Smothering of Reason/incorporeality (author's intention)
Smothering of Reason/incorporeality (author's intention)
I had occasion recently to go back and read attentively the description of the Smothering of Reason Dread Possibility for Lamordia. Basically it will eventually cancel out any continuous supernatural effect which entails, as I read it, that no incorporeal undead lasts for long in Lamordia (2% chance per day of winking out of existence until the smothering ends).
Parsing out how this effects a ghost is more complex. Manifestation is a supernatural effect but it is not continuous and even if it were cancelled by the smothering a ghost could just try again. When a ghost does manage to manifest it becomes incorporeal. So a ghost that remains manifest for a sufficient period of time will be winked out . . . only to return again. But isn't etherealness a continuous supernatural ability too? Looking it up, it is actually an extraordinary ability, as is an incorporeal creature's ability to fly.
Magic items? An antimagic shell puts them out of action and the Smothering of Reason is described in terms of an antimagic shell.
Depending on how one reads it, a ghoul or a lycanthrope might lose its 'continuous' supernatural ability to pass on its disease while remaining in the domain. Alter Form is a supernatural ability too but not a continuous one. Still its cancelling at an inopportune time poses a problem, although more for a wolfwere that reverts to a wolf than for a werewolf that reverts to a man.
More clearly it should be a race to see if the Mummy Rot or Ghoul Fever kills a carrier entering Lamordia before the smothering winks the supernatural disease out of existence. You can almost hear the Lamordian presses churning out the health spa brochures. The Plagian viri should be essentially inexistant in the domain.
(When is damage reduction, particularly damage reduction/magic, a supernatural ability?)
Yes, it is 'just' a Dread Possibility. And yes, the write up invites the DM to consider the effects rather than just applying them inconsideredly. But that is exactly what I am trying to do.
Personally, I like the idea of a Lamordia with very few instances of the 'supposed supernatural horrors' that are so popular in the 'folklore' of less modern nations.
Rotipher takes the opposite tact:
"This seems so heavy-handed, and so restrictive, I'd be more inclined to interpret the DreadPoss as saying that critters with continuous supernatural abilities must roll every 24 hours, to see if their powers work on a given day or not. By this interpretation, their Su abilities wouldn't be treated as singular effects that last indefinitely (in which case, one suppression by Reason would snuff them out forever), but as repeated discrete effects with a 24-hour duration, that are automatically re-activated each day.
By that mechanism, an incorporeal spirit would have a 2% chance of vanishing each day, only to reappear 24 hours later. A victim of mummy rot or lycanthropy would have a 2% chance of suffering no ill effects on a given day, rather than being granted a Get-Out-Of-Curse-Free card. A dread doppelganger in Lamordia would have a 2% chance of reverting to its true form for a day, but would probably regain its shapechanging ability 24 hours later (if it isn't lynched in the meantime), and so on.
That way, you aren't forced to exclude all supernatural menaces from the domain (save those spawned in laboratories) in order to utilize the "Smothering of Reason" option. Heck, it even permits the use of the "Wolves of the Sea" DreadPoss in the same campaign, which would be impossible otherwise: Rudolf and his pals would all revert to human form and freeze to death in the icy waters, if their supernatural abilities were indefinitely suppressed."
For my part, I am curious whether I am reading correctly the DP as written.
Equally, I am curious what the author, if available, intended. (Yes, that is the intentional fallacy.) Perhaps there has been a slip of the pen that needs fixing or perhaps not.
And finally I am curious what others think on the matter.
Parsing out how this effects a ghost is more complex. Manifestation is a supernatural effect but it is not continuous and even if it were cancelled by the smothering a ghost could just try again. When a ghost does manage to manifest it becomes incorporeal. So a ghost that remains manifest for a sufficient period of time will be winked out . . . only to return again. But isn't etherealness a continuous supernatural ability too? Looking it up, it is actually an extraordinary ability, as is an incorporeal creature's ability to fly.
Magic items? An antimagic shell puts them out of action and the Smothering of Reason is described in terms of an antimagic shell.
Depending on how one reads it, a ghoul or a lycanthrope might lose its 'continuous' supernatural ability to pass on its disease while remaining in the domain. Alter Form is a supernatural ability too but not a continuous one. Still its cancelling at an inopportune time poses a problem, although more for a wolfwere that reverts to a wolf than for a werewolf that reverts to a man.
More clearly it should be a race to see if the Mummy Rot or Ghoul Fever kills a carrier entering Lamordia before the smothering winks the supernatural disease out of existence. You can almost hear the Lamordian presses churning out the health spa brochures. The Plagian viri should be essentially inexistant in the domain.
(When is damage reduction, particularly damage reduction/magic, a supernatural ability?)
Yes, it is 'just' a Dread Possibility. And yes, the write up invites the DM to consider the effects rather than just applying them inconsideredly. But that is exactly what I am trying to do.
Personally, I like the idea of a Lamordia with very few instances of the 'supposed supernatural horrors' that are so popular in the 'folklore' of less modern nations.
Rotipher takes the opposite tact:
"This seems so heavy-handed, and so restrictive, I'd be more inclined to interpret the DreadPoss as saying that critters with continuous supernatural abilities must roll every 24 hours, to see if their powers work on a given day or not. By this interpretation, their Su abilities wouldn't be treated as singular effects that last indefinitely (in which case, one suppression by Reason would snuff them out forever), but as repeated discrete effects with a 24-hour duration, that are automatically re-activated each day.
By that mechanism, an incorporeal spirit would have a 2% chance of vanishing each day, only to reappear 24 hours later. A victim of mummy rot or lycanthropy would have a 2% chance of suffering no ill effects on a given day, rather than being granted a Get-Out-Of-Curse-Free card. A dread doppelganger in Lamordia would have a 2% chance of reverting to its true form for a day, but would probably regain its shapechanging ability 24 hours later (if it isn't lynched in the meantime), and so on.
That way, you aren't forced to exclude all supernatural menaces from the domain (save those spawned in laboratories) in order to utilize the "Smothering of Reason" option. Heck, it even permits the use of the "Wolves of the Sea" DreadPoss in the same campaign, which would be impossible otherwise: Rudolf and his pals would all revert to human form and freeze to death in the icy waters, if their supernatural abilities were indefinitely suppressed."
For my part, I am curious whether I am reading correctly the DP as written.
Equally, I am curious what the author, if available, intended. (Yes, that is the intentional fallacy.) Perhaps there has been a slip of the pen that needs fixing or perhaps not.
And finally I am curious what others think on the matter.
The cure for what ails you
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
I can't help you with the author's true intent, but neglecting crunch for the moment, and focusing on fluff, the way I read it is this:
"It's an interesting possibility that Mordenheim's devotion to science over magic is reflected in the domain having the property of hindering magic effects"
And I agree with that.
But I also agree with Rotipher, that no domain should be complete one-note. I like the possibility of Lamordian ghosts, dopps, etc. And we also know from canon sources that lycanthropes do exist there and seem to have no problems. (The aforementioned sea wolves, as well as Ivan Dragonov)
So the solution lies in finding a decent middle-ground in terms of crunch to match the fluff. The existing rule is obviously troublesome, not to mention not very "d20-ish". Perhaps a Will save of some sort to overcome the smothering? rather than a percentile chance.
"It's an interesting possibility that Mordenheim's devotion to science over magic is reflected in the domain having the property of hindering magic effects"
And I agree with that.
But I also agree with Rotipher, that no domain should be complete one-note. I like the possibility of Lamordian ghosts, dopps, etc. And we also know from canon sources that lycanthropes do exist there and seem to have no problems. (The aforementioned sea wolves, as well as Ivan Dragonov)
So the solution lies in finding a decent middle-ground in terms of crunch to match the fluff. The existing rule is obviously troublesome, not to mention not very "d20-ish". Perhaps a Will save of some sort to overcome the smothering? rather than a percentile chance.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Just for another possible spin on the idea of incorporeals in Lamordia, it's very likely that "One Piece At A Time", GenCon 1999's Ravenloft play, is set in that realm. (The female golem-maker in the story makes use of electrical switches, and the presence of conventional D&D adventurers makes it unlikely to be Gothic Earth.) Thanks to brothersale, we have a copy of the script available on this thread:
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=5757
Several ghosts appear in the skit, but these murder victims are invisible to anyone but each other (and the audience). They linger in the area for weeks, linked to the golem built from their own body parts, without being annihilated by the Smothering Of Reason. They aren't able to manifest themselves to the living, but the golem can hear them, and his stitched-together body eventually falls under their control.
So perhaps one way to split the difference, where incorporeals are concerned, would be to restrict their ability to manifest in or affect the material world. This would ensure that they remain undetected by the majority of Lamordia's inhabitants (save those with Ghostsight), and feed Mordenheim's bull-headed conviction that such spirits do not exist. They wouldn't actually be "snuffed out", however, even if they're demoted to powerless geists when the Smothering suppresses their presence. That preserves their potential use as a plot-device for DMs, and would allow a PC with ghost-related powers to visit Lamordia without being too severely handicapped.
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=5757
Several ghosts appear in the skit, but these murder victims are invisible to anyone but each other (and the audience). They linger in the area for weeks, linked to the golem built from their own body parts, without being annihilated by the Smothering Of Reason. They aren't able to manifest themselves to the living, but the golem can hear them, and his stitched-together body eventually falls under their control.
So perhaps one way to split the difference, where incorporeals are concerned, would be to restrict their ability to manifest in or affect the material world. This would ensure that they remain undetected by the majority of Lamordia's inhabitants (save those with Ghostsight), and feed Mordenheim's bull-headed conviction that such spirits do not exist. They wouldn't actually be "snuffed out", however, even if they're demoted to powerless geists when the Smothering suppresses their presence. That preserves their potential use as a plot-device for DMs, and would allow a PC with ghost-related powers to visit Lamordia without being too severely handicapped.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Unfortunately, the DrPoss describes the SoR effect as being like that of an Antimagic Field. That spell's effect on incorporeal creatures lasts as long as the Field overlaps the creature's location at the time it was first exposed. As Lamordia (i.e. the Field) is stationary, that implies the effect is either permanent or of 24 hours' duration, depending on how you read the DrPoss.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
For ghosts at least it is not a significant problem. They can hang around in ethereal form indefinitely. It is only very occassionally that their attempt to manifest will fail or their ongoing manifestation will be cancelled out. Whereupon they can (perhaps after an appropriate delay) attempt to manifest once more. Likewise, the doppelganger, if not yet lynched, can attempt to reassume its disguise.gonzoron wrote:I like the possibility of Lamordian ghosts, dopps, etc. And we also know from canon sources that lycanthropes do exist there and seem to have no problems. (The aforementioned sea wolves, as well as Ivan Dragonov)
The issue bites for those undead froze in an incorporeal existence for once that existence is gone they are gone. A Lamordia mostly devoid of such undead is one I actually like. Ghosts are quite sufficient.
Unfortunately the dread disease likewise falls afoul of the smothering and we know that there are lycanthropes living happily in the land. Do we know, however, whether they are succesfully spreading the dread disease itself? Since it is that which would be impacted most significantly. Like the doppleganger who hasn't yet been lynched, they can attempt to reassume a shape that they have been shunted out of.
Mudding the waters further, Mordenheim is no stranger to lycanthropy, having transplanted (rather implausibly) wereboar organs into a party so as to bend them to his will. (This is from the module Adam's Wrath.) Even reinterpreting this as a bluff on the part of the doctor, he is still dabbling with supernatural effects that he doesn't believe in . . . . The obvious solution is for him to maintain that there is nothing supernatural about lycanthropy, but then why would it be surpressed?
Last edited by cure on Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
The cure for what ails you
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Perhaps it's not suppressed, due to Mordenheim's belief (possibly one he's shared with Horstman?) that it's an organic disorder rather than a supernatural one. This would be an exception to the DrPoss's rule that all supernatural abilities are affected, offering another excuse for why Dragonov (an infected lycanthrope) hasn't been cured by his time spent in Lamordia, and why those seawolves haven't reverted at sea and turned into human-form popsicles.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Canon is certainly on your side. And presumably the good doctor doesn't have any ectoplasm tucked away in his lab as part of his research into the biology of what the superstitious stupidly imagine are spirits. Then again, he could. What in fact, aside from gods, does Mordenheim not believe in according to canon? Sadly, I don't have the novel. The problem with the standard answer of seeing 'magic' as but instances of as yet unexplained natural phenomena is that there is then no grounds for its suppression either.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Perhaps it's not suppressed, due to Mordenheim's belief (possibly one he's shared with Horstman?) that it's an organic disorder rather than a supernatural one. This would be an exception to the DrPoss's rule that all supernatural abilities are affected, offering another excuse for why Dragonov (an infected lycanthrope) hasn't been cured by his time spent in Lamordia, and why those seawolves haven't reverted at sea and turned into human-form popsicles.
All of which brought Nathan's refrain back to mind: "I've said so before and I'll say so again, most likely--in a place where magic really works according to rational principles (i.e., if you chant the same five words and flick some bat guano at a guy it always creates a fireball), "magic" is itself a science. Lamordia is obviously a special case, because the modern bifurcation between "magic" and "science" is a foundation of the domain[.]"
Which itself invites the question of what Mordenheim thinks when confronted with a feat of magic?
The cure for what ails you
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Lamordians in general believe magic is some sort of a nautral phenomena that has yet to be explained. Mordenheim no doubt shares that opinion. When he sees magic in use I imagine he equates it to a child fiddling with electricity; they're fooling around with something they know nothing about.cure wrote:Which itself invites the question of what Mordenheim thinks when confronted with a feat of magic?
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
This is interesting, from Gaz I's description of Mordenheim: "Mordenheim studied the sciences, both natural and arcane. He soon disdained magic, however, deeming it a diversion from the Truth." (p. 151)
Also interesting for a man who denies the gods and presumably curses: "He is a fearless man . . . . Victor's confidence stems from his link to Adam: he cannot die until Adam dies with him." (p. 153)
Equally, the Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens "believes wholeheartedly in the supernatural but holds that it is a force of chaos and destruction that must be eradicated." (p. 79)
Further, Lamordians "outright deny the existence of magic and unnatural creatures or - more commonly - dismiss them as natural phenomena for which there are not yet elucidated scientific principles. Those who dabble in such 'preternatural' forces without truly understanding them, such as wizards, are akin to savages playing with gunpowder." (p. 72)
And on religion, Lamordians "subtly chide clerics and devout layfolk, speaking to them as they would to foolish children. No organised faiths . . . have so far penetrated Lamordian rationality." (p. 74)
Lastly from the Smothering of Reason itself, "the cold rationalism in which Victor Mordenheim put his faith has begun to infect Lamordia like a plague. It has settled not only over the minds of the Lamordians, but into the very fabric of the land itself." (p. 73)
Also interesting for a man who denies the gods and presumably curses: "He is a fearless man . . . . Victor's confidence stems from his link to Adam: he cannot die until Adam dies with him." (p. 153)
Equally, the Syndicate of Enlightened Citizens "believes wholeheartedly in the supernatural but holds that it is a force of chaos and destruction that must be eradicated." (p. 79)
Further, Lamordians "outright deny the existence of magic and unnatural creatures or - more commonly - dismiss them as natural phenomena for which there are not yet elucidated scientific principles. Those who dabble in such 'preternatural' forces without truly understanding them, such as wizards, are akin to savages playing with gunpowder." (p. 72)
And on religion, Lamordians "subtly chide clerics and devout layfolk, speaking to them as they would to foolish children. No organised faiths . . . have so far penetrated Lamordian rationality." (p. 74)
Lastly from the Smothering of Reason itself, "the cold rationalism in which Victor Mordenheim put his faith has begun to infect Lamordia like a plague. It has settled not only over the minds of the Lamordians, but into the very fabric of the land itself." (p. 73)
The cure for what ails you
So Lamordian rationalism comes in different flavours:
-Propaganda (vulgar rationalism) - magic, ghosts, werebeasts and their ilk are groundless myth - view held and spread by the least educated and experienced;
-Empiricism (exploratory rationalism) - nature is a sea, both broad and deep, and although we shall one day have the complete measure of it, until that time phenomena that are not unfathomable, but rather have to be fathomed, are to be expected and even sought out - view held by the curious and educated.
-Idealism (crusading rationalism) - the beauty of law governed nature is threatened by the chaos of the supernatural, so the sword must be taken up in defense of nature and her cycles - view held by the powerful who fear a challenge to the status quo.
-Mastery (modern rationalism) - no phenomena is to exist that defies understanding in terms of scientific principle and control by means of technological manipulation - view held by Mordenheim (as well as by Galileo and Descartes, although Mordenheim is a far more consistent atheist about it).
Notice that mastery includes elements of exploratory rationalism, not closing its eyes to superrnatural seeming phenomena, and of crusading rationalism, being determined to root out the supernatural by unmasking it as nature confusedly understood. What is distinct, however, is that to the extent that a phenomena defies mastery by reason, reason retaliates by calling into question its very existence. That calling into question of the very existence of the unfathomable is precisely the Smothering of Reason.
So what Mordenheim most fears as being beyond the reach of reason, he wishes out of existence and, by fiat of the Dark Powers, it indeed is, albeit to a small degree, wiped from existence.
Clearly Mordenheim fears failure in his work. That work is to create and recreate life, which is the preserve of the gods. And it is a preserve into which the cleric is an invited. and the wizard, is an uninvited guest. Mordenheim wishes that divine and arcane magic did not exist, fearing that it weilds power over life and death that is foreclosed to science and fearing that he made the wrong choice in spurning that greater power in favour of the lesser power of science.
Mordenheim clearly does not think that lycanthropy lies beyond the pale of science, so does not fear it as a danger to the empire of science, and hence does not unconsciously wish that it not exist.
As to incorporeal undead, who can say?
So perhaps the following change, in brackets, to the Smothering of Reason "any spell, spell-like effect, or [scientifically unaccounted for] supernatural effect has a 2% chance of being suppressed." A phenomena for which Mordenheim lacks a sound scientific theory is scientifically unaccounted for. Evidently this is in the end up to the DM. But there can be two guiding principles: modern science & Mordenheim's fields of interest. It is a relatively short leap from a single body of research on electricity, which includes arcing and ball lightning, to will-o-wisps. Whereas it is a relatively large leap from multiple bodies of research to get to an incorpereal undead from the various evidences of its haunting. Equally, Mordenheim has thoroughly researched electricity, but probably hasn't researched insubstantiality. So if there is a not wholly implausible scientific path to a monster and if that path is one that Mordenheim is likely to know, then it and its powers fit and are not smothered.
-Propaganda (vulgar rationalism) - magic, ghosts, werebeasts and their ilk are groundless myth - view held and spread by the least educated and experienced;
-Empiricism (exploratory rationalism) - nature is a sea, both broad and deep, and although we shall one day have the complete measure of it, until that time phenomena that are not unfathomable, but rather have to be fathomed, are to be expected and even sought out - view held by the curious and educated.
-Idealism (crusading rationalism) - the beauty of law governed nature is threatened by the chaos of the supernatural, so the sword must be taken up in defense of nature and her cycles - view held by the powerful who fear a challenge to the status quo.
-Mastery (modern rationalism) - no phenomena is to exist that defies understanding in terms of scientific principle and control by means of technological manipulation - view held by Mordenheim (as well as by Galileo and Descartes, although Mordenheim is a far more consistent atheist about it).
Notice that mastery includes elements of exploratory rationalism, not closing its eyes to superrnatural seeming phenomena, and of crusading rationalism, being determined to root out the supernatural by unmasking it as nature confusedly understood. What is distinct, however, is that to the extent that a phenomena defies mastery by reason, reason retaliates by calling into question its very existence. That calling into question of the very existence of the unfathomable is precisely the Smothering of Reason.
So what Mordenheim most fears as being beyond the reach of reason, he wishes out of existence and, by fiat of the Dark Powers, it indeed is, albeit to a small degree, wiped from existence.
Clearly Mordenheim fears failure in his work. That work is to create and recreate life, which is the preserve of the gods. And it is a preserve into which the cleric is an invited. and the wizard, is an uninvited guest. Mordenheim wishes that divine and arcane magic did not exist, fearing that it weilds power over life and death that is foreclosed to science and fearing that he made the wrong choice in spurning that greater power in favour of the lesser power of science.
Mordenheim clearly does not think that lycanthropy lies beyond the pale of science, so does not fear it as a danger to the empire of science, and hence does not unconsciously wish that it not exist.
As to incorporeal undead, who can say?
So perhaps the following change, in brackets, to the Smothering of Reason "any spell, spell-like effect, or [scientifically unaccounted for] supernatural effect has a 2% chance of being suppressed." A phenomena for which Mordenheim lacks a sound scientific theory is scientifically unaccounted for. Evidently this is in the end up to the DM. But there can be two guiding principles: modern science & Mordenheim's fields of interest. It is a relatively short leap from a single body of research on electricity, which includes arcing and ball lightning, to will-o-wisps. Whereas it is a relatively large leap from multiple bodies of research to get to an incorpereal undead from the various evidences of its haunting. Equally, Mordenheim has thoroughly researched electricity, but probably hasn't researched insubstantiality. So if there is a not wholly implausible scientific path to a monster and if that path is one that Mordenheim is likely to know, then it and its powers fit and are not smothered.
Last edited by cure on Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:04 am, edited 6 times in total.
The cure for what ails you
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
My Lamordia doesn't have all those werebeasts. The horrors of Lamordia are freakish products of the good Doktor's laboratory, dread golems created through obesssion [and not just flesh golems, mind you], wild animals, dangerous criminals, etc. Oozes are a real threat, one of which the local trappers and scouts are well aware, and take precautions against. Stepping into a black pudding hidden in a pool of stagnant water, or running across a white pudding in a snow bank are decidely unpleasnat experiences!
IMC Ivan Dragunov doesn't exist. He's a bit too epic for my purposes.
I've done a little with Lamordia in the background notes section of my campaign. Here's some of it:
Lamordia:
IMC, Lamordians tend to fall into one of three schools of thought about the 'origins of the world' question. These are:
Watchmakers, who believe that gods created the world, but have nothing to do with it now, as it runs itself.
Nebulogenesists, who hold that the Mists are the pre-existent primal substance of the universe, and everything in existence formed out of them through eons of natural processes. This is the prevailing scientific view, by a slim margin.
Skeptics, who believe that current data are insufficent to draw any conclusions about the orgins of the universe or the existence of gods and an afterlife. This is most popular with the cafe set in Neufurctenburg.
As for the way they view ''supernatural'' phenomena, here's one approach:
Gasists:
Some Lamordian scientists believe that ghosts and other incorporeal beings are actually just gas-based lifeforms native to the Mists. These aeroforms can therefore be trapped inside bottles....theoretically.
IMC Ivan Dragunov doesn't exist. He's a bit too epic for my purposes.
I've done a little with Lamordia in the background notes section of my campaign. Here's some of it:
Lamordia:
IMC, Lamordians tend to fall into one of three schools of thought about the 'origins of the world' question. These are:
Watchmakers, who believe that gods created the world, but have nothing to do with it now, as it runs itself.
Nebulogenesists, who hold that the Mists are the pre-existent primal substance of the universe, and everything in existence formed out of them through eons of natural processes. This is the prevailing scientific view, by a slim margin.
Skeptics, who believe that current data are insufficent to draw any conclusions about the orgins of the universe or the existence of gods and an afterlife. This is most popular with the cafe set in Neufurctenburg.
As for the way they view ''supernatural'' phenomena, here's one approach:
Gasists:
Some Lamordian scientists believe that ghosts and other incorporeal beings are actually just gas-based lifeforms native to the Mists. These aeroforms can therefore be trapped inside bottles....theoretically.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
- A G Thing
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1216
- Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
- Gender: Female
- Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan
I just recently purchased a copy of Mordenhiem from a remainderd book store and read it through.
In it Mordenhiem starts under the belief that these "frauds" have no power but is willing to desperately beg for assistence from the two "Necromancers". When seeing proof of power he begins to rationalize it with metaphysics and begins to see it as an unrefined science steeped in ignorance and ritual superstitions.
Then at the end when he is betrayed he believes it to be a corrupt and chaotic force controled by cruel whim and regrets ever placing faith into it at all.
From this I can interpret that he only accepts the truths that are convinent to his use and he will rationalize anything that he wants to bring it under his understanding. By having knowledge of a thing you have power over it is his seeming belief and when he cannot explain something he sees it as false or fraudulent.
Smothering of Reason based on the interpretations of Mordenhiem from the novel seem to suggest that he views these things as unrefined fakes or undependable quirks and he feels that tested and proven science is more sound. I suggest possibly that Rotipher may be more accurate on some level. I say the first time the continuous magic item or supernatural ability is attempted to be used infront of a lamordian citizen in that 24 hrs the 2% should be rolled and if it is rolled then the ability should be suppressed for 24 hrs or so. Spells and spell like abilities as well as one use items and spell completion items such as potions or scrolls should just have a 2% spell failure chance rolled at the time of use or be wasted with no effect.
In it Mordenhiem starts under the belief that these "frauds" have no power but is willing to desperately beg for assistence from the two "Necromancers". When seeing proof of power he begins to rationalize it with metaphysics and begins to see it as an unrefined science steeped in ignorance and ritual superstitions.
Then at the end when he is betrayed he believes it to be a corrupt and chaotic force controled by cruel whim and regrets ever placing faith into it at all.
From this I can interpret that he only accepts the truths that are convinent to his use and he will rationalize anything that he wants to bring it under his understanding. By having knowledge of a thing you have power over it is his seeming belief and when he cannot explain something he sees it as false or fraudulent.
Smothering of Reason based on the interpretations of Mordenhiem from the novel seem to suggest that he views these things as unrefined fakes or undependable quirks and he feels that tested and proven science is more sound. I suggest possibly that Rotipher may be more accurate on some level. I say the first time the continuous magic item or supernatural ability is attempted to be used infront of a lamordian citizen in that 24 hrs the 2% should be rolled and if it is rolled then the ability should be suppressed for 24 hrs or so. Spells and spell like abilities as well as one use items and spell completion items such as potions or scrolls should just have a 2% spell failure chance rolled at the time of use or be wasted with no effect.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
So Mordenheim's first instinct is a prejudice against what does not immediately fit into his world view. But there is either enough uncertainty in his world view or/and there is enough empiricism in his rationalism that he can be persuaded by events to take a second look.A G Thing wrote:Mordenhiem starts under the belief that these "frauds" have no power but is willing to desperately beg for assistence from the two "Necromancers".
A G Thing wrote:When seeing proof of power he begins to rationalize it with metaphysics and begins to see it as an unrefined science steeped in ignorance and ritual superstitions.
Once Mordenheim has seen for himself that something beyond the current pale of his world view indeed exists, he immediately sets about stripping away its foreigness and in particular its pretensions of belonging to a different and rival worldview, such that it can be incorporated into his own worldview with little or no real change to that worldview. This is to say that his own worldview is always the True description of things, and the rival and different worldview which at a glance might seem to offer the better account of the phenomena, is a confused and unhelpful distortion of the Truth.
Once the phenomena fails to behave as it should in his worldview and in fact that behaviour lends credience rather to the rival and different world view, the phenomena earns his condemnation as being that should not be. He may tell himself that his understanding has simply yet to master it, but his unconscious knows better and wishes it out of existence. And the Dark Powers indulge that subconscious wish in terms of the Smothering of Reason.A G Thing wrote:Then at the end when he is betrayed he believes it to be a corrupt and chaotic force controled by cruel whim and regrets ever placing faith into it at all.
From canon then we know that Mordenheim seems to have an untroubled relationship with lycanthropy and Lamordia harbours lycanthropes, so the doctor clearly thinks that he has a good scientific handle upon the dread disease and wishes it no ill. (Perhaps were he ever to set out to cure it, he might discover otherwise and his attitude toward it would change.) Spells and magic items, on the contrary, have presumably never ceased to resist his attempts to neatly lock them away within his worldview, and in particular have resisted his attempts to command reliably their effects on the basis of that world view, and consequently he wishes they would not exist leading to their suppression.
If this approach is right, then for something to be suppressed, it must have attracted Mordenheim's attention and ultimately defied imprisonment within his rationalism. Incorporeal undead then may escape supression by dint of Mordenheim never having been obliged in the first place to admit their existence. Alternatively, and very unlikely I would say, he may have what he considers to be a perfectly sound scientific theory as to their true nature and as such they again escape suppression.
The cure for what ails you
