FoS Report in depth analysis - L’Île de la Tempête

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

FoS Report in depth analysis - L’Île de la Tempête

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Image

Esteemed members of the Fraternity,

Last November, we released the FoS Nocturnal Sea Survey. For those who haven’t got it, you can get this 400 pages netbook in the Library room.

We’ll continue the experiment of discussing in depth the NS Report domains, one after the other.

---

This time we visit (and hope to escape it afterward) L’Île de la Tempête.

We suggest you reread this chapter and provide us (and all the others who chipped in for ideas and dread possibilities) some feedback, questions, comments, etc.

If it is worth it, we’ll make an official erratum file or add a complement information web enhancement from these discussions.

Also, we will share some design choice he made, and add similar thoughts and we had during the revisit to L’Île de la Tempête.

Get your FoS NS report copy and let's start the discussion!

Next is the Isle of Ravens!

The Souragne Fraternity of Shadows

Image
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Well done. A lonely Monette who is eager to talk is a great improvement. His character development is excellent as is his relation with bats and their varients.

I find a skull, even or especially a disembodied one, to be, however, unappealing as the source of the light.

I am only slightly more sympathetic towards the nephew and his murder. Is the rationale that Monette's evil was somehow lacking for Darklord status in their absence?

Speaking of the light, I am not sure there is an advantage in stating that it can reach into other planes only once a year.

Given that Monette has no way of policing undersea monsters and given the rich prey he offers up in terms of ships' crews, there should be consequential predators. Not krakens but certainly scavengers that rob Monette of his prey from time to time, and perhaps drive him to drink or even send visiting adventurers after them. Would this be best tackled with an encounter table for the shore and immediately surrounding sea?

I have serious doubts that reefs were conceived by the Dark Powers to line up ships at high tide but to spare them at low tide. Why wouldn't there be reefs all the way down? At best, when the tide is high, there might be no reefs visible. So at low tide, one would have a warning that the area is reef infested, but certainly not hope that all the reefs of consequence are now visible.

The ships are remarkably durable. Vessels caught in rocks that a moderate sea would destroy in days are described as lingering for years if not decades. This seems largely unnecessary. Unless one insists on including the full complement of offered wrecked ships at any one moment, there is little need to artificially preserve the life of the ships. On any given revisitation of the island, two or three new vessels can be added, and the previous ones can be reduced, save for exceptionally, to skeletons or planks on the shore. I believe that it was suggested that the light may even reach across time, so old ships can be simply plucked up as need be rather than lingering on.

As to the necromancer who slew Monette, would that be the run away clone from Todstein?
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

cure wrote:As to the necromancer who slew Monette, would that be the run away clone from Todstein?
Could be, although we hadn't actually discussed that possibility! Feel free to make Thedmore the culprit IYC, if you like. :)

IIRC, Joel'd initially meant for the killer to be Meredoth himself, testily blasting the werebat out of the sky at long range, but that option was largely ruled out once we started integrating the domains' timelines. (Monette's temporary death preceded his island's incorporation into the Nocturnal Sea, so they wouldn't have shared a border at the time.) Nonetheless, it does give Monette considerable cause to hate his necromantically-inclined neighbor ... assuming he ever realizes he has one, that is.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

cure wrote:The ships are remarkably durable. Vessels caught in rocks that a moderate sea would destroy in days are described as lingering for years if not decades. This seems largely unnecessary.
Considering how there's been a spoiled wedding cake sitting in Castle Ravenloft's dining hall for 400+ years, never quiiiite collapsing into dust, I wouldn't place too much weight on natural decay-rates' being consistent in the Land of Mists. Certainly not when the shattered reminders of a darklord's greatest crimes and failures can linger indefinitely in place, to mock them.... :twisted:
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
JDCorley
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 9
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:30 pm
Location: Tucson

The Fugitive

Post by JDCorley »

The Fugitive

The player characters are approached by the civil authorities, low-ranking personages concerned with the day-to-day details of the administration of justice. They are deeply concerned. A warrant for the arrest and trial of the Richemulot traitoress Bernadine Le Dontecu has been sworn out for some time now. They were awaiting the outcome of her trial in Mordent, where she was apprehended after fleeing the border towns which had harbored her and her seditious ways. There was no point in extraditing her if she was to be decapitated.

However, the local authorities lack leverage over the more powerful Mordentine nobles and information has not been forthcoming. Could the player characters, as personages of good standing and experienced travellers find out the status of Le Dontecu and insist upon the legal rights of the area?

Dontecu's crimes, borne of madness inflicted upon her as a child by cruel and legally untouchable nobility, led her to a reign of sabotage and terror, degrading eventually into, it is whispered, debauchery and even the cannibalistic witchery to absorb the power of the noble blood she hated into herself. Poor conditions and inhuman treatment by local leaders against the populace led many to help her hide and prosper as a revolutionary. When a reformist leader and his men came, however, and exposed her insanity, her previous associates turned on her in return for lenient treatment. All the crimes of her followers would be laid at her feet.

The players travel to Mordent and discover that Le Dontecu was convicted, but before she could be sentenced to death, and the warrant the players possess discharged, the prison where she was held was assaulted by a mob intent on vigilante justice. In the confusion, she escaped. Embarrassed and mortified, the Mordentine nobility have tried to keep her escape quiet, in order to keep the political situation from spiraling out of control.

The player characters will fairly easily pierce the curtain of silence, as those perpetrating the coverup are more nervous about exposure than they are uncooperative with the attempt to bring her to justice. Indeed, the player characters are welcomed to try to find the escapee, although the Mordent leadership has already paid a princely sum to the implacable bounty hunter Aldrich Belden, a keen-minded investigator who tracked her via the very few contacts who remained loyal to her to the docks, where she bribed her way onto a smuggler's sloop. Belden gave pursuit in a small Mordentine naval vessel he commandeered for the purpose. Neither has been heard from in some days.

The player characters may investigate Le Dontecu's contacts and intimidate them into giving up her eventual destination - an island in the Finger known for harboring pirates and scoundrels. Investigating there or in nearby ports will reveal neither the smuggler's ship, The Coppinger nor the Mordentine cutter Hayle's Health has been seen, sidewise looks and muttered rumors note that the Devil's Lighthouse has been spotted...and that a ship matching the Coppinger's description was silhouetted raised high up on the rocks, at a great distance...

In reality, the Coppinger smashed on the rocks, killing everyone aboard but Le Dontecu herself and the Health barely survived a deadly scrape with a reef.

Now on the island, Bernadine Le Dontecu plays a deadly game of cat-and-mouse with her unstoppable pursuer, while the sailors guarding the one ship that can get them back off the island are picked off one by one in the night. Mutiny and flight seems inevitable...

Obviously there are many opportunities for adventures along the way, travelling from place to place, but in the end...

Can the players find the fugitive? Has she hatched a diabolical scheme with the cursed darklord of L'Ile? Will anyone escape...or will Belden's obsession with his prey lead him to plunge into the darkness forever?

NPCs

Bernadine Le Dontecu

Female Human Rogue 8
Chaotic Evil

Strength 10 (+0)
Dexterity 10 (+0)
Constitution 13 (+1)
Intelligence 13 (+1)
Wisdom 13 (+1)
Charisma 17 (+3)

Size: Medium
Height: 4' 11"
Weight: 120 lb
Skin: Pale
Eyes: Light Brown
Hair: Dark Brown; Wavy

Total Hit Points: 42

Speed: 30 feet

Armor Class: 10

Touch AC: 10
Flat-footed: 10 (uncanny dodge)

Initiative modifier: +0
Fortitude save: +3 = 2 (base) +1 (constitution)
Reflex save: +6 = 6 (base)
Will save: +3 = 2 (base) +1 (wisdom)
Attack : +6/+1 = 6 (base)

Dagger (1d4, crit 19-20/x2, range inc 10 ft., 1 lb., light, piercing)

Shortbow (1d6, crit x3, range inc. 60 ft., 2 lb., piercing)

Feats:

Athletic
Leadership (Bernadine has been deprived of the advantage of her followers due to being arrested and hunted. She may regain them over time.)
Persuasive
Point Blank Shot


Skills:

Appraise +6, Balance +4, Bluff +16, Climb +2, Decipher Script +3, Diplomacy +18, Disguise +8, Escape Artist +8, Forgery +1, Gather Information +14, Intimidate +18

(These include all feat bonuses, stat bonuses and most common synergy bonuses, other skills are at their base levels)



Knowledge (nobility) +3
Listen +12
Move Silently +3
Open Lock +4
Sense Motive +9
Spot +5
Survival +1
Swim +2
Use Magic Device +11

Special Bonuses:

Her level in the Bluff skill gives +2 on disguise checks to act in character.
Her level in the Escape Artist skill gives +2 on Use Rope checks for bindings.

Human:

* Extra feat at first level (already included)
* Four extra skill points at first level (already included)
* One extra skill point at each additional level (already included)

Rogue:

* Sneak Attack +4d6
* Trapfinding
* Evasion (level 2)
* Trap Sense (level 3)
* Uncanny Dodge (level 4)
* Improved Uncanny Dodge (level 8)

Bernadine's story is actually quite sad. A fiery passion for justice in her youth was exploited by a vampiric lover who tormented her into insanity, inadvertently creating a bloodthirsty political revolutionary from an idealistic young woman. She may, at the GM's discretion, have evidence of being a vampire's thrall at various points in her life, or still carry evil blood-driven magical items that she can unleash when cornered. Adept with a shortbow, she prefers hiding and striking from darkness to direct confrontation, especially with superior forces. Her weakness is that she does not know the island and lacks even basic wilderness survival skills - which is why she must keep Monette loyal to her at all costs, even though she fully intends at some point to backstab him, or to drink his blood and take his power for herself.

Aldrich Belden

Male Human Ranger 4 / Rogue 4
Lawful Neutral

Strength 12 (+1)
Dexterity 10 (+0)
Constitution 13 (+1)
Intelligence 16 (+3)
Wisdom 13 (+1)
Charisma 10 (+0)

Size: Medium
Height: 6' 2"
Weight: 190 lb
Skin: Tan
Eyes: Dark Brown
Hair: Dark Brown; Straight; Light Beard

Total Hit Points: 42

Speed: 30 feet

Armor Class: 10
Touch AC: 10
Flat-footed: 10 (uncanny dodge)

Initiative modifier: +0
Fortitude save: +6
Reflex save: +8
Will save: +5
Attack (handheld): +8/+3
Attack (unarmed): +8/+3
Attack (missile): +7/+2
Grapple check: +8/+3


Club [1d6, crit x2, range incr. 10 ft., 3 lb, one-handed, bludgeoning]

Longbow [1d8, crit x3, range inc. 100 ft, 3 lb, piercing]

Feats:

Combat Expertise
Endurance [free to rangers]
Iron Will
Point Blank Shot
Rapid Shot [ranger archery track]
Exotic Weapon Proficiency (Net)
Track [free to rangers]

Traits:


Balance +5
Diplomacy +5
Gather Information +11
Handle Animal +7
Heal +6
Hide +7
Intimidate +11
Listen +12
Move Silently +7
Profession (bounty hunter) +8
Ride +10
Spot +12
Survival +12
Swim +3
Use Rope +4

* = check penalty for wearing armor

First-level Ranger spells: 1 (0+1) per day

Human:

* Extra feat at first level (already included)
* Four extra skill points at first level (already included)
* One extra skill point at each additional level (already included)

Ranger:

* Favored enemies (human +2)
* Track as bonus feat (already included)
* Wild empathy (roll level + charisma bonus + 2 for Handle Animal synergy bonus)
* Endurance (level 3)
* Animal Companion (level 4) (Hawk)

Favored Enemies:

* Humanoids (human) +2

Rogue:

* Sneak Attack +2d6
* Trapfinding
* Evasion (level 2)
* Trap Sense (level 3)
* Uncanny Dodge (level 4)


After his family was tormented by a bandit king, Belden gained a great appreciation for law and order, turning his natural hunting talents towards brigands and highwaymen. Celebrated by several rather exaggerated and popularized stories of his exploits, none of which he had anything to do with, he found himself drawn into the intrigues of politics, where his talents as a bounty hunter were put towards more and more elaborate and sensitive tasks. Now he hunts primarily for the challenge of catching the prey - although he continues to talk, in his quiet way, about justice, deep inside himself he is starting to wonder if perhaps he is addicted to the chase more than satisfied by delivering them to gaol. His weakness in this adventure is that he has no mount and can't use the superior mobility he is used to to get ahead of his prey. His hawk is a masterful advantage on the stony island, driving Bernadine to hide where the hawk can't see, at least until she kills it...
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

JD, that's something that could fit with Tempête as an adventure hook!
cure wrote:Well done. A lonely Monette who is eager to talk is a great improvement. His character development is excellent as is his relation with bats and their varients.
Thanks!
I find a skull, even or especially a disembodied one, to be, however, unappealing as the source of the light.
Oh. Well, I tried to warp it all together into one story, and thought interesting the idea that his nephew’s skull, being the skull of the person that made him a darklord, was the beam attracting people to the island.

By the way, I also thought for a moment of this dread possibility idea: perhaps Monette knows his beam can also sent people elsewhere (but not himself of course). He have seen a few people "sucked" into the beam on whatever condition (new moon?). But similar to the Gundar blood gate in Hunadora, Monette doesn't know / care where they go (even if he could lie that he does.). I thought this could be a good way to get rid of powerful / annoying visitors?
I am only slightly more sympathetic towards the nephew and his murder. Is the rationale that Monette's evil was somehow lacking for Darklord status in their absence?
The Darklords entry was extremely short (a few paragraphs at the most) in that we had to extend this a lot for the FoS Report (where one would expect detailed background). I had something with Monette’s fiancée, but Sharon came with this idea of adding his nephew to the mix, and making his slaying the thing that made him go over the top to darklordship. That was the choice he made.

I also toyed with the idea of removing him from darklordship and simply make him a one-shot cursed human.
Speaking of the light, I am not sure there is an advantage in stating that it can reach into other planes only once a year.
I found it a nice touch of having it reach the planes on the anniversary of Monette’s arrival on RL. Indeed, but as a DM tool, it means it can be “on” any time when needed ;)
Given that Monette has no way of policing undersea monsters and given the rich prey he offers up in terms of ships' crews, there should be consequential predators. Not krakens but certainly scavengers that rob Monette of his prey from time to time, and perhaps drive him to drink or even send visiting adventurers after them. Would this be best tackled with an encounter table for the shore and immediately surrounding sea?
Good point there, that’s indeed another way to add to this place.
I have serious doubts that reefs were conceived by the Dark Powers to line up ships at high tide but to spare them at low tide. Why wouldn't there be reefs all the way down? At best, when the tide is high, there might be no reefs visible. So at low tide, one would have a warning that the area is reef infested, but certainly not hope that all the reefs of consequence are now visible.
One way to see it, indeed, but then it means the near only entry point to the island is by getting your ship wrecked. See next point too.
The ships are remarkably durable.
Well Sharon answered this, but I’d like to add that one design goal I was pursuing was to make the island something more that “hey, there’s a lighthouse, oh, we are wrecked”. So having these wrecked ships there gave plenty of adventure hooks, which was a design choice very different from the Darklords entry. I thought that having all these different wrecks there could give DMs many ideas for their PCs to visit the island, or to find other adventure hooks by plundering wrecks for parts.

Or a reason to go there more then once, to move away from the “let’s kill the DL and get away from this place” scheme that was in Darklords.

I asked for wrecks ideas on Enworld, and got many suggestions. I had to reset these for RL, but I kept most of them.

But a DM could also select just a few wrecks at any given time, instead of the whole area filled with old wrecks.
As to the necromancer who slew Monette, would that be the run away clone from Todstein?
Indeed, see Sharon’s answer. That was my intention IIRC, but we let this as a mystery later. The spell caster mistrust was to give another personality trait to Monette.

---

I liked the description of the sunset – eerie long shadows, mix of black and golden orange (rocks), and later when the sun sets, it’s very dark. I saw this as very helpful in atmospherics. Ravenloft is often a mix of horrors set in beautiful landscapes. Since the island’s top surface is mainly rocks and shrubs, I thought of a way to create dread with these long shadows where anything could hide.

The first time PCs see it, it’s beautiful. After, since Monette likes to hunt by night, the survivors see this sunset as dread: he will be coming back soon…

---

Monette and île de la Tempête have French names. So I suggested that Monette come from French Caribbean pre-GE, so the Port-of-the-Prince port where he comes from (Haiti)

Before Chris Nichols reminded me that he already had a first name in Darklords, I had him named Archibald Monette :)

---

Sharon suggested the “nervous habits” Monette developed as a werebat lycanthrope, i.e. tilting his head and similar.

---

Chris suggested decimation as a way top punish his crew, hence the card drawing for hanging.

---

Another idea that didn’t make the final cut: if Monette is killed, what happens to the light house beam while he is dead or in the regrow phase? Sharon suggested the beam could turn to illuminate Monette's corpse. That is very eerie. And it can be creepy after a long battle, to see the beam reaching for him...

---

That’s it for now !

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

And I forgot to say the main designer for Monette's stat was Giamarga! It was a fun cooperation.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

Thanks Joel.
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Frank, if you want to add details on the stat creation, please feel free to do it here.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Post by The Giamarga »

Well there isn't that much to say about his stats. I followed the description and stats from 2E source closely. His backstory provided many of the feats and skills. (Diehard because he survived the keelhauling, courageous because he was said to be fearless, etc.) I also consulted with the seabased netbook a lot for his build. Applying the werebat template was a bit tricky, but between the FR werebat, the SRD and Sean Reynolds Were-progression classes we persevered.

His equipment and tactics are a bit inspired by the Robinson Crusoe movie with Pierce Brosnan. (I think the Crusoe angle should be played up a bit more in his story, after all Ravenloft is all about amalgamating different pastiches.)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Joël of the FoS wrote:
I am only slightly more sympathetic towards the nephew and his murder. Is the rationale that Monette's evil was somehow lacking for Darklord status in their absence?
The Darklords entry was extremely short (a few paragraphs at the most) in that we had to extend this a lot for the FoS Report (where one would expect detailed background). I had something with Monette’s fiancée, but Sharon came with this idea of adding his nephew to the mix, and making his slaying the thing that made him go over the top to darklordship. That was the choice he made.
Frankly, we thought the Darklords description of Monette's crimes as a human was a bit skimpy. Yes, he was a brute, but there would've been literally thousands of other sea captains with an equally bad attitude on his world of origin. Obviously the Dark Powers didn't claim any of the others, so there needed to be something darker in his history, that made Monette stand out.

There's canon precedent for potential darklords' being subjected to a test of their nastiness, when they first attain a domain. Both Azalin and Von Kharkov went through a transition period when they entered the Mists -- Azalin, split into two facets of his identity in King of the Dead; Von Kharkov, confronting visions of old enemies in his Tales of Ravenloft short story -- and only became full-blown darklords when they responded to their circumstances with ruthlessness and violence. Had Monette not murdered his nephew on sight, and out of human wrathfulness rather than werebat hunger, he might well have remained as an ordinary (albeit lycanthropic) outlander, not a darklord.

Joel's fiancee idea was good too, BTW, but there's already been so many darklords whose love lives messed them up that it's a bit stale as a plot device. Plus, one of the Nocturnal Sea's running themes was loneliness -- Evensong trapped in his parlor for centuries, the Lady wishing the ravens would speak to her, Meredoth so antisocial he can barely relate to his own familiar, Easan suspecting everyone around him is a figment of his imagination -- and proclaiming that one of its darklords had been married or engaged in the past would violate that theme.




Given that Monette has no way of policing undersea monsters and given the rich prey he offers up in terms of ships' crews, there should be consequential predators. Not krakens but certainly scavengers that rob Monette of his prey from time to time, and perhaps drive him to drink or even send visiting adventurers after them. Would this be best tackled with an encounter table for the shore and immediately surrounding sea?
Mundane scavengers such as sharks or eels, certainly. Scouts from Virundus's undersea empire have probably also begun sniffing around Tempete, looking for potential prisoners or salvagable surface-crafted items, although the unpredictable currents would make this difficult. (Just because you breathe water doesn't mean you shouldn't fear being swept up by the waves and dashed against sharp rocks! :wink: )
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote: Mundane scavengers such as sharks or eels, certainly. Scouts from Virundus's undersea empire have probably also begun sniffing around Tempete, looking for potential prisoners or salvagable surface-crafted items, although the unpredictable currents would make this difficult. (Just because you breathe water doesn't mean you shouldn't fear being swept up by the waves and dashed against sharp rocks! :wink: )
It seems to be a prosperous place for reavers, aquatic trolls and aquatic ghouls, creatures that can climb aboard a stricten ship. A crew of sea zombies from a ship that broke up and scattered along one of the shores would not be unbecoming. Ravens are a nice touch, to remind sailors that, if lucky, they are destined to become carrion, rather than being carried off in the night by 'something.'
The cure for what ails you
JDCorley
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 9
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 12:30 pm
Location: Tucson

Post by JDCorley »

Joël of the FoS wrote:JD, that's something that could fit with Tempête as an adventure hook!
Feel free to use it for that, or any other purpose. :)
User avatar
Jeremy16
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 323
Joined: Fri Dec 16, 2005 1:38 am
Location: Louisville, KY

Post by Jeremy16 »

This was a very straightforward and tidy chapter. The domain description did a good job of recapping the information found in the Darklords accessory and expanding it just enough to make the island more interesting.

A Permanent Colony

I know this was suggested on the message boards before, and I’m glad it made it into the book. It’s a good way of drawing players to the island without running the standard shipwreck adventure. It also makes sense that someone would eventually try this. The idea of someone trying to establish a permanent settlement on the island (perhaps peasants from Nova Vaasa, who decide to set sail for a new land free from their old masters) is rife with possibilities.

Shipwrecks

Counting them up, there were 28 entries in this sidebar. While I like the detail given to each ship, I think this section could have been tightened up. Some descriptions were too generic, and some ideas seem to be repeated. But I guess there’s no law saying anyone has to use them all, so having a variety to choose from is a good thing.

Captain Monette

I liked the in-text meeting with Captain Monette. It was a good way to illustrate how an encounter with this particular darklord would go. The description of the lighthouse was also well done.

The Bats

I’m not sure why there needs to be two different species occupying the domain. Is this a plot point I’m missing? That being said, I like the attention given to the island’s dominant species. The sidebar about the Afflicted Bats is an interesting addition, but I’m not sure a lot can be done with them.
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Two possible and slight contradictions:

Monette has developed a hatred of spellcasters but proceeds to hail one flying about. Perhaps it was specified that the hatred was directed at necromancers, but is he really likely to know the difference?

The dread possibility has Monette gathering pen, paper and bottles to dispatch 'invitations' to the unwary. The description of the ship wrecks have pen and paper untouched.
The cure for what ails you
Post Reply