Divinity of Mankind and losing faith
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Divinity of Mankind and losing faith
Presented for your consideration, hypothetical case A:
Simon is a young man born in Paridon. As a boy, he expects to follow in his father's footsteps, but he soon becomes impressed with Paridon's local religion: the Divinity of Mankind. Finding the Divnity's message that man has unlimited potential an inspiration, Simon joins the church and starts training as a cleric, eventually attaining the power to cast spells. His faith in the superiority of humanity is complete and he is quite vocal about it.
One evening, Simon is attacked in his own home by a dread doppelganger who needs Simon's life for a few days. The doppelganger is a bit negligent, or maybe Simon's just that good. In either case, Simon falls out a window into the river, and his body washes up on the riverbank, battered, broken, filthy. He actually survives until morning, when people start walking by.
Simon calls out to several humans walking past, begging them for help, one of them even a fellow priest. None of them recognize him in his state; the wealthy pass him by because he looks filthy, the poor pass him by becaus there's nothing in it for them to help him out, and the priest even berates him: if he's in such a state, he clearly hasn't lived up to his potential, so he should be glad to die and attain a new chance in his next life. Out of spells, incapable of movement, with his life leaking out of him, Simon despairs and blacks out ...
... and wakes up in a filthy, miserable hovel. As it turns out, a caliban found Simon blacked out, bound his wounds as well as he could and carried him to his home. Over the next days, the caliban (Pjotr) brings Simon what food and medecines he can purchase or steal. When Simon asks Pjotry why he's helping him, the answer is simply "Because you needed help."
Simon recovers enough to return home, but his faith in the doctrine of his church is shattered: even a fellow priest was incapable of seeing past the external aspects of his fellow man, and worse, showed a distinct lack of nobility. Simon still believes in people's potential, but he no longer believes in the church that sheltered him for so long. He also does not believe that the potential for divinity resides with humans alone any longer: he invites Pjotr into his home and, in gratitude, presents the caliban with every advantage he can offer, including education and an introduction to the training methods of the Divinity of Mankind.
Should Simon lose his spellcasting abilities? Strictly speaking, he is betraying the doctrine of his church. He maintains that the potential to improve still exists, he just doesn't see it in his fellow Paridoners in general anymore -- at least, not the human ones.
Simon is a young man born in Paridon. As a boy, he expects to follow in his father's footsteps, but he soon becomes impressed with Paridon's local religion: the Divinity of Mankind. Finding the Divnity's message that man has unlimited potential an inspiration, Simon joins the church and starts training as a cleric, eventually attaining the power to cast spells. His faith in the superiority of humanity is complete and he is quite vocal about it.
One evening, Simon is attacked in his own home by a dread doppelganger who needs Simon's life for a few days. The doppelganger is a bit negligent, or maybe Simon's just that good. In either case, Simon falls out a window into the river, and his body washes up on the riverbank, battered, broken, filthy. He actually survives until morning, when people start walking by.
Simon calls out to several humans walking past, begging them for help, one of them even a fellow priest. None of them recognize him in his state; the wealthy pass him by because he looks filthy, the poor pass him by becaus there's nothing in it for them to help him out, and the priest even berates him: if he's in such a state, he clearly hasn't lived up to his potential, so he should be glad to die and attain a new chance in his next life. Out of spells, incapable of movement, with his life leaking out of him, Simon despairs and blacks out ...
... and wakes up in a filthy, miserable hovel. As it turns out, a caliban found Simon blacked out, bound his wounds as well as he could and carried him to his home. Over the next days, the caliban (Pjotr) brings Simon what food and medecines he can purchase or steal. When Simon asks Pjotry why he's helping him, the answer is simply "Because you needed help."
Simon recovers enough to return home, but his faith in the doctrine of his church is shattered: even a fellow priest was incapable of seeing past the external aspects of his fellow man, and worse, showed a distinct lack of nobility. Simon still believes in people's potential, but he no longer believes in the church that sheltered him for so long. He also does not believe that the potential for divinity resides with humans alone any longer: he invites Pjotr into his home and, in gratitude, presents the caliban with every advantage he can offer, including education and an introduction to the training methods of the Divinity of Mankind.
Should Simon lose his spellcasting abilities? Strictly speaking, he is betraying the doctrine of his church. He maintains that the potential to improve still exists, he just doesn't see it in his fellow Paridoners in general anymore -- at least, not the human ones.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
A cleric who grossly violates the code of conduct required by his god loses all spells and class features, except for armor and shield proficiencies and proficiency with simple weapons. He cannot thereafter gain levels as a cleric of that god until he atones (see the atonement spell description).
The question is did he grossly violate the code of conduct of his "god"?
I see two possibilities:
1) His personal beliefs havn't changed, he just rejects some parts of the doctrine. Political conflict follows. (This is bound to happen in almost every church as different alignments are allowed for every deity. The could even be a conflict inherent in a pure LG doctrine i.e. a conflict of L vs G. Read spulchrave's excellent Wyre story hour on ENWorld for a great example of this and a deep ontological disourse.)
2) Simon readjusts his own philosophy, which i would see analogous to a cleric switching deties.
The question is did he grossly violate the code of conduct of his "god"?
I see two possibilities:
1) His personal beliefs havn't changed, he just rejects some parts of the doctrine. Political conflict follows. (This is bound to happen in almost every church as different alignments are allowed for every deity. The could even be a conflict inherent in a pure LG doctrine i.e. a conflict of L vs G. Read spulchrave's excellent Wyre story hour on ENWorld for a great example of this and a deep ontological disourse.)
2) Simon readjusts his own philosophy, which i would see analogous to a cleric switching deties.
See also the atonement spell.DotF FAQ wrote:Q. What happens to a cleric who switches deities?
A. The cleric must typically go on a quest to prove his devotion to his new deity. When this is accomplished, a cleric of the new deity grants the first cleric an atonement. At this point, the first cleric regains all of his old class powers and abilities, and chooses two domains for his new deity (p. 18).
- Baron Zamedi
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 100
- Joined: Tue Apr 28, 2009 1:37 pm
I think that in any other world Simon would loose his powers... But this being Ravenloft, religion doesn’t give very rigid codes or standards. Take for example that the Ezran faith allows for 4 different alignments! As the nature of the power Ravenloft's priests receive is uncertain I would guess that this little change of view doesn't lead Simon to loose his powers.
Or maybe what’s really important is what the priest himself thinks, if he believes that his faith is still strong but just different perhaps he will get spells anyways but if he feels like this new philosophy of his doesn’t hold the power he thought the other one had then he doesn’t.
Or maybe what’s really important is what the priest himself thinks, if he believes that his faith is still strong but just different perhaps he will get spells anyways but if he feels like this new philosophy of his doesn’t hold the power he thought the other one had then he doesn’t.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Exactly what I was going to say. The "Unspoken Pact" Sidebar on p64 of the RLPH lays it right out: "Tales even exist of clerics who betrayed the core beliefs of their faith, yet kept their divine powers"Baron Zamedi wrote:I think that in any other world Simon would loose his powers... But this being Ravenloft, religion doesn’t give very rigid codes or standards.
Well, that's not that odd, actually. It's right in the SRD that "A cleric’s alignment must be within one step of his deity’s" That means that unless the deity makes a special rule for himself, any D&D deity can have between 3 and 5 alignments among their priesthood. Ezra is just the only one I've seen that specifically makes each one a different sect.Take for example that the Ezran faith allows for 4 different alignments!
More telling is the example the RLPH gives: Belenus still grants spells to his evil worshippers in Nidala and Tepest who think they are still worshipping the NG god, even though anyone evil is at least two steps away from NG.
Great idea. I'll go you one step further though: Whichever choice makes for a better story is the one to go with. Do you want Simon to feel he's the bearer of a new covenant for his priesthood? or do you want him tortured by the conflict between what he clearly sees is true about the divinity of people vs. what his loss of powers imply.Or maybe what’s really important is what the priest himself thinks, if he believes that his faith is still strong but just different perhaps he will get spells anyways but if he feels like this new philosophy of his doesn’t hold the power he thought the other one had then he doesn’t.
(Another great NPC, by the way, Rock.)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Considering that at least one sect of the DoM has made a well-meaning attempt to (forcibly) bring dread doppelgangers into the fold of Mankind, it's inaccurate to assume that the entire church considers nonhumans to be beyond salvation. Preaching to calibans wouldn't cause him to lose his powers, IMO -- he's just redefining "Mankind" to encompass calibans too -- although if he started claiming that his own kind are innately inferior to calibans, based on his own bad experiences, and that humans are too corrupt to attain enlightenment, he'd certainly have to switch faiths.
FWIW, it'd be amusing if the "priest" who berated the injured Simon was actually the very doppelganger who'd tossed him in the river! Having come by to tidy up the mess, and finding its victim still alive, it might've decided to poke fun at the DoM's doctrines by undermining the arrogant young clergyman's beliefs. The "priest's" comments about how such a failure rightly ought to die seems more in line with the Divinity of Masters than the Divinity of Mankind, anyway.
FWIW, it'd be amusing if the "priest" who berated the injured Simon was actually the very doppelganger who'd tossed him in the river! Having come by to tidy up the mess, and finding its victim still alive, it might've decided to poke fun at the DoM's doctrines by undermining the arrogant young clergyman's beliefs. The "priest's" comments about how such a failure rightly ought to die seems more in line with the Divinity of Masters than the Divinity of Mankind, anyway.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Keep in mind that there is no god granting him powers in the first place.I think that in any other world Simon would loose his powers... But this being Ravenloft, religion doesn’t give very rigid codes or standards.
It is the dark powers. As long as he believes in something, no matter how he twists it, the dark powers are likely to keep granting him power.
I'm sure it talks about this in the Ravenloft PHB as well, but I'm too lazy to dig it out.
- Rock of the Fraternity
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 6844
- Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm
Thanks for the compliment! ^^Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:(Another great NPC, by the way, Rock.)
Rotipher, you have a wicked sense of humour. ^^; Eek. As for the comments being more Divinity of the Masters than Divinity of Mankind ... *waggles hand* Remember, LN does not equal nice. And LE could get real nasty real fast.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:FWIW, it'd be amusing if the "priest" who berated the injured Simon was actually the very doppelganger who'd tossed him in the river! Having come by to tidy up the mess, and finding its victim still alive, it might've decided to poke fun at the DoM's doctrines by undermining the arrogant young clergyman's beliefs. The "priest's" comments about how such a failure rightly ought to die seems more in line with the Divinity of Masters than the Divinity of Mankind, anyway.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Actually, the Ravenloft products have always kept it ambiguous whether or not the gods grant spells to their worshippers in the Land of Mists. In a few cases (e.g. Zhakata, the Overseer), the god is officially established as a false deity, in which case it's generally assumed that the Dark Powers grant the nonexistent god's clergy their spells. In others, direct or circumstantial evidence tells us that the deity had provided the actual source of spells to Ravenloft clerics, as when Vecna's clergy received spells directly from their master in Cavitius, or when the Lawgiver's clergy all lost their spells when Bane got killed during FR's Time of Troubles.Troile wrote:Keep in mind that there is no god granting him powers in the first place.
It is the dark powers. As long as he believes in something, no matter how he twists it, the dark powers are likely to keep granting him power.
I'm sure it talks about this in the Ravenloft PHB as well, but I'm too lazy to dig it out.
In most cases, however, it's left up to individual DMs to decide whether a cleric's spells are deity-granted, DP-granted, or simply a manifestation of the character's own faith.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Maybe I'm confusing the Divinity of Mankind.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Actually, the Ravenloft products have always kept it ambiguous whether or not the gods grant spells to their worshippers in the Land of Mists. In a few cases (e.g. Zhakata, the Overseer), the god is officially established as a false deity, in which case it's generally assumed that the Dark Powers grant the nonexistent god's clergy their spells. In others, direct or circumstantial evidence tells us that the deity had provided the actual source of spells to Ravenloft clerics, as when Vecna's clergy received spells directly from their master in Cavitius, or when the Lawgiver's clergy all lost their spells when Bane got killed during FR's Time of Troubles.Troile wrote:Keep in mind that there is no god granting him powers in the first place.
It is the dark powers. As long as he believes in something, no matter how he twists it, the dark powers are likely to keep granting him power.
I'm sure it talks about this in the Ravenloft PHB as well, but I'm too lazy to dig it out.
In most cases, however, it's left up to individual DMs to decide whether a cleric's spells are deity-granted, DP-granted, or simply a manifestation of the character's own faith.
I didn't think they worshipped a god?
I thought they were more self reliant and the religion comes from the idea of humans being potentially perfect beings.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
True, the Divinity of Mankind doesn't worship a god, but the philosophical ideal of human perfectibility. IIRC, it started out as a concept that TSR's Ravenloft writers imported from the 2E Complete Priest's Handbook, although it's evolved into something much more distinctive since then.
My previous post wasn't intended to suggest that the DoM worshipped a god, but only that the Dark Powers aren't necessarily the ones who grant clerics of the DoM their spells. None of the Ravenloft products have been eager to define the DPs' role and limitations, and that includes how much role they play in clerics' acquisition of spells.
My previous post wasn't intended to suggest that the DoM worshipped a god, but only that the Dark Powers aren't necessarily the ones who grant clerics of the DoM their spells. None of the Ravenloft products have been eager to define the DPs' role and limitations, and that includes how much role they play in clerics' acquisition of spells.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Fair enough.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:True, the Divinity of Mankind doesn't worship a god, but the philosophical ideal of human perfectibility. IIRC, it started out as a concept that TSR's Ravenloft writers imported from the 2E Complete Priest's Handbook, although it's evolved into something much more distinctive since then.
My previous post wasn't intended to suggest that the DoM worshipped a god, but only that the Dark Powers aren't necessarily the ones who grant clerics of the DoM their spells. None of the Ravenloft products have been eager to define the DPs' role and limitations, and that includes how much role they play in clerics' acquisition of spells.
I suppose I've taken to associating the Dark Powers with being the force that keeps Ravenloft together.
For anyone's game they could have spells granted from anywhere/thing, even from outside of Ravenloft.
What I was trying to get at is the Dark Powers could grant the character spells even if his original source stopped.
