the key to ebay is patience. Most non-boxed adventures can be had for <$10, if you're willing to wait and pass up anything that goes too high. (At least, that was the case a couple years ago when I was amassing my complete collection.) Set an ebay saved search for "ravenloft" and another for "ravenloff" and another for "ravenlott" (font ambiguity is a bargain hunter's best friend.) Ebay will send you daily listings that match your search. Your best buys usually come in large lots, too. Don't be afraid to buy a few duplicates or non-RL junk.

You can usually sell it off and make back a decent portion of the lot cost, making the stuff you did want close to free.
Anyway, for recommendations, check the review section of this site (the drawing room). As for my faves:
The Evil Eye
The Evil Eye
The Evil Eye
Feast of Goblyns
The Evil Eye
Night of the Walking Dead
Bleak House (though this one is best if it follows a long association with Dr. Van Richten, IMHO)
The Evil Eye
Castles Forlorn (though I'm too daunted to try it thus far)
Servants of Darkness
and oh, yeah... The Evil Eye.
Don't miss the collections of mini-adventures too. A mixed bag, but with many standouts. My faves:
Children of the Night: Ghosts
Children of the Night: The Created
Chilling Tales (ignore the dumb "terror tips," though)
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."