Indeed. That wasn't meant as an accurate representation of the math, but an illustrartion of the point that it's all just window-dressing for "x% chance of decrementing hp by y"HuManBing wrote:In any case I believe you're offering it more for illustrative purpose, so I accept it for such.
Agreed. One could imagine a system where the maximum bonus from armor is +1 and evasive manuevers can add huge bonuses, or a system where the more money you put into your armor, the better it gets, unboundedly, and the max bonus from evasion is +1, or anywhere in between. I agree with you that the system should support a decently balanced character on either path.depending on the designer's whimsy it can end up favoring evasion more than armor, or vice versa.
But I guess I disagree on how much realism should play a role. As much as I'm usually a fan of the system existing to model reality. As you said,
Even if it were desirable, I don't think any system is going to accurately predict the chance that a real person wielding a certain weapon against someone with a certain armor and a certain dexterity is going to kill them or not. Without doing massive immoral experiments, we're going to have to accept some amount of guesswork and hand-waving, and go with what "feels right." Obviously what feels right to me doesn't to you, and that's fine.To be perfectly fair, it's also a well-known truism that what is realistic isn't always what's fun.
but I guess where I disagree even more is with this:
Like I said, if armor was so great in D&D, I'd expect to see heavy armor used more, and it just isn't in the games I've seen, except for the "Tank" chracters where it makes sense.My point is that DnD is firmly in the armor-favoring camp
I understand completely the goal of making combat more scary and dangerous. I'm just not sure that's related to armor vs. evasion. Sounds like more of an issue with the HP system (blahblahblah insert standard "hp isn't wounds, it's ability to avoid damage" spiel here blahblah).
yes, though in standard D&D, it's easy to convert wealth into stats. Gloves of Dex are almost standard equipment on most non-RL PC's. (More expensive than armor for a given AC bonus, but the armor doesn't help your Reflex saves, Dex-based skills, Initiative, and Ranged attacks)It's far easier to accumulate wealth in DnD than it is to boost stats.
OK, two 18's may be a bit exaggerated, but even with say 2 16's or 16/14, he's still as good as all but the best armors, and will only get better for free in the future, while the armored guy will be sinking money into magic enhancement for his armor because it tops out. (Not even mentioning bracers of armor, which the monk can dump his money in, thus cancelling out that benefit.) Plus the monk reaps all the other benefits of high Dex/Wis.Your hypothetical monk already has two 18 scores, without even mentioning that he's going to need a decent Strength and Con to stay alive
Speed, no. But the monk will be happy to have the Dex bonus to Reflex saves.personal speed (oddly) doesn't translate into evasion or have much relation to Dex.
It's not a matter of running away, but getting into decent melee attack position. That extra speed is crucial.Add to that the fact that range penalties for distance are very gentle, so running away from an enemy won't help much.
Anyway, I suppose we're digressing here. I'm not trying to sway you back to D&D. You've found other systems you like better, have fun and play them. I just can't wrap my mind around armor being considered overpowered in D&D. I've always considered it quite the opposite.
(Having just played last week in an Epic game (21st level), where not a single character wore any armor heavier than Hide, and the most armored one had the lowest AC, I just don't see it...)

