I think part of the issue there is, that people are coming to grips with the idea that if this book isn't for them, the book for them will never exist. It's easy to say "this one's not for me" when there are 10 more coming down the pike that might be. (No matter how much someone hated Champions of Darkness, hey Gaz II came out 2 months later, and VRGttWD two months after that.) But if you're an old-school Ravenloft fan who's been hoping for a revival that picks up where old-school left off, this book, the one singular book that's been announced, the clear break from the past, is a signal that your hopes will not be met by this book, nor any other book in the future. This is 5th edition Ravenloft now, for the remainder of the time 5th edition has left. 6th edition or later Ravenloft, if it exists, might ignore 5th, but it's not going back to 3rd. The 3e version will only ever be continued by fan-made stuff, here, on dmsguild, and elsewhere online.Jonathan Winters wrote:I was ''talking'' with James Lowder on FB earlier this week and what some people need to remember is that, because a / this book might not be for you, does not mean it is a bad book.
I've come to terms with that, which is part of the reason for my optimism on the book as it is, on it's own merits. I have no illusions that the perfect book for me would ever be made, so I'm interested to see what the new twist is.