for evils sake. As in lacking substance behind their motives. So your pc/npc who's doing things to be evil, wearing the black robes to alarm the normals yadda yadda; all round seeking attention and that juvenile evil sort of way. What do you folk think?
I guess it depends on how you define "evil for evil's sake". Even in the example given above, the "evil poser" as it were isn't doing evil as an end in and of itself; rather the evil poser is doing it in order to defy social conventions and gain attention, a variant on the classic motive of "I just want to be special!"
However, you are right in there is some precedence of the evil poser not always being struck directly by the dark powers. However, this doesn't mean they're necessarily ignored altogether by the dark powers. Azrael Dak, for example,wants to become the lord of Sithicus. But perhaps because of his desire to become the darklord, he was denied that and instead Inza became the lord of Sithicus after Soth left. We can see Azrael Dak represents a sort of almost cartoony evil, but one may make an argument that he isn't ignored by the dark powers but instead indirectly tormented and humiliated through their actions on another person (giving lordship of the domain to Inza).
For those who seem to pursue evil for evil's sake, I would explore and perhaps deconstruct the perpetrator's underlying desires for pursuing such a philosophy. For example, semingly doing evil for evil's sake can often be a manifestation of embracing nihilism and wanting to teach the world that existence is but a big cosmic joke. Look at the Joker here, for example. Something's happened in his past to give him "a really bad day", and he wants the whole world to know the same "truth" he knows and then laugh about it. The Joker's a compelling character despite being fairly predictable in his ultimate intent and almost monolithic in personality like a boogeyman. A force for chaos and evil and making no excuses or justifications for it other than that these things aren't even needed in the big picture.
You might also say he even has his own curse- not to be able to understand Good as a moral force- such as in the Dark Knight Rises when he expects the two escape barges to blow each other up but they don't end up doing it. This could easily be enforced on a "Evil cannot understand/is confounded or even pained by Good/Order" schtick- perhaps balanced with a reward of preternatural foreknowledge of the future for everything aside from Good (as the Joker often has a sense of serendipity in being in the right place at the right time to screw everybody over). Not every punishment/reward from the DPs needs to be directly or physically noticeable quality but could easily be more subtle. While I wouldn't make the Joker a darklord, he is evidence that a guy who follows the road of evil with no qualms about it can make for a compelling villain- going all the way through to the Creature status in the path of corruption (a vile monster clown that can barely said to be human).
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Sat Oct 26, 2013 9:58 am
by HuManBing
I wrestled with the idea of Good and Evil. In the end, I have to admit that my viewpoint of morality and ethics is a stringently relativist one. As such, objective ideals of Good and Evil flat-out don't exist (they're intrinsically subjective), and objective ideals of Lawful and Unlawful behavior are at best demagogic and at worst completely arbitrary.
So many problems cropped up with the whole DnD objective alignment chart for me that I just scrapped it and went with GURPS' behavioral disadvantages/advantages instead. More details of my thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns (and the discussions it generated) are found
here.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Sun Oct 27, 2013 7:48 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
HuManBing wrote:I wrestled with the idea of Good and Evil. In the end, I have to admit that my viewpoint of morality and ethics is a stringently relativist one. As such, objective ideals of Good and Evil flat-out don't exist (they're intrinsically subjective), and objective ideals of Lawful and Unlawful behavior are at best demagogic and at worst completely arbitrary.
So many problems cropped up with the whole DnD objective alignment chart for me that I just scrapped it and went with GURPS' behavioral disadvantages/advantages instead. More details of my thoughts on removing morality from my campaigns (and the discussions it generated) are found
here.
D&D has wrestled with the gray areas of morality since the beginning. Both the
BoVD and
BoED struggle with defining any objective standards of good and evil. As for law and chaos, from a cosmological point of view better terms would be "order" and "anarchy." Put ethics and morals together and you get a framework of behavior, not absolutes. What one would define as neutral good or chaotic good may actually be lawful good behavior. Intent seems to be the final arbiter of chaos/evil/good/law, even if it's completely unconscious.
Complete Scoundrel goes into what delineates alignment perhaps better than anything if only because it gives ideas for the frameworks of specific alignment behaviors and even specific examples in the form of fictional characters.
In Ravenloft I understand the need for some more precise definitions of what is and isn't evil, but those are the standards of the Dark Powers (read: the DM). Some things (murder, for one) are so universally deplored they make sense. But again the question is, what constitutes murder? Does a criminal execution count? Self-defense? War? It's really up to individual groups to decide a general idea of morality in their game and refine it as the game goes on. No system can handle everything and there will be gray areas to handle.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Sun Oct 27, 2013 11:32 pm
by Dark Angel
But the concept of murder gets muddled as many cultures consider murder one of the worst things a sentient can do to another living being. Ones who are truly deplorable become desensitized to the act and put into a place where they cannot hurt others. Unless you are a soldier in another country fighting for your leaders cause. Do they make powers checks for carrying out orders? Or just taking some acts to far? I am not talking about something akin to the Einzatsgruppen (Nazi death squads), but a commander who cannot continue the war effort because of the large number of prisoners he has to watch and feed.
An interesting campaign would have the characters fighting for an army and dealing with harsh situations that could prompt powers checks as they are ones that could literally cost the battle, if not the war (static political shifts notwithstanding). Unless they are ruthlessly killing any and all in their way (if I don't kill this family, then they might inform our position), could they fall prey to the same checks as their adventuring counterparts? If it was not in their (dark) hearts to justify these actions, would they be held to the same standard?
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Mon Oct 28, 2013 2:46 pm
by Satyrwyld
General objective alignment rules that have served me well:
MORALS:
"Good" generally tries to do things that benefit other people. There is no restriction on benefiting one's self, provided the motive/result is not selfish or taking advantage of others.
"Evil" generally tries to act in self-serving ways, frequently harming or exploiting others.
ETHICS:
"Lawful" creatures believe organized society and enforced rules are the best means to accomplish their ends.
"Chaotic" creatures feel rules just get in the way, and that individuals need to work out for themselves how to meet their needs.
So: Lawful Evil tries to enact (or live in places with) laws that benefit them personally - slavery, noblesse oblige, etc.
Chaotic Good is a more complex version of "an ye harm none, do as ye will"
So on and so forth.
Now, where this leaves inflicting death on another creature... a good creature should have no moral qualms about ending an irredeemably evil creature: fiends, most undead, etc. Self-defense is also a reasonably objective acceptable case for potentially fatal violence. Some philosophies (say, a god of mercy) may be more stringent, but that's a localized phenomenon and not part and parcel of the alignment as a metaphysical law.
Conversely, excessive force that results in death, pre-emptive strikes, and similar tactics are usually unjustified murder.
The good, honorable thing to do is not always stupid, but it is often a position of difficulty and vulnerability. If it were easy and pleasant, evil wouldn't be as seductive.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Mon Oct 28, 2013 5:37 pm
by HuManBing
High Priest Mikhal wrote:In Ravenloft I understand the need for some more precise definitions of what is and isn't evil, but those are the standards of the Dark Powers (read: the DM).
Speaking as the DM for my campaign, I can confidently say the DM has abdicated all authority in defining what is good and what is evil - largely because he believes they are inherently and intensely subjective, and he is ideologically opposed to imposing his own definitions on anybody else.
Some things (murder, for one) are so universally deplored they make sense.
Murder is actually defined as the unlawful taking of a life. Which is interesting because it references
legality, which is a question of ethics and therefore relies on group decisionmaking to arrive at the semblance of an objective code. In other words, it's not at heart a moral issue - it's an ethical issue. As you rightly point out, there are many shades of grey when it comes to defining what "murder" is (homicide in self-defense? manslaughter with careless driving of a vehicle? killing of an enemy combatant on the battlefield with clearly defined rules of engagment?).
I maintain that the GM can hide behind RPG Rule 1 ("the GM defines the world and the campaign and his word overrides all canon to the contrary") as far as ethics goes. Cultural and societal standards can result in many different legal situations, and the GM usually has free rein to define the culture and society of the campaign. Because ethics derive from societal norms, players usually afford the GM significant leeway in rewriting what a society considers acceptable.
But I am increasingly uncomfortable with trying to define morals within the ambit of RPG Rule 1. Players tend to come to the table with their own ideas of good and evil (being subjective morals). If the GM then throws them into a universe where they can and will be punished for "good" or "evil" behavior as determined by an objective metric, it's a quick devolution into a complex debate over what is "evil" to the player, what is "evil" to the setting, and why there's a difference. Essentially it boils down to "I'm okay with a GM telling me what's legal or not, but it is presumptuous for the GM to tell me what's evil".
I suspect this is one of the reasons Ravenloft gets a bad reputation among players who think it's just an OP campaign setting for the GM to bludgeon their players with. One of the first things you're asking players to do is to essentially abdicate their own judgment of good and evil and somehow divine the GM's sense. If you're really similar with your players, then that's all well and good, but if you're catering for an eclectic crowd of people, the DnD morality alignment model tends to create many more problems than it solves. This goes doubly for moral dilemmas. I'm happy to present them with dilemmas, but I'm not going to punish them in any sort of divine, karmic, or cosmic fashion for taking a step I don't approve of. There's plenty of fascinating
mundane consequences that can arise.
My gaming group currently: GM is a UK-educated Chinese American
EDIT - who is a professional attorney; players include Chinese, European, Jordanian, and Korean upbringings. All are atheists; one essentially by Chinese legislation, the rest by choice. Not a lot of space left for any appeal to a divine arbiter of human behavior.
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Mon Oct 28, 2013 6:25 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
HuManBing wrote:I maintain that the GM can hide behind RPG Rule 1 ("the GM defines the world and the campaign and his word overrides all canon to the contrary")
That's technically Rule 0, but otherwise points taken. I won't derail the thread to argue finer points (Rule Zero trumps everything). Suffice to say I prefer a fairly objective code of morality in my campaigns based on the general outlines of alignment in the player's books. There will always be gray areas that need to be expanded upon with each group. In Ravenloft I adhere to the spirit of what constitutes a powers check, for example, and not the word. The same goes for ethics; spirit, not word.
Why do I suddenly feel like a lawyer arguing a case?
Re: Evil for evils sake ignored
Posted: Mon Oct 28, 2013 8:13 pm
by HuManBing
High Priest Mikhal wrote:Why do I suddenly feel like a lawyer arguing a case?
Crap, I knew I'd forgotten to include something in my breakdown of my gaming group!
Edited in.