Indeed. I can't wait for a a depiction of Strahd that is true to his german roots. Or better yet Bavarian: Where are his Lederhosen ?Rafael wrote:Barovia is actually BAVARIA, where I come from!
And has anyone of you EVER apologized to me? Anyone???
Vistani in 4E.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Last edited by Gonzoron of the FoS on Thu Sep 27, 2012 7:16 am, edited 1 time in total.
Reason: hot link broken by request of host
Reason: hot link broken by request of host
I think there is a significant difference between the medusa and the examples you have cited Cure.cure wrote:Continuing the digression, requiring somewhat potent magic to convert stone back to flesh is too harsh? A party serving as decor in a medusa's cave for a few years or even decades until someone puts the matter aright is going to crush game sales (as opposed to creating an original roleplaying opportunity)? Dumbing down rare and miraculous abilities, specifically that of a spellcaster who can convert stone back to flesh, into common knowledge readily available to whoever isn't stoned adds to the game (by undermining the prestige of classes)? If unpleasant outcomes are too unpleasant to contemplate why not also specify that hags would never eat a PC halfling before he/she has been rescued, no matter how apt let alone tasty the opposite outcome might be? Evil enjoying a triumph that is, horror of horrors, not readily reversable is sending the wrong signal? What does that say about the future of lycanthropy in Ravenloft where you only get one very inconvenient shot at a cure . . . . hence making the Dread Disease . . . well . . . dreaded . . . as the medusa should be.
I don't think the ease of curing petrification has anything to do with game sales; it's a concept of 4E. Basically, the idea that you don't have one (or slightly more) character classes that are "medical kits." Thus, in 4E, you don't HAVE to bring a Cleric because they are the only one who can cure disease, petrification, etc. You can bring ANY character with access to those rituals, even the Fighter!
How much of a role-playing opportunity was it in past editions, really? Assuming the DM doesn't break any rules, if the Cleric/Wizard/only character in the party capable of removing petrification was stoned, then the party had to stop what they were doing and head back to the nearest town where they could buy a scroll or magic item capable of reversing the effect. The DM might play this out, or might not. But if he/she does, then what does the stoned player do? Get to sit there and watch? Wow, that's fun.
This is assuming that the players weren't expecting to fight the medusa. If they are, then they probably brought items along with them. In which case...how is this different from 4E?
Note, that petrification itself isn't affected in 4E; it's reversal is. Being turned to stone is just as bad as it was in previous editions. It's just a little easier to cure if the party acts quickly after the fight. It's not as if the player can be cured in the middle of the fight, so being turned to stone effectively removes the character from the rest of the fight.
And if the players don't act within 24 hours? Well, technically there's nothing I know of that can cure the character then. This is where that DM creativity comes in, designing a quest for the players to cure their comrade, and hopefully giving that player something to do in the game in the meantime...
Tangentially related to the Medusa discussion (very tangentially) it always annoyed me that DnD misrepresented the "gorgon" monster as a bull-like thing that petrifies people.
The original gorgon was a race of snake-haired women. Medusa was just the most famous of them. I wonder why the DnD writers morphed the gorgon into a bull. (Of course, in Greek myth roots, there were plenty of very dangerous bulls and bull-like monsters, but I'm not sure why they picked that name to represent them.)
The original gorgon was a race of snake-haired women. Medusa was just the most famous of them. I wonder why the DnD writers morphed the gorgon into a bull. (Of course, in Greek myth roots, there were plenty of very dangerous bulls and bull-like monsters, but I'm not sure why they picked that name to represent them.)
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
True, but it is also a DC 30 Nature check to know this, so unless you have a druid or shaman in the party it might be rules unknowable.Mortavius wrote:In 4E the medusa's petrification is permanent, but it is worth noting that recovering from said stiffness is slightly easier than in previous editions. Any character can make a Heal check and use some of the Medusa's blood to reverse the petrification, as long as this is done no more than 24 hours from when it took place.
A nice change I think, for those times when in previous editions the only one or two people could remove the effect, and they ended up being the one petrified.
I like much of 4e's less permanent permanent effects where you can just ritual-up without costing resources (except gold, which means less magic in the long run and is the HUGE flaw in rituals) or the monsters have a built-in fix.
It does have some interesting side effects. Suddenly you want to fight a rust monster as it's a free 100% refund of a magic item that can become an upgrade or a swap to something of equal value.
If I ever have a PC run into one I'm knocking it out and keeping it roped-up in the basement.
"Sorry, Steve, but there's a reason the darn thing was that hungry!" Or, if you wanna be mean about it, have the residumm have soaked up a dangerous curse that affects any magic item made from it.It does have some interesting side effects. Suddenly you want to fight a rust monster as it's a free 100% refund of a magic item that can become an upgrade or a swap to something of equal value.
Guarantees are for suckers. I mean, if the ranger decides to try and use every part of a monster she killed, that's one thing, but if a player treats a monster as a resource for harvesting, it's like giving me a gilded invitation to make their life worse.
The concept of the gorgon as a monstrous, scaly bull comes from a 1607 medieval bestiary written by a fellow named Topsell, which was based in turn on the work of a 16th century Swiss naturalist named Gesner. It was essentially a variant on the catoblepas.HuManBing wrote:Tangentially related to the Medusa discussion (very tangentially) it always annoyed me that DnD misrepresented the "gorgon" monster as a bull-like thing that petrifies people.
The original gorgon was a race of snake-haired women. Medusa was just the most famous of them. I wonder why the DnD writers morphed the gorgon into a bull. (Of course, in Greek myth roots, there were plenty of very dangerous bulls and bull-like monsters, but I'm not sure why they picked that name to represent them.)
A DM who throws a Medusa at a party as a random monster is accepting the risk of someone inconveniently, and perhaps everyone, getting stoned. Assuming Knowledge Nature with a DC 30 is anything but readily available to anyone other than high level druids or rangers, then the situation is indeed as insoluable as in 3rd edition, even potentially if you have a high level druid or ranger as he/she could be the one stoned.Mortavius wrote: I don't think the ease of curing petrification has anything to do with game sales; it's a concept of 4E. Basically, the idea that you don't have one (or slightly more) character classes that are "medical kits." Thus, in 4E, you don't HAVE to bring a Cleric because they are the only one who can cure disease, petrification, etc. You can bring ANY character with access to those rituals, even the Fighter!
How much of a role-playing opportunity was it in past editions, really? Assuming the DM doesn't break any rules, if the Cleric/Wizard/only character in the party capable of removing petrification was stoned, then the party had to stop what they were doing and head back to the nearest town where they could buy a scroll or magic item capable of reversing the effect. The DM might play this out, or might not. But if he/she does, then what does the stoned player do? Get to sit there and watch? Wow, that's fun.
This is assuming that the players weren't expecting to fight the medusa. If they are, then they probably brought items along with them. In which case...how is this different from 4E?
Note, that petrification itself isn't affected in 4E; it's reversal is. Being turned to stone is just as bad as it was in previous editions. It's just a little easier to cure if the party acts quickly after the fight. It's not as if the player can be cured in the middle of the fight, so being turned to stone effectively removes the character from the rest of the fight.
And if the players don't act within 24 hours? Well, technically there's nothing I know of that can cure the character then. This is where that DM creativity comes in, designing a quest for the players to cure their comrade, and hopefully giving that player something to do in the game in the meantime...
If someone sitting around with nothing to do is forbidden, then perhaps the Medusa is an in appropriate random monster, some thought should be put into the use of one, a backstory worked up, a lair devised, a web of clues constructed, and so forth so a party that is enlightened can make the effort of arming itself which of course implies some roleplaying, whether with high level druids or rangers in 4th edition or high level clerics or wizards in 3rd edition. A party that blows off the investigative work gets partially or totally stoned, is aptly punished, and players left sitting around with nothing to do can consider what they did wrong.
My beef with the design concept is that the DM and the players are to be spared the disagreeable consequences of their own incompetence. Of course if play is close to the rules, the needed knowledge is not going to be available to those who don't look for it and punishment is served. But the threshold of requiring a 6th level spell seems alot higher to me than a successful knowledge check for anyone inclined to not bother with such nicities. I can see it now: "Oh my, Greywolf has been stoned, but not to worry everyone knows that stoning is reversible through the application of Medusa's blood, so he will be up and ready for the next fight . . ."
The cure for what ails you
I still don't see the difference Cure. You didn't address my point that in 3E, if a party was prepared for fighting a Medusa, then they would have backup magic to reverse the stoning if the key character who could do it normally got stoned. This is the same as 4E, with the simple removal of the players having to get the magic items.
Yeah, your reasoning of Greywolf being stoned and being ready for the next fight is completely sound. The point you're missing is that Greywolf is out for that fight, and the rest of the players still have to defeat the Medusa without themselves being turned to stone. IF and only IF they defeat it, then they can go about curing Greywolf.
I repeat myself. The immediate consequences of petrification are exactly the same as in any other edition of D&D; the removal of a character from the fight. It's only the after effects that have changed, and for the obvious reasons of character design philosophy that I also stated above.
I really don't see how the DM and player are as you say, spared the disagreeable consequences of their own incompetence. Just because an afflicition may be easier to cure outside of the situation where the affliction has it's main effect to me doesn't make said affliction any less dangerous. If you can give me another example, perhaps I can understand where you're coming from?
Yeah, your reasoning of Greywolf being stoned and being ready for the next fight is completely sound. The point you're missing is that Greywolf is out for that fight, and the rest of the players still have to defeat the Medusa without themselves being turned to stone. IF and only IF they defeat it, then they can go about curing Greywolf.
I repeat myself. The immediate consequences of petrification are exactly the same as in any other edition of D&D; the removal of a character from the fight. It's only the after effects that have changed, and for the obvious reasons of character design philosophy that I also stated above.
I really don't see how the DM and player are as you say, spared the disagreeable consequences of their own incompetence. Just because an afflicition may be easier to cure outside of the situation where the affliction has it's main effect to me doesn't make said affliction any less dangerous. If you can give me another example, perhaps I can understand where you're coming from?
Man, you're jumping right from, "Oh hey, Greywolf got stoned, he is, uh, dead because of a bad saving throw." to, "lol mo'like suckdusa.". Most DMs I know would change how the curse worked out of spite if their players actually acted like that.I can see it now: "Oh my, Greywolf has been stoned, but not to worry everyone knows that stoning is reversible through the application of Medusa's blood, so he will be up and ready for the next fight . . ."
I think you're making a lot of noise over a nothing issue. It still sucks to get turned to stone, and you can still cure it through a moderately difficult magical cure. It's just no longer mechanically impossible for non-wizards and clerics to have a hand in the cure.
Thanks for the reference. Prompt as always!Mangrum wrote:The concept of the gorgon as a monstrous, scaly bull comes from a 1607 medieval bestiary written by a fellow named Topsell, which was based in turn on the work of a 16th century Swiss naturalist named Gesner. It was essentially a variant on the catoblepas.
Well, were lycanthropy more easily cured, it would spread less, less people would be killed by lycanthropes, making it less dangerous, and would no longer merit description as 'the Dread Disease,' even though the killing capacity of any given lycanthrope in any given fight would be unchanged.Mortavius wrote:I really don't see how the DM and player are as you say, spared the disagreeable consequences of their own incompetence. Just because an afflicition may be easier to cure outside of the situation where the affliction has it's main effect to me doesn't make said affliction any less dangerous. If you can give me another example, perhaps I can understand where you're coming from?
Or, were level draining by the undead more easily cured, a change in fact made between 2nd and 3rd edition, it would be less dangerous as less characters would be enfeebled going forward and those who were enfeebled would be less enfeebled, again despite the fact that the killing capacity of any given level draining undead in any given fight would be unchanged. And as widely recognised the previous reigning fear of the undead went away, as they became a monster among others, that players were eagar to face.
All this is applicable to petrification IF the new cure is indeed more accessible than the old. I suspect that having someone in a party manage a DC 30 Knowledge nature check is less difficult than guessing that a sufficiently powerful spellcaster could be of assistance (DC ?), finding one with the necessary spell, and presuading him/her to prepare and apply it. The 4th edition solution would certainly be less time consuming and less expensive in any case. So the 3rd edition solution would tend to deprive the party for a longer period of the assistance of their comrade in any subsequent fights making the condition more dangerous. Indeed the idea seems to be that the 4th edition solution would ensure that the comrade is up and ready for the next fight. Less inconvenience, less danger, less fear, less consequences for blithely playing with fire.
In a distantly related vane, do ghosts and demiliches retain the power to put those they kill beyond the reach of resurrection? A matter that brings to mind the scene in Indiana Jones were the old professor tells Dr. Jones that going after the Ark of the Covenant is not simply another archelogical hunt. It is deadly serious work with consequences extending well beyond the current fight or even the next fight to one's immortal soul.
Not, granted, that this is so serious a matter.
The cure for what ails you
The first impression I got from reading your post is that you're jumping a bit, but I'll endeavor to respond as best I can.
On the issue of lycanthropy, I agree with you. However, it has always been this way. Lycanthropy has always been much easier to cure in a traditional D&D world, and Ravenloft imposed it's own rules making it very difficult.
We haven't seen how Ravenloft would handle lycanthropy in 4E, so I think it's premature to say that it's easy to cure in Ravenloft in 4E. If I were to make my own call, I would make similar rules to the way lycanthropy was handled in 3E, making it difficult to cure.
However, comparing lycanthropy to petrification, with the different rules imposed by the setting, is a bit like comparing apples to oranges IMO. Petrification works the same in both Ravenloft and other worlds; lycanthropy doesn't.
On the point of level draining, you are correct. It has become less dangerous. This is because level draining was so unpopular in 2E, and I can understand completely why. Roleplaying aside, the reward players get for playing is that their character gets more powerful. Level draining as mechanic was a deliberate punishment to that, and an almost arbitrary and harsh one at that. With the simple roll of a dice, a player could lose months of actual play time and effort. Sure, you could cure it, but in 2E it wasn't easy or usually even possible except for higher-level characters.
3E made level-draining easier, but even though it was easier to overcome, it didn't address one key problem; the book-keeping aspect. Even with the simpler methods of 3E, there was still some definate changes that needed to be made if your character suffered this attack, and that could easily bog down the fight.
4E did away with level-draining entirely. Instead, many undead drain healing surges now, which is a unique effect to the undead and one that although players may not see the importance of immediately, becomes apparent after play.
You're correct that the 4E solution of curing stoning is easier than the 3E one; I've never said anything contrary to that. (In fact, the DC 30 Nature check at the levels that the PC's should be facing a Medusa is not at all that hard.) I would ask you though: In what 2E or 3E game would you have a party of adventurers fight a medusa, one or more of the members gets turned to stone, and the party keeps on going having subsequent fights? This just seems unintelligent and ignorant to the afflicted player to me. Not only are you continuing on into harm with diminished resources, but the other players are willingly allowing one of the number to sit at the table with nothing to do? I mean, all the players showed up to play the game, not sit and watch other people.
As well, if we're talking 3E, then the person turned to stone who could've helped the others would have been the cleric or the wizard, and continuing on without that member of the party means the party loses signifcant healing or damage, which would in most cases be very unwise.
Ghosts in 4E don't have the ability to put those they kill beyond resurrection; indeed I don't remember ghosts being able to do that in 3E, though there may have been an exceptional ghost capable of it. On the subject of Demiliches, if they kill a victim with a Drain Soul attack, then that victim cannot be brought back to life until the Demilich is slain and the soul is released from one of the gems that are in the Demiliches skull.
On the issue of lycanthropy, I agree with you. However, it has always been this way. Lycanthropy has always been much easier to cure in a traditional D&D world, and Ravenloft imposed it's own rules making it very difficult.
We haven't seen how Ravenloft would handle lycanthropy in 4E, so I think it's premature to say that it's easy to cure in Ravenloft in 4E. If I were to make my own call, I would make similar rules to the way lycanthropy was handled in 3E, making it difficult to cure.
However, comparing lycanthropy to petrification, with the different rules imposed by the setting, is a bit like comparing apples to oranges IMO. Petrification works the same in both Ravenloft and other worlds; lycanthropy doesn't.
On the point of level draining, you are correct. It has become less dangerous. This is because level draining was so unpopular in 2E, and I can understand completely why. Roleplaying aside, the reward players get for playing is that their character gets more powerful. Level draining as mechanic was a deliberate punishment to that, and an almost arbitrary and harsh one at that. With the simple roll of a dice, a player could lose months of actual play time and effort. Sure, you could cure it, but in 2E it wasn't easy or usually even possible except for higher-level characters.
3E made level-draining easier, but even though it was easier to overcome, it didn't address one key problem; the book-keeping aspect. Even with the simpler methods of 3E, there was still some definate changes that needed to be made if your character suffered this attack, and that could easily bog down the fight.
4E did away with level-draining entirely. Instead, many undead drain healing surges now, which is a unique effect to the undead and one that although players may not see the importance of immediately, becomes apparent after play.
You're correct that the 4E solution of curing stoning is easier than the 3E one; I've never said anything contrary to that. (In fact, the DC 30 Nature check at the levels that the PC's should be facing a Medusa is not at all that hard.) I would ask you though: In what 2E or 3E game would you have a party of adventurers fight a medusa, one or more of the members gets turned to stone, and the party keeps on going having subsequent fights? This just seems unintelligent and ignorant to the afflicted player to me. Not only are you continuing on into harm with diminished resources, but the other players are willingly allowing one of the number to sit at the table with nothing to do? I mean, all the players showed up to play the game, not sit and watch other people.
As well, if we're talking 3E, then the person turned to stone who could've helped the others would have been the cleric or the wizard, and continuing on without that member of the party means the party loses signifcant healing or damage, which would in most cases be very unwise.
Ghosts in 4E don't have the ability to put those they kill beyond resurrection; indeed I don't remember ghosts being able to do that in 3E, though there may have been an exceptional ghost capable of it. On the subject of Demiliches, if they kill a victim with a Drain Soul attack, then that victim cannot be brought back to life until the Demilich is slain and the soul is released from one of the gems that are in the Demiliches skull.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
One other thing to remember is the story aspects.
You have a field of people turned to stone, and the only way to cure all of them is to find and kill the medusa and return within 24 hours of her death.
If the medusa escapes or you're delayed, then you've failed at the quest.
It's easier with a druid or shaman who hit on wisdom and should be starting with an 18 or 20 which is bumped to 20-22 at paragon, so they should be rocking a +14 to +17, so they need a 16 to 13 to nail the check, harder but more likely.
You have a field of people turned to stone, and the only way to cure all of them is to find and kill the medusa and return within 24 hours of her death.
If the medusa escapes or you're delayed, then you've failed at the quest.
L10 creature. So PCs in the 8-12 range. That means a straight bonus to skills of +4-6, +5 if trained. +9 to +11. And the only classes in PHB1 trained were ranger and wizard who do use wisdom as a kicker stat, but probably don't have more than a 16 in that, max of 18. So that's another +3 to +4, but that's with stat boosts so it's even less for <10s. So the range is +11 to +15, with a 19 needed on the lower end and only a 15 required on the upper end.Mortavius wrote: (In fact, the DC 30 Nature check at the levels that the PC's should be facing a Medusa is not at all that hard.)
It's easier with a druid or shaman who hit on wisdom and should be starting with an 18 or 20 which is bumped to 20-22 at paragon, so they should be rocking a +14 to +17, so they need a 16 to 13 to nail the check, harder but more likely.
Fair enough; I hadn't crunched the numbers on the DC. I was going off my experience; my 11th level players are quite easily able to make DC 30 checks most of the time when necessary.
Could be because of magic items and backgrounds, which would add to the numbers you listed. Feats and races are another possibility as well.
I was also thinking they could just take 20, but then I remembered that you can't take 20 on a Knowledge check.
Could be because of magic items and backgrounds, which would add to the numbers you listed. Feats and races are another possibility as well.
I was also thinking they could just take 20, but then I remembered that you can't take 20 on a Knowledge check.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Taking 20 is also a 3e rule that isn't in 4e. You can take 10 but not 20.
11th level PCs at at the higher end of that scale I mentioned, receiving the +5 to levels and the bonus +1 to all stats.
And, yes, with racial bonuses or backgrounds that can easily be knocked-up to a +16 or a +18 for a druid/shaman or divine character who took skill training or a background that unlocked nature. With backgrounds and racial it could easily touch-on +20.
But with PHB1 classes, high nature checks are difficult without an amazing roll.
A good example of synergies is my groups' dragonborn ranger, who has a +11 to perception at level 4 (passive of 21, they never get surprised). And she's a hybrid range with high strength and dex so her wisdom is low.
11th level PCs at at the higher end of that scale I mentioned, receiving the +5 to levels and the bonus +1 to all stats.
And, yes, with racial bonuses or backgrounds that can easily be knocked-up to a +16 or a +18 for a druid/shaman or divine character who took skill training or a background that unlocked nature. With backgrounds and racial it could easily touch-on +20.
But with PHB1 classes, high nature checks are difficult without an amazing roll.
A good example of synergies is my groups' dragonborn ranger, who has a +11 to perception at level 4 (passive of 21, they never get surprised). And she's a hybrid range with high strength and dex so her wisdom is low.
