How should Necromancy & the Like be Affected in 4E?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

How should Necromancy & the Like be Affected in 4E?

Post by Mortavius »

Hey all.

Well, the subject line about says it all. I'm stuck on how Necromancy, Shadow, and such should be affected in 4E. I like the previous editions, where these effects had extra things going on, but one of the primary drawbacks to these extra effects was that the ability usually required a Powers Check.

Now in 4E, I like Jester's idea that a character's build should not provoke Powers Checks, but their choices in game.

So how should Necromancy, Shadow, and all sorts of things like this be affected? I want to give them a benefit (like maybe a +1 to hit or damage or something), but they have to have a drawback too (otherwise everyone would be using these abilitiies).

Any ideas?
User avatar
NeoTiamat
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4119
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Post by NeoTiamat »

Tricky, very tricky. Balancing the benefits and drawbacks so that it works out is not easy, unless you stick to pretty clear mechanical things (+2 damage, -1 to hit, for instance).

Rituals are a bit easier to fiddle around with, since what a Ritual does generally can't be replicated easily. PCs have a ton of attack-spell options, but if they want to talk to the murder victim, only one way to do it.

But to actually answer your question, one possibility might be a small chance of spontaneously arising undead. An alternative might be to simply make some spells IC-Illegal. In other words, sure, you can use Speak with Dead to question a corpse, but don't do it where the sheriff can see you unless you aim to spend the next few months behind bars.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

NeoTiamat wrote:An alternative might be to simply make some spells IC-Illegal. In other words, sure, you can use Speak with Dead to question a corpse, but don't do it where the sheriff can see you unless you aim to spend the next few months behind bars.
Very few shriffs in very few lands would have much competence in the policing of good versus evil magic. And frankly, it is the Dark Powers's work.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

Or maybe the old way of having a Powers Check for Necrotic powers should be back in effect. It is unnatural magic. Maybe that's the best consequence? The only thing about going that way is that every Necrotic power that requires a Powers Check has to have an upside then, so that players know that there is a trade-off.

But maybe not...do you really want to be rolling a powers check everytime the PC uses his encounter power Cursebite...

Hmmm...still confused.
User avatar
Igor the Henchman
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 832
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 6:50 pm

Post by Igor the Henchman »

It would be necessary to narrow down the exact goal of the mechanic before deciding how to implement it.

Is it just out of tradition or is there a storytelling purpose involved?
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: How should Necromancy & the Like be Affected in 4E?

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Mortavius wrote:Well, the subject line about says it all. I'm stuck on how Necromancy, Shadow, and such should be affected in 4E. I like the previous editions, where these effects had extra things going on, but one of the primary drawbacks to these extra effects was that the ability usually required a Powers Check.

Now in 4E, I like Jester's idea that a character's build should not provoke Powers Checks, but their choices in game.

So how should Necromancy, Shadow, and all sorts of things like this be affected? I want to give them a benefit (like maybe a +1 to hit or damage or something), but they have to have a drawback too (otherwise everyone would be using these abilities).
The bonus/drawback tends to be an earlier edition thing, less common in 4e which just focuses on pluses. The idea being it's too easy to place a stronger plus with a weaker minus for a net gain, or min/max to that same effect. Or have a stronger weakness that causes less skilled players to unintentionally handicap their characters.

This was often aimed at the Power Checks system and I had many arguments on the WotC boards over story/world balancing with game mechanics.

For necromancy/shadow, I'd probably refrain from a broad mechanical change and have a strictly fluff increase.
Their shadow darkens, they slowly become more and more monochromatic, darkness seems to cling to them, etc.

Or I'd use the terrain rules to regularly create places where those powers were more effective, moreso than other powers or types of terrain.

For lengthy and severe cases you could also change their type from natural (or fey) to shadow, which has almost no mechanical effects but sounds dramatic
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

Thanks Jester! I'm going to go with this idea. Still allows for there to be "detriments" to Necromancy but they keep the game simple by not having game mechanic changes. As well, this encourages more role-playing!
User avatar
NeoTiamat
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4119
Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
Gender: Male
Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Post by NeoTiamat »

cure wrote:
NeoTiamat wrote:An alternative might be to simply make some spells IC-Illegal. In other words, sure, you can use Speak with Dead to question a corpse, but don't do it where the sheriff can see you unless you aim to spend the next few months behind bars.
Very few shriffs in very few lands would have much competence in the policing of good versus evil magic. And frankly, it is the Dark Powers's work.
*shrug* Nothing says you can't do both.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

NeoTiamat wrote:
cure wrote:
NeoTiamat wrote:An alternative might be to simply make some spells IC-Illegal. In other words, sure, you can use Speak with Dead to question a corpse, but don't do it where the sheriff can see you unless you aim to spend the next few months behind bars.
Very few shriffs in very few lands would have much competence in the policing of good versus evil magic. And frankly, it is the Dark Powers's work.
*shrug* Nothing says you can't do both.
Certainly one can do both.

Indeed in Souragne there is extensive policing via a spy network that consists seemingly of most everyone. Although it is evocation not necromancy that will get you in trouble there.

But in other domains where the idea that the 'day you see magic is the day that you die' holds sway witnesses are going to be running for their lives not making careful observations that might clarify what sort of magic and what precise spell was being put to use, and any sheriff unfortunate enough to be informed of such is not going to investigate for fear of being turned into a toad or worse.

Ultimately, the Powers Check worthiness of a spell is not nearly so important as its flamboyancy or lack thereof. A burning hands spell, which is not evil by its nature, might get you lynched in Tepest. Seemingly mumbling to yourself in front of a corpse in Tepest probably won't get you lynched for Speaking with the Dead, unless of course the Dead screech out their answers.

So although one could do both, the agendas are not really very similar save in those places with a broad and deep understanding of magic and uncorrupted authorities answering to leadership that is upstanding and good.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

I was looking for more of the game mechanics or such for the consequences of Necromantic magic.

As far as in character stuff; I would say the reaction varies by the domain, and iregardless, this infringes on telling the DM how to role-play the NPCs in their games, and I'm not prepared to go there.

Suffice it to say that in most places, Necromancy (and possibly all magic) is viewed in a negative light and leave it at that.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: How should Necromancy & the Like be Affected in 4E?

Post by brilliantlight »

Mortavius wrote:Hey all.

Well, the subject line about says it all. I'm stuck on how Necromancy, Shadow, and such should be affected in 4E. I like the previous editions, where these effects had extra things going on, but one of the primary drawbacks to these extra effects was that the ability usually required a Powers Check.

Now in 4E, I like Jester's idea that a character's build should not provoke Powers Checks, but their choices in game.

So how should Necromancy, Shadow, and all sorts of things like this be affected? I want to give them a benefit (like maybe a +1 to hit or damage or something), but they have to have a drawback too (otherwise everyone would be using these abilitiies).

Any ideas?

Most necromancy is going to call for power checks because most of it is evil in the first place as it deals with death, pain and weakening. However I wouldn't have raise dead or the ilk result in a power check.
User avatar
DocBeard
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2165
Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 5:35 pm

Post by DocBeard »

I agree with Jester in that the specific style of magic should not be good or evil. Fighters don't get punished for knowing how to disembowel people, they get punished for using their skills poorly.

Rituals, on the other hand, may or may not demand horrific sins in exchange for working. In that case, I'd treat it as though you were murdering or harming the victim for funsies. As far as effects go, I think that should work on a map by map basis: a haunted forest might make feylock or shadow powers a little stronger, but just being in Ravenloft shouldn't.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Post by brilliantlight »

The problem is that it is hard to see a necromancer as anything other than evil. The literal definition is "Death magic", how can that be anything other than evil?
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

brilliantlight wrote:The problem is that it is hard to see a necromancer as anything other than evil. The literal definition is "Death magic", how can that be anything other than evil?
Easily enough, I'd say:

Necromancy, in the original sense of the word, is essentially communication with the spirits of the dead. A spiritualist need not be evil.

A 'ghost-buster' sort of wizard, or any kind of undead-hunter, would benefit greatly from the study of necromancy.

A necromancer might also be a physician, and embalmer, a scientist,etc.

The real question, IMO, isn't whether using necromancy is automatically 'evil', but whether the Dark Powers are interested enough in it to require powers checks to be made by its users. Does the magic of death involve forces and energies that carry a risk of corruption- in the context of Ravenloft. Short answer, YES. A good cleric attempting the resurrection of a saintly person still has to make a powers check, because the magic involved transgresses certain barriers and thus calls the attention of the Dark Powers. By its very nature, necromancy is a dangerous thing in Ravenloft. That's my take on it, at any rate.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Does 4E have rules on thread necromancy?

B-boom-tssssch!
Post Reply