Page 1 of 1

How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Fri Nov 22, 2013 6:10 pm
by alhoon
I was wondering about the morals and ethos considered as right and proper in traditional Gothic horror and tales and the morals of which era they reflect better.

For example, we have this:
A man works as an executioner. He is tasked to hung a man he doesn't know that was a thief. The moment he pulls the lever he realizes from a mark on the man's face that this man is his father, that left him while he was a little child. With his last words the man curses his executioner, unrepentant for his crimes before his neck breaks.

The man to be executed is guilty of the crime he's accused for. He hasn't repent. He also abandoned his family. He's not a good fellow. The executioner didn't know he was killing his father. If the executioner didn't go on with the order to kill that man, he'd be also punished.

In modern thinking the executioner wouldn't be considered a terrible person and the curse would be unjustified.

Yet, in most gothic horror stories the act of killing one's father would be considered terrible sin whatever the circumstances and since he's coming from a bad person, along with the act of patricide, the executioner would be considered an evil person, the villain of the story. In the end, he would pay for his sins, the act of killing his father and the other crimes such an evil person would undoubtly commit. He would either face the same fate from his own children or some other calamity. And even losing his life or terrible suffering wouldn't be enough to absolve him from the "sin" of killing his (condemned and evil) father.

Another thing is that nobles aren't "by default" rightful rulers. Someone killing an evil but rightful king in 1300 would be considered the worst kind of criminal; people don't have the right to judge their king. If he wants to kill 1000 random people each day then he obviously has his reasons to do so and he has the right to do it; after all, his rule is divine.
Someone killing an evil king in 1800 would be considered a liberator. So gothic horror morals and ethos don't consider priests and monarchs as "right by default even when you don't get it".

Yet, keeping slaves around isn't considered terrible. Stripping a person from their right to decide for themselves, to define themselves, turning them to commodities to be exploited isn't considered that far fetched. Child labor is also not a taboo.
The executioner that killed a condemned criminal that happened to be his father would be a terrible person. The workshop owner that employs 5 year old orphans having them working 12 hours, providing them with food and roof and keeps a couple of slaves to look after them even if he has to discipline said kids and slaves if they perform bad isn't considered a bad person.


So... before I stray off my question, I would like to ask:
What are the proper morals and ethos in gothic stories? What is right and what is wrong?

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Sat Nov 23, 2013 12:57 am
by Boris Drakov
To truly sway the emotions of PCs in my experience means abandoning strict adherence to strict Gothic origins ethics/morals.

One must take advantage of contemporary and/or regional morals/culture to achieve true empathy with and revulsion from Ravenloft characters IMO

As the Gothic stories themselves did in implanting medieval settings with Victorian age moral quandaries.

Which is what Dracula embodied really. The clash of a feudal warrior way of thinking with then modern individualistic liberal philosophies and sentiments.

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Mon Nov 25, 2013 5:48 pm
by Mortavius
alhoon wrote:What are the proper morals and ethos in gothic stories? What is right and what is wrong?
In my games, I've always instituted an omniscient view of right and wrong. For example, premeditated murder is wrong. I had to do this way back when I played Ravenloft in 2E. I had a couple of players who wanted to play Paladins of the evil god Cyric, from Forgotten Realms. They claimed that they could do it, because in their view, what they were doing was "right and just."

After that fiasco, I put down the hammer and said "These actions are good, these actions are evil." It didn't matter what an individual thought; if an action was evil, it was evil. This was important because of things like Powers Checks, mainly.

I find once you start analyzing the subject, and getting into creating scenarios, it's very easy to go too far, and suddenly everything starts to look subjective and up for scrutiny.

It's also important to realize what kind of game you want to run? If you want your game to closely mirror historical medieval periods, then you may alter things to reflect that. With your example of questioning the king, alhoon. Default D&D doesn't have that however, and they actually portray a version of medieval fantasy through the lens of a 20th century individual. There are many examples that I won't go into that support this.

Ultimately, my games have always stuck to the default idea of the setting, with what's acceptable and what's not being either defined by directly what's in the books, or by what's acceptable in today's society.

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Mon Nov 25, 2013 6:26 pm
by Mangrum
A quick summary of every Gothic novel:

Villain:: "Good and evil are nothing more than subjective constructs."
Universe: "Bzzt! Wrong!"

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Mon Nov 25, 2013 7:48 pm
by alhoon
Yes, I agree that at least in Gothic stories there's clear right and clear wrong and good isn't subjective.
But WHAT is right in Gothic stories?

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Tue Nov 26, 2013 5:28 pm
by Alastor
There was a pretty wide range of opinions on acceptable behavior during the Victorian Era. Certainly if we use the example of child labor, a reading of Charles Dickens will show that not all the authorities of the time were in favor. We can apply our own sensibilities in most cases and still be confident that at least a few thinkers of the time would agree.
However, I think that Gothic literature deliberately adopts a harsher standard than the author (or DM) would in everyday life, and rightly so. If we agree that the villains truly deserve all their sufferings, it robs their stories of the tragic element which helps to make them compelling.

Re: How certain things are (right/wrong) in Gothic horror?

Posted: Tue Nov 26, 2013 10:05 pm
by alhoon
Not a bad take, that's perhaps why I like them.