Page 1 of 4

osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 4:10 pm
by jules
how would osma bin ladin work as a darklord in ravenloft?

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 5:08 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Not well, I fear. Too soon, IMHO. We can do a Hitler-inspired Drakov because there aren't many of his victims (or supporters) still alive, and those that are are most likely older than the target audience for D&D. (I dunno, I'd love to hear about D&D at the old-age home, but I doubt there's much of it.) The same can't be said of bin Ladin. You make a darklord too close to him, and you're likely to push your players buttons in all the wrong ways.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 5:09 pm
by jules
well it's just a thought.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 7:43 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Way, WAY too soon for bin Laden! And I wouldn't discount Hitler and his supporters, Gonzoron. The sick reality is his message of hate still resonates strongly with many people, most especially in America where "Freedom of Speech" protects pro- as well as anti-Nazi sentiment. Try that in Germany and you'll end up in prison.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 8:10 pm
by Zilfer
Are German's really anti anything from that war? I know they don't like acknowledging it from what I've heard.... I'm in america so i don't know that but we do have Skin heads and Neo Nazi's around.... other types of things that believe "i'm better than said group"

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 8:20 pm
by Dark Angel
The fact that Nazis and Neo-Nazis are really never "empathized" with is one thing. Unfortunately, bin Laden is labeled as a Muslin extremist (but wanna guess how devout a Muslim he was?) and those who are Muslim are put in the same category. Not all Muslims are terrorists, but that does not matter to many close-minded people. I have a game that has a Jihad quality to it based on a war with religious conflict and I was concerned about a Crusades-like atmosphere (Christian vs. Muslim issues). It doesn't help that Nazism is a fairly harsh political philosophy while the Muslim faith has many who are advocates for peace, not violence. Yeah, too soon (if ever).

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 8:25 pm
by Ryan Naylor
It's illegal in Germany to defame those killed by the Nazis, and far right/neo-Nazi groups/bands/speech is banned.

When I was there, the shadow of World War Two still seemed pretty prominent. It wasn't my experience that people didn't like to acknowledge it. I don't think they have the opportunity to forget, in a lot of ways.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 8:26 pm
by jules
how would you fine people handle bin ladin as a darklord?

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Wed Oct 09, 2013 8:27 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
High Priest Mikhal wrote:And I wouldn't discount Hitler and his supporters, Gonzoron. The sick reality is his message of hate still resonates strongly with many people
Oh, no doubt, but the man and the message are two separate things. (intertwined of course, but separate).

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 1:59 am
by Zilfer
Dark Angel wrote:The fact that Nazis and Neo-Nazis are really never "empathized" with is one thing. Unfortunately, bin Laden is labeled as a Muslin extremist (but wanna guess how devout a Muslim he was?) and those who are Muslim are put in the same category. Not all Muslims are terrorists, but that does not matter to many close-minded people. I have a game that has a Jihad quality to it based on a war with religious conflict and I was concerned about a Crusades-like atmosphere (Christian vs. Muslim issues). It doesn't help that Nazism is a fairly harsh political philosophy while the Muslim faith has many who are advocates for peace, not violence. Yeah, too soon (if ever).

A good book by Frank Herbert called Dune (which some of you may remember) has a Jihad, as well as desert elements because Frank studied a bit of the culture over there....


Muad'ib!

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 2:58 am
by Dion of the Fraternity
He's not worthy enough to be a darklord.

Image

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 6:40 am
by alhoon
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Not well, I fear. Too soon, IMHO. We can do a Hitler-inspired Drakov because there aren't many of his victims (or supporters) still alive, and those that are are most likely older than the target audience for D&D. (I dunno, I'd love to hear about D&D at the old-age home, but I doubt there's much of it.) The same can't be said of bin Ladin. You make a darklord too close to him, and you're likely to push your players buttons in all the wrong ways.
IIRC Falkovnia in GazII draw some fire for this. Personally, I didn't like the Hitler reference but mostly because we have a large number of other genocidal maniacs and warmongers in history from the Roman Republic where genocide was socially accepted and applauded (poor Carthage :( ) to ancient China, Medieval Japan, Europe etc.
If anything, I would prefer a more generic "tyrant-vibe" for Drakov so that everyone could tailor him to the campaign's needs.


As for OBL, yes, too early BUT Yagno of Zerhisia could work.

Ryan Naylor wrote:It's illegal in Germany to defame those killed by the Nazis, and far right/neo-Nazi groups/bands/speech is banned.

When I was there, the shadow of World War Two still seemed pretty prominent. It wasn't my experience that people didn't like to acknowledge it. I don't think they have the opportunity to forget, in a lot of ways.
A good portion there had uncles/parents/grandparents that remembered the war. The old generation of Germans have suffered at the hands of Nazis and at the hands of the allies. I guess when your grandparent tells you stories about how he was struggling to survive in a war-devastated economy as an orphan because the Gestapo killed his father and his mother died in a bombardment by the allied airforce you don't forget WW2

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 7:01 am
by Alastor
I agree that it is too soon to create a Darklord close enough to the real person to be recognizable, especially since Muslims are being associated with this man and his followers more than modern-day Germans are associated with Nazis. However, there is no reason you can't use more subtle elements of the real character to inspire a villain who outwardly looks very different. Someone from any number of backgrounds might:
a)Feel that the culture with which he/she identifies is being persecuted by a more powerful group
b)Accuse said "enemy" of carrying on a conflict everyone else believes ended many years in the past
c)Decide to fight by means of attacks on civilian populations

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 7:48 am
by alhoon
So... The nomads attacking Pharazia and stealing slaves?

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 9:37 am
by Mortavius
Alastor wrote:Someone from any number of backgrounds might:
a)Feel that the culture with which he/she identifies is being persecuted by a more powerful group
b)Accuse said "enemy" of carrying on a conflict everyone else believes ended many years in the past
c)Decide to fight by means of attacks on civilian populations
We actually already have a character who fits this bill completely.

Ardonk Szeria, the leader of the Gundarakite rebels in Barovia. He's actually filled all three of those criteria above.

And although he's not closely related to the new church of Erlin, they are courting him to try and win him over. It's easy to just carry things forward.