New, from WotC!

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Ok, it was lethal. But I still finished it by the rules, with one character made at the start. I got Imoen, Jaheira and Khalid. After that, the game was easier to play. And no, I didn't take Xzar nor Montaron to the Friendly Arm Inn.

So, it was doable. It just gave you much more excitement than if it were easier. I remember some amazing fights in BG1, and I do love that feeling of growing up, so that lethality of the game was actually a plus in my book.

Oh, I played a mage, by the way, so, loooow hit points, and low defense, and only 1 or 2 spells per day. Boy, how I ran from bears (as opposed to trying killing them!) until I had some decent fighters in my party.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

alhoon wrote:Oh, and you shouldn't blame BG1 for the lethal first levels! It was 2nd edition. Just that. One of the reasons I prefer 3rd from 2nd.
I actually don't mind lethal combat. It's one of the things that actually made me abandon DnD, because I feel combat should be much more lethal so PCs learn to fear it and avoid it like realworld people generally do.

My beef with BG1 was the way they handled lethal combat. Basically, it was largely unavoidable. There is no way to avoid it.

1. No way around the combat. They throw so much at you so early and there's craploads of scripted areas you have to go to for plot advancement. But surviving them is a highly chancey affair, and nothing you do makes much of a difference. Most early must-see destinations warp you onto a map with a nearby enemy aiming to kill you as quickly as possible, and nine times out of ten they were successful. Even just wandering around in the woods I faced phenomenally overpowered enemies wearing magical arms and armor. If the exercise is to pummel the player into submission, they succeeded.

2. Combat does not scale to your party strength. This feature is not hard to implement - games way back in 1985 like Ultima IV did scale the difficulty to your party strength. Turmesh, the magic user outside the Friendly Arms Inn, is an unavoidable plot enemy and he fires off enough Magic Missiles when you fight him to be at least Level 5. Hardly surprising that he massacred my Level 1 PC each time I encountered him. And "XP grinding" is not an option - some gamers will do it, but I'd sooner quit the game and play something else than spend my time killing rabbits and squirrels for piddling XP rewards to work around one designer's shortsighted inflexibility.

Both these aspects of the game essentially killed the game's biggest selling points, in my opinion. You had flexibility in making a character, and flexibility of exploring the surroundings. But any character other than a combat build was more or less doomed from the start, and the amount of overpowered enemies wandering around the landscape basically shuts down any attempt at exploration until you're strong enough to match their arbitrary power. Essentially the game said "Look at all the cool stuff you can do!" and then when you actually did it, it said "You're dead! Sucks to be you!"

For me the final straw came during a trip to some mines or other. Badly injured, from a single combat, I moved my people to a safe place and started resting to heal their injuries. We were attacked again while resting and the game (and my laptop) was finished for me.

Bad, bad, bad game. I'm very surprised Black Isle had the balls to make a sequel, but I'm glad they got their act together and made it much more playable. BG2 is still one of the best DnD games out there, but it was clearly built on the foundations of some really hard lessons from BG1.


For what it's worth, my brother disagrees with me and believes BG1 is far better in terms of plot. But then again my brother used to throw frisbees up in the air and then shoot them with a BB-gun shaped like a shotgun so his opinion may need a grain of salt before consumption. :)
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Ok, Humanbing, I think we're getting way off-topic, but let me just state that I disagree with most of what you said in the previous post.
As I said before, I had a mage, hardly a combat build. So, yes, I avoided some of the fights.

Indeed, the fight at the entrance to the Friendly Arm Inn was difficult, as were many others after that, namely some group of 5 Amazons later in the game (the one I recall and cherish the most, for winning that felt really good).

Anyhow, if you have Imoen attack that mage fast enough, he's doomed. He can't throw his missiles. So BG1, to a greater extent than BG2, really requires tactical thought. That's the key to winning those fights.

And as for exploring the first woods when you're level 1, that's simply not wise. Plot will require that you go down there later so you can do it later. At this point, even what plot suggests, is that the main character hurries to the inn to get some friends. And if he does it by the road instead of cross-country all the better. That's also what a sensible person in the real world would do.

I personally prefer encounters not to scale, and BGx never had scaled encounters in the series, as far as I know. I prefer this, even from a DM's point of view, to give verisimilitude to the game. My players should know when they face a hard fight, and they should back off when they recognize it. It's unrealistic for all enemies to be perfectly balanced to be taken by the adventuring party at each moment, just because they decided to arrive there. As it would be unrealistic to scale down a dragon just because a party decided to go explore an extremely (in the game world) dangerous region. So, status quo encounters (as the DMG puts it) are my encounters of choice, and I enjoy it when I find them in games. It makes the whole experience more believable to me.

Of course, other people may prefer different things, as seems to be your case, but I don't think any of us can call a game bad just because it happens to suit a different set of people than ourselves.

Oh, and of course you wouldn't go far if you'd have to grind for 1xp at a time. I never had to in BG1 or any other. And I played BG1 to the end some 3 or 4 times.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Ail, the only thing I agree with in your post is that we have very different opinions of the game. That's fine - you've played it all the way through, and I haven't.

There is one part of your post that worries me.
I don't think any of us can call a game bad just because it happens to suit a different set of people than ourselves.
From your words, I'm reading an implied mischaracterization of my view. My reasons for calling it bad have nothing to do with whether somebody else likes it. It has everything to do with whether I liked it. I played it, thought it poorly written and consistently frustrating, and did not enjoy it. For me, it was a bad game.

By the same token, you're perfectly entitled to call it a good game, if you played it, enjoyed it, and found it to be a fulfilling and entertaining experience. For you, it was a good game. There is no mutual contradiction between you and I playing something and walking away with very different experiences.

This is a very different view from what you're implying, which I read as "Ail liked the game. HuManBing did not like it. Therefore, because Ail liked it, HuManBing cannot possibly call it a bad game." Hopefully I've made clear why I find this statement disturbing.

As for off-topic, I wasn't actually aware that this particular thread ever had a topic! ;)

(A long, long time ago it was talking about Tarrasques, codpieces, and virgin belt-leather, as I recall...)
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

And BTW HMB, most of the customers of Black Isle absolutely loved BG1. You make some points, but the majority of the customers disagree with you, that's why the game is considered a great success and inspired an expansion, a sequel, an expansion for the sequel and many many BG1 clones. Icewind Dale and Planescape torment were built on the same platform mostly.
NWN was based somewhat on BG1 and BG2. You have to compare BG with the types of RPG we were used to at the time and you'll see that BG1 was a vast improvement on plot and character development and on being close to D&D rules.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Sure, I understand that. I understood that long before I ever played the game, and I was very surprised by how poorly it lived up to my expectations.

It does not distress me in the slightest that my opinion is different from most people's. They're entitled to their opinion just as I am to mine. But by the same token, my opinion is based on my own experience, not on what everybody else thinks. My opinion is no less sincere merely for being in the minority.

Don't get the idea that I begrudge the game its success, either. The paradigm it set down is, as you say, a very successful one and many amazing games came after it with the same model. Time after time in this very thread, I've said BG2 was an awesome game, one that I'm very happy I got to play. Without BG1's success, that would never have happened. My point (to repeat it again) was that there was a very surprising quality gap when I put BG1 in the computer and gave it a whirl. I'm happy BG1 was successful because it gave rise to BG2, Planescape, and all the other great games you mention - but as a game on its own I had serious issues.

My point is that it's really odd why people speak so highly of it, yet my playthrough turned out so unsatisfactory. It may very well be that I was spoiled by playing the superior after-arriving games first, and thus the unpolished precursor did not impress.

Either way, it seems like we're dancing around the point here. I found the game unplayable. Yes, other gamers may have found otherwise. Yes, it may have inspired a series of very polished successor games. Yes, it may have defined the computer genre that followed. I believe all these points are true and I heartily agree with them. But they're unrelated to the issue of why my experience was so different for BG1 than most other peoples.

Is that clearer now? It seems like there's a lot of separate, valid, but unrelated arguments being explored here - and for most of them, I'm in complete agreement.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

alhoon wrote:BG1 was very lethal. Period. :) So you had to just import/export your PCs until you had nice equipment and was at an acceptable level. Oh, and don't play at single player, with just one premaid char. Make a party of 2-3 powerful chars and then play.
Imoen is the only NPC that can compare to a player made char.
Yes, that was actually the tactic I used in my second runthrough of BG2. I basically made five custom PCs, and left one slot open for quest-related NPCs.

I might have decided to do that with BG1, but as a rule I usually try to play the game according to its original rules for the first runthrough. My second runthrough is the "read GameFAQs, snag every powerup" runthrough.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

I'll play BG1 again...The magazine that gifted ICW Dale and expansions now offers a DVD with BG1,BG2 and expansions. Old memories of an innocent youth, before 3rd edition (which placed functioning and believable rules) where the house rules were everything.
I remember fondly the days and weeks I played it. That's the reason I got defensive of the game BTW.

Story related NPCs... :? That was a new thing for me back in the day. And to think, the "story" of the story related NPCs was mostly a quest back then I think? You couldn't talk to the NPCs during the game, right?

As a question: Do they still make RPGs or other type of games with this kind of look-from-above graphics? I find that I'm quite fond of this type of graphics, like playing in a nice painting.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

HuManBing wrote:
From your words, I'm reading an implied mischaracterization of my view. My reasons for calling it bad have nothing to do with whether somebody else likes it. It has everything to do with whether I liked it. I played it, thought it poorly written and consistently frustrating, and did not enjoy it. For me, it was a bad game.

By the same token, you're perfectly entitled to call it a good game, if you played it, enjoyed it, and found it to be a fulfilling and entertaining experience. For you, it was a good game. There is no mutual contradiction between you and I playing something and walking away with very different experiences.

This is a very different view from what you're implying, which I read as "Ail liked the game. HuManBing did not like it. Therefore, because Ail liked it, HuManBing cannot possibly call it a bad game." Hopefully I've made clear why I find this statement disturbing.
You have, HMB, but you also caught me at sensible point where I seem to disagree with many people. I usually have a tendency to believe that 'good items' of a certain category should not be subject to individual personal opinions. I believe there must be some inherent aspect of quality that transcends individual feelings about the item. For example, I don't like Michael Jackson or Pop-music in general, but I must recognize that there were aspects of genius in him and that some people/pieces of Pop music do have something of high value. I can not deny quality to some of it, even though I personally prefer other kinds of music.

I also remember a coleague of mine once arguing that 'Citizen Kane' could never possibly be the best film ever because it was black and white; and I cringe with personal comments I see on youtube declaring this and that music 'the best ever'. Much of these are biased from what the poster knows. But they should not be taken as objective measures of being 'good' and 'bad' within their field.

I'm not saying I hold the true scales for good and bad; I'm not saying BG1 is good because I liked it, not at all; what I meant is that one negative personal opinion can not make an item (in this case BG1) objectively bad.

And this is the point that may sound more shocking in our age: I tend to go by what the critics and scholars of the field say. Of course this may seem a bit sheepish but I still believe those people should, in essence, have a broader view of the many variables that go into any item (for example, for a film, far more than being shot in B&W or colour, like montage, plot, casting, photography, etc) than non-experts. And that once that community reaches a general consensus, that should give a fair guideline to the others.

But individuality is still preserved in one thing: you don't have to feel aligned with the experts. I do not listen to pop-music just because the experts in the field like x and y. I simply don't listen to it, period. I don't adjust to that field. But most people would jump on me if I began saying 'all pop music is bad because I prefer z and w'.

It may happen the same to you: the more average view does not coincide with your own likes and dislikes, which is totally fair.
Just to conclude this point for now, this reminds me of what magazine reviewers must keep in mind in their reviews, as I once read from one: they have a target audience, the readers of the magazine, and they must write the review for their view point, even if that clashes with their personal opinions, because they are acting as guides for them.

However, other magazines may have different audiences with different tastes and therefore different viewpoints.
HuManBing wrote: As for off-topic, I wasn't actually aware that this particular thread ever had a topic! ;)

(A long, long time ago it was talking about Tarrasques, codpieces, and virgin belt-leather, as I recall...)
Lol... I didn't even notice that :-)
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Yes, I see your point Ail. Also, looking back through the thread, I see your first post on the BG1 issue is also a very wise one. I should have listened. :)
Ail wrote:
As for the quality of BG1, let's leave it as a matter of opinion, shall we?
While we're on the topic of CRPGs, has anybody completed Strahd's Possession? I got it running on my modern PC through DOSBox, but I can't make much progress on it. I also have Stone Prophet but I haven't tried running it yet.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

HuManBing wrote: While we're on the topic of CRPGs, has anybody completed Strahd's Possession? I got it running on my modern PC through DOSBox, but I can't make much progress on it. I also have Stone Prophet but I haven't tried running it yet.
I tried playing it years ago. But apparently I stepped on a bug that made completing the game impossible, like going to a certain house too soon in the game. Time was short and I didn't get back to it.

On the other hand, I found the interface a tad cumbersome and so difficult to play. I was used to EotB which seemed much more fluid.

Still, I liked the ambience very much.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Post Reply