Playing Vistani?
Not a class, but racial feats, rather like the Dhampyr from an earlier Dragon. Unusual, not what I was expecting, but not a bad way to handle things. There's also a sidebar stating that, while the "Core" Vistani are a mix of races united by shared culture, a DM is perfectly valid to restrict them to a single race, be it human or something else. Couple that with the future articles promising a way to reflect the more mystical aspects of the Vistani, it's easy enough to replicate the traditional Ravenloft Vistani: Humans Only, and play up the background elements that most apply- alienation, superiority, mystique, ecetera.
"Is there any word more meaningless than 'hope'? Besides 'blarfurgsnarg,' of course."
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
"Seek and Locate! Locate and Destroy! Destroy and Rejoice!"
I'm of two minds about it all. The Purist in me really hates that this is really a reuse of the AD&D Gypsy class as a heritage, and the use of the term "Vistani" is merely so no one sues for using the term Gypsy.
But I really do like it. I think it has a strong way to do the mythos of the Vistani, and you can tell a lot of work went into it to try to be true to both the original intent as well as the 4e Core.
As a note, I'm pretty sure if I use the "mysterious Vistani" I would apply the feats and such to Shadar-Kai. Dunno why, just seems right.
But I really do like it. I think it has a strong way to do the mythos of the Vistani, and you can tell a lot of work went into it to try to be true to both the original intent as well as the 4e Core.
As a note, I'm pretty sure if I use the "mysterious Vistani" I would apply the feats and such to Shadar-Kai. Dunno why, just seems right.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Well, now I've read the article and... eh.
It's nothing too egregious, pretty much as described. It strips a good deal of the flavorful meat off of the vistani and leaves some generic bones to use for a gypsy-esque society in any campaign setting. (but as noted, doesn't use the word gypsy even once!)
It seems to really emphasize this new multi-racial, adoptive family aspect a bit strongly, but a sidebar in the article explicitly "allows" my proposed solution: it's up to the DM what races comprise the vistani in his world. So we can limit it to humans if we want.
And using heritage feats rather than a race does have a few advantages, even if we don't want goblin vistani in Ravenloft. At least that gives us built in stats for giamargas (take the half-elf race and slap the heritage feat on it) and for vistani calibans (take a caliban race (Jester's version, for example) and add the feat). It also allows a character to choose more or less of the vistani powers in a balanced way, by choosing to take the extra feats or not.
It was clear that the author did read the VRG, which is nice. Little details slipped past the flavor-scrubbing, like the vistani justice system, and the giogoto scars (which are now on all vistani, as a rite of passage).
A few things were very grating on me, as a purist. For one, stripping all the patterna names out seemed silly. You've got built-in flavorful names for "wagon" and "elder" and "outcast," why dump them? In a totally-fluff article, why rip out the fluff that already exists? And it's certainly not ignorance, because where do all those words show up? In the sample clan names section. I was pleased to see the old tribe and tasque names there, (even Hyskosa!) but then it seems the author just went down the VRG glossary and threw every patterna word in. Clan Rauni? Clan Vardo? And who wants to be from Clan Vishnad? or Clan Mishamel? Bleh... I'm surprised there's no Clan Mortu or Clan Darkling...
And we get a sidebar for "vistani in Faerun" and "vistani in Eberron". How about a sidebar for "vistani in Ravenloft"? ( or "vistani in the domains of dread" if they're not ready to use that name.)
So is there anything new we can use? Well, the concept of the Jaunt is nice, (remind anyone else of Rumspringa?) and despite RL vistani's insistence that you are either "of the blood" or not, I could actually see the very rare adoption of a giorgio child (even of a non-human race) being incorporated somehow. Perhaps a raunie foresees some mysterious reason that it must be done, and the rest of the tribe obeys her. There are a few new clan names that sound like actual tribe names. And a two nice pictures.... once you crop the non-human stuff out.
It's nothing too egregious, pretty much as described. It strips a good deal of the flavorful meat off of the vistani and leaves some generic bones to use for a gypsy-esque society in any campaign setting. (but as noted, doesn't use the word gypsy even once!)
It seems to really emphasize this new multi-racial, adoptive family aspect a bit strongly, but a sidebar in the article explicitly "allows" my proposed solution: it's up to the DM what races comprise the vistani in his world. So we can limit it to humans if we want.
And using heritage feats rather than a race does have a few advantages, even if we don't want goblin vistani in Ravenloft. At least that gives us built in stats for giamargas (take the half-elf race and slap the heritage feat on it) and for vistani calibans (take a caliban race (Jester's version, for example) and add the feat). It also allows a character to choose more or less of the vistani powers in a balanced way, by choosing to take the extra feats or not.
It was clear that the author did read the VRG, which is nice. Little details slipped past the flavor-scrubbing, like the vistani justice system, and the giogoto scars (which are now on all vistani, as a rite of passage).
A few things were very grating on me, as a purist. For one, stripping all the patterna names out seemed silly. You've got built-in flavorful names for "wagon" and "elder" and "outcast," why dump them? In a totally-fluff article, why rip out the fluff that already exists? And it's certainly not ignorance, because where do all those words show up? In the sample clan names section. I was pleased to see the old tribe and tasque names there, (even Hyskosa!) but then it seems the author just went down the VRG glossary and threw every patterna word in. Clan Rauni? Clan Vardo? And who wants to be from Clan Vishnad? or Clan Mishamel? Bleh... I'm surprised there's no Clan Mortu or Clan Darkling...
And we get a sidebar for "vistani in Faerun" and "vistani in Eberron". How about a sidebar for "vistani in Ravenloft"? ( or "vistani in the domains of dread" if they're not ready to use that name.)
So is there anything new we can use? Well, the concept of the Jaunt is nice, (remind anyone else of Rumspringa?) and despite RL vistani's insistence that you are either "of the blood" or not, I could actually see the very rare adoption of a giorgio child (even of a non-human race) being incorporated somehow. Perhaps a raunie foresees some mysterious reason that it must be done, and the rest of the tribe obeys her. There are a few new clan names that sound like actual tribe names. And a two nice pictures.... once you crop the non-human stuff out.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
