Does anyone play (or have played) 3.5 e6?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

Well, everything seems fine, balanced, and interesting (Especially the article about Aragorn and Einstein being no more than 5th level), it is like the initial idea the people at WotC were promoting when they launched D&D 4E (i.e. Keeping the sweet spot of level advancement), and it seems perfectly fitted for RL, even though I can already hear my players ranting about it...

The only problem I have with it is purely a matter of conception: I don't like telling my players that they have an uppermost limit (Especially so low a limit), and that they won't be able to advance after that. I know you will be able to get new feats, but somehow it's a poor exchange, and it somehow seems as it would take some of the excitement out of the table (You've got to admit it: Gaining levels is FUN).

So, even though I'm not all-against it, as Jester seems, I would also be tempted to space-out the levels, perhaps by increasing the XP cost for each level, or perhaps by adding "in-between" levels, as Jester suggested (Maybe with those added benefits), perhaps even stretching that 1-6 levels into the 1-20 spectrum, but that would be another game entirely, and that would need a lot of extra work.
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

The only problem I have with it is purely a matter of conception: I don't like telling my players that they have an uppermost limit (Especially so low a limit), and that they won't be able to advance after that. I know you will be able to get new feats, but somehow it's a poor exchange, and it somehow seems as it would take some of the excitement out of the table (You've got to admit it: Gaining levels is FUN).
I agree.

I don't think it is something that you can spring on them mid game.

I think they have to design characters with it in mind.

I've yet to play it but I have a feeling that players would actually really like it. There wouldn't be this feeling that they have to get insanely more powerful to start mattering in the world.

When the world's greatest heroes are level 6 the players will feel that they can be great heroes too - and they don't have to become gods first.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

WolfKook wrote:Well, everything seems fine, balanced, and interesting (Especially the article about Aragorn and Einstein being no more than 5th level),
Where is this? I'd like to read that.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

WolfKook wrote:So, even though I'm not all-against it, as Jester seems, I would also be tempted to space-out the levels, perhaps by increasing the XP cost for each level, or perhaps by adding "in-between" levels, as Jester suggested (Maybe with those added benefits), perhaps even stretching that 1-6 levels into the 1-20 spectrum, but that would be another game entirely, and that would need a lot of extra work.
I'm not so much against it as think it's odd on insisting on using a game system that's obviously not meeting your needs.
The d20 system is flexible and it should be customized to be what you want, but there is this critical mass when the amount of customization becomes a new game system on its own, at which point it might be time to move. When you're setting out to only use less than 1/3rd of the resources, rules, or content of the game you're just not getting much bang for your buck.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Troile wrote:
My first thought is: why keep playing?
Make some new characters, start again.
You keep advancing past 6th level, just with feats. I would say your end point would be around +10 feats to +20 feats.

The story rewards would be there, the characters would still be accomplishing things. We ensure each character has a specific motivation and/or goal in mind.

So the answer to your question would be...when they've reached their goals.
One thing to remember is that it is still a game. There's a heavy element of shared storytelling but at its core the game is a game.
Continuing for story reasons is good for the DM, but takes much of the game elements away from the PCs. It's like going around the board of Monopoly a few more times without keeping track of money just to keep things going.
Troile wrote:And stopping at 6th level allows them the time to strive for their goals without becoming gods in the process. That way the challenges can be within reach the whole time too.

Fighting types tend to need a lot of feats to fully realize their characters and in this system you can make up feats to gain certain 4th level spells and such for magic driven characters. I would find more rewarding to uncover the secret scroll of a long lost 4th level spell after a month of adventuring than simply gaining another level and getting it for free.
In theory, but after months of playing and earning that xp it is really satisfying to survive and level-up.
In my homegame, after five sessions I finally leveled-up to 4th level. And that jump from 3rd to 4th really matters for a wizard. I really felt I earned those two new spells. This was easily 2-3 months of playtime, and after any anticipation of that length there's a feeling of victory.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

Where is this? I'd like to read that.
http://www.thealexandrian.net/creations ... ating.html
I'm not so much against it as think it's odd on insisting on using a game system that's obviously not meeting your needs.
I agree.
When you're setting out to only use less than 1/3rd of the resources, rules, or content of the game you're just not getting much bang for your buck.
You're looking at this the wrong way.

I'm using all of the content in that level range. If I decided I didn't like magic and still wanted to play d&d that might be a little strange. But I'm not changing the game in that level range, I'm not really sure where the disconnect is.

It could be that you enjoy high level play and don't see how anyone could play d&d without it. That's cool, maybe you'll just have to take me at my word for it.

I don't think I'm losing any part of the game.

Let me approach this a different way. I'm vegan which means I don't eat meat or dairy. People usually think I'm giving up meat. But I don't want to eat the meat so I'm not giving it up. Instead I get to eat more of the things that I really do want to eat.

So here I'm not playing the levels I don't like as much and have more play time in the levels that I really do like. So I'm not losing anything.

Does that make more sense?

I really don't like Psionics or Tome of Battle or Epic levels so I don't play with those rules. They're out there so you could say that I'm missing out, but I don't think that I am.

e6 will suddenly make a lot of character concepts viable that weren't previously. I can look through the books and see all sorts of PrCs that simply didn't work before have new merit. I think I'm gaining a lot.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

In theory, but after months of playing and earning that xp it is really satisfying to survive and level-up.
In my homegame, after five sessions I finally leveled-up to 4th level. And that jump from 3rd to 4th really matters for a wizard. I really felt I earned those two new spells. This was easily 2-3 months of playtime, and after any anticipation of that length there's a feeling of victory.
And where does it end?

Do you play to 40th level because it is fun to advance? And if you do would you play to 100th level?

All groups tend to have a sweet spot that they would like to end at. The game is e20 by default but there is nothing stopping you from changing that around. You can't really go higher because the classes don't go that high but you could certainly go lower. Don't like 9th level spells? Play e16.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Troile wrote:I don't think I'm losing any part of the game.

Let me approach this a different way. I'm vegan which means I don't eat meat or dairy. People usually think I'm giving up meat. But I don't want to eat the meat so I'm not giving it up. Instead I get to eat more of the things that I really do want to eat.
Yes, but by continuing to play D&D you're the vegan that insists on going to McDonalds and ordering 3 salads.
You're not getting the best product because its simply not designed for you.
artemis wands
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 2:22 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Post by artemis wands »

Jester of the FoS wrote:
Troile wrote:I don't think I'm losing any part of the game.

Let me approach this a different way. I'm vegan which means I don't eat meat or dairy. People usually think I'm giving up meat. But I don't want to eat the meat so I'm not giving it up. Instead I get to eat more of the things that I really do want to eat.
Yes, but by continuing to play D&D you're the vegan that insists on going to McDonalds and ordering 3 salads.
You're not getting the best product because its simply not designed for you.
Quite the contrary, I'd say.

D&D is flexible enough to allow different people to obtain different kinds of enjoyment from it. As long as I've been playing the game, I've always found mid-level play the most entertaining, and would always begin to dread the approach of high-level bookkeeping and power word kill-throwing.

I have found that every version of D&D up through 3.5 (and especially 3.5) supports that level of play beautifully, better than any other fantasy game I've tried.

Now 4e.... there's a game that is simply not designed for me. :P
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

artemis wands wrote:D&D is flexible enough to allow different people to obtain different kinds of enjoyment from it. As long as I've been playing the game, I've always found mid-level play the most entertaining, and would always begin to dread the approach of high-level bookkeeping and power word kill-throwing.

I have found that every version of D&D up through 3.5 (and especially 3.5) supports that level of play beautifully, better than any other fantasy game I've tried.

Now 4e.... there's a game that is simply not designed for me. :P
Yeah, 4e is really for the people who enjoyed L5-15 and kinda ignores anyone who liked the squishy feel of 1-5 or the godly wackiness of 15+.

Personally, I enjoyed that range more than the early reality simulator levels of 1-4 when you're just too darn easy to kill and have to rest all the time (this is eighteen months of playing an under-4 wizard speaking here).
I like my low-power, low-fantasy games (as seen for my great fondness for Ravenloft) but limiting advancement to only feats at the endgame just doesn't seem very rewarding as it's essentially cramming a level-less game into a leveled game creating a bastard hybrid.
I'd be much more open to a game that weakened classes across the board (ie my earlier suggestion of dividing the benefits of levels 1-6 in half and spreading them out). Or an entirely class-less version of d20 that dumps the class structure entirely in favour of rapidly gained feats (gain hp through toughness, gain skill points through a skill focus variant, perhaps switch to a spell point system and do the same, etc).
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

Yes, but by continuing to play D&D you're the vegan that insists on going to McDonalds and ordering 3 salads.
You're not getting the best product because its simply not designed for you.
I would say that would be true if I went and played a bad RPG just because I didn't think this one was perfect.

We went from talking about eating meat or not to talking about the quality of the food we eat in general, these are entirely different things.
One thing to remember is that it is still a game. There's a heavy element of shared storytelling but at its core the game is a game.
Continuing for story reasons is good for the DM, but takes much of the game elements away from the PCs. It's like going around the board of Monopoly a few more times without keeping track of money just to keep things going.
Your definition of game troubles me.

If I play chess and win I don't get to have 2 queens next time. So what was the point? What is the point even if I get more queens next time I play?

What is the reward from playing d&d? Sure you gain levels but they're all imaginary anyway.

I get a lot more satisfaction from achieving story goals than I do from leveling up.

I could play a game where we're all level 30 and we pretend to run around being gods, but I don't see the value in it. Other people do and that's fine. That is why there is an Epic handbook.

My point still stands, no one uses all of the resources available for their game. They construct the kind of game they want to play.

Are you completely against houserules? Do you only play published adventures?

I really don't see where you're coming from.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Troile wrote:
One thing to remember is that it is still a game. There's a heavy element of shared storytelling but at its core the game is a game.
Continuing for story reasons is good for the DM, but takes much of the game elements away from the PCs. It's like going around the board of Monopoly a few more times without keeping track of money just to keep things going.
Your definition of game troubles me.

If I play chess and win I don't get to have 2 queens next time. So what was the point? What is the point even if I get more queens next time I play?
That's a bad analogy. D&D doesn't really compare well to traditional board games.
But we'll run with it. 3.5 e6 is like playing a game of chess until a third of the pieces are off the board, then you house rule that no other pieces can capture other pieces: you're not really playing the game any more, you're just going through the motions

It doesn't work well but levelling in D&D is as close as you get to "winning". Ending a campaign is ending the story, which is its own reward. But the reward for the game is levelling.
Troile wrote:What is the reward from playing d&d? Sure you gain levels but they're all imaginary anyway.

I get a lot more satisfaction from achieving story goals than I do from leveling up.
And story rewards are very important. But story rewards are the reward for following the story: allowing yourself to become invested in the tale.

Levelling is a mechanical game reward for playing the game.

There is some overlap ("yay, you solved the mystery of the haunted amusement park, here's some xp") but the game works best when there's a balance. The exact ratio varies but there needs to be a little of each.
Remove the story and you're just playing a miniature combat game. Remove the game and you're just telling a shared story.
Now, both of those are fine activities, but there are better ways to do both. Telling a shared story with loose D&D rules is just a handcuff on the imagination, limiting your possibilities.
Troile wrote:My point still stands, no one uses all of the resources available for their game. They construct the kind of game they want to play.

Are you completely against houserules? Do you only play published adventures?

I really don't see where you're coming from.
I'm not against house rules, but this is a little beyond a house rule and is rapidly approaching a new system. And really, it's just a kludge stop-gap solution.

I suppose the bit that chafes is that it is such a sudden change in how the reward mechanism works. You go from getting a level with a BAB bonus and saving throw bonus and new spells and skill points and feats to just getting feats. When the story is getting climactic the game is getting stagnant.
Suddenly, there is NO mechanical advancement per se.
Why even bother with xp? Treat it like Warcrarf and just keep getting more gold and better gear. Keep fighting the same range of monsters again and again.

It's probably the little internal game designer in me that's reacting to the odd arbitrary change of "let's dump levels after L6 for feats". It's like in 1st Edition how you stopped getting new hit dice and just got set points after a certain level. Why? Just because.
The system is very loose. Like they didn't want to spend much time really working on it so they just slapped together something rather than put the effort re-writing all the classes to spread out abilities.

There's probably a neat way to make an entirely feat-based variant of d20, where you gain reduced xp that's tradable for feats. If 3e wasn't a dying system I might even sit down and think of how to put it out (although, it might work well with 4e and its +1/2 level mechanic).
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Troile wrote:
Where is this? I'd like to read that.
http://www.thealexandrian.net/creations ... ating.html
So, I read the essay.
It's really an interesting read of someone trying to fit novels into game rules. This is a bit odd since Tolkien really, really is not D&D. Tolkien and the LotR is this deeper high fantasy while D&D takes its cues from the older Swords & Sorcery of Conan, Lankhmar and their bad '70s counterparts that inspired Gygax.

The author really collides with the "D&D as a reality simulator" that became such a problem for developers at WotC that they just said "F it" and abandoned any pretence to being realistic in 4e (#15 in the list of #39 ways they alienated some of the fan base).

I felt much of the essay worked hard to justify what literary characters could or could not do compared to in-game variants.
All I could think of was "what level is Tanis Half-elven and Raistlin Majere"?
We know what level they are in the game. We know that by the end of Dragons of Spring Dawning (aka DL14: DL14: Dragons of Triumph) they were all close to level 14. Yet in the novels we see the heroes felled by single blows and having trouble with creatures they should be able to kill dozens or even hundreds of.

It is odd when D&D breaks away from reality. I played Living Greyhawk for a time and saw some spectacular munchkin behaviour: a dwarf in full plate making a standing jump up 10', an elf with a movement speed of over 100'/round that was all (Ex) so non-magical, etc.
But it is a fantasy game. If I wanted pure realism I'd switch to GURPS and play a procedural cop game or something... (not that C.S.I. is anywhere even remotely close to reality. Magic powers are more realistic than that show).
User avatar
BigBadQDaddy
Champion of the Maiden
Champion of the Maiden
Posts: 1751
Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 5:47 pm
Location: The Dread Realm of Minnesota

Post by BigBadQDaddy »

Personally I say "Kudos" for trying something new. On the other side of the coin I would have to say that IMHO since the incarnation of d20, D&D was no longer the home of RL. Now, that will probably make a lot of people angry, but before this thread degrades to that level, Allow me to squash that. I am not insulting anybodies game that is run using any incarnation of the d20 system, I have just found from my personal experience that d20 was far better suited to be a game which is more fun for the players than the DM. I get the impression that "rules lawyering" runs rampant in many d20 games as the system is designed to give the DM and the players an equal understanding of the rules.

But I digress. Mainly I just want to say, anyway to make d20 less of a powerful game in regards to Ravenloft I will support. Also, the players are still being rewarded mechanically by means of feats. Do the players really need to have a ridiculous amount of hit points to compensate for good old fashion creativity and ingenuity? Or to reference an earlier example, do they need to have a skill with 10+ ranks? The GM has the ability to adjust difficulty checks. Anything beyond a certain point is simply posturing and basically ridiculous. If someone in any somewhat logical setting could construct a lock that has a difficulty check of 30 to pick, they would be the god of locksmiths or something equally stupid and pointless. d20 essentially reinforces adding numbers for the sake of addition rather than allowing the creative process to thrive. Who needs to think their way around a difficult treasure chest when you can just declare that you are taking 20?

As far as 4th ed is concerned, I personally hope that it never sees RL. If anything, 4th edition feels like a static video game system to me.
There I go again, ranting when no one asked for a rant. Basically, if you as a GM are comfortable with a party of 20th level characters marching in to Barovia with the sole intent on "Pantsing" Strahd, go ahead. If you are having fun, roll with it. But if you want your players to fear that scratching noise outside their inn room window at night, which unknowingly to them is really a single goblyn, I say go with the level cap. And kudos for figuring out a way to put fear into the Number Cruncher class of player.

Before I leave to dodge the rotten tomatoes, I would like to point out that their are many other systems that are far better suited for the play style necessary for gaming in the Dread Realms. I personally would love to play a WFRP incarnation of RL.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

I suppose the bit that chafes is that it is such a sudden change in how the reward mechanism works. You go from getting a level with a BAB bonus and saving throw bonus and new spells and skill points and feats to just getting feats. When the story is getting climactic the game is getting stagnant.
Okay I think I see your point of view now.

I'll have to see how it plays out. I think the concept is solid. Another take on it would be to just end the game at a certain level. Like have a level cap of 12 where all the NPCs could only go up to 12th level too and then you just end the game there.

You wouldn't have a problem with that sort of system right?

The thing with levels in d&d is that your power increases exponentially. So after a certain point (the top end of which is 6th level) you suddenly start getting a lot of power with each level.

I suppose it depends on how much you value feats too. Feats are very valuable and you usually only get them once every 3 levels. Humans are the best race (as long as we're not talking strange things like water orcs) because they get a bonus feat. Then every 5k experience you get another one.

I do see where you're coming from. Unfortunately I might not be able to test this system for a while since we just started a new game and we're only going to convert over if all my players are enthusiastic about it. This system has been around for a couple of years and I've read a good deal of success stories. I wanted to see if anyone had tried it in Ravenloft.

Feats can give you all of the level dependent things, just over time.

I'm going to make a system of capstone and prestige feats where you can take one at level 6 +1 and then another at level 6 +5. The feats will give you class/prestige class specific abilities so you will still further develop the flavour of it.

I would guess that you could go to 6 +10 feats before the stagnation sets in. If I were to run an e6 campaign I would want to structure the big finale to arrive somewhere between +5 and +10 feats.

Level 6 gives you enough time to construct a unique character, then you get to play with it for a while. I suppose that's how I see it.
If I wanted pure realism I'd switch to GURPS and play a procedural cop game or something... (not that C.S.I. is anywhere even remotely close to reality. Magic powers are more realistic than that show).
I'm in agreement with you there. I came over from the Storyteller system. It's a great system, but doesn't lend itself well to RPGs I think.

I love the hit point based system in d&d. I like that it isn't realistic but it also lets you visualize the characters as real people. It strikes a good balance I think.

I can have an in depth meaningful story but then when the time for crunch comes around it doesn't get in the way. The balance of fluff and crunch is why I like d&d 3.5e so much.
Post Reply