Page 1 of 3
Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Wed Nov 13, 2013 1:08 am
by Grumpy RPG Reviews
What would you want of Ravenloft in D&D 5E? That is, assuming it gets a treatment in the next version of the game system.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Wed Nov 13, 2013 4:27 am
by alhoon
The same I wanted from Ravenloft since I started into it in 1998:
- Cool adventures,
- engaging NPCs, stories and items
- Adherence to the setting as it was laid down in late 2e and 3e (available for both Gothic AND fantasy horror, also outlanders AND natives)
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Wed Nov 13, 2013 8:58 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
The main thing I'd like to see is a respect for what's come before. Any new version of any setting has to cater to both new fans and old ones. I understand that RL has a lot of baggage that might seem strange and unwieldy to a newcomer, but a lot of that baggage is the charm of the setting and sets it apart from other horror settings. And I believe it's possible to smooth things to a point where both old and new fans could enjoy it. What I'm getting at is that I don't want to see a complete reboot or a another world-shattering reshuffle of the setting. I don't want to see separate domains that don't relate to each other like 4e had. I want the interconnected world that I love, and the characters I love. The timeline would have to be advanced, probably, so things would change, and maybe some characters would be dead and what have you, and that's ok (and good!). But I'd want it to build on the setting and not start over.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Wed Nov 13, 2013 11:30 am
by Grumpy RPG Reviews
I agree with "Cool adventures" and "engaging NPCs, stories and items" and the need to please fans both new and old. However, I find myself increasingly ambivalent over the setting as presented in 2E and 3/3.5E. On another forum someone remarked the setting is "delicate" which is a fair assessment - the mood and tone are things difficult to establish and easy to break. I have not, in my own head, been able to come up with a better solution.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Wed Nov 13, 2013 11:36 am
by Joël of the FoS
What Ron said, indeed. 4e RL was that a clash with previous RL, so that it wasn't useful in an ongoing campaign.
But they do not need to keep everything, of course, as that would be a lot of 5e rewrite. But if they keep the Core domains and NPCs, and a few iconic island of terror (Souragne, ...), that would be great and well received with both old and new fans.
Joël
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 3:46 am
by alhoon
Well, Gonzoron put it better than I did. I don't mind some of the 4e material, they seem good for the "weekend in hell" thing. But I would like the deep background that comes with the core and the old setting, where there is stuff happening and the background expanding for 25 years. Ravenloft shouldn't miss that much work and the emotional appeal it has to old schoolers.
I just hope WotC will find a way to incorporate most if not all of the material of the Gazetteers even if not directly, or at the very least not cancel it so I can keep using it without having to work around the new canon.
I.e. Azalin should have returned, Necropolis should be a domain within Darkon etc.
I don't want to see something like "Heroes defeated Death and Azalin never returned" or "Dominic died 2 years after the Grim Harvest" etc.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 9:42 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I just hope WotC will find a way to incorporate most if not all of the material of the Gazetteers even if not directly, or at the very least not cancel it so I can keep using it without having to work around the new canon.
I wouldn't expect all or most of it, especially in the little details, but yeah, I agree, don't undo the major events or contradict the 3e stuff needlessly.
It's OK to let the details fade. The 3e line was great about dropping hints to old 2e stuff without making the 2e knowledge necessary. (e.g., you don't need to have read Death of a Darklord to understand the reference to the Ambrose Compound in Gaz I. You can just take it at face value as a group of monster hunters who live in Kartakass.) But even that is gravy. If it was left out, as long as it's in a way that someone in the know could still use it and stick it in, that's fine. But I'd want the broad strokes to be there, even beyond the darklords. Azalin should be "alive" again, yes. And Malocchio should be ruling Invidia. The Gundarakites should be rebelling against Barovia. The Weathermay Twins should be hunting monsters and writing books. The Carnival should be roaming the lands. etc., etc.
In brief, Ravenloft should be treated as a world with 20+ years of published history and loyal fans. It shouldn't be mined for parts, or stripped back to the original I6 module.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:07 pm
by Mortavius
Since we're talking about advancing the setting, obviously the elephant in the room is the ToUD. Should that have occurred? Should it be nigh?
I was re-reading the original plans for S and the Gaz's the other day. I noted that one of the possible fallouts was a war with Falkovnia and the southern Core, with Borca getting crushed.
I agree that's probably likely...but I won't lie, a little part of my soul dies when I think of that. I know, I know, it's my game, and I can do what I want. But what do you folks think? Does it bug you that Borca could be destroyed? Do you think that the Core loses something with the loss of the domain, or are you for the idea?
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:23 pm
by alhoon
Personally I would have no problem if the ToUD was still "decades in the future" and not about to hit the world.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:52 pm
by Dark Angel
alhoon wrote:Personally I would have no problem if the ToUD was still "decades in the future" and not about to hit the world.
I have heard/read many complain how they want their groups to experience the Grand Conjunction and Great Upheavals for themselves and not have them summarized into a paragraph before a trip to Darkon (etc.). Having the ToUD as an upcoming event with the adventures and clues and hints that can be stretched over months and years (and decades if you desire). It allows for that flexibility and customization (or at least until the dates are canon). Leaving the adventures themselves open for exploration/goals (basically like I-6), but with the ToUD objectives that need to occur at the end.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 1:57 pm
by Zilfer
Well time can always be relative in Ravenloft.... I mean the Mists aren't fully understood. Perhaps all times exist at the same time next to eachother but are just unaware

.
I'd like to see how the ToUD goes, but I'd still want to keep playing after that.

Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2013 2:05 pm
by Dark Angel
Zilfer wrote:Well time can always be relative in Ravenloft.... I mean the Mists aren't fully understood. Perhaps all times exist at the same time next to eachother but are just unaware

.
I'd like to see how the ToUD goes, but I'd still want to keep playing after that.

Oh there would likely have to be some form of alternate ending (s) that could put the setting to rest, change it significantly, and/or keep everything on the rails. Having it be a death knell for the setting only and fans would likely drop it entirely.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 1:12 pm
by alhoon
I think the 4E approach could be "retconned" as "ToUD hit the world. Ravenloft as we know it dissolved. Then the mists started a new cycle, forming new islands in shadowfell but not a new Core yet. Here is one with a treant as a darklord."
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 2:34 pm
by Deewun
alhoon wrote:I think the 4E approach could be "retconned" as "ToUD hit the world. Ravenloft as we know it dissolved. Then the mists started a new cycle, forming new islands in shadowfell but not a new Core yet. Here is one with a treant as a darklord."
This is the best theory for 4e I've heard.
Re: Ravenloft in D&D 5E
Posted: Sun Nov 17, 2013 6:41 pm
by alhoon
Glad to be of service!
Although I hope 5e will go traditional core etc with respect of WWolf material. Pre-desolution if you want.