quilted armor?
quilted armor?
What domain would use quilted armor?
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Assuming they share IRL Indians' religious and cultural aversion to harming cattle, Sri Rajians would mostly use quilted armor rather than leather. Hide armor would still be an option there, probably made from crocodile or rhino hides.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
I feel that you could probably find it in use in all the core domains. It is cheap and historically was used for a looooooonnnnngggggg time despite there being better alternatives. Cost is king in all things unfortunately.
Expect militia to wear it, expect brigands to wear it, expect military units to wear it, expect low cr monsters to wear it etc.
Expect militia to wear it, expect brigands to wear it, expect military units to wear it, expect low cr monsters to wear it etc.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gambeson
AFAIK quilted armour = padded armour = gambeson = doublet. If this is so, it would be prevalent in almost all domains.
AFAIK quilted armour = padded armour = gambeson = doublet. If this is so, it would be prevalent in almost all domains.
Giamarga, great find.
This is a good reminder as to how well off many of our players are in Ravenloft- imagine how it would be if they actually had to deal with having realistic equipment loads? BTW, from mass graves that have been found...helmets were also a luxury in medieval warfare for the infantry.
Actually, if anyone here's ever played a Midnight campaign they would know exactly what that's like lol.
This is a good reminder as to how well off many of our players are in Ravenloft- imagine how it would be if they actually had to deal with having realistic equipment loads? BTW, from mass graves that have been found...helmets were also a luxury in medieval warfare for the infantry.
Actually, if anyone here's ever played a Midnight campaign they would know exactly what that's like lol.
Armor in DnD is over protective and under burdened. DnD makes no distinction between avoiding an attack and absorbing an attack (which is what armor actually does). In reality, keeping a good rate of movement and flexibility is also important, so archers and horsemen will likely wear quilted if they still need to keep up mobility. Quilted armor would probably be fairly effective against bludgeoning weapons and may also be effective at helping dislodge arrows from wounds.
Actually, this is untrue. The Dexterity modifier that a character has represents the characters ability to avoid an attack, while the AC from their armor represents the armor's absorption ability.HuManBing wrote:Armor in DnD is over protective and under burdened. DnD makes no distinction between avoiding an attack and absorbing an attack (which is what armor actually does). In reality, keeping a good rate of movement and flexibility is also important, so archers and horsemen will likely wear quilted if they still need to keep up mobility. Quilted armor would probably be fairly effective against bludgeoning weapons and may also be effective at helping dislodge arrows from wounds.
So if a character wears armor that gives them +5 and has a +2 Dex mod, then their AC is 17, right? Well, in my games, if an attack is rolled against them, and it hits AC 15 or 16, that's still not a hit, but I describe it as the character dodges out of the way, rather than the weapon skittering off their armor.
As well, in 2E there was a system where different armor gave better or worse protection against different types (Bludgeoning, Piercing, or Slashing) weapons, but I presume it was dropped because of the complexity it added to combat that the designers felt wasn't needed.
Quilted helps against bludgeoning but remember that it was still worn by knights as an undercoat...and people would regularly use maces and clubs (yes, pieces of wood- no joke) to beat and break their bones despite having a layer of metal and the quilted armor underneath.
Quilted is basically better than nothing : ) I doubt that quilted armor would help with the dislodging of arrows- would probalby go right through taking some of the armor material with it. Hello gangrene lol.
You might be thinking of the practice of well spun silk shirts which were anecdotally were used for that purpose. I am not sure if it was ever proven that this worked reliably.
We also have to keep in mind that battle was hellishly close quarters for most of human history- so close that it is hard to imagine how horrible it must've been.
In an environment like that where human flesh is pressing in on all sides, blood, excrement, bodies of the dead and dying underfoot; you cannot really move (denied your dex modifier as it were lol). We have to keep this in mind.
Most dnd combat is spacious and roomy in contrast to reality
Quilted is basically better than nothing : ) I doubt that quilted armor would help with the dislodging of arrows- would probalby go right through taking some of the armor material with it. Hello gangrene lol.
You might be thinking of the practice of well spun silk shirts which were anecdotally were used for that purpose. I am not sure if it was ever proven that this worked reliably.
We also have to keep in mind that battle was hellishly close quarters for most of human history- so close that it is hard to imagine how horrible it must've been.
In an environment like that where human flesh is pressing in on all sides, blood, excrement, bodies of the dead and dying underfoot; you cannot really move (denied your dex modifier as it were lol). We have to keep this in mind.
Most dnd combat is spacious and roomy in contrast to reality
My point still stands. DnD as a system makes no distinction. Your home-grown rule does, but that's an example of a player addition that accounts for a dimension that the game does not. (And, in fact, it treats the effect of armor in exactly the same way as it does Dex bonus, so the difference is purely descriptive rather than mechanical.)Mortavius wrote:Actually, this is untrue. [...] Well, in my games (emphasis added), if an attack is rolled against them, and it hits AC 15 or 16, that's still not a hit, but I describe it as the character dodges out of the way, rather than the weapon skittering off their armor.HuManBing wrote:DnD makes no distinction between avoiding an attack and absorbing an attack (which is what armor actually does).
As an aside, this is not the first time somebody has introduced a homegrown rule that departs from the DnD rules as written, and then argued that it validates the original DnD rule. I find this curious.
A number of games (e.g. GURPS, TriStat dX, and Qin: The Warring States) give an evasion bonus dependent on Dexterity that affects the chance of a hit landing. Armor is a completely separate bonus, applied directly to the damage as a reduction. In these games the difference is purely mechanical, which was a distinction I felt DnD oversimplified from the beginning. Although it's only a minor complaint, it does shortchange a lot of the classes that don't wear armor, especially monks, who are expected to wade into close combat without any AC from armor and with stringent Dex requirements to avoid getting hit.
The 3rd ed DnD book Unearthed Arcana has a stopgap "armor as DR" measure whereby they reduce the armor's AC bonus by half, and then count that as a DR bonus instead. I describe this as a stopgap measure because armor generally doesn't give any "AC bonus" at all (insofar as wearing plate mail doesn't make your enemy any less likely to hit you with an arrow). Armor conceptually is purely DR (preventing the hitting arrow from penetrating through to you). My suspicion is that the game has fairly small damage ranges for weapons already, so applying any amount of DR at all will nerf a large number of weapons. Applying high DRs will make numerous weapons completely useless.
That's really not what I'm driving at, but maybe I have been unclear. To clarify: They apply in different circumstances, but each time the mathematical effect is the same. It reduces the chance of making contact, rather than the effect of making contact. The various bonuses and penalties to attack tend generally to affect the chance of a hit, rather than to increase or decrease the damage done.Mangrum wrote:It does, actually. In 3.X, it makes the difference between an attack and a touch attack.HuManBing wrote:My point still stands. DnD as a system makes no distinction.
When they do apply, DnD 3.X applies them to the same effect in terms of game mechanics.
As a system, DnD has given a considerable evasion bonus for wearing armor that a) doesn't really reflect the fact that armor tends to deflect or absorb blows that have already landed, and b) is disproportionate with the effects of Dexterity.
I don't deny that armor historically has been very useful in this time period, and that if you're going into battle you probably want to rely more on a good breastplate than on your own affirmative reflexes. But these two defense mechanisms are not synonymous and don't really belong as part of the same dice roll, otherwise there is really no reason why a canny character wants to bother with armorless Dex. As mentioned before, monks get screwed because of this.
It's also not unworkably hard to implement either. Other game systems adopt the view that armor will make you more likely to get hit (because you can't move as fast) but when you do, the armor reduces the damage you take.
Ah, yes, that would be it. I was thinking of the Mongolian riders who wore silk under the quilting, theoretically to help dislodge arrows after they've hit. I got the silk confused with the quilt.Archedius wrote:I doubt that quilted armor would help with the dislodging of arrows- would probalby go right through taking some of the armor material with it. Hello gangrene lol.
You might be thinking of the practice of well spun silk shirts which were anecdotally were used for that purpose. I am not sure if it was ever proven that this worked reliably.
This brings up an interesting issue. The Mongols defeated better-armored European horseback forces, using speed and mobility instead of endurance. This is a philosophy that DnD rules clearly do not support well, as armor is king.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
But in the end, isn't that all really just flavor? Either you take damage from the attack or you don't. After 5 rounds of combat, if you've been hit 5 times for 1 damage or 1 time for 5 damage. Who cares?HuManBing wrote:That's really not what I'm driving at, but maybe I have been unclear. To clarify: They apply in different circumstances, but each time the mathematical effect is the same. It reduces the chance of making contact, rather than the effect of making contact. The various bonuses and penalties to attack tend generally to affect the chance of a hit, rather than to increase or decrease the damage done.
Yes, it's an abstraction that takes a bit of realism away, but speeds up combat. In the end it's all just inputs to a probability function that alter the expected value of the damage taken.
That's why the monk gets a Wis bonus to AC, as well as a level based bonus. By 5th level, a monk with 18 Dex and 18 Wis can have a 19 AC, just like a character with 12+ Dex and Full Plate. But the full plate character has a speed penalty, an armor check penalty, and will never get any better without magic. The monk can keep improving as he gets higher Wis and Dex, and higher monk level, and has access to the same magic, so magic cancels out. Plus the monk is 1500gp richer.no reason why a canny character wants to bother with armorless Dex. As mentioned before, monks get screwed because of this.
In my experience, things are quite the opposite. I rarely see a character take more than a chain shirt, to avoid losing their dex bonus, and to avoid massive armor check penalties and/or speed reduction from the medium and heavy armors. (not to mention spellcasting issues).
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Your example is so numerically simplistic I'm not going to rebut it - and in any case I believe you're offering it more for illustrative purpose, so I accept it for such. Suffice it to say that this neat little symmetry of probabilities rarely lines up in actual systems that use it, and depending on the designer's whimsy it can end up favoring evasion more than armor, or vice versa. My point is that DnD is firmly in the armor-favoring camp - which is fine if you like that balance in the game, but it was one of the unbalancing factors I disliked.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:But in the end, isn't that all really just flavor? Either you take damage from the attack or you don't. After 5 rounds of combat, if you've been hit 5 times for 1 damage or 1 time for 5 damage.
To be perfectly fair, it's also a well-known truism that what is realistic isn't always what's fun. DnD characters favor the hero who can take a beating and keeping on slashing. GURPS and other game systems like Warhammer and Cthulhu deal with combat as a much more dangerous phenomenon. I've personally gravitated towards a more high-risk ideal of combat, specifically for games that are based in horror and mystery-style themes.
For heroic or epic themes, the DnD philosophy is perfectly workable. I suppose in video game analogies it's like comparing System Shock 2 against Call of Duty in terms of how many hits you can take and still keep running.
Well... I suppose I do, for starters...Who cares?
True enough. This comes down to personal taste, and here I freely admit I think combat should be high-risk in most cases. In DnD, hp and other resistance metrics scale up with levels, but damage generally doesn't (at least not from weapons). This leads to the anomaly of a high-level character taking several dozen max-damage swordthrusts to incapacitate.Yes, it's an abstraction that takes a bit of realism away, but speeds up combat. In the end it's all just inputs to a probability function that alter the expected value of the damage taken.
This is fine for high fantasy roleplaying, but it was another reason why I thought DnD wasn't a particularly good vessel for Ravenloft.
It's far easier to accumulate wealth in DnD than it is to boost stats. Your hypothetical monk already has two 18 scores, without even mentioning that he's going to need a decent Strength and Con to stay alive while getting bashed around in mostly close-up combat. His mobility is useful in actual miniature combat geometry, but personal speed (oddly) doesn't translate into evasion or have much relation to Dex. Add to that the fact that range penalties for distance are very gentle, so running away from an enemy won't help much.By 5th level, a monk with 18 Dex and 18 Wis can have a 19 AC, just like a character with 12+ Dex and Full Plate. But the full plate character has a speed penalty, an armor check penalty, and will never get any better without magic. The monk can keep improving as he gets higher Wis and Dex, and higher monk level, and has access to the same magic, so magic cancels out. Plus the monk is 1500gp richer.
Ultimately, these are fairly minor quibbles about the DnD system that have been present in some form or another since 1st ed. I'm not sure if they're around in 4th - I haven't looked closely. There is a whole host of other far more major systemic problems I found with DnD 3.5 that precipitated my search for other systems instead, to which the armor/evasion and class balance debates are fairly tangential at best.
