Would This Count As A Powers Check?
Would This Count As A Powers Check?
Firstly: Geez, how long has it been since I posted here? Two years?
To the topic: Well, my warlock character, Math, has a bit of fiction to show who he is at the DM's request.
I decided to show him saving a shifter-a human with lycanthrope blood, basically, more primal then normal people but not savage in the bad sense of the term-from a racist bully. Word for word:
"Does it make you feel better?
The man beating the razorclaw shifter looked up in surprise. "Who said that?"
"Attacking someone who didn't do anything wrong, simply because you dislike his race in general. Does it make you feel better about yourself?"
"Hmph". The man gave the half-lycanthrope child a kick, then looked in the general direction of the voice-a particularly shadowy alley. Not that this was all that strange, as it was night. "Yeah, right. He's a lycan-spawn. If he didn't want it, he wouldn't have come here. He belongs in the woods, like the rest of the beasts."
If the man had known anything about magic, he would have guessed that the strange humming noise was a wand being primed for battle. As it is, he mainly payed attention to the voice, which now grew hard and sharp. "You didn't answer my question. But to the point, did you know about this lovely concept druids call the 'Primal Beast'?"
"Huh?"
Guess you don't. Not at all surprising. Anyway, the Primal Beast is supposedly the primal spirit of predators, all those that have come before or since. It is by turns ruthless and kind, bloodthirsty and yet caring. One thing it is never, however, is cruel."
"Heh. Bet you know a lot about that, lycan."
"Lycan? *chuckle* I am not a lycanthrope of any sort, however you may wish me to be. My point being that all things that have eaten other things are in someway connected to the Primal Beast-and that includes humans.
The voice drew closer, as the humming grew louder.
"My point being: By bullying those weaker than you, you have devolved to a state that can no longer be called a predator-just a slug."
The bully grew angry at this. "Well, come and say that to my face, chicken!"
The voice laughed. "My friend, that's what I'm about to do."
There was a flash of purplish light as the bully's body caught on fire. Whatever bravery he had was quickly lost as he began to scream, desperately trying to put out the flames. When the pain had ceased, he looked up to find the source of the flames. He screamed louder.
The...thing...held him up in a shadowy claw, staring at him with enraged, terrible eyes, a scowl on the closest thing to a face it had.
"If I ever find you bullying another shifter, tiefling, or half-orc, I will not hesitate to break your ribs. So I would recommend you leave, and never return. Slug."
The man took his advice. Chuckling to himself, Math dismissed his aura as the dust kicked up by the bully fled, and kneeled next to the shifter, who had been petrified in fear.
"Are you OK?"
The half-lycanthrope gulped. "Y...ye...yes." *whimper*
"That's good. There's a place to the northeast of here. I'll take you there."
Lifting the wounded shifter, Math made his way to Moonsong Temple.
"The priest here will treat your injuries. He's an elf, but he doesn't mind shifters at all. Just tell him that a warlock brought you here."
Math knocked on the door, then began to leave, not wishing to be forced to talk to Starlight.
"Wait! Mister!"
*Sigh* "Yes?"
"...Thank you."
"No trouble. No trouble at all."
Now, obviously, he isn't a Ravenloft character-half-orcs don't exist, after all-but if he was...
Would this be grounds for a Powers Check, and if so, what Terror Track would he go down?
Just a rules/moral question.
To the topic: Well, my warlock character, Math, has a bit of fiction to show who he is at the DM's request.
I decided to show him saving a shifter-a human with lycanthrope blood, basically, more primal then normal people but not savage in the bad sense of the term-from a racist bully. Word for word:
"Does it make you feel better?
The man beating the razorclaw shifter looked up in surprise. "Who said that?"
"Attacking someone who didn't do anything wrong, simply because you dislike his race in general. Does it make you feel better about yourself?"
"Hmph". The man gave the half-lycanthrope child a kick, then looked in the general direction of the voice-a particularly shadowy alley. Not that this was all that strange, as it was night. "Yeah, right. He's a lycan-spawn. If he didn't want it, he wouldn't have come here. He belongs in the woods, like the rest of the beasts."
If the man had known anything about magic, he would have guessed that the strange humming noise was a wand being primed for battle. As it is, he mainly payed attention to the voice, which now grew hard and sharp. "You didn't answer my question. But to the point, did you know about this lovely concept druids call the 'Primal Beast'?"
"Huh?"
Guess you don't. Not at all surprising. Anyway, the Primal Beast is supposedly the primal spirit of predators, all those that have come before or since. It is by turns ruthless and kind, bloodthirsty and yet caring. One thing it is never, however, is cruel."
"Heh. Bet you know a lot about that, lycan."
"Lycan? *chuckle* I am not a lycanthrope of any sort, however you may wish me to be. My point being that all things that have eaten other things are in someway connected to the Primal Beast-and that includes humans.
The voice drew closer, as the humming grew louder.
"My point being: By bullying those weaker than you, you have devolved to a state that can no longer be called a predator-just a slug."
The bully grew angry at this. "Well, come and say that to my face, chicken!"
The voice laughed. "My friend, that's what I'm about to do."
There was a flash of purplish light as the bully's body caught on fire. Whatever bravery he had was quickly lost as he began to scream, desperately trying to put out the flames. When the pain had ceased, he looked up to find the source of the flames. He screamed louder.
The...thing...held him up in a shadowy claw, staring at him with enraged, terrible eyes, a scowl on the closest thing to a face it had.
"If I ever find you bullying another shifter, tiefling, or half-orc, I will not hesitate to break your ribs. So I would recommend you leave, and never return. Slug."
The man took his advice. Chuckling to himself, Math dismissed his aura as the dust kicked up by the bully fled, and kneeled next to the shifter, who had been petrified in fear.
"Are you OK?"
The half-lycanthrope gulped. "Y...ye...yes." *whimper*
"That's good. There's a place to the northeast of here. I'll take you there."
Lifting the wounded shifter, Math made his way to Moonsong Temple.
"The priest here will treat your injuries. He's an elf, but he doesn't mind shifters at all. Just tell him that a warlock brought you here."
Math knocked on the door, then began to leave, not wishing to be forced to talk to Starlight.
"Wait! Mister!"
*Sigh* "Yes?"
"...Thank you."
"No trouble. No trouble at all."
Now, obviously, he isn't a Ravenloft character-half-orcs don't exist, after all-but if he was...
Would this be grounds for a Powers Check, and if so, what Terror Track would he go down?
Just a rules/moral question.
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Hmmm, so he used an illusion to frighten the bully, with the intent of protecting a child? That doesn't seem powers check worthy to me.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Well, that and he set the bastard on fire to emphasize his point.ewancummins wrote:Hmmm, so he used an illusion to frighten the bully, with the intent of protecting a child? That doesn't seem powers check worthy to me.
He intentionally blunted his attack-enough to put him in pain, but not enough for large burns-but I think that might count as "unneeded brutality".
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
You could make a case for that being "unprovoked assault", but the case would be an extremely tenuous one indeed. I'm pretty sure that the Dark Powers treat saving another person's life the same as saving yourself, and they've never been known to punish people for acting in self-defense.
If he'd murdered the bully, or intentionally brutalized him far past the point of the bully being any kind of threat, you might be talking.
If he'd murdered the bully, or intentionally brutalized him far past the point of the bully being any kind of threat, you might be talking.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
- ewancummins
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 28523
- Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm
Yes, the extent of the flame attack matters. If it is only superficial burns, I'd let it go. Really torch the guy, and I might agree with Nathan.Nathan of the FoS wrote:I'd rate it a Grievous Assault against an Evil NPC, for a 1% powers check, myself, assuming the burns were serious enough to scar the guy. Math seems to be enjoying himself a bit too much, there, for me to think he's perfectly justified in his course of action.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
That's what I thought.ewancummins wrote:Yes, the extent of the flame attack matters. If it is only superficial burns, I'd let it go. Really torch the guy, and I might agree with Nathan.Nathan of the FoS wrote:I'd rate it a Grievous Assault against an Evil NPC, for a 1% powers check, myself, assuming the burns were serious enough to scar the guy. Math seems to be enjoying himself a bit too much, there, for me to think he's perfectly justified in his course of action.
For the personality I had in mind, a powers check is perfectly IC for him.
A big part of his personality is that he was basically foretold to be a "great enemy of the gods" at his birth, and was treated pretty horribly by his hometown, culminating in them trying to sacrifice him to a devil. The primary reason he made a soul pact with his patron (who isn't evil, just morally alien-a bit like a shadow fey) for power over the arcane was to spite the people whose truly vile actions lead to the death of his parents.
The bit of fiction above was him indulging in a bit of catharsis against the unjust discrimination he suffered. While he would prefer to be a kind and noble hero rather than a ghastly vigilante enslaved to his own hate, it's...hard, sometimes.
While I want him to have a happy ending-learning to channel his anger and bitterness into a force for tolerance and true justice-I have no doubt that he has every chance of becoming a tragic hero; So obsessed with the injustice done to him and to others that he loses sight of what's important, becoming the monster everyone thought him to be in the end.
Who knows? In Ravenloft, he might even have become a darklord, and so learn what true suffering is like.
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
- brilliantlight
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1003
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm
Re: Would This Count As A Powers Check?
I wouldn't give him a powers check, he didn't kill the bully and he could save other lives by scaring him a bit.
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
I side with Nathan on this.
Always remember the first sentences of RLCS on Power Checks: "Evil comes in many forms, but it is never so dangerous as when it is convenient. Evil can seduce us in ways that Good would never try. Good demands much — patience, compassion, self-sacrifice — and its rewards are often obscure. Evil seems to ask nothing but gladly offers anything we could desire: power, riches, even love."
---
Using fire to scare? no problem.
Using fire to burn ? That's indeed an assault, unprovoked (it includes bullying, by the way: and no matter the good intent, in this case he did bully the bully
)
Joël
Always remember the first sentences of RLCS on Power Checks: "Evil comes in many forms, but it is never so dangerous as when it is convenient. Evil can seduce us in ways that Good would never try. Good demands much — patience, compassion, self-sacrifice — and its rewards are often obscure. Evil seems to ask nothing but gladly offers anything we could desire: power, riches, even love."
---
Using fire to scare? no problem.
Using fire to burn ? That's indeed an assault, unprovoked (it includes bullying, by the way: and no matter the good intent, in this case he did bully the bully
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
I think a slight issue that hasn't been clarified here is whether the bully intended more harm to the boy if he hadn't been driven off, or whether Math thought he intended more harm.
I was under the impression that yes, more harm was meant, and said bully had only stopped to converse with the illusion and wasn't going to bug off just because Math called him some names - in which case I disagree with everyone, that is not a Power's Check. You're allowed to punch a bully in self-defense, and the author stated Math blunted the attack to cause less harm. Unless Math had some other way that would have caused lesser harm and chose not to take it just out of sadism (author may clarify), that seems like the evil equivalent of cheating a parking meter.
I don't recall the exact percent on Unprovoked Assault of an (evil?) NPC, but if it's 1% the check would be halved into oblivion due to Math doing it for altruistic means (saving the boy).
It is rather jerkish for Math to be enjoying it as much as he seems to be. I can see this kind of attitude and behavior leading him down a dark path.
I was under the impression that yes, more harm was meant, and said bully had only stopped to converse with the illusion and wasn't going to bug off just because Math called him some names - in which case I disagree with everyone, that is not a Power's Check. You're allowed to punch a bully in self-defense, and the author stated Math blunted the attack to cause less harm. Unless Math had some other way that would have caused lesser harm and chose not to take it just out of sadism (author may clarify), that seems like the evil equivalent of cheating a parking meter.
I don't recall the exact percent on Unprovoked Assault of an (evil?) NPC, but if it's 1% the check would be halved into oblivion due to Math doing it for altruistic means (saving the boy).
It is rather jerkish for Math to be enjoying it as much as he seems to be. I can see this kind of attitude and behavior leading him down a dark path.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
I would think not, but just barely.
Had he attacked the bully first, without even knowing the reason the shifter was getting beaten (might have been a pickpocket, which would make it a little more acceptable, society pending), I'd be more inclined. Had he used lethal or permanently marring force, I'd say yes.
That he assessed the bully's reasons, and in my estimation, confirmed that the he was a bully and he would pick on anyone he thought different, the attack was pretty justified to end the bullying permanently. In fact, he was invited to teach the man a lesson--and did just that. In this case, the bully's own bravado caused his injury: he got a taste of his own medicine, pretty much at his request. I don't think the Dark Powers would care one bit.
Now if the bully had walked away, repented, or surrendered and Math still burned him "just to teach him a lesson" then that is a whole lot of yes from me.
To me, this is just a step or two shy of a power check. Steps this character will probably make.
Had he attacked the bully first, without even knowing the reason the shifter was getting beaten (might have been a pickpocket, which would make it a little more acceptable, society pending), I'd be more inclined. Had he used lethal or permanently marring force, I'd say yes.
That he assessed the bully's reasons, and in my estimation, confirmed that the he was a bully and he would pick on anyone he thought different, the attack was pretty justified to end the bullying permanently. In fact, he was invited to teach the man a lesson--and did just that. In this case, the bully's own bravado caused his injury: he got a taste of his own medicine, pretty much at his request. I don't think the Dark Powers would care one bit.
Now if the bully had walked away, repented, or surrendered and Math still burned him "just to teach him a lesson" then that is a whole lot of yes from me.
To me, this is just a step or two shy of a power check. Steps this character will probably make.
Firstly: Yes, from everything the shifter-beater was doing, it certainly looked like he meant more harm.Isabella wrote:I think a slight issue that hasn't been clarified here is whether the bully intended more harm to the boy if he hadn't been driven off, or whether Math thought he intended more harm.
I was under the impression that yes, more harm was meant, and said bully had only stopped to converse with the illusion and wasn't going to bug off just because Math called him some names - in which case I disagree with everyone, that is not a Power's Check. You're allowed to punch a bully in self-defense, and the author stated Math blunted the attack to cause less harm. Unless Math had some other way that would have caused lesser harm and chose not to take it just out of sadism (author may clarify), that seems like the evil equivalent of cheating a parking meter.
I don't recall the exact percent on Unprovoked Assault of an (evil?) NPC, but if it's 1% the check would be halved into oblivion due to Math doing it for altruistic means (saving the boy).
It is rather jerkish for Math to be enjoying it as much as he seems to be. I can see this kind of attitude and behavior leading him down a dark path.
Secondly: Yes and no. Math could have restrained himself a little better-the fire was a bit much-but he knows that one of the few things a bully responds to is someone standing up to them.
Thirdly: Exactly my point. Math's fatal flaw is a vindictive streak, combined with an inferiority complex. It's easy to see how that could ultimately rule him in the end. Were he not, this question would not needed asking.
I am The Archangel of Night.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
I am the Guardian of Shadow
I am the Vindicator of the Unknown
I am..Leliel.
Then I would say solidly "No". Not unless Math's response grievously outweighed the threat the bully represented, and it seems to be pretty clear he held back.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."


