Emergency Ravenloft Makeovers
I don't really know anything about Jack Be Quick, but the first thing I would change in him, sure as taxes, would be the name.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
- Yaoi Huntress Earth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 247
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 1:15 am
- Gender: Female
- Location: MO
- Contact:
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Re. Tsien herself:
If there's one thing I think would make sense to change about her, it's to make her a wu jen rather than a necromancer. Not so much because it's "more Asian", but because she's always seemed a lot more interested in working with wood and metal than with the undead. Making her a wu jen with Mastery of the element of Wood, and a secondary interest in that of Metal, would be far more suited to someone who transforms into an animated tree, has crafted powerful cursed bells, and is served by evil treants and con-tinh (= tree-spirits).
That'd go a long way to help alleviate the "Oh hell, yet another necromancer!" problem that plagues too many 2E Ravenloft modules and products, while giving Tsien access to spells and powers that are far more interesting than generic wizardry. Heck, it could even make the bone-and-flesh construction of her palace seem plausible, on something other than a fairy-tale-witch and/or Texas Chainsaw Massacre gross-me-out level. Wu jen all have taboos that they are compelled to heed, to retain their powers, so Tsien's taboo might be that she can never use wooden tools, furniture or housing, to prove her respect for the element she favors. Using bones as a substitute might simply be Tsien's way of making do with materials she is permitted ... and, perhaps, of taking an ironic revenge on her beloved trees' behalf, to utilize humans' bodies in the way humans normally use the bodies of trees. Sort of like how the Floronic Man tried to take a chainsaw to Abigail in Saga of the Swamp Thing.
If there's one thing I think would make sense to change about her, it's to make her a wu jen rather than a necromancer. Not so much because it's "more Asian", but because she's always seemed a lot more interested in working with wood and metal than with the undead. Making her a wu jen with Mastery of the element of Wood, and a secondary interest in that of Metal, would be far more suited to someone who transforms into an animated tree, has crafted powerful cursed bells, and is served by evil treants and con-tinh (= tree-spirits).
That'd go a long way to help alleviate the "Oh hell, yet another necromancer!" problem that plagues too many 2E Ravenloft modules and products, while giving Tsien access to spells and powers that are far more interesting than generic wizardry. Heck, it could even make the bone-and-flesh construction of her palace seem plausible, on something other than a fairy-tale-witch and/or Texas Chainsaw Massacre gross-me-out level. Wu jen all have taboos that they are compelled to heed, to retain their powers, so Tsien's taboo might be that she can never use wooden tools, furniture or housing, to prove her respect for the element she favors. Using bones as a substitute might simply be Tsien's way of making do with materials she is permitted ... and, perhaps, of taking an ironic revenge on her beloved trees' behalf, to utilize humans' bodies in the way humans normally use the bodies of trees. Sort of like how the Floronic Man tried to take a chainsaw to Abigail in Saga of the Swamp Thing.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Oh, I like the wujen idea very much. Here's an old wujen 20 build for Tsien by GreenGiant. (the last build in the post) With the SQs "Watchful spirit, elemental mastery (wood), spell secrets x5, taboos x6. Shapechange (treant only) at will" it fits Rotis description very well. So what that build lacks is to flesh out her 6 taboos and what shape her watchful spirit takes in her imagination. And her spellbook and items of course.
- Kaitou Kage
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2115
- Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2007 11:53 am
- Location: Here and there
- Contact:
Well, based on Chinese history, one major idea comes to mind: the Taiping Rebellion. I don't know if the general idea is completely appropriate for I'Cath, but I'll leave that for you experts to decideYaoi Huntress Earth wrote:So what do you think we can add with the opposing tribe which I suggested being the reincarnations of the men she slayed in that ritual?
The Taiping Rebellion happened during the 19th century and was led by a man named Hong Xiuquan who claimed to be the brother of Jesus Christ. He sought to overthrow the imperial Qing government and claimed he revolted because God showed him the way. Incidentally, this same fellow had tried to pass the Chinese civil service exams and failed (these are the grueling exams on Confucian scholarship that men had to pass to become bureaucrats). Strictly from a secular-historical point of view, it is possible, though probably unprovable that the rebellion started because Hong was discontent with the establishment.
I stress the word possible because I don't want to give the impression that really is why he initiated the rebellion. Hong claimed he started it because he received a vision. I also stress it because if you wanted to adapt the Taiping concept to I'Cath, that sounds to me like a good way to do it. Perhaps a man worked for the old Emperor and when Tsien Chang ousted his lord, the man went into exile. In exile, he somehow decides the Empress must go. You can play various angles here -- she murdered her father, she is a woman and thus unfit, he just doesn't agree with her policies, he's disgruntled for losing his power. In any case, the fellow claims to receive religious revelation (or perhaps he does actually receive some kind of vision) and begins organizing an army to reconquer the domain and kick Tsien Chang out on her fanny. The idea is certainly not unprecedented in Chinese history, though the religious emphasis isn't always present
As far as wood goes, that sounds pretty cool. Something you might be able to play off of, too, is that wood is often associated with the wind in Chinese cosmology. Not sure how that can work with Tsien Chang, but there might be something there.
- Yaoi Huntress Earth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 247
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 1:15 am
- Gender: Female
- Location: MO
- Contact:
Let's see...As sort of a nod to the legend of Mulan, I was thinking that one of the sacrifical victims was a girl in disguise (we'll call her Ming) who sort of looked up to Tsien for her accomplishments and advancements for women. While not blind to Tsien more ruthless side, Ming knew that her father would be too weak to fight and was curious why Tsien would only want men to help her. When Tsien springs her sacrifical trap by locking them in an air-tight room and filling it with poisonious smoke and notices the mists circling the area, Ming offers her soul to the Dark Powers (thinking they're the gods in disguise) to help her and the men.
Having offered part of herself to the DPs has addled her mind a bit, making her believe that she is the illigetimate child of Tsien Chiang and was killed along with them because "she was too much of a threat". The Taiping (the reincarnated solgiers) look to her as their leader, not knowing that Ming is female. While the Taiping don't hate women, they just feel a bit uncomfortable around them and prefer that any outsiders who wish to trade or hire them give them a healthy male child\infant in return. Thinking on an Eastern monk-like existance for them to keep a low profile.
Having offered part of herself to the DPs has addled her mind a bit, making her believe that she is the illigetimate child of Tsien Chiang and was killed along with them because "she was too much of a threat". The Taiping (the reincarnated solgiers) look to her as their leader, not knowing that Ming is female. While the Taiping don't hate women, they just feel a bit uncomfortable around them and prefer that any outsiders who wish to trade or hire them give them a healthy male child\infant in return. Thinking on an Eastern monk-like existance for them to keep a low profile.
I'm a deviant: yaoi-huntress-earth.deviantart.com
- Nevermorrow
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 111
- Joined: Sat May 02, 2009 5:57 am
Sorry to bump an old thread again, but I had the idea of looking up Chinese female names to help name the daughters. This is what I got:Kaitou Kage wrote:Some English-to-Chinese translation:
Hatred: chouhen
Scream: jianjiao sheng (As a name, I'd truncate this to jiansheng, which is part of the verb form. Chinese given names are always one or two syllables, usually two.)
Spite: jinu
Nightingale; yeying
Hate: Given name - Changpu ("forever simple") or Huian ("kind peace"). Nickname Chouhen as above, perhaps occasionally shortened to Hen.
Scream: Several common female names begin with "Ji", but I think the best one for her would be Jiao ("dainty" or "lovely"). Other good ones are Jia ("beautiful"), Jiayi ("household fitting") or Jiaying ("household flourishing"). Nickname Jiansheng, as above.
Spite: See Scream above; a possibly fitting one for her is Jinghua ("situation splendid"). Nickname Jinu as above.
Nightingale: Many of the female names beginning with Y would be good fits as her given name. I think Yuan ("shining peace") or Yuanjun ("goddess" or "princess") would be the best one. Others: Ya ("grace"), Yan ("gorgeous" or "swallow"), or Ying ("clever" or "eagle").
As you can see, I went for a theme that has the first three basically being very unlike the meanings of their given names, where as Nightingale was the opposite, sort of living up to her name.
All this put together carries a few implications about Tsien Chang in her pre-RL homeland. One, the girls were given traditional names that extort weakness or servility in women (in Tsien Chang's view, anyway), so that probably means Tsien Chang was still climbing to power when the girls were born (or created, if you prefer). If Tsien Chang has been at full power, so to speak, she would likely have chosen stronger names, though not necessarily male names, probably giving them names that could also be directly translated words and phrases.
Secondly, the fact the girls have school nicknames says that Tsien Chang did have the power to co-opt or open a girls school when her daughters were still young. If she opened the school herself, it makes one wonder how this was viewed. Did the fathers of the students think they were sending their daughters to learn womanly crafts like sewing and hostessing? What was the incentive for men to send their daughters to a school run by a man-hating woman who defied all tradition like Tsien Chang? If she had the power to simply order men to send the girls of her choice to her school then it shows a meteoric rise to power after the birth of Nightingale. Perhaps the first assumption is correct (pretending that they were learning "feminine arts"), but still implies that Tsien Chang's power was growing so fast that even after it became known that the girls were being taught "male" subjects (mathematics, history, etc.) that she was able to order them to not withdraw the girls, maybe even send more of their daughters to her school.
The whole Taiping Rebellion angle interests me. So why not switch it around? In connection with a woman, it makes me think of Tianhou, who like Jesus Christ, was supposed to have originally been a mortal human being. Could Tsien Chang be descended from the family of the Holy Mother? Could she have claimed to be the Holy Mother returned to Earth, offering her intelligence and magical power as proof? That would certainly explain such a quick rise to power; perhaps she wasn't quite that powerful when her daughters were born because she hadn't made her claim as the reincarnation of the Holy Mother yet, waiting until she was more powerful magically. Her preference for the company of eunuchs would be attributed to her purity (even though the goddess she was supposed to be hadn't been noted for any such preference in life).
Formerly known as SpiritCaller.
- brilliantlight
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1003
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm
I made a write up for him here http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... php?t=6429. I gave him two powers emotion and possession.Yaoi Huntress Earth wrote:And the Pennywise-meets-Joker aspect really works for him.
Now what about the Darklord whose past and domain has potiental: Haki Shinpi? I like the idea of a prideful, corrupt honnor-bound warrior especally one who is so convinced that he's the only one who can make things better that he's willing to walk-over, kill, and use an honnor system that other hold above their own lives to ruin them. Much like Thorax from Pibgorn\9 Chickweed Lane, Shinpi also arrogantly believes that humankind as a whole are nothing more than a bunch of worthless, corrupt idiots and that he alone is the smartest\wisest and it's his wisdom and beleifs that can save them from themselves. Making him a ghost that can do nothing was a terrible idea.
I remember another site had something on Shinpi's sons which I remember liking, but Shinpi is the one who need the most work. How about letting him posses people (except his sons) and like a certain headless theif, have the bodies age or lose levels for each week he possess them? Maybe at first he believes his ghost state is more of a reward because he can now stay with his kingdom forever and control his sons without them being the wiser until his curse kicks in.
- Strahdsbuddy
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 605
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: A Finger Lake
I'Cath suffered from a rather weak theory at time of publishing, and that seems to be the feeling of someone at TSR jumping up and saying "Darn we need a Chinese domain!" To say nothing of the fact that the only oriental area in all of published D&D was Kara-Tur, and no mention of this exists in the I'Cath history. So if it seems like it doesnt have a place in the great D&D cosmology, that's probably because it doesn't.
Two situations lead to this kind of thinking. The first is a player saying "I want to be a ninja" and his DM saying "There isn't really a Japanese domain." The player's response: "Ravenloft sucks."
The second is the DM who reads some sort of fable or tale from a different culture and says "That would work great In Ravenloft, but i will need to make an ENTIRE domain that reflects Japanese/Chinese/African/Brazilian/Micronesian culture first..." This is not necissary. Take a few steps back, imagine the characters and situations in a vacuum and try to make it work within the existing framework. Ravenloft is a Euro-centric setting for a reason: Western thought lends itself well to Gothic horror. We don't need a new domain for every culture/concept.
Building entire Clusters around I'Cath to make I'Cath workable seems silly to me. Give her a western name, put her in a rugged part of the Core or the Shadowborn Cluster and make her background into false history. I think that ties it up rather well.
And now i shall be killed by the China-philes on the board!
Two situations lead to this kind of thinking. The first is a player saying "I want to be a ninja" and his DM saying "There isn't really a Japanese domain." The player's response: "Ravenloft sucks."
The second is the DM who reads some sort of fable or tale from a different culture and says "That would work great In Ravenloft, but i will need to make an ENTIRE domain that reflects Japanese/Chinese/African/Brazilian/Micronesian culture first..." This is not necissary. Take a few steps back, imagine the characters and situations in a vacuum and try to make it work within the existing framework. Ravenloft is a Euro-centric setting for a reason: Western thought lends itself well to Gothic horror. We don't need a new domain for every culture/concept.
Building entire Clusters around I'Cath to make I'Cath workable seems silly to me. Give her a western name, put her in a rugged part of the Core or the Shadowborn Cluster and make her background into false history. I think that ties it up rather well.
And now i shall be killed by the China-philes on the board!
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
- Nevermorrow
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 111
- Joined: Sat May 02, 2009 5:57 am
I'm not going to kill you, Strahdsbuddy. But I played RL for years before 3rd Edition D&D and came out, before even the post-GC red box set came out. Back then RL domains were all English, French or Slavic (except for Lamordia -- Falkovnia wasn't as German then). It got kind of monotonous after a while.
Some people prefer a bloat-free simpler campaign setting, while others want a larger one with more diverse cultures.
Some people prefer a bloat-free simpler campaign setting, while others want a larger one with more diverse cultures.
Formerly known as SpiritCaller.
- Yaoi Huntress Earth
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 247
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 1:15 am
- Gender: Female
- Location: MO
- Contact:
Strahdsbuddy: I won't kill you, but I like how the system tried to exploit the horror, mystery and tragic stories that other cultures can provide. They could've put more though at least as much as they did for european ones. It makes things more interesting.
I'm a deviant: yaoi-huntress-earth.deviantart.com
- Strahdsbuddy
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 605
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: A Finger Lake
::Still fearing death::
I think it is harder to pull off since Gothic horror is so ingrained in Western society. particularly Enlightenment-era anti-religion, or the 19th Century Nietzcheism (sp) where humanity started graying the moral lines. It sets a free-willed human on a path where he can become so obsessed with doing good that he actually becomes a monster. Irony is at the heart of the story, and i think a good dose of Catholic guilt as a background only helps that along.
THis is why things like Greek tragedy translate poorly to Ravenloft because so much of the story is based on Fate. Kinda hard to feel like you're making moral choices when everything is already laid out before you, according tot he Oracle.
I wasn't trying to say there was NO place for other cultures (though i guess it did kinda sound that way), only that it feels like jamming a square peg into a round hole. Har-Akir is kind of a one-shot domain, Sri Raji never seemed to work for me, and The additions of I'Cath, Pharazia, and Rokoshima Taiyoo seemed SO tacked on, like what was the point except to create the UN of domains?
THis isnt to say all the post-Black Box stuff was bad. Take Shadowborn Manor/Nidala, later itss own cluster. THERE is a domaint aht works, a pathos driven concept with soemthing a party can sink its teeth into. In fact, if the "foreign" domains had been given the meat that SHadowborn was, they could be workable; but as they are, they are just outlines.
my two pence...
I think it is harder to pull off since Gothic horror is so ingrained in Western society. particularly Enlightenment-era anti-religion, or the 19th Century Nietzcheism (sp) where humanity started graying the moral lines. It sets a free-willed human on a path where he can become so obsessed with doing good that he actually becomes a monster. Irony is at the heart of the story, and i think a good dose of Catholic guilt as a background only helps that along.
THis is why things like Greek tragedy translate poorly to Ravenloft because so much of the story is based on Fate. Kinda hard to feel like you're making moral choices when everything is already laid out before you, according tot he Oracle.
I wasn't trying to say there was NO place for other cultures (though i guess it did kinda sound that way), only that it feels like jamming a square peg into a round hole. Har-Akir is kind of a one-shot domain, Sri Raji never seemed to work for me, and The additions of I'Cath, Pharazia, and Rokoshima Taiyoo seemed SO tacked on, like what was the point except to create the UN of domains?
THis isnt to say all the post-Black Box stuff was bad. Take Shadowborn Manor/Nidala, later itss own cluster. THERE is a domaint aht works, a pathos driven concept with soemthing a party can sink its teeth into. In fact, if the "foreign" domains had been given the meat that SHadowborn was, they could be workable; but as they are, they are just outlines.
my two pence...
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
