How should Necromancy & the Like be Affected in 4E?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

ewancummins wrote:
brilliantlight wrote:The problem is that it is hard to see a necromancer as anything other than evil. The literal definition is "Death magic", how can that be anything other than evil?
Easily enough, I'd say:

Necromancy, in the original sense of the word, is essentially communication with the spirits of the dead. A spiritualist need not be evil.

A 'ghost-buster' sort of wizard, or any kind of undead-hunter, would benefit greatly from the study of necromancy.

A necromancer might also be a physician, and embalmer, a scientist,etc.
There's the White Arcanist in Heroes of Light who is all about being a good necromancer.

I've thought about playing one as well.
Someone who willingly sacrifices their soul and sanity to best fight the unnatural, someone who fights fire with fire. Or uses the natural energies death to power their magic to fight those who would violate nature's cycle.

It's all portrayal as well. There's the necromancer that doesn't raise dead by asks spirits for assistance and barters aid from the dead. They might pay for the service (hence the material component).
ewancummins wrote:The real question, IMO, isn't whether using necromancy is automatically 'evil', but whether the Dark Powers are interested enough in it to require powers checks to be made by its users. Does the magic of death involve forces and energies that carry a risk of corruption- in the context of Ravenloft. Short answer, YES. A good cleric attempting the resurrection of a saintly person still has to make a powers check, because the magic involved transgresses certain barriers and thus calls the attention of the Dark Powers. By its very nature, necromancy is a dangerous thing in Ravenloft. That's my take on it, at any rate.
I left this for DMs and individual campaigns to make the call in my 4e pamphlet.
There's the argument that they're violating the natural order. But, then again, so is summoning fire from nothing like many 1st-level wizard powers. All magic is, by definition, a violation. And raising a pious priest who will do good and help people and be a positive force for the world is hard to label an "evil" act. Not with compared to raising an evil priest who wants to corrupt people and stain their souls.

Personally (just for me at least), for cases like raise dead where it's a big part of the "game" I'm more lenient. It's like punishing players for other grey actions like killing bad guys (murder) and looting dungeons (grave robbing). In essence it's a story action necessitated by a gaming convention and I punish through the story means.
The best example I can think of at 7:45am is Buffy the Vampire Slayer where a character is raised from the dead and everyone has to deal with a monster/spirit that comes with them.
When the players do evil things that are above and beyond that's punishment worthy.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Post by brilliantlight »

I agree. I can see raising evil people from the dead may be evil in itself (If you are doing so that it can again wreck havoc) but I can't see it for raising non-evil dead.
Post Reply