Ravenloft Reanimated Domain Contest - Round 1

Discussing all things Ravenloft
NykylaiHellray
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:32 am

Post by NykylaiHellray »

Just curious madstep, there are two entries of mine missing from your second round ratings.

Which is floating coffin and grand central. Is that because they were cut?
[quote="Kelliack"] It is the lost coin of the gods when they first flipped to see who would get which portfolio.[/quote]
User avatar
MadStepDad
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 353
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 10:42 am
Location: Broken City, MA State
Contact:

Post by MadStepDad »

No I'm pretty sure they're there. I do remember GRAND CENTRAL quite distinctly. I like that one, I really do. And again, as previously stated, I am but one man. My opinion is unique to me alone. Everybody that submitted did a terrific job.

peace,

MSD
MSD's Black Box
(2002 - 2005)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/TheVeranda.html

MSD's Red Box
(2015 - 2021)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9249

Doc
(2005)
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

Both Grand Central and the Woods of the Floating Coffin (Second to last) are there in MSDs forum...
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
NykylaiHellray
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:32 am

Post by NykylaiHellray »

I feel like such an idiot :oops: ......i didnt understand how to get to the second page of your forum ^^:....... so I assumed there wasnt ....

....yeah I will sit in the corner now..
[quote="Kelliack"] It is the lost coin of the gods when they first flipped to see who would get which portfolio.[/quote]
User avatar
Igor the Henchman
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 832
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm

Post by Igor the Henchman »

No, frankly, its not you. The page-flipping mechanic in MSD's board is pretty confusing. I never wouldn't have figured it out myself, except by cheer, blind luck... even though web interfaces happens to be my current field of study.
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

Igor the Henchman wrote:No, frankly, its not you. The page-flipping mechanic in MSD's board is pretty confusing. I never wouldn't have figured it out myself, except by cheer, blind luck... even though web interfaces happens to be my current field of study.
...and one of my specialties, but I agree with Igor that it is not friendly at all...
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
NykylaiHellray
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:32 am

Post by NykylaiHellray »

I will say I love the idea of the Labyrinth. It could serve as a very disturbed twist on the feywild concept (since according to 4e each world has a potential for a shadowfell and a feywild).

An artitect who is creating a dark maze deep underneath the world, has a certain charm about it.

Twisted fairy groves, and Goblin towns selling penny dreadfulls and eggs which hatch into fear could be things hidden within. Madness for humans, but normal for the fey.
[quote="Kelliack"] It is the lost coin of the gods when they first flipped to see who would get which portfolio.[/quote]
User avatar
MadStepDad
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 353
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 10:42 am
Location: Broken City, MA State
Contact:

Post by MadStepDad »

Igor the Henchman wrote:No, frankly, its not you. The page-flipping mechanic in MSD's board is pretty confusing. I never wouldn't have figured it out myself, except by cheer, blind luck... even though web interfaces happens to be my current field of study.
:?:

The part where it says "Go To Page 2" is confusing??? I don't understand. And I'm suprised you've never seen a proboards page before. They're pretty common and have been around for quite a while.
MSD's Black Box
(2002 - 2005)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/TheVeranda.html

MSD's Red Box
(2015 - 2021)
https://www.fraternityofshadows.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9249

Doc
(2005)
User avatar
Ornum
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 91
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2007 2:01 pm

Post by Ornum »

MadStepDad wrote:
Igor the Henchman wrote:No, frankly, its not you. The page-flipping mechanic in MSD's board is pretty confusing. I never wouldn't have figured it out myself, except by cheer, blind luck... even though web interfaces happens to be my current field of study.
:?:

The part where it says "Go To Page 2" is confusing??? I don't understand. And I'm suprised you've never seen a proboards page before. They're pretty common and have been around for quite a while.
I had the same initial problems. To me, it's about placement. All the forums I visit have the "next page" option at the bottom of the page (and sometimes the top), but it's on the right-hand side of the screen next to the scroll bar. On your page, I first looked at the bottom right, then scrolled up and looked at the top right, THEN I noticed it on the top left (and then later on the bottom left). For the forums I visit, that's different. It also looks and works a bit different than most (again, based on the forums I visit), but it wasn't hard to figure out once I actually found it.
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

I beg you to wait till tonight (Tomorrow if you're in the old continent :wink:) for the results... I'm still waiting for one of the judges to send me their results...
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

And the winners (with the comments from the judges) are:

Annaes
MSD: I'm proud to say I was one of the first to see the potential in a domain like this. It's a throwback but yet fresh and new at the same time. Again I have no idea about SPELLJAMMER other than its an oldschool TSR world just like the others.
Tec-Goblin: A ship darklord, and a great way to come and escape from the domain. I would like to have some clues on why a ship would be taken by the mists in the first place.

Archiginnasio di Felsinea
MSD: I changed the rating system! I can't say "I Don't Care" but I'm not jumping out of my seat with excitement either. It's a cool creepy twist, with the living books and all, but overall it's not that exciting.
Tec-Goblin: How he selects which individual would become which lost book?

Black Showroom
MSD: I liked this domain submission, but the Darklord is... for lack of a better word... "mediocre". But therein perhaps lies the beauty. Tale of the common man selling his soul to the devil is are as old as Gothic literature itself. Is this a roaming Domain? How will he continue to harvest these masterpieces once the well runs dry?

Casteldebole
MSD: Wow what a twist! I was waiting to see what they could come up with this, as the suggested Darklord in the domain description is actually a living flesh doll and just another tool of the REAL evil force of Casteldebole! Good stuff!
Tec-Goblin: a very different take in the master & creation theme. I am impatient to learn why Baccio wants a revenge.

Cirundi-Velle
MSD: I didn't love the domain submission but the Darklord is infinitely better. Psionic vampires are cool and a source of demented pleasure for the DM (see Daclaud Heinfroth). I'm torn here because the low rating for the domain combined with a good rating for the Darklord leaves me stuck firmly in the middle.
Tec-Goblin: It builts on a theme of loss and inability to stop the decay. Why a failed attempt to do something good, though, would curse someone to darklordship?

Cratia
MSD: Had high expectations for the Darklord, and it's cool... but not awesome. So what happens now to AISCHOS? What's his curse? What does his new wife think? What does the domain actually do?
Tec-Goblin: Aischos has way too many ways to be pronounced in English, a small hint would help.

Crewsaw Island
MSD: Spooky! We've all heard stories of cannibilization to stay alive and this fits the bill perfectly. A ghoul lord, false Gods, cannibals and saviors... this has it all!

Devil's Fork
MSD: Gotta stay with my original vote. Awesome domain, great darklord but I'm not sure how this fits the current RAVENLOFT landscape.
Tec-Goblin: the mine or the miner?

Endemia
MSD: Too much. It's cool but the "technology powered by the Mists" throws me off. ISAAC BURNEY sounds like the Engineer from THE EVIL EYE but with a more evil slant, I guess.
Tec-Goblin: He could be the creator of the warforged, which were given life from the mists, much to his dismay!

Este
MSD: Reminds me a little of the jester from that BOOK of CRYPTS adventure. If they somehow found a way to combine this submission with a little canon material from that adventure I'd be all over it. As its written now, I'm not in love.

Felsinea
MSD: Weird. Sounds cool and again, no major Sphinx presence in RAVENLOFT. But I'm curious to hear how this would divurge from all the other scholarly, research-oriented domains.
Tec-Goblin: An interesting cross-reference could be the existence and death of another sphinx in another domain, showing the effects of Astylos' betrayal of his race.

Forest of Hunger, the
MSD: Huh? Man I'm totally not understanding this at all. What is TAR'KARUS? A pile of muddy leaves? A wolf? The land itself? I don't know what to think here.
Tec-Goblin: It would be interesting if this hunger also affects visitors to the domain: scarce resources etc (maybe the resources are more near the depths, but there awaits Tar'Karus)

Forest of Memory, the
MSD: Very creepy, with a deep tinge of sadness. Sounds kinda like the death pall over Necropolis though, and we should be deviating AWAY from other published ideas with this project. So make sure this idea stays unique.
Tec-Goblin: She doesn't seem very evil to me. Just insane. How did she outlive those she loved?

The Free League
MSD: Darklord description not as good as the domain. I wouldn't take my players here as its written.

Isles of Saint Helena
MSD: Overkill. It's just too much for me. Seems like its own campaign world, and less a Domain of Dread.
Tec-Goblin: Are all three darklords? How are they evil enough to gain this title?

Labyrinth, the
MSD: Having read the Boogeyman chapter from DARK TALES and DISTURBING LEGENDS, I feel there's definitely a place for this kind of domain. It's just not my personal preference. Good stuff though.
Tec-Goblin: It slightly reminds me of the vestige Halphax from Tome of Magic. How did Jarthias managed to build such a supernatural labyrinth?

Nosos
MSD: Thanks for not trying to out-think yourself by changing the darklord or his backstory, instead choosing to build upon that.
Tec-Goblin: How do these efforts outcast him?

Oriebo
MSD: Gloomy and gothic for sure, and I like the powerlessness of AMADEAO. But it seems to tread too heavily on rehashed topics and bits and pieces from other domains for me.

Pharazia
MSD: I was anxious too see what kind of ill twist they could come up with here, but as its written I'd rather just read DOMAINS of DREAD and call it a day.

Phragma
MSD: Now THAT'S fresh! I didn't like the domain much at all, but that's an ill twist for the Darklord. I like how they kept canon RAVENLOFT concepts yet expanded it in an original way. Plus the "change RAVENLOFT for the better" bit actually makes sense now that the Darklord has had psionic impairment. Good job!
Tec-Goblin: Do these minds manifest in the same body? Is he at the same time in multiple academies?

Principato delle Grazie
MSD: I'm disgusted and repulsed just reading about it! Creepy as hell and I can't wait to see more! Best of the day so far!
Tec-Goblin: The horror of failed birth. Daring but working (I had players having nightmares after just a short encounter with an atropal).

Roeschap
MSD: Whoa, a hoe Darklord??? Nasty sluts feeding on lust? Sounds really cool but I'm not jumping out of my chair. Joint darklords is interesting, I'd like to hear more about how they co-exist. But then again I've read other submissions that sound better.
Tec-Goblin: I don't see exactly who's the puritan here, among these two.

Sassomonte
MSD: A little convoluted, but disgustingly appropriate. Twin Darklords again though? That fight against each other? Interesting to see how that plays out, because I've NEVER heard of two Darklords trapped in a domain with each other and deuling it out…
Tec-Goblin: I suppose that by eating skins, Riccardi can hide his nature.

Scarabraech
MSD: Not what I expected from the original submission. Including the Fraternity of Shadows in there could be construed as blatant pandering, but I won't go there. I will say however that JOHN would make a better wandering NPC than a true Darklord.
Tec-Goblin: What do the other members do about him? His knowledge is a danger to the Fraternity.

Vespa
MSD: Domain seems too fantastic for my tastes, or where I envision this project going.
Tec-Goblin: fanatic*

Vinara
MSD: Bring on the urban anarchy! Interesting twist to the Darklord too, I didn't expect that. So what, does he have psionic fire-starting talents or something too?
Tec-Goblin: It plays well with the theme of passion difficult to control, I like. How did this person end up as a mummy lord, though?

Woods of the floating coffin, the
MSD: Nice twist! I'm still unsure on how this can be a fully functioning domain, but after PRINCESS STELLA I'm eager to see you try!
Tec-Goblin: "I listen to your steps. Are you my prince?" Still a tricked darklord doesn't seem evil enough to be so cursed.

Zumbera
MSD: Very weird Darklord. I like the "Pleasure filled island" part though (heh heh heh). But the permanently turning into a shadow thing seems to prevent it from being a domain you can pull PCs from.
Tec-Goblin: How can someone know himself to be an illusion? This is a tricky subject, it reaches some profound philosophical questions about the nature of existence.

So, 10 domains are out, and there are 28 still on the competition. The results for round 2 promised to leave us with 24 domains, but it could be even less...
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
NykylaiHellray
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:32 am

Post by NykylaiHellray »

Just curious what were the other judges opinions on the cut domains?

As I would like to improve grand central and some critique would be usefull.
[quote="Kelliack"] It is the lost coin of the gods when they first flipped to see who would get which portfolio.[/quote]
User avatar
WolfKook
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 573
Joined: Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:10 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Bogotá, Colombia
Contact:

Post by WolfKook »

Off course!

The 10 domains that dind't make it:

Ast
MSD: What the heck? I don't even remember this one. The Darklord sounds cooler than the domain - a dracolich is definitely a rare breed in RAVENLOFT. And I'm all about updating RAVENLOFT to cover 4E and some of the disregarded races, but I also think it's delving too far into the realm of fantasy for my tastes.
Tec-Goblin: Evil that is, and did not become (or maybe it did, a long time ago). A more on his story would make him more tragic.

Callista
MSD: Aww man, this was one of my favorite domain submissions. But the Darklord leaves me lacking a little. BUT - I like Bards, and I'm curious to know what judgement awaits him every night - so color me curious, but I can't give it my full support quite yet.
Tec-Goblin: he will satisfy his ego until his curse? I do not understand

Coral Sea, the
MSD: The curse is kinda cool but overall I've seen canon pirate domains I like much better.
Tec-Goblin: Haha, tragicomic! (Trying to do an occasional good and ending up with even worse reputation).

Demise
MSD: What? I don't get it. Where's the curse? Where's the struggle? How do the PCs fit in?
Tec-Goblin: Does this mean that her apperance has changed?

Grand Central
MSD: Grand Central back again. I'm a huge fan of the authors work regarding drugs in RAVENLOFT but this reflects none of that. Domain submission (to me) was far too modern-day and the Darklord only cements that notion. Again, I think it's a great domain - I really do - but for MASQUE of the RED DEATH... not RAVENLOFT.
Tec-Goblin: I would love to see more info on how (s)he became a darklord.

I'Cath
MSD: Run with this! Nice revision, I'm eager to see more.
Tec-Goblin: Still not tragic. Why does she do this?

Richmont
MSD: This was a heady submission to begin with, I can't believe it even made it past the censors. It IS vile and awesome, and to me it fits the Old Southern motif of ARKANDALE (not canon, but an ill revision regardless) better. It could work, but how will you make it non-offensive to most civilized minds???
Tec-Goblin: There's already a domain with a humano-supremacist dogma, and I think this theme is already abused in Ravenloft.

Sunset Wastes, the
MSD: Again it's an awesome submission, but it fits MASQUE or BOOT HILL better than RAVENLOFT.
Tec-Goblin: The devil? I suppose you mean Gentleman Caller.

Vallorca
MSD: Again, LEONE is a stronger NPC than a Darklord. I'd like to see him targeting churches of Ezra or other established domains, and spreading his evil propaganda wherever he travels.
Tec-Goblin: A domain where the Church is actually good? It works because it's unexpected, but I fear it might confuse readers about the nature of Ravenloft.

Veaer (The Living)
MSD: How is this even a domain? I don't really get this submission. Is this GHOSTWALK remixed for RAVENLOFT?
Tec-Goblin: This wilderness, though, is not a human-like darklord with a tragic past.
"The road of excess leads to the palace of wisdom"
William Blake
User avatar
Manofevil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!

Post by Manofevil »

Okay I feel the need to register a serious complaint here! :x I am really not pleased here :evil: NOBODY TOLD ME I'D ONLY HAVE A WEEK TO GET BACK TO YOU ON THIS!!! :evil: :evil: SOME OF US HAVE JOBS!!!! :evil: Also nobody said that this thread was the only place where we could find out which DarLord goes with which domain! Some less impressive domains are made by their DarkLords and vice versa. I only just found this thread and am not pleased that I'm too late to submit my vote. I have done so anyway and may post my comments here. but still... :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil: :evil:
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!

So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
NykylaiHellray
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 242
Joined: Tue Apr 18, 2006 10:32 am

Post by NykylaiHellray »

Slightly dissapointed...especially since my domain is probably the exact same level of technology then the other steampunk domain (they both have mist power to).


But meh at least the other two got in I guess....
[quote="Kelliack"] It is the lost coin of the gods when they first flipped to see who would get which portfolio.[/quote]
Post Reply