FoS Report in depth analysis - L’Île de la Tempête

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Jeremy16 wrote:The Bats

I’m not sure why there needs to be two different species occupying the domain. Is this a plot point I’m missing?
Hey Jeremy16! It's definitely great to see someone from my own neck of the woods! :)

Since I wrote the portion in question, I suppose I ought to provide an answer. It'll be a bit round-about, so please bear with me...

The meta-purpose of my one-page Tepetian bat entry was to answer that lingering question, "How is it that Monette became a werebat simply by eating bats?" Since this isn't a normal vector for lycanthropy, it seemed to beggar an explanation.

When I wrote the article, it was in the middle of the summer and there was another outbreak of the West Nile virus. That got me thinking about the mosquito and how it can take a disease from one victim, store the virus/bacteria within itself in a way that doesn't infect itself, and then pass that still-active disease on to a new victim. Could that method be applied to bats?

Monette obtained the dread disease of lycanthropy by eating a bat. As such, my submission needed to cover predators eating such infection-carrying bats and getting infected, so as to compare with Monette's eating and getting infected. Unfortunately, though, L'Ile de la Tempete is pretty barren and can't support much in the way of life, so finding a predator for my bat wasn't really working... And so I looked to see if some bat species are predators for other bat species. I found a few and so went with that, thus putting two different bat species in my submission.

So, to answer your question, did there need to be two types of bats? No, but I did need one type and a predator for that one type, and having bats prey on bats just seemed to work. In retrospect, though, I wish I'd done some more research and found an appropriate raptor to be the predator... Oh, well, so it goes.

<><><><><><><><><><><>

The submission failed as a whole, anyway. My main points (and why they didn't work out):

1) Why did eating a bat change Monette? (Wasn't that important, and didn't get the point across to the in-game Gaz writer that he shouldn't eat the wildlife)

2) Link to the Becoming Plague, a Dread Possibility in the Richemulot section of Gaz III, as both deal with using normal animals as carriers for lycanthropy. (My reference to Dr. Milhavet was a little too oblique and so I think it failed)

3) Create a specie of demihuman-eating aquatic humanoids, the Ikosik, which was a reference to my Liffean submission (ALTO) regarding Armeikos as Arme and Ikos, with Ikos falling into the ocean for its citizens' crime of rampant cannibalism -- the Ikosik are the cursed descendents of Ikos's cannibals, cursed to search for but never find their lost city of Ikos. (This was *way* overshadowed by Virundus, which I had no idea was coming; if I did, I would have linked the Ikosik to Virundus and wouldn't have been so coy about the idea of an aquatic humanoid specie)
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

On the chapter as a whole, I found it worked quite well. One thing seemed odd to me, however:

It's made quite plain, both from the people snatched from the shipwreaks and from the individual sailor stolen from the Black Pelican, that Monette has a considerable ability to fly out across the waters and attack. However, in my mind, this seems to conflict with his Landlocked (Su) quality (p307) that makes him weaker and weaker the further he gets from shore...

Are those shoals a lot closer to the shore than I imagined upon my reading of the chapter?

And, with the Black Pelican being "just a tiny point on the horizon" when Monette sees it (p99) and yet Monette loses -1 from Con and Str for every 300 ft from shore, how was he strong enough to pull a full-grown man from the ship, much less cross the distance to the ship to begin with?

I dunno, it just seems a touch odd to me.

Especially since, if he can cross that distance and get to the Black Pelican, then he could land on the Pelican and do some sailing, thus contravening his curse that keeps him from ever engaging in his one true love again.

Thoughts?
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Well, most of the shipwrecks he raids are only a few hundred feet from shore. If he's hungry enough, Monette can put up with a little weakness and nausea to snatch up a victim from a rock-hung derelict. Most sailors would be low-level experts, hence wouldn't be able to defend themselves against him even if he's not at his physical peak. Given how dangerous the waves and currents are among the shoals, they don't need to be all that far from shore to trap shipwrecked victims on the derelicts.

As for the "tiny dot" reference, you're right, that's a bit of a discrepancy. Perhaps Captain Howe took his ship farther offshore for a time, the better to keep clear of the rocks and to watch the whole island for Viktor's signal? Then, when it got dark(er), he took Black Pelican closer to the isle to find a secure anchorage for the night.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

cure wrote:Two possible and slight contradictions:

Monette has developed a hatred of spellcasters but proceeds to hail one flying about. Perhaps it was specified that the hatred was directed at necromancers, but is he really likely to know the difference?
No, it's more of a "darn, now this one is casting spells... I hate those... Better meet him ASAP to see what kind... Better an evil you know... Closer I can battle him, from a distance they cast spells"

He wanted to assess the threat, and if it goes bad, he flees in bat form.
The dread possibility has Monette gathering pen, paper and bottles to dispatch 'invitations' to the unwary. The description of the ship wrecks have pen and paper untouched.
From Viktor's story:

I located the officers’ quarters and
searched for a logbook, but didn’t find any.
When the second boat was similarly devoid
of such journals, I had an intuition which
further wreck-searches bore out: the ships
had been stripped of any and all written
material – no logs, letters, or books remained
on board. I found blank paper, ink and quills,
but no writing. Someone, or something, was
hungry for literature?
Last edited by Joël of the FoS on Mon Apr 13, 2009 9:39 am, edited 1 time in total.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

Lord Cyclohexane wrote: 1) Why did eating a bat change Monette? (Wasn't that important, and didn't get the point across to the in-game Gaz writer that he shouldn't eat the wildlife)
You can also add that the Watchers helped a bit too. They had brought him to RL at that point, and they needed to give him a curse too.

Also, it's not only eating bats. Note that some of them were lapping the blood on him when he awoke in the cave. Their saliva could be a way the Watchers used to curse Monette.

---

Good one, Lord C. I saw that too but by then the book was out. I admit it needs more explanation, but you can easily explain/retcon it by saying Howe took his boat closer indeed, at one point during the night. It could be for any reason you need in game (Sharon’s proposition is good; a trickery by Monette – false light signal (he spied on Viktor and saw him signal the ship every few hours); the currents brought him closer at one point; during Howe’s sleep, the nightwatch fell for the beam but Howe somehow realizing they were now very close took the wheel and moved the ship farther, etc.)
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Well, most of the shipwrecks he raids are only a few hundred feet from shore. If he's hungry enough, Monette can put up with a little weakness and nausea to snatch up a victim from a rock-hung derelict. Most sailors would be low-level experts, hence wouldn't be able to defend themselves against him even if he's not at his physical peak. Given how dangerous the waves and currents are among the shoals, they don't need to be all that far from shore to trap shipwrecked victims on the derelicts.
That is how indeed I saw it. The currents bring the boats very close to the island’s side, may be 500 feet at the most when they wreck.

So for Monette, it's a minor disgust to get there, to search a wreck or to snatch victims.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Actually, I think I found better:
Lord Cyclohexane wrote:Especially since, if he can cross that distance and get to the Black Pelican, then he could land on the Pelican and do some sailing, thus contravening his curse that keeps him from ever engaging in his one true love again.
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:As for the "tiny dot" reference, you're right, that's a bit of a discrepancy. [snip fluff-based retcon]
Joël of the FoS wrote:Good one, Lord C. I saw that too but by then the book was out. I admit it needs more explanation, but you can easily explain/retcon it by [fluff-based reasons, snipped]
Honestly, why are we trying to come up with reasons to change a perfectly good story (the fluff) when the problem is really with a silly bit of crunch from way back in 2nd Ed?

I mean, really, Monette's curse should be all about 1) creating isolation and loneliness for M and 2) keeping M from engaging in his true love, sailing, ever again. How exactly does M's physical proximity to his island make any difference whatsoever, considering that there is no habitation to visit within his domain's borders and that flying to the edges of his domain wouldn't give him the exuberance that sailing to those same edges would have? How exactly does that change if a shipwreck or functional ship is 1000 ft away from shore as opposed to 100 ft away?

I say we scrap the old Landlocked drawback that originated from Darklords as it doesn't really fulfill the requirement.

In its place, I say we give Monette an allergy to seaworthy vessels: if Monette ever steps foot on any part of a functional ship (decks, masts, rigging, etc), he immediately takes 1d10 points of damage (or whatever it is that vampires take when hit by sunlight).

If Monette wishes to visit a wreck, that's completely fine since he can't sail it. If Monette wishes to fly over a seaworthy vessel like the Black Pelican and attack or snatch a crewmember, he's perfectly welcome so long as he doesn't land on it (or get knocked from the air by a lucky shot and crash onto the deck or get caught in the rigging). If he wishes to use his (IIRC) Current Control power to beach the ship, he can then walk on it normally since it's lost the ability to sail. (Think of the horror checks as the crew thinks it's at least safe in the hold, since the monster can't land on the ship, and then learns that this is no longer the case once they run aground...)

I'd also extend this as a change of his vulnerability to silver: if anyone strikes Monette with an implement that is part of a functional ship (whether it's a bit of the bannister that's been ripped off, a fully functional oar, a piece of rigging used as a garrote, or what-have-you), this will bypass Monette's damage reduction or act as a +1 weapon or whatnot.

Of course, there'd be nothing stopping Monette from destroying the ship and thus making the weapons powerless... But then, if the heroes created so much as a seaworthy raft by lashing together wreckage from other ships, those weapons would regain their power...

Anyway, this would then resolve my issue with the fluff while also giving Monette a more fitting curse, not to mention making him more dangerous by allowing him to attack vessels still at sea (well, actually Joël is the one that made him more dangerous; I'm not trying to take credit for that). Additionally, that may make Monette even more isolated as he can now fly far enough to smack into the borders of his domain, finally learning for sure that no matter how hard he tries to make it further and further before passing out that there is nowhere to escape to... (Better might be, at the border, he can just see another island, outside his grasp...)

Thoughts? (My apologies again on my long-windedness...)
Last edited by Lord Cyclohexane on Mon Apr 13, 2009 12:07 pm, edited 1 time in total.
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

That's a pretty cool option, IMHO: it gives Monette more miles to act. It is a different approach to the limits set on Monette than the canon one.

I would put the same limitation on water in general. He could fly over it, but touching the sea he loves / craves, or a ship would hurt him.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
Lord Cyclohexane
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 512
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 1:59 pm
Location: Tanelorn, OH

Post by Lord Cyclohexane »

Joël of the FoS wrote:That's a pretty cool option, IMHO: it gives Monette more miles to act. It is a different approach to the limits set on Monette than the canon one.
/me is beaming from the FoS approval. Yayfulness abounds! :D
Joël of the FoS wrote:I would put the same limitation on water in general. He could fly over it, but touching the sea he loves / craves, or a ship would hurt him.
While that's a cool idea, I think it almost makes it a little too easy. In the same way that I made my vulnerability (above) apply only to items that are currently part of a functional ship, I'd originally thought to make it as anything that had once been part of a ship until I realized that the raw quantity of shipwreck material made that vulnerability almost irrelevant.

Similarly, with how easy it'd be to knock Monette into the sea during encounters on either functional ships or on the shipwrecks or on the beach or in the seaside caves, it seems to me that the vulnerability would be a bit too common. Not to mention, IMHO your description would also apply to flasks of seawater working like flasks of holy water, which again gives Monette too wide of a vulnerability.

Additionally, while I might need to reread the Darklords entry again, I don't recall Monette having a huge love for swimming or for the concept of the sea itself. As far as I recall, he was only really big about boats and sailing. If my recollection is true, denying him access to the water in general would not actually deny him anything that he cares about and so would not be a fitting curse in my eyes.

Of course, considering my taste on what to deny and what to allow curse-wise, I might not be good Dark Power material. :)
My name is lost to me
I know not who I am
And I await the crimson fires
That'll wash this world away!
- Wolfbait, "In My Lonely Time Of Dying"
Post Reply