Talk:Crumble - Revision history

DeepShadow at 06:38, 1 February 2010

2010-02-01T06:38:59Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 00:38, 1 February 2010
Line 6:		Line 6:

	:I hear you. Still, some of these "specs" are painfully obvious, so much so that we'd have to stick a sign up to keep people from editing them. Like [[Anthrazit Brew]]. The original said it was a vodka brewed from Ghastrian grains. If I wrote that, I'd actually be _grateful_ to the editor who came along and pointed out that vodka is made from potatoes. Here's my idea: we say that these are derived from the list on Alanik's site, and point people to that list, maybe even have a link. Then we include a note that, this being a wiki, it may not exactly resemble the original. Thus, the authors get credit, the wiki gets to be a living text like its supposed to be, and no one has to put "potatoes" in spec brackets when we all know that's how you get vodka. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 05:47, 1 February 2010 (UTC)		:I hear you. Still, some of these "specs" are painfully obvious, so much so that we'd have to stick a sign up to keep people from editing them. Like [[Anthrazit Brew]]. The original said it was a vodka brewed from Ghastrian grains. If I wrote that, I'd actually be _grateful_ to the editor who came along and pointed out that vodka is made from potatoes. Here's my idea: we say that these are derived from the list on Alanik's site, and point people to that list, maybe even have a link. Then we include a note that, this being a wiki, it may not exactly resemble the original. Thus, the authors get credit, the wiki gets to be a living text like its supposed to be, and no one has to put "potatoes" in spec brackets when we all know that's how you get vodka. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 05:47, 1 February 2010 (UTC)

			Okay, now I'm editing all of them to add the citations, and I think not having a citation is enough here to suggest it's not part of the original. I prefer that to putting spec brackets in an entry that's already non-canon. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 06:38, 1 February 2010 (UTC)

DeepShadow at 05:48, 1 February 2010

2010-02-01T05:48:43Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:48, 31 January 2010
Line 5:		Line 5:
	Also, if it's from Alanik Ray's archives, it's probably a good idea to cite it. Added -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)		Also, if it's from Alanik Ray's archives, it's probably a good idea to cite it. Added -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)

	:I hear you. Still, some of these "specs" are painfully obvious, so much so that we'd have to stick a sign up to keep people from editing them. Like Anthrazit Brew. The original said it was a vodka brewed from Ghastrian grains. If I wrote that, I'd actually be _grateful_ to the editor who came along and pointed out that vodka is made from potatoes. Here's my idea: we say that these are derived from the list on Alanik's site, and point people to that list, maybe even have a link. Then we include a note that, this being a wiki, it may not exactly resemble the original. Thus, the authors get credit, the wiki gets to be a living text like its supposed to be, and no one has to put "potatoes" in spec brackets when we all know that's how you get vodka. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 05:47, 1 February 2010 (UTC)		:I hear you. Still, some of these "specs" are painfully obvious, so much so that we'd have to stick a sign up to keep people from editing them. Like [[Anthrazit Brew]]. The original said it was a vodka brewed from Ghastrian grains. If I wrote that, I'd actually be _grateful_ to the editor who came along and pointed out that vodka is made from potatoes. Here's my idea: we say that these are derived from the list on Alanik's site, and point people to that list, maybe even have a link. Then we include a note that, this being a wiki, it may not exactly resemble the original. Thus, the authors get credit, the wiki gets to be a living text like its supposed to be, and no one has to put "potatoes" in spec brackets when we all know that's how you get vodka. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 05:47, 1 February 2010 (UTC)

DeepShadow at 05:47, 1 February 2010

2010-02-01T05:47:55Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 23:47, 31 January 2010
Line 4:		Line 4:

	Also, if it's from Alanik Ray's archives, it's probably a good idea to cite it. Added -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)		Also, if it's from Alanik Ray's archives, it's probably a good idea to cite it. Added -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)

			:I hear you. Still, some of these "specs" are painfully obvious, so much so that we'd have to stick a sign up to keep people from editing them. Like Anthrazit Brew. The original said it was a vodka brewed from Ghastrian grains. If I wrote that, I'd actually be _grateful_ to the editor who came along and pointed out that vodka is made from potatoes. Here's my idea: we say that these are derived from the list on Alanik's site, and point people to that list, maybe even have a link. Then we include a note that, this being a wiki, it may not exactly resemble the original. Thus, the authors get credit, the wiki gets to be a living text like its supposed to be, and no one has to put "potatoes" in spec brackets when we all know that's how you get vodka. [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 05:47, 1 February 2010 (UTC)

Gonzoron at 04:23, 31 January 2010

2010-01-31T04:23:21Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:23, 30 January 2010
Line 1:		Line 1:
	I feel odd putting Spec lines in a homebrew entry, but it's not my homebrew. It's from Alanik Ray's archives. If my thoughts are as non-canon as the original, should I delineate it this way? [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 02:30, 31 January 2010 (UTC)		I feel odd putting Spec lines in a homebrew entry, but it's not my homebrew. It's from Alanik Ray's archives. If my thoughts are as non-canon as the original, should I delineate it this way? [[User:DeepShadow\|DeepShadow]] 02:30, 31 January 2010 (UTC)

			:Man, if I only knew the kind of hairs we'd have to split around here.... I'd have brought a sharper scalpel. :) I dunno... I guess it doesn't hurt to label it. I mean, suppose someone edited an entry on something of yours, say something about [[Kara's Daughters]]. You'd probably appreciate that the speculation was labelled as such, no? -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)

			Also, if it's from Alanik Ray's archives, it's probably a good idea to cite it. Added -- [[User:Gonzoron\|Gonzoron]] 04:23, 31 January 2010 (UTC)

DeepShadow: Created page with 'I feel odd putting Spec lines in a homebrew entry, but it's not my homebrew. It's from Alanik Ray's archives. If my thoughts are as non-canon as the original, should I delineat…'

2010-01-31T02:30:00Z

Created page with 'I feel odd putting Spec lines in a homebrew entry, but it's not my homebrew. It's from Alanik Ray's archives. If my thoughts are as non-canon as the original, should I delineat…'

New page

I feel odd putting Spec lines in a homebrew entry, but it's not my homebrew. It's from Alanik Ray's archives. If my thoughts are as non-canon as the original, should I delineate it this way? [[User:DeepShadow|DeepShadow]] 02:30, 31 January 2010 (UTC)