Hello Everyone!

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Marxsus
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:28 am
Location: Southwest Virginia

Post by Marxsus »

@Ail

Hey, thanks so much for the advice. I feel as though we may have similar groups, my friends have a "wonderful" habit of dashing my hopes and dreams of a game plan. Ah Well. Anyways, I really appreciate the information and advice, very beneficial. I was seriously confused about the nature of the Islands of Horror, on the maps them seem to be only surrounded by mists.

I think that with Souragne I will simply turn it into an island, similar to Portuguese sugarcane colonies in the 16-18th centuries. However the others, like the Egyptian desert one, I forget the name, but the idea of making it it's own island seems a bit confusing to me... Oh well.

Thanks!
Nothing clever or witty enough comes to mind when I'm asked to provide a signature. Damn.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Marxsus wrote:@Ail
I think that with Souragne I will simply turn it into an island, similar to Portuguese sugarcane colonies in the 16-18th centuries. However the others, like the Egyptian desert one, I forget the name, but the idea of making it it's own island seems a bit confusing to me... Oh well.
Thanks!

No problem, I'm always glad to help. Souragne is usually more of a French thing, and people usually refer to it as being modeled on New Orleans. I used Haiti instead for inspiration, since it is an island and I don't go too well with the american south, but if you want to make it based on Portuguese / Brazilian colonies.... well, just ask away :-D :-D
I'm sure I could find many ways to help you. :misori:
It's not every day that I see someone bringing Portuguese history/culture to the fore as a suggestion.:oops:

The Egyption one is Har'akir. You'd figure that in a mishmash of horror settings, you'd have to have something featuring a mummy :-D Some domains that are nowadays islands of terror, namely Markovia and Bluetspur, were once in the core and were moved away because they didn't fit geographically speaking (Bluetspur namely). And given that the Core has basically a very european climate (Exception made, maybe, to Valachan), Har'akir wouldn't fit there either.

But I don't know if that's the real reason, I don't remember what were the Islands of Terror in the early days of the setting, and whether there was any reason for having them separated at all. I think it's maybe because they were simply out of theme in regard to the domains in the Core, it was like a separate subject the creators wanted to treat independently, but that's a personal guess.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Har'Akir is one of the original Islands of Terror, dating from the initial Black Box set, as well as one of the oldest domains in Ravenloft's internal chronology (~550 BC). The other two Middle East-ish domains, Sebua and Pharazia, come from later game supplements.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Yeah, generally speaking, the Island of Terror domains are not part of the core due to theme. (with some exceptions, of course.) And yes, "Island" is a bit of a misnomer. There are real islands in ravenloft, surrounded by water (like Markovia, Todstein, Dominia, etc.) and then there are "Island" domains, which are surrounded by Mist, but not water at all. (like Bluetspur, and Har'Akir, for example, thought the Mist in the desert takes the form of swirling sands.) To make matters more confusing, there are some Island domains that have some water within them (like Sourangne, or Rokushima Taiyoo).

Generally speaking (without a vistani or anchorite guide, and not on a charted mistway) if you enter the mists via land (say on the south of Sourange), you eventually emerge somewhere else where the Mists border land (say Northern Darkon). And if you enter the mists via water (say on the north of Sourange), you eventually emerge somewhere else where the Mists border water (say The Sea of Sorrows).
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Replyin'

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Marxsus wrote:Funny, if they were meant to be run in a certain order, you would think that the levels would reflect that. Silly planning on their part. :)
Lack of planning, really. I'm pretty sure they had no idea the 1st three would be related until they wrote the 4th. And even when they wrote the 4th, they didn't exactly know what they were going got do in 5 and 6. (Hence the Inajira/Arijani screw-up).
I think I’m going to go the Vistani caravan route, as NotWD already provides an introduction to a Vistani caravan and a family of characters.
Regarding that family... as of Champions of Darkness, Valana, of that family is the leader of a group called the Tribe of Hyskosa. Turns out they were family of the seer, trying to help his prophecy come to pass, rather than killing him, as would be the "proper" vistani response to a male with the sight. For that sin, they were cast out of the vistani as a group and became darklings. Up to you whether you want to incorporate that or not...
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:And yes, "Island" is a bit of a misnomer. There are real islands in ravenloft, surrounded by water (like Markovia, Todstein, Dominia, etc.) and then there are "Island" domains, which are surrounded by Mist, but not water at all. (like Bluetspur, and Har'Akir, for example, thought the Mist in the desert takes the form of swirling sands.) To make matters more confusing, there are some Island domains that have some water within them (like Sourangne, or Rokushima Taiyoo).
Perhaps the native languages of Ravenloft actually use different words for Islands vs islands (or Mists vs mists, for that matter!), and translating the terms into English obscures the distinction? :wink:
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Marxsus
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:28 am
Location: Southwest Virginia

Post by Marxsus »

Alas, Another four hour gaming session down the drain, and still no Ravenloft. Silly players, hurry up! =)

@Ail

Well, Haiti certainly does make more sense. I had forgotten about that island, and how it was at one time a French colony, which I think represents this sort of geography and what I’ve read about Souragne best. Yes, I think Haiti will work.
I think your guess is as good as anyone else’s. Personally, I think that I’m going to run ToD next after the events in NotWD. For a couple of reasons, firstly, it looks fun, and secondly, it fits the level that the heroes are likely to be at.

@Gonzoron

I think I will incorporate that, although the players won’t likely realize the depths of what they’re doing, due to their lack of understanding of the world. Personally, I think that’s a good thing. Hah.

@ AG Thing

Hey, forgot to mention. One of my players isn’t a fighter, actually a Paladin. Also, I have a Ranger joining in as well.
Nothing clever or witty enough comes to mind when I'm asked to provide a signature. Damn.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

By ToD, do you mean Thoughts of Darkness?!!!
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Marxsus
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:28 am
Location: Southwest Virginia

Post by Marxsus »

No, actually. I meant Touch of Death. Sorry, I should have been more specific, I didn't realize two modules contained the same abbreviations.
Nothing clever or witty enough comes to mind when I'm asked to provide a signature. Damn.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

And I should have known you meant one of the GC, but I really couldn't remember that one's name, though I tried :-) Too taken up with other things to go looking too, so I'm to blame

I'm more relieved now, Thoughts of Darkness really doesn't mesh that well. :oops:
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Marxsus
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 15
Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2009 11:28 am
Location: Southwest Virginia

Post by Marxsus »

Heh. Ill just agree that we share the blame equally.

Do you, or anyone else have any particularly favorite RL adventures, and why? :)
Nothing clever or witty enough comes to mind when I'm asked to provide a signature. Damn.
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

@ AG Thing

Hey, forgot to mention. One of my players isn’t a fighter, actually a Paladin. Also, I have a Ranger joining in as well.
Well here goes... These may be more detailed and like all my before suggestions they are based off experience. These can be fitted as well on to other classes with similar motives but they have worked well for me…

On with the show

Paladins tend to be a mixed bag of problems and joys for any DM running a Ravenloft game... Still out of that bag a rich tapestry can be woven! I have met three types of paladins but I have only personally run games for two and watched the other as another player... The first is the Goody Goody Paladin who does everything as a saint and seems slow to act but quick to defend. The second would be the Avenging Paladin that acts kindly but is the wrath of the god they represent to any evil that crosses them. The third is the Inquisitor type Paladin, and I have seen this played and it is perhaps the hardest one to reign in as they cross excesses of their code on a border line while finding the truth of the issues to weed out the guilty...
All paladins suffer similar experiences as clerics in that they are servants of a deity and in Ravenloft that feeling of connection is muted. Still paladins have their code to fall back on and while they may not here the gods as clearly and they can no longer know evil with absolute certainty they tend to fair better. Few paladins have weak will for that sort of thing or they probably would have failed. Not to say that there could not be one but don't expect them to have as much of a reaction as the Cleric to the loss of their god but don't discount it either.
Now I have run a game with the Goody Goody Paladin in another homebrewed setting and I imagine so very much difficulty had I ever brought him into Ravenloft. The standard GG will slow the game when ever there is a moral choice to be made, or if it is combat related they will defend the downtrodden and weak even if they could be villains... Sometimes the refuse to kill intelligent life no matter what… They simply will not act without considering what is right. Therefore when you wish to speed up the moral choice to be for the GG Paladin then you can sometimes give it a time limit and make them choose. They will most likely do one of two things, and the first is to choose the defensive option and try not to harm or do anything possibly corrupting, or they will bow to the groups other suggestions if they are not the leader, and perhaps find themselves having to defend their almost unrealistic standard of good. Now you can do this every so often ( But not always!!! ) to set up a betrayal or backstab for the character and they will be truly shocked when they are. Paladins of all stripes attract conflict in Ravenloft and to truly test a GG Paladin you need the impossible scenario...
This is a scene where the Paladin must make an immoral choice to escape death or save lives and it is harsh. However you should always make it clear that consequences of his choice are negative as well. An example of this is the Paladin who is trapped in an unstable cavern with several villagers and he must maintain order and calm even though it seems hopeless. Food will run out, and they may begin to starve, tempers will flare and while perhaps they still have good air coming in they have no light and begin to go mad. The GG Paladin will most likely try to ration food, cast light to occasionally ease their worries, even talk and council those losing it. However who is there to council them when the pressing walls of weaker souls and hard choices come. When food runs out does he try to deny others chance to eat the dead? When even the light does little but mock the peoples suffering does he continue or despair that his gifts failed to aid them? When finally someone snaps how far does he go to stop them from bringing the unstable cave down further? Will he kill them? Will he snap?
At the end of this challenge however long you wish it to be, there should be some sort of save from an outside force, such as fate knocking a clear path, the others in the party eventually rescuing him if they try, or most regrettably and usually only if agreed in advance the final sacrifice that saves others or is just right. If they live through the rescue then they may have become jaded and quite different or even more sure of their faith in their path... Then again they might also have corrupted themselves quite badly... Save this for something special as it is meant to have impact.
The Avenging Paladin is probably the most complex of the three and I ran this one in the Ravenloft setting. This one reacted most like a regular person and they have rather more realistic emotions and conflicts, making them more normal... For the most part I found that the conflicts I had most success in using to test this paladin involved avenging betrayals. I ran from the Dark Tales and Disturbing Legends the Curse of Ashington Manor and when after a rather interesting encounter in the Asylum portion the Doctor turned on them, and the player made their own choice to strike at the downed Doctor... I was surprised and yet this capacity may have been the player or may have been the character as well. Still it varied from circumstance to circumstance but when ever he was betrayed I found he liked the idea of holding back, or even making that regrettable choice and to try and forgive himself later. Now the biggest event I think that an Avenging Paladin can face is the deceivingly obvious betrayal... You need to craft a web that the rather forthright and straight forward Paladin may, if not very careful mistake the truth. In the end the betrayal never was or the perceived innocent was the villain, and the coincidence of the actions should fit both sides of the story leaning only toward the one you choose by a slim margin. Now this is a one time thing as this should bring the character to one or two conclusions. One they will doubt their actions if they fail to find the truth and shocked as it is revealed, or two they see through the deceptions and now are more confident and rightly so for that matter. After one of these ends is defined however you simply have to play off that in occasional moments, such as if they are doubtful give them things that force them to choose whether to trust rather unknown people again.
Now if they are confident, then throw someone or something to test that confidence in a spitting match of sorts. Some personal slight that is directed at the character and a villain that perhaps hates the Paladin for some reason… This works well with a reoccurring villain if you establish some personal motive. If they get too wrapped up in the events and they begin to chase this taunting evil then you only need throw things in the way to delay this vengeance. Once frustrated enough they will either ignore or battle there way through to get to the main villain. There is where you measure exactly how far they are willing to go to get to them.
Now separately these are all good ways to test the Avenging Paladin but combine them into a connected series and they provide a campaigns worth of events. If perhaps they kill the right person or the wrong person for the betrayal and then one of the family feeling slighted and angry turns down a dark path to harm him, this leads to constant situations where he must doubt who is working for the angry relative and who is earnest. The villain strikes several times until they hit a personal area and attract the players ire. Finally the layers of contacts and deceits of the relative have brought several forces against the character or they place innocents in peril to escape. The player must now choose is vengeance worth any price.
Inquisitor Paladins I have never run for but I have watched one played and I must stress that they are different than most other Paladins I have seen. They use intimidation, gather information, and diplomacy to learn all they can of the truth of what sin’s are beneath the surface of a person. Like straight laced but hard nosed detectives they find the truth, and while they may accept a confession, when they must they can torture to save others… But I am not talking simple torture… I am talking Spanish Inquisition type tortures and he felt no real sorrow that it happened. Now this was in a Forgotten Realms game and the God was Torm, but still they were able to follow the rest of the paladins code by that DM’s reckoning. In Ravenloft torture for a good character is absurd to think of as just, as it is an Act of Ultimate Darkness. Still despite that seeking of evil, he never did other evil things yet he justified that one sin by only doing it as he said to save lives. Beyond this however he was almost as kind as the Goody Goody to people and yet in combat he fought quite vigilantly not to kill to question first, intimidate second, and torture last if he needed to do such…
This category I guess is more along the lines for a Paladin who is entrenched in the dogma of his church, and is given mortal authority to do these things. Still they are wrong and this type is rare but it brings up another issue that could come into play. What do you do if you serve a good god but at times that god or your faiths leaders say it is okay to do these things? It is hard to answer even for me… I imagine that they see it just as any other religious rite… I think then you have to define whether they do it and get no satisfaction from it or despise it…

Rangers are similar to Druids on some levels and yet are also similar to fighters in others… Some prefer two weapons others are ranged… Some like to train animals and others like to be hunters of beasts… While they have the potential to be all these things at once as well, and have minor hedge magic that can be of some use occasionally. Like Druids they are connected to the Natural and draw power from it but it is more of a connection, less of a communion between them. Rangers have less trouble dealing with people but more often they feel distant from people by their personal nature. They are hunters and guides but at times scouts as well. Rangers usually fall into the paths of the mysterious stranger, or the burly woodsman…
Mysterious strangers are often either the silent and stealthy ones who prefer to strike from concealment or with extreme speed and use their knowledge sparingly or magically bent in that they play up the mysticism of their characters. They are already mysterious and like when you expand that mystery in a personal way. There is a tendency for these types to try to be loners and yet they have to connect to the group to work in the game. They prefer solitary action and that is exactly what you need to give them… When ever this character goes of on their own I give them either a real easy task that they can feel mysterious while doing… A hard task that they need to turn back on for help… Or I give them a deceptive task that makes them wish they had the others with them after it is too late to turn back such as a trap. This is just something I have found to add realism and help keep them feeling useful without overshadowing the others very often. Still use the trap varient sparringly when using this as it can be quite annoying when they always suspect a twist.
Now as for corrupting the mysterious stranger… Well this is hard as they have fairly varied personalities but most often they seem to have a cold demeanor of some sort. Emotion is seldom a motivator for them and often they are mercenary in their outlook. Coldly they may ignore those asking for aid if they are turned off by their sensibilities or even a misunderstanding. Few cold individuals can forgive and will be more inclined to be uncaring. Chances for mercy are useful to use against to the cold mysterious stranger as they usually do not grant it especially for enemies.
Still not all are cold and some are downright filled with hidden emotions, and sometimes a deep past to go along with it. However as they still must even for all their solitude, relate to others a good way to freak them out is to have someone track them, know of them, and even disturb or taunt them… Paranoia is the crutch you then may use on them as they can be convinced that perhaps words have double meanings and others are plotting against them. If you really want to make them squirm you can frame conversations with the other players or between NPC’s to make him imagine that they are speaking in code about him. Never admit even in the slightest what you are doing and if the other players are in it as well which I recommend then make sure they do not tell the player either. The paranoia is just a tool for the set up… Now spring the actual villain who while revealing their existence, does not reveal who or what they are… You want this Mysterious Stranger to be seeing conspirators everywhere and they will investigate as you give them both true leads and also false leads.
Depending on how he reacts you can make a lot of moral conflicts… As they stumbles from supposed conspirators they should eventually find a real one but before that he may find nearly harmless pickpockets, drunken thugs, a mad man who speaks nonsense that sounds wise and relevant to his problems. He may if provoked or suspicious enough threaten or harm them to learn what they know. The actual conspirators should know perhaps very little and admit eventually to working for someone wanting to know about the character specifically. Mercenaries may also be sent against them as would be assassins to end their life should they get close.
Now you may ask what do you use to connect this stalker to the character… Well you should watch and see how far they go and then connect something rather impersonal to why. Perhaps the villain thought him/her the villain from their past or there is something that the player put in their background. It could even be as recent as a first adventure in the game that was in the background. Once connected however and the mystery solved the character should look back on either how meaningless the misunderstanding was or with angered regret of what they had to do to solve it. Perhaps their suspicions prevented them from warning the others of the group, as the character thought from the above planned words that one or more of them is in on it. Placing others in danger, harming others on suspicion alone, and perhaps other minor crimes may be committed. Finally you must also decide if the villain is sorry or unable to accept that they may have been wrong. Which ever fits as only you know how delusional and evil they really are.
The Burly Woodsman is led by his superiority of knowledge concerning the woods and also his toughness when faced with hardship. Some are very intelligent and some can also display a wisdom that is like an instinct that drives them. They often also are either just grumpy or overly friendly, when relating to others as they prefer the wilderness and solitude. This Burly Woodsman is proud of his prowess and that is what to target when trying to mess with him… Often they take on their opponents in a sort of hunting fashion and it becomes somewhat personal in that sense…
The woodsman more than any other should feel that he is the most skilled thing in the woods… He will compete with all others and loves a challenge. Hunters and trackers they love to follow and bring down crafty or overtly powerful opponents. If you want this hunter to be happy, give him opponents only he could find, or that require his knowledge to bring down. Almost a monster hunter in some respects but most are more diversified. Still if he selects one monster type then that is your villain most likely.
You have to turn his pride into fear… Make each monster that he is chasing a cunning challenge and when perhaps you get to the one you want, make it turn his strategies on him. If he uses entangle often have the monster know this and almost kill him… You have to be careful not to show that you are holding back as this monster is trying to kill him slowly. Every time he comes after this beast he should have a chance of winning but only if he continually improvises and reacts to the surprise. The monsters traps should be realistic and cunning driving him to do more risky things to stop its predations… The more it wounds him personally the more he will hate it for escaping. Occasionally the Burly Woodsman should win but less than the beast and the creature should never be tricked the same way twice. If he catches the creature make sure there is a way for it to try and escape.
When he begins having to propose things like live human bait, you have started to get him on the hook. The classic captain Ahab scenario and you can as the cunning fades make it more brutal and painful. They will begin going to extremes that could involve torching the forest, killing the live stock to motivate a hunting party, perhaps he will charge off after the beast abandoning the now helpless townspeople to their fates just for following him. He could put everyone at risk and he may not even care or realize it near the end as he just wants the death of the constantly better opponent.
The only way this scenario ends good is if this ranger gets it into his head that he started this hunt to protect people and takes every opportunity to use all resources and does not let this be personal. He has to avoid hunting it on its terms as it is a solo creature and it wants to torment him… If the beast is mystical such as a Demon or such it can become a wonderful amusement to it so if he wants to win, he must avoid giving it the type of raw conflict it wants.

I hope this helps and I realise these are more detailed then the others but I was not wanting to give excess if you did not want it... Still now that you seem to want it I hope you find these just as helpful as the others.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Marxsus, without having actually played them, I would advise The Evil Eye, which seems to be generally well regarded. It is set in Invidia and works like a full gazetteer to that domain. Of course, and this is going to apply to any other 2nd Ed Module, the setting has evolved a lot since it happened, and the motivations of characters, what they do and their age of course have changed a lot.

Another I would be very fond of playing is Bleak House, which ends with a likely death for Rudolph Van Richten, but also seems to be well regarded and have many possibilities.

A lukewarm one that might be interesting for low level characters is Howls in the Night. It seems very inspired in the Hound of the Baskervilles and is set in Mordent. There are things I would change, namely the dogs themselves which would improve if you used Mist Hounds or other similar monsters from the 3.x books, but you've got, iirc, 4 different possibilities for who's the victim and the villain and you can it according to your tastes, which is always good.

Of the remaining ones, perhaps the one I would most likely want to try is Castles Forlorn, because I like so much the idea of a Scottish / Welsh setting, but I hear it requires a lot of work from the DM and your own adventure, as the module seems to be more a way of showing the story of the domain than a problem per se for the PCs to solve.

That's it. Hope that helps. There are also Fan Adventures around on the site, and I hear A Call from Verbrek, if I have the name right, is also very good.

Edit: just a small addendum to HitN.
Last edited by Ail on Mon Jun 08, 2009 10:39 am, edited 1 time in total.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Wow, AG, I'm impressed!, I really am, with how deep you can go on characters' motivations and DM plotting... There's just so much I have to learn or change in my own characters :shock:
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

Thank you Ail! I tend to become quite detail focused, but still they are only ideas and you have to be very crafty to use them and not make them obvious to the players when you shift things in that direction.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Post Reply