As many have noticed, I like 4E's simple and fast rules that save me the DM a lot of time and don't require dozens of calculations BUT I don't like the lack of real variation on how classes work and I would like a bit more realism.
So, I present you here my latest experiment to amend that.
I changed the fighter class. I find it strange that a fighter can once every five minutes find the opening to use strike X or the opportunity to hit the bad guy more powerfully.
So, I'm in the process of replacing all of fighter attacks with at will attacks. That is, no combos that the fighter miracusly finds the opportunity to use once per day or once every five minutes.
Let's take a look behind encounter powers.
They do more damage than at will attacks and they usually do something more, like giving an advantage to the fighter or hindering his enemy.
Daily powers are trickier, not because they do more damage but because they give significant advantages that are hard to replace.
Removing encounter and daily attack powers work like this:
First the character gets some other advantages to recompensate for lack of powers. Suggestions are given for the first 5 levels.
1st: extra 1st level at will power not tied to a weapon (without a + in front of name in the powers shown in the following post.)
1st: +1 dam with at will powers.
3rd: +1 1st level at will power.
5th: +1 5th level at will power.
4E Changes for realism
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
4E Changes for realism
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Examples of 1st level at will powers:
INSIGHTFUL STRIKE:
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage. If the target is
bloodied, the attack deals extra damage equal to your
Wisdom modifier.
STEEL SERPENT STRIKE: (check dance of steel)
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] damage, and the target is
slowed until end of your next turn.
+ BELL RINGER: AX, HAM, MAC
Requirement: You must be using an axe, a hammer, or a mace.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength -2 vs. Fortitude
Hit: damage equal to your Constitution modifier and the
target is dazed until the end of your next turn.
+ DANCE OF STEEL: HB, PARM
Requirement: You must be wielding a heavy blade or polearm.
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage and the target is slowed
until the end of your next turn.
+ DISTRACTING SPATE 2w
Requirement: You must be wielding two melee weapons.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage, and the target
grants combat advantage to you until the end of your
next turn.
+ ARMOR PIERCING STRIKE: LB, SP
Requirement: You must be wielding a light blade or spear.
Target: One creature
Attack: Dexterity vs. Reflex
Hit: 1[W] + Dexterity modifier damage.
+ SHIELD BASH: SH, DWARF
Requirement: You must be using a shield.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. Fortitude
Hit: 1d6 + Strength modifier damage, and you push the
target 1 square.
Special: If you are a dwarf, the attack deals extra damage
equal to your Wisdom modifier.
Special: When charging, you can use this power in place of
a melee basic attack.
+ SHIELD BLOCK: SH
Requirement: You must be using a shield.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage and you can move
2 squares without provoking attacks of opportunity from
the target.
+ SWORD & SHIELD: SH & HB OR AXE, DWARF
Requirement: You must be using a shield and a heavy blade or an axe.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + 1d6 + Strength modifier damage.
Special: If you are a dwarf, the attack deals extra damage
equal to your Wisdom modifier.
Effect: You don't gain the normal benefits to AC or reflex
from your shield until the start of your next turn.
+ SPINING SWEEP: ST,SP,PARM
Requirement: You must be using a staff, spear or polearm.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength -2 vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] damage, and you knock the target prone.
INSIGHTFUL STRIKE:
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage. If the target is
bloodied, the attack deals extra damage equal to your
Wisdom modifier.
STEEL SERPENT STRIKE: (check dance of steel)
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] damage, and the target is
slowed until end of your next turn.
+ BELL RINGER: AX, HAM, MAC
Requirement: You must be using an axe, a hammer, or a mace.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength -2 vs. Fortitude
Hit: damage equal to your Constitution modifier and the
target is dazed until the end of your next turn.
+ DANCE OF STEEL: HB, PARM
Requirement: You must be wielding a heavy blade or polearm.
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage and the target is slowed
until the end of your next turn.
+ DISTRACTING SPATE 2w
Requirement: You must be wielding two melee weapons.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage, and the target
grants combat advantage to you until the end of your
next turn.
+ ARMOR PIERCING STRIKE: LB, SP
Requirement: You must be wielding a light blade or spear.
Target: One creature
Attack: Dexterity vs. Reflex
Hit: 1[W] + Dexterity modifier damage.
+ SHIELD BASH: SH, DWARF
Requirement: You must be using a shield.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. Fortitude
Hit: 1d6 + Strength modifier damage, and you push the
target 1 square.
Special: If you are a dwarf, the attack deals extra damage
equal to your Wisdom modifier.
Special: When charging, you can use this power in place of
a melee basic attack.
+ SHIELD BLOCK: SH
Requirement: You must be using a shield.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + Strength modifier damage and you can move
2 squares without provoking attacks of opportunity from
the target.
+ SWORD & SHIELD: SH & HB OR AXE, DWARF
Requirement: You must be using a shield and a heavy blade or an axe.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] + 1d6 + Strength modifier damage.
Special: If you are a dwarf, the attack deals extra damage
equal to your Wisdom modifier.
Effect: You don't gain the normal benefits to AC or reflex
from your shield until the start of your next turn.
+ SPINING SWEEP: ST,SP,PARM
Requirement: You must be using a staff, spear or polearm.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength -2 vs. AC
Hit: 1[W] damage, and you knock the target prone.
Last edited by alhoon on Sat Aug 22, 2009 12:34 am, edited 1 time in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Examples of 5th level at will powers:
+ CRACK THE SHELL: 2HW
Requirement: You must be You must be wielding a two-handed
weapon
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: [W] + Strength modifier damage, and the target takes a
–2 penalty to AC (save ends, not culmulative).
+ BLADE TORNADO 2w
Close burst 1
Requirement: You must be wielding two melee weapons.
Target: Every enemy in the burst
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: Weapon enchantment bonus + Strength modifier damage
COMETFALL CHARGE:
Prerequisite: You must be trained in Athletics.
Requirement: You must charge and use this power in place
of a melee basic attack.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 2[W] + Strength modifier damage.
Effect: You grant combat advantage and have a -2 penalty
to attacks until until the start of your next turn.
Furthermore, because you need to rebalance yourself, in
your next turn you must make only a basic attack (i.e not
use at will attack) or you keep granting combat advantage.
+ CRACK THE SHELL: 2HW
Requirement: You must be You must be wielding a two-handed
weapon
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: [W] + Strength modifier damage, and the target takes a
–2 penalty to AC (save ends, not culmulative).
+ BLADE TORNADO 2w
Close burst 1
Requirement: You must be wielding two melee weapons.
Target: Every enemy in the burst
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: Weapon enchantment bonus + Strength modifier damage
COMETFALL CHARGE:
Prerequisite: You must be trained in Athletics.
Requirement: You must charge and use this power in place
of a melee basic attack.
Target: One creature
Attack: Strength vs. AC
Hit: 2[W] + Strength modifier damage.
Effect: You grant combat advantage and have a -2 penalty
to attacks until until the start of your next turn.
Furthermore, because you need to rebalance yourself, in
your next turn you must make only a basic attack (i.e not
use at will attack) or you keep granting combat advantage.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Reserved for higher level powers examples
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
The discussion about the Fighter has intrigued me since it was first brought up. Although I understand the lack of realism in the 4E Fighter, I've always chalked it up to balancing, and just suspended my disbelief. Having said that, I'm open to the idea that there might be a better way to do it.
But one thing has come to my mind right off the bat. I don't think it's the Fighter that people have a problem with. He's just the poster child.
It's the Martial Power source. After all, Rangers, Rogues, and Warlords all use this source too. If the Fighter is changed, shouldn't these classes be changed too?
Your ideas Alhoon, are interesting. But the thing that pops out at me right away is that you've taken away the classes "boom" ability. I think everyone wants to have the "ace in the hole" so to speak. The big boom ability that they can pull out and use when they really need it. Your system above takes that away from Fighters, at least at the first 5 levels or so. A Fighter will really just have 3 at-wills to use each turn, and that's it. So they might switch it up every so often, but they'll probably find an ability they like and use that most of the time.
I've been playing with some different ideas in my head.
First, the complaint seems to be the idea that the Fighter has an ability that is only usable once per day or encounter. So to fix that, we have to free up these abilities to be used more often. If we do that, we have to limit them in some way, otherwise Fighters become much too powerful and no one would ever use an at-will ability.
One idea was to have abilities "unlock" when a critical hit occurs (monster or PC, who knows?). This sounds good, and I think it holds promise, but it's important to consider that any fight where criticals occur more often will then favor the Fighter. Whether it's the monster's ability to crit is increased, or the PC's ability, or a terrain feature or whatever. A foil to this might be limiting this to only affecting when a "20" is rolled.
Of course, this could mean entire encounters could go by with the Fighter not being able to use their big abilities.
Another idea I had was a mechanic similar to "rage" in WoW. Allowing the Fighter (and by extension, all Martial classes) to build up a points pool to use their abilities. Perhaps points could be accrued on damage done, or damage taken. But this brings problems of it's own. Monsters that do a lot of damage will build the pool faster, and Strikers will build it faster than Defenders.
Another idea I had was allowing the Fighter to "pay" for bigger abilities by not using all his actions. Perhaps encounter powers require both a standard and a move action to use. Perhaps dailies require standard, move, and minor actions, or even more.
One of the important things to remember is that if the Fighter can use his daily more than once per day (even if it's once per encounter) than it has to be limited in some way. The simplest method involves nerfing the power, but that takes away the big boom of the character, and I want to avoid that option.
Any thoughts?
But one thing has come to my mind right off the bat. I don't think it's the Fighter that people have a problem with. He's just the poster child.
It's the Martial Power source. After all, Rangers, Rogues, and Warlords all use this source too. If the Fighter is changed, shouldn't these classes be changed too?
Your ideas Alhoon, are interesting. But the thing that pops out at me right away is that you've taken away the classes "boom" ability. I think everyone wants to have the "ace in the hole" so to speak. The big boom ability that they can pull out and use when they really need it. Your system above takes that away from Fighters, at least at the first 5 levels or so. A Fighter will really just have 3 at-wills to use each turn, and that's it. So they might switch it up every so often, but they'll probably find an ability they like and use that most of the time.
I've been playing with some different ideas in my head.
First, the complaint seems to be the idea that the Fighter has an ability that is only usable once per day or encounter. So to fix that, we have to free up these abilities to be used more often. If we do that, we have to limit them in some way, otherwise Fighters become much too powerful and no one would ever use an at-will ability.
One idea was to have abilities "unlock" when a critical hit occurs (monster or PC, who knows?). This sounds good, and I think it holds promise, but it's important to consider that any fight where criticals occur more often will then favor the Fighter. Whether it's the monster's ability to crit is increased, or the PC's ability, or a terrain feature or whatever. A foil to this might be limiting this to only affecting when a "20" is rolled.
Of course, this could mean entire encounters could go by with the Fighter not being able to use their big abilities.
Another idea I had was a mechanic similar to "rage" in WoW. Allowing the Fighter (and by extension, all Martial classes) to build up a points pool to use their abilities. Perhaps points could be accrued on damage done, or damage taken. But this brings problems of it's own. Monsters that do a lot of damage will build the pool faster, and Strikers will build it faster than Defenders.
Another idea I had was allowing the Fighter to "pay" for bigger abilities by not using all his actions. Perhaps encounter powers require both a standard and a move action to use. Perhaps dailies require standard, move, and minor actions, or even more.
One of the important things to remember is that if the Fighter can use his daily more than once per day (even if it's once per encounter) than it has to be limited in some way. The simplest method involves nerfing the power, but that takes away the big boom of the character, and I want to avoid that option.
Any thoughts?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Yeap. If I test out this system and find it to my liking then yes, I'll do the same for all martial classes. But it takes time and I don't even know if it's worth it.Mortavius wrote: It's the Martial Power source. After all, Rangers, Rogues, and Warlords all use this source too. If the Fighter is changed, shouldn't these classes be changed too?
Actually no.Mortavius wrote: Your system above takes that away from Fighters, at least at the first 5 levels or so. A Fighter will really just have 3 at-wills to use each turn, and that's it. So they might switch it up every so often, but they'll probably find an ability they like and use that most of the time.
There are 3 at will at 1st level.
4 at will at 3rd level.
5 at will at 5th level.
And check the abilities, many of them are useful at certain instances. Like, sometimes you want to knock down the bad guy even if you don't do much damage. Sometimes you want to hit hard even if you put down your defences. etc.
Remember, most of them are actually toned down per encounter powers.
Many of these ideas I'm toying with already.Mortavius wrote:
Any thoughts?
Check the 5th level powers. THere's one that the fighter can do a lot of damage, but the wild swing throws him out of balance and he has a penalty until he spends a round with just a basic attack to rebalance himself.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
I see one significant problem with this, which is that by weakening the Daily and Encounter powers sufficient to let them be usable At-Will, you're also reducing the Fighter's overall damage output quite dramatically.
Let me try to explain this, forgive me if I don't quite manage.
In order to balance out the higher level powers being turned to At-Wills, you need to weaken them. But if you weaken all of the Daily and Encounter powers, that cuts back on the fighter's overall damage ability. In a normal fight, a Fighter would use almost all of his Encounters (many of which are 2[W] or have very good effects) as well as possibly a Daily or two.
This means that over the course of a ten-round battle, the Fighter is using half his standard actions to use Encounter or Daily powers. The new Fighter has the same ten rounds to attack, but he's limited to weaker attacks on every round.
Mathematically, say that a regular Fighter had four encounter powers that he used in an eight round fight, and all four encounters did 2[W] while his at-wills just did [W]. If he used all four encounters, then over the course of the battle he does [12[W] plus all the random additions. A fighter limited to using only at-Wills is stuck with dealing just 8[W].
Therefore, for the Fighter to remain as powerful relative to the other classes, his At-Wills have to be more powerful, relatively speaking. A fighter using only At-Wills should have equivalent damage dealing to someone possessing Encounters and Daily powers. Now, you could argue that the Fighter is paying for the added versatility of having so many At-Wills, but it should be noted that he had previously had a fair bit of versatility with Encounter and Daily powers. Not as much, but the versatility increase shouldn't be coming at the cost of a pretty hefty damage penalty.
Also, at this point you're running into one of the main problems that plagued the 3E fighter, which is balancing him compared to the characters with encounter and daily powers. Over the course of a regular battle, your fighter needs to be comparable to folks with Encounters and such. But if you improve his at-wills to be better than other folk's at-wills, but worse than their encounters and daily powers, then the Fighter's effectiveness is going to fluctuate with the length of the battle. At minimum, the battle needs to be long enough for the Fighter's allies to run out of encounter and daily powers (that they're willing to use at any rate) and for the fighter's superiority to their regular at-Wills to show through.
Problem there is that I have yet to meet anyone who likes really long battles where they run out of their Encounter and Daily powers.
As a final note, I think this might actually be a much worse problem with Rangers and Rogues than with Fighters. A fighter is a defender, so he accomplishes most of his combat role just by standing around wearing full plate. But strikers live and die off their powers and specifically their damage output, so weakening that is going to be a kiss of death for martial strikers.
Let me try to explain this, forgive me if I don't quite manage.
In order to balance out the higher level powers being turned to At-Wills, you need to weaken them. But if you weaken all of the Daily and Encounter powers, that cuts back on the fighter's overall damage ability. In a normal fight, a Fighter would use almost all of his Encounters (many of which are 2[W] or have very good effects) as well as possibly a Daily or two.
This means that over the course of a ten-round battle, the Fighter is using half his standard actions to use Encounter or Daily powers. The new Fighter has the same ten rounds to attack, but he's limited to weaker attacks on every round.
Mathematically, say that a regular Fighter had four encounter powers that he used in an eight round fight, and all four encounters did 2[W] while his at-wills just did [W]. If he used all four encounters, then over the course of the battle he does [12[W] plus all the random additions. A fighter limited to using only at-Wills is stuck with dealing just 8[W].
Therefore, for the Fighter to remain as powerful relative to the other classes, his At-Wills have to be more powerful, relatively speaking. A fighter using only At-Wills should have equivalent damage dealing to someone possessing Encounters and Daily powers. Now, you could argue that the Fighter is paying for the added versatility of having so many At-Wills, but it should be noted that he had previously had a fair bit of versatility with Encounter and Daily powers. Not as much, but the versatility increase shouldn't be coming at the cost of a pretty hefty damage penalty.
Also, at this point you're running into one of the main problems that plagued the 3E fighter, which is balancing him compared to the characters with encounter and daily powers. Over the course of a regular battle, your fighter needs to be comparable to folks with Encounters and such. But if you improve his at-wills to be better than other folk's at-wills, but worse than their encounters and daily powers, then the Fighter's effectiveness is going to fluctuate with the length of the battle. At minimum, the battle needs to be long enough for the Fighter's allies to run out of encounter and daily powers (that they're willing to use at any rate) and for the fighter's superiority to their regular at-Wills to show through.
Problem there is that I have yet to meet anyone who likes really long battles where they run out of their Encounter and Daily powers.
As a final note, I think this might actually be a much worse problem with Rangers and Rogues than with Fighters. A fighter is a defender, so he accomplishes most of his combat role just by standing around wearing full plate. But strikers live and die off their powers and specifically their damage output, so weakening that is going to be a kiss of death for martial strikers.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
I stand corrected on the number of At-Wills Alhoon, thank you.
The problem with multiple At-Wills is simply this:
You can only use one per round.
You can give them 20 At-Wills to use, and it may increase their versatility, but not their power level or balancing. And forgive me, but I don't see as having a bunch of 1(W) At-Wills, some of which might knock down the opponent, or slow them, or give them a -2 penalty to defenses to be worth a 3(W) damage attack with the Reliable keyword.
On a side note, if I was the Fighter I would stick with the attack that knocked my opponent down most of the time. That one seems much more powerful than the rest. It's a guaranteed effect and it forces the enemy to spend an action just to stand back up, as opposed to something like a -2 to defenses for a turn.
And yes, they get a 2(W) hit. But they have to wait 5 levels before they do so! A 1st level character usually has a 3(W) hit right off the bat.
Something else occurred to me while looking over the powers Alhoon. Most of the require a certain type of weapon. Now, I haven't looked over my Fighter PHB powers recently (and don't have the book at my desk) but IIRC, the majority of powers in the Fighter section didn't *require* certain weapons, but they had extra effects if those weapons were used. I like this idea; it allows player flexibility. And it allows for if the PC loses his favored weapon and is forced to use something else, he isn't instantly crippled and doesn't have access to some of his powers.
I'm not trying to dump on your system. I really do appreciate the work you've put forward on this, and I still think there is possibility somewhere to work this out. But I figure if you put it up on the boards here you're looking for feedback, so I'm going to give it.
The problem with multiple At-Wills is simply this:
You can only use one per round.
You can give them 20 At-Wills to use, and it may increase their versatility, but not their power level or balancing. And forgive me, but I don't see as having a bunch of 1(W) At-Wills, some of which might knock down the opponent, or slow them, or give them a -2 penalty to defenses to be worth a 3(W) damage attack with the Reliable keyword.
On a side note, if I was the Fighter I would stick with the attack that knocked my opponent down most of the time. That one seems much more powerful than the rest. It's a guaranteed effect and it forces the enemy to spend an action just to stand back up, as opposed to something like a -2 to defenses for a turn.
And yes, they get a 2(W) hit. But they have to wait 5 levels before they do so! A 1st level character usually has a 3(W) hit right off the bat.
Something else occurred to me while looking over the powers Alhoon. Most of the require a certain type of weapon. Now, I haven't looked over my Fighter PHB powers recently (and don't have the book at my desk) but IIRC, the majority of powers in the Fighter section didn't *require* certain weapons, but they had extra effects if those weapons were used. I like this idea; it allows player flexibility. And it allows for if the PC loses his favored weapon and is forced to use something else, he isn't instantly crippled and doesn't have access to some of his powers.
I'm not trying to dump on your system. I really do appreciate the work you've put forward on this, and I still think there is possibility somewhere to work this out. But I figure if you put it up on the boards here you're looking for feedback, so I'm going to give it.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I have thought of that and calculated in already.NeoTiamat wrote: I see one significant problem with this, which is that by weakening the Daily and Encounter powers sufficient to let them be usable At-Will, you're also reducing the Fighter's overall damage output quite dramatically.
Check the suggested changes. At 1st level the fighter gets a +1 to damage with at will attacks. (Not daily attacks).
Follow me in my reasoning on how I worked.
Assuming 4 encounters of 8 rounds each day = 32 rounds.
Low level encounter powers usually do 2W+something cool.
Low level dailies usually do 3W+ something VERY cool or give lasting bonuses.
To replace the dailies, I assume 3W + reliable
1st level:
1 encounter +1 daily.
ENCOUNTER:
By lowering the damage of the per encounter and adding prerequisites or penalties I keep the "something cool" and replace about 4x2W damage with 4x W damage. Now, assuming that about half of these per encounters would have hit, I have actually removed only 2W damage overall in the encounter.
Assuming a weapon that does 1d10 damage I have removed on average 11 damage from the encounter.
So I decided to give a +1 damage to at will attacks. Again assuming half of them hit, we come to a net loss of 7 damage.
Then I add powers that do a bit more damage with certain combinations...
And the fighter actually does more damage or inflicts the bad condition on the enemy far more often that once per two encounters (assuming again 50% of the attacks hit).
Dailies:
That's more difficult. It's NOT the 3W reliable damage. It's the cool effect that cannot be replaced easily.
The 3W reliable damage is actually just 2 1/2 x W more damage in a day. Why 2 1/2? Because this attack WILL hit, it's reliable. But it's still about 14 more damage in at least 32 rounds of combat = non important.
The effect though, usually gives a great tactical advantage that helps the party deal far more damage than this 3W.
Oh and most importantly, it's not that the encounter would be undefeatable without the use of a daily... it's that daily effects are fun for the player.
To recompensate for these lost effects however, the fighter can do a cool effect every round.
3rd level:
+1 encounter. No biggy. This fighter build is already doing more damage than the normal one. So the fighter gets a new at will to have more options on conditions to impose on enemies.
5th level:
Oh boy... another daily lost.
I have thought of some ways to do that.
7th level:
+1 per encounter. Again, no biggy. The effects will be incorporated in the 5th level at will powers.
About weapons:
I have thought of that and decided to use them as requirements instead of extra bonus, to give variability, so that a fighter with a spear plays different than a fighter with a sword or one with an axe.
I'm going to add more powers without requirements in the future... and more powers that need the staple of the medevial warrior: the sword!
Exactly.Mortavius wrote: I'm not trying to dump on your system. I really do appreciate the work you've put forward on this, and I still think there is possibility somewhere to work this out. But I figure if you put it up on the boards here you're looking for feedback, so I'm going to give it.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
