3.5 statistics for the common scalpel?
no offense- but that in no way negates anything I wrote. Can't have dozens of attacks in DnD. The one or two characters are given would represent multiples IRL. But that's still all moot.
We aren't talking about shanks- we were talking about the lethality of a scalpel and the prison shank was a way to put it in perspective. BTW, many shanks aren't stabbing weapons- a lot are slashing weapons e.x metal edge melted onto toothbrush. But all of this is neither here nor there.
Perhaps if I compared the scalpel to a box-cutter. A lot of people carry those to get around knife laws and they cause wounds that can create a LOT of damage (intestines being exposed is well within the capability of both a box-cutter and scalpel)- and they aren't even as sharp as a scalpel would be. Plus, you can stab with a scalpel unlike a box-cutter.
Again- 1d2 19-20/X2 makes the most sense for a 3.5 ed scalpel.
We aren't talking about shanks- we were talking about the lethality of a scalpel and the prison shank was a way to put it in perspective. BTW, many shanks aren't stabbing weapons- a lot are slashing weapons e.x metal edge melted onto toothbrush. But all of this is neither here nor there.
Perhaps if I compared the scalpel to a box-cutter. A lot of people carry those to get around knife laws and they cause wounds that can create a LOT of damage (intestines being exposed is well within the capability of both a box-cutter and scalpel)- and they aren't even as sharp as a scalpel would be. Plus, you can stab with a scalpel unlike a box-cutter.
Again- 1d2 19-20/X2 makes the most sense for a 3.5 ed scalpel.
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Or making mileage on Giamarga's, you could give the choice to the PC:Archedius wrote: 1d2 19-20/X2 makes the most sense for a 3.5 ed scalpel.
1d2 19-20/X2 used as a slashing weapon, or
1d2 20 x 3 when used as a piercing weapon.
I do not see much more damage then that, i.e. a d2 (a d3 at the most!).
Last edited by Joël of the FoS on Thu Mar 12, 2009 2:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
I agree with Jester; 1d2 damage. Most of the weapons in D&D seem to do damage based upon their size; this is why a Greatsword does more damage than a short sword (among other things) even though a short sword is quite capable of killing someone. Heck, if you make weapons bigger or smaller, the only thing that changes on them *is* their damage.
If you want to differentiate it a bit, make all scalpels masterwork weapons due to their craftsmanship.
Still, I would consider going with the improvised weapons rule. A scalpel is not made to be a weapon. Its handle (as others mentioned) is wrong, it's not weighted for combat (not that there's much *to* weight), etc. If you make them all MW, then this is only a -3 penalty to hit with it, which I think is pretty fair.
Of course, if this is only for an NPC or monster, give it whatever hit you think it should have and be done with it. If the PC's pick it up and want to fight with it (disturbing thought, considering the weaponry most PCs have at their disposal), then figure out the rules.
If you want to differentiate it a bit, make all scalpels masterwork weapons due to their craftsmanship.
Still, I would consider going with the improvised weapons rule. A scalpel is not made to be a weapon. Its handle (as others mentioned) is wrong, it's not weighted for combat (not that there's much *to* weight), etc. If you make them all MW, then this is only a -3 penalty to hit with it, which I think is pretty fair.
Of course, if this is only for an NPC or monster, give it whatever hit you think it should have and be done with it. If the PC's pick it up and want to fight with it (disturbing thought, considering the weaponry most PCs have at their disposal), then figure out the rules.
- BigBadQDaddy
- Champion of the Maiden

- Posts: 1751
- Joined: Tue Sep 06, 2005 5:47 pm
- Location: The Dread Realm of Minnesota
You kind of missed my point. I was merely pointing out how impractical such a weapon would be in combat. Conceptually it is just silly. As for the dozens of attacks, that would be represented as the sneak attack and a narrative explanation of how such an impractical weapon could deliver such a high amount of damage.Archedius wrote:no offense- but that in no way negates anything I wrote. Can't have dozens of attacks in DnD. The one or two characters are given would represent multiples IRL. But that's still all moot.
When I gave my example, I was speaking from the limited amount of prison movies and TV shows I have seen. In each example I have ever seen a shank being used, it was used as a stabbing implement and in rapid succession and done in a sneak attack-like fashion, not in combat were both opponents were facing each other.Archedius wrote:We aren't talking about shanks- we were talking about the lethality of a scalpel and the prison shank was a way to put it in perspective. BTW, many shanks aren't stabbing weapons- a lot are slashing weapons e.x metal edge melted onto toothbrush. But all of this is neither here nor there.
Again, used in a sneak attack like fashion, not in combat. Or if used in combat, against an unarmed opponent or some other sorry sap with a box cutter.Archedius wrote:Perhaps if I compared the scalpel to a box-cutter. A lot of people carry those to get around knife laws and they cause wounds that can create a LOT of damage (intestines being exposed is well within the capability of both a box-cutter and scalpel)- and they aren't even as sharp as a scalpel would be. Plus, you can stab with a scalpel unlike a box-cutter.
As a solution, I would propose this. Special rules associated with make shift weaponry. For example, the scalpel could do 1d2 with absolutely no critical threat range UNLESS used in a sneak attack like fashion. In which case the threat range would be relatively high, 17-20 x4 for example.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Based on having used scalpels for years in my anatomy & physiology labs, I'd say that the 1d2 damage is about right. Maybe drop that to 1 if the blade has been used much, as even stainless steel scalpels don't hold their edges for long, and that quality of metal probably isn't common in Ravenloft.
Yes, theoretically you could inflict a lethal wound with one, but it'd take sneak-attack-style precision to do it. Otherwise, it's just as likely to snap from striking solid bone as sever something significant like an artery.
Scalpels would not be useable as piercing weapons, BTW, except in a crude, poke-helpless-victim-in-the-eye sense that you could just as well attempt with a ballpoint pen. I don't know how many times I've had to remind students to draw their scalpels across a dissection specimen, not push on the blade or saw it back and forth.
Given the extreme delicacy and fragility of a scalpel, FWIW, I'd suggest it automatically be treated as if a wielder has the Weapon Finesse feat, and that any Strength bonus to damage be ignored. Use of extra force would only break the blade, not inflict a deeper wound.
Yes, theoretically you could inflict a lethal wound with one, but it'd take sneak-attack-style precision to do it. Otherwise, it's just as likely to snap from striking solid bone as sever something significant like an artery.
Scalpels would not be useable as piercing weapons, BTW, except in a crude, poke-helpless-victim-in-the-eye sense that you could just as well attempt with a ballpoint pen. I don't know how many times I've had to remind students to draw their scalpels across a dissection specimen, not push on the blade or saw it back and forth.
Given the extreme delicacy and fragility of a scalpel, FWIW, I'd suggest it automatically be treated as if a wielder has the Weapon Finesse feat, and that any Strength bonus to damage be ignored. Use of extra force would only break the blade, not inflict a deeper wound.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- MadStepDad
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 353
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 10:42 am
- Location: Broken City, MA State
- Contact:
Yo I'm packin scalpels
I stole em from the hospital
I gots to kill
If you step, I'm representin this gospel
Killin me is mission impossible
There's many weapons
Machetes and buck knives will slice through intestines
WHAT I'll cut open a gut like butter
It comes from the family of the buzz cutter
The scalpel - the surgery master
Lacerating brains and tissue
How I do it remains the issue
I'm in a doctors office getting a checkup
He leaves the room so I start searchin through drawers
I find test tubes and gauze
Blood deposits and gore
And hypodermic needles galore - just what I'm lookin for
Paraphenelia for movies
Grab a couple scalpels to pack up my baseball cap
In case you try to remove me from EARTH
Remove the beauty from your face - til you feel disgraced
Walkin in public like you got a leprosy case
- NECRO ("Scalpel")
Just figured I'd throw that in there.

I stole em from the hospital
I gots to kill
If you step, I'm representin this gospel
Killin me is mission impossible
There's many weapons
Machetes and buck knives will slice through intestines
WHAT I'll cut open a gut like butter
It comes from the family of the buzz cutter
The scalpel - the surgery master
Lacerating brains and tissue
How I do it remains the issue
I'm in a doctors office getting a checkup
He leaves the room so I start searchin through drawers
I find test tubes and gauze
Blood deposits and gore
And hypodermic needles galore - just what I'm lookin for
Paraphenelia for movies
Grab a couple scalpels to pack up my baseball cap
In case you try to remove me from EARTH
Remove the beauty from your face - til you feel disgraced
Walkin in public like you got a leprosy case
- NECRO ("Scalpel")
Just figured I'd throw that in there.
MSD's Black Box
(2002 - 2005)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/TheVeranda.html
MSD's Red Box
(2015 - 2021)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9249
Doc
(2005)
(2002 - 2005)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/TheVeranda.html
MSD's Red Box
(2015 - 2021)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9249
Doc
(2005)
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Interesting trivia. Obsidian flakes have sharper edges than surgical scalpels and were used for early surgery where today doctors use stainless steel.
Can we stop this madness? Why are we splitting hairs (pun intended) over what damage a tiny blade does?
Can we stop this madness? Why are we splitting hairs (pun intended) over what damage a tiny blade does?
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
My scalpel wielding mad scientist is not amused. For what could be more important than how dangerous he is with a scalpel, save of course for his obsessional research into discovering a cure for lycanthropy of course.High Priest Mikhal wrote:Can we stop this madness? Why are we splitting hairs (pun intended) over what damage a tiny blade does?
The cure for what ails you
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
So a good natural "1" should also break said improvised weapon.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Scalpels would not be useable as piercing weapons, BTW, except in a crude, poke-helpless-victim-in-the-eye sense that you could just as well attempt with a ballpoint pen. I don't know how many times I've had to remind students to draw their scalpels across a dissection specimen, not push on the blade or saw it back and forth.
Given the extreme delicacy and fragility of a scalpel, FWIW, I'd suggest it automatically be treated as if a wielder has the Weapon Finesse feat, and that any Strength bonus to damage be ignored. Use of extra force would only break the blade, not inflict a deeper wound.
1d2, x3, slashing and improvised.
And can be used with weapon finesse.
Unarmored person- I'd allow it to do piercing. People've gotten pens into the gut. Any armor at all- then probably only piercing on a sneak attack. There's plenty of the body that is free of intervening bone.
The throat's also not that hard of a target to hit if you have training (which any martial character would in DnD) and the blood vessals are still pretty easy to hit from the front- the musculature of the neck and the cartilidge of the trachea basically guide objects right towards the lethal areas.
The throat's also not that hard of a target to hit if you have training (which any martial character would in DnD) and the blood vessals are still pretty easy to hit from the front- the musculature of the neck and the cartilidge of the trachea basically guide objects right towards the lethal areas.
How about this:
Scalpel - masterwork instrument costing 55 gp, weighing 1/4 lb, that may be used as a one-handed improvised weapon, striking with a -3 to hit penalty, scoring 1d2 hit points of slashing damage with no additional damage from a Strength modifier, with a x3 critical, breaking on a natural 1. Wielders with a base attack bonus of at least +1 may use their Dexterity modifier instead of their Strength modifier on their attack roll to hit. The strength based Brawler feat is not applicable to the scalpel. But as a substitute, a character with Dexterity 13+ may take the Scalpel feat, which converts the -3 to hit penalty into a +1 to hit bonus.
As this is an improvised weapon, treating it as a weapon and adding 300 gp for being masterwork to the base cost seems excessive, especially as it breaks on a natural 1. But I couldn't find a formula for pricing masterwork items, as opposed to masterwork weapons, so fairly arbitarily I came up with 55gp. Any better suggestions for pricing?
Incidently, the weapon as described should appeal to a very small set of individuals, chiefly high dexterity persons, with only average strength, with better uses for a feat than Weapon Finesse, and found in settings where there is a premium on tiny, highly concealable weapons. That is to say that they would be appealing to a chiurgeon in a modern domain like Paridon.
Scalpel - masterwork instrument costing 55 gp, weighing 1/4 lb, that may be used as a one-handed improvised weapon, striking with a -3 to hit penalty, scoring 1d2 hit points of slashing damage with no additional damage from a Strength modifier, with a x3 critical, breaking on a natural 1. Wielders with a base attack bonus of at least +1 may use their Dexterity modifier instead of their Strength modifier on their attack roll to hit. The strength based Brawler feat is not applicable to the scalpel. But as a substitute, a character with Dexterity 13+ may take the Scalpel feat, which converts the -3 to hit penalty into a +1 to hit bonus.
As this is an improvised weapon, treating it as a weapon and adding 300 gp for being masterwork to the base cost seems excessive, especially as it breaks on a natural 1. But I couldn't find a formula for pricing masterwork items, as opposed to masterwork weapons, so fairly arbitarily I came up with 55gp. Any better suggestions for pricing?
Incidently, the weapon as described should appeal to a very small set of individuals, chiefly high dexterity persons, with only average strength, with better uses for a feat than Weapon Finesse, and found in settings where there is a premium on tiny, highly concealable weapons. That is to say that they would be appealing to a chiurgeon in a modern domain like Paridon.
The cure for what ails you

