Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by alhoon »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:- I figured ways to make monsters of lower CR threatening to a degree. Because in the past (3rd edition) I have found out that many 4 CR 2 monsters just aren't the same with a CR 6 monster.
I'm interested to hear details on this point. It's something I've struggled with.
A lvl 8 fighter/warblade with 12 dex could easily afford to have:
A large shield+2, Full plate armor +2. Then his buddy the cleric uses protection from evil, +2 deflection.
So that's 27 AC.

8 CR2 monsters are supposed to be a CR 8 encounter.
Checking CR2 monsters we see that a great many of them (Sahuagin, cheetah, goblin fighter 1/rogue 1, dire bat or badger etc) don't have a chance to hit the heavily armored warrior of lvl 8.
Most fighter players that know what they do, will tell you that they prefer to fight solo against 8 badgers than a single hill giant although the hill giant is CR 7.

Sure, flanking is an advantage, especially for those goblins, right? Well, not really. They still hit the fighter with just a natural 20. While a fighter with cleave or two weapons will propably kill a couple each round.

What I do:
I make monsters from scratch.
- Reducing hp by a bit to increase hit roll by a bit. Not Str 12 dex 15 con 14. Str 10 dex 18 con 12 +weapon finesse works better. A Racial curse or power check or a family curse handed down by ancestors etc that gives a +1 to hit rolls, but removes 4 hp. It's not like the CR 2 monster would survive the damage from a fighter's full attack anyway. :)
- Every 2-3 abilities increase CR by +1. So... I make those abilities count.
The CR 2 undead explodes when dropped to 0 hp for 2d6+6 negative energy damage 10' radius, save vs will for half.
Perhaps it also can make a single ranged touch attack 1/something (hour, 1d?rounds etc) Spewing acid/exhaling fumes/throw a bolt of darkness.
Or perhaps it can make 1 attack like a melee touch attack as if using emerald razor from Tome of Nine Swords.
- Damage reduction 5/something rare.
- For mages: Simply give the monster Resistance to what they usually have. Not all elements they use because that would be unfair to the wizard/sorcerer players. Or a bit of SR, like 14.

4E tactics usable:
Use leaders. :)
CR 8 = 1 CR 6 + 4 CR 2. If that CR 6 has an aura that gives a 1/4 chance fallen monsters will rise up in the next round with half their hp, or +2 morale to hit/damage rolls, or can use spells to boost their health like mass aid (+1 hr, +1d10+1/lvl hp) etc etc the followers of the bad guy become more important.


Just be careful to not neutralize completely the powers of class all the time.
A fighter that boosts his AC would expect some protection. If 30% of all monsters just ignore his AC then he will rightfully feel cheated.
CR 2 monsters with SR 20 are just plain mean and make wizards feel cheated. I know from experience. "Scorcthing ray... failed. Oh, the fighter kills the one I was targeting... and with cleave the next one too. :( "
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

[edit: it looks like this thread is intended for specific discussion of CR mechanics. I have cut this post and will post it in another thread, so that it doesn't derail this one.]
Last edited by HuManBing on Mon Dec 07, 2009 1:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

On a humorous note, I recall that even something as useless as a Flumph can easily kill something if you teleport it into the enemy's head. :)
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Would 8 Sahuagin with nets or 8 Goblins with nets and an approriate polearm for tripping need to punch through AC 27? Shouldn't their goal be getting the opponent prone, entangled, and flank on all sides? And for more fun, at least above the waves, one can liberally apply acid or at least alchemical fire. A heat metal spell, although it allows a saving throw, would might be fun too.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

HuManBing wrote:
5. Pandas. These are cute and nobody wants to shoot them. Examples: Tai Shan, the young cub panda in the Washington DC zoo. I'm including this item to make sure you're still reading my post carefully. Even today China's Communist government sends pandas overseas in a cunning strategy to make other nations less likely to start a war. In a fantasy setting, they might turn into your dad if you pour hot water on them. And everybody would think twice before shooting their own dad.
Said father most likely visited the cursed springs at Jusenkyo in the Bayankala Mountain Range in the Qinghai Province of China... Oh cursed springs... An infinite source of amusement and pandas... Of course the Chinese are still trying to oust the native Amazon tribes to gain control of that territory... Perhaps they should use your tactics. Their warriors could be converted over to seem as harmless pandas, the perfect camouflage and armor...
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

alhoon wrote: What I do:
I make monsters from scratch.
- Reducing hp by a bit to increase hit roll by a bit. Not Str 12 dex 15 con 14. Str 10 dex 18 con 12 +weapon finesse works better. A Racial curse or power check or a family curse handed down by ancestors etc that gives a +1 to hit rolls, but removes 4 hp. It's not like the CR 2 monster would survive the damage from a fighter's full attack anyway. :)
Hmm... but is that really keeping the CR low then? I can make a CR 2 creature CR6 by slapping 4 fighter levels on it, but then it's not CR2 anymore.


But you do have a point, the problem with low CR creatures is their abyssmal to-hit rolls. Even if the damage is low, getting hit a few times is at least an annoyance, but when the damage is 0 because they only hit on a 20, that's where low-CR creatures become completely useless.

maybe all it takes is to give them every bonus to hit you can find. Flanking, higher ground, get your PC's prone etc, etc..
The CR 2 undead explodes when dropped to 0 hp for 2d6+6 negative energy damage 10' radius, save vs will for half.
Not bad. One thing low-CR monsters are good at is dying. Make their deaths do something. check.
- Damage reduction 5/something rare.
again, treading into raising the CR there.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

I've been out of the CR metric for a while, but I think the question is whether you can increase the danger from a mook enemy without actually increasing their stats and innate capabilities, essentially. This means equipment and tactics.

Any attack roll is going to generally fail when you're that low level vs. something higher. So you'll need environmental hazards and area effect things to help you out.

Caltrops usually do not require an attack roll to hit. They may not do much damage, but they'll slow down the enemy, making him easier to hit afterwards.

Nets can act as an area effect, slowing the enemy down or even taking them out of the fight altogether.

Thrown vessels containing objectionable contents could work too. Poison powders, acid, contact venom, or even exotic harmful spores could all take their toll. If the agent inside is airborne then an attack roll only needs to successfully target the general area. A substance that hardens to gluelike consistency upon contact with air could effectively immobilize an enemy upon contact.

Fire can distract and obscure things. Placed between you and the target, they can't see you too well with missile attacks and they generally will think twice before coming through the fire after you. Less heat-intensive, smoke will usually do something similar.

Cave-ins can take out numerous enemies at once, especially if they're human-sized or larger and can't crawl out even if they survive.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by alhoon »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: Hmm... but is that really keeping the CR low then? I can make a CR 2 creature CR6 by slapping 4 fighter levels on it, but then it's not CR2 anymore.
- Damage reduction 5/something rare.
again, treading into raising the CR there.
[/quote]

Two things:
1. Not 4 fighter levels to a gnoll. That will indeed increase CR much. Giving 2-3 abilities however, just increases CR by 1.
So, let's take a CR 1 monster and play with it a bit.
Gnoll to Traitor shell!
Instead of a useless Hyena faced humanoid of CR 1 let's make a CR 2 charcoal skinned, hairless and sexless humanoid that is what's left after the big bad monster called Forsaken master is done with the "traitors" that forsaked him.
Let's assume our Forsaken master is an aberration that believes a village (or a family or descendants of certain individuals etc) owes it and owes it a lot. Now, the Forsaken master returns to claim what it thinks it's rightfully its and exact some revenge on those pesky humans that forgot their oaths (victims the PCs have to save).
It abducts humans and through a certain poison/ disease/ procedure/ Keepting-them-in-its-belly /whatever it turns them to obedient monstrous humanoids called Traitor Shells! The victims lose most of their memories, identity and most of their personality. They may keep a few habbits like huming or drumming their fingers when bored, but they are a new creature. The human inside them, the one with friends, family, etc is lost.
Bad monster! Bad! Needs to be stopped!

Important stats (mostly like gnoll stats):
Medium Monstrous humanoid:
2d8+2 hp (11 hp), 15 AC (+2 dex, +3 nat), F +4 R +2 W+1, Str 14, Dex 14, Con 12, Int 5, Wis 12, Cha 7. Base attack +2. Feats: Weapon Focus (Claw), Skills: Spot/Listen +3.
Attacks: 2 Claws +5 => 1d4+2 Or calculated attack (see below)

Now, so far, that's a CR 1 monster. Let's add a couple of abilities then to make it CR 2.

- Death shriek: When the Traitor shell dies, it releases a powerful wail that's damaging to everyone within 10' radius except other Traitor Shells or the Forsaken Master (which are immune). 3d6 sonic damage and the target is dazed for 1 rd. Will save DC 12 for half damage and it negates the daze effect.
(Has a chance to affect an 8th level fighter fully, doesn't endanger wizards or clerics much. A rogue backstabing it also has to deal with the daze)
- Calculated attack: As a standard action, the Traitor Shell can lunge forward in order to make a very precise strike although exposing itself in the process. It can use this power whenever it likes but uses it mostly against heavily armored enemies.
When using this attack, it makes a single claw attack with a +5 to hit roll, dealing more damage but suffers a -2 penalty to AC.
Calculated Attack: Claw +10 hr => 1d4+3 damage. AC 13
(Calculated attack deals about the same damage as the normal two attacks vs AC 19. For target AC > 19, it deals more damage. For target AC less than 19 (wizard, sorcerer etc) two claw attacks deal more damage.)
- SR 13
(Oh well, not much but leaves a small chance for spell failure)

See? That's a CR 2 monster. 8 of them can be threatening against a party with a fighter of 27 AC, an 8th level wizard, an 8th level cleric and an 8th level rogue.
I really believe that these monsters are more threatening to high level chars than 8 gnolls rangers lvl 1.
On the same time, 2 of them are about as threatening against say a party of 4th level as 2 gnolls lvl 1 Rangers. They have very low AC and they don't do much damage with melee attacks nor can hide.

2 and MOST important:
No, no, 1000 times no.
A 4th level CR 2 monster isn't usually a CR 6 monster. The DMG is wrong.
A 10th level sahuagin fighter isn't a CR 12 = as tough as 2 fire giants. Playtest it if you want.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: again, treading into raising the CR there.
Indeed, but not much. 2-3 abilties increase CR by 1.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:2 and MOST important:
No, no, 1000 times no.
A 4th level CR 2 monster isn't usually a CR 6 monster. The DMG is wrong.
OK, OK, I'll try to stop hitting on your pet peeve! ;) The numbers weren't my point. Whatever CR you want to call Gnoll Ftr4, it's not the same as a CR2 Gnoll. The point is that by added ANY ability to a low-CR creature, you're increasing the CR. Even if it's just increasing CR by 1.

Now that's not necessarily a bad thing. I love the Build-a-monster style of adding abilities from the VRG's, and your Traitor Shells are very cool. But I guess I was looking more for tactics that off-the-shelf low CR creatures could use.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Re: Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by alhoon »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: But I guess I was looking more for tactics that off-the-shelf low CR creatures could use.
So, not by adding powers or making changes but by making them more effective?

Well... check HMB's thread :)

You asked me how I make CR2 monsters worth their salt against level 8-10 characters.

Quick answer: I give 3 effective-against-high-levels powers to CR 1 monsters.






Psssst: Traitor Shells are cooler than gnolls with nets and goblins that trip you and swarm you. And more Ravenloft oriented. ;)
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Nevermorrow
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 111
Joined: Sat May 02, 2009 5:57 am

Post by Nevermorrow »

I know it must sound ridiculously obvious, but I think the simplest thing is to just increase their intelligence stat and make them put it to good use.

Sometimes trimming or altering their goals works too. What if, instead of the critters/people attempting a TPK like all the good little monsters do, they instead set up a kidnapping? Perhaps they could nab the weakest character in the group and position them as a (demi)human shield during a future ambush.

That's simple strategy, but a simpler, classic one has more potential for a horror campaign; picking the characters off one by one. A small group of clever monsters (or people - don't forget how devious and evil us humans can be!) can be worse than a more predatory enemy like a typical werewolf.

Oh, yeah, I'm back. :)
Formerly known as SpiritCaller.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Making low CR monsters more threatening.

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:So, not by adding powers or making changes but by making them more effective?

Well... check HMB's thread :)
Well... yeah. :) But I do see your point about specific powers that low-CR monsters can have that give them a fighting chance. The key, IMHO, is getting them able to land a hit of some sort against AC's that are out of their league. Whether that be by tactics, or by powers that bypass high AC, either way, at least they do _something_, rather than wave their claws about ineffectively while getting slaughtered.
Psssst: Traitor Shells are cooler than gnolls with nets and goblins that trip you and swarm you. And more Ravenloft oriented. ;)
Yes, but it was really never about gnolls or goblins. :) It's skin theives, tegs, bloodroses, goblyns, crawling claws and skinkites. Lots of Ravenloft-oriented critters are nice and atmospheric, but lose their scare factor when the off-the-shelf versions can't hit you.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Herman Strauss
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 11:36 am

Post by Herman Strauss »

Greetings!
I would like to think that the Ravenloft oriented monsters are not about their numeric threat on a one-on-one melee confrontation, but more on the psychological impact they have on the PCs when they encounter them.
Let me give an example on some of the creatures mentioned by Gonzoron:

-Skin Thieves- Imagine the PCs entering the Town Hall after a gruesome battle on the dark rainy streets and finding the barricaded terrified townsfolk there (mostly women and children). Some of them are Skin Thieves and the first one that attacks tears its skin of in a terrifying display of its true nature. Horror checks aside, the panic caused by this revelation to the true villagers will create a chaotic terrain filled with innocents and disguised monsters attacking without warning. Heroes who are not up to the task of making sure not to injure children will face a serious set of Dark Powers checks (the skinless zombies of the impersonated villagers can be encountered either before or after)

-Bloodroses – I always thought this particular monster works well as a garden! The PCs are hunted in a twisted botanical labyrinth by a more powerful creature that is affiliated with the roses or the roses are just nuisances before the big evil undead Treant. Remember to play their entangling power and perhaps make an increased or cumulative effect due to multiple roses attacking a single target within their reach. Attacks of the roses can gain a bonus if someone bull-rushes a character into the square occupied by it. Don’t forget to pull this one on characters that are naked and unarmed and throw some plants with poisons that do Dex damage.

-Crawling Claws- This one is reserved for sleeping and incapacitated characters (being strangled in your sleep is a really horrifying experience) or as a really nasty addition to a balance feat, say a web of narrow walkways and a ugly landing below (spikes or a sea of ravenous ghouls). The claws can move freely both on top and below the walkways making them difficult to hit and their attacks need not damage the characters, just trip them.

Darkness, falling for great heights, and illusions are just few of the mechanical tools, but the old advice from the 2nd edition is more effective: use fear, terror and uncertainty. If the PCs are running for their lives or are frozen in terror by what they are facing they are easier to hit. Things may have low stats but that doesn’t stop them from being frightening or terrifying. :twisted:
Nature offers the sick and dying.
We offer the best we have.
That's why the Gods prefer our sacrifices!
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Indeed, situations like you mentioned are in theme.
The 8th level party can slaughter the skinthieves or the Toben zombies but should make sure it doesn't take innocents down too.
However the party's 8th level fighter doesn't have to worry about one of the "innocents" suddenly turning on him and flanking him with one more skinthief. The +2 wouldn't help the skinthief win. The fighter would actually shout "Cool! I found another one!"
Even an 8th level mage, propably polymorphed to a troll with mage armor wouldn't be threatened.
It's more about protecting the people, than saving yourself.

The treant with the bloodroses is a very good example of what I meant. The thief hiding in the bushes will be in some trouble since the roses have a chance (although somewhat small) to trap him for the treant to pawn. And as you said... another thing that does dex damage is usefull in this situation.
But the bloodroses are an effective low CR monster. I didn't say that ALL monsters should be reworked.

The crawling claws in the sleep are also good... unless the party has someone on guard. My PCs usually set someone on guard even in inns.
The crawling claws on the stairs and corridors with nasties are also cool. I have used a similar tactic in the past. It worked. Too well in fact. I almost killed a couple of 13th level chars in what I thought was an EL 12.
Taking a dive in lava sucks.
However: Now I play with spell points and every spellcaster I know takes mass fly. So tripping 10th+ level chars is far more difficult. In the above example, I had a vassalich using a greater dispel scroll to dispel fly. Bad decision as I said.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Herman Strauss
Agent of the Fraternity
Agent of the Fraternity
Posts: 50
Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 11:36 am

Post by Herman Strauss »

Polymorphing into a horrible (large) monster in front of innocent children might be even more horrible for them than the Skin Thieves (as well as a warrior shouting cool when their mother rips the skin off her face). That moment will be excellent for the militia to return, find the dead monsters, the slain innocents (by the hands of the skin thieves) and the Troll Wizard. It will be an excellent opportunity for the villain leading the militia to frame the PCs (which was his plan in the first place) and place public accusations. Because of this easy low CR encounter they will have the law enforcers of the Domain Lord on their tails, not to mention several young men who will turn avengers to extract painful revenge from those they feel are responsible for the deaths of their beloved.
-if you really want to be a bastard put only one Skin Thief in the encounter (the one ripping his skin off) and make the rest real charmed innocents ordered to act like attacking. Then have the PCs realise what they have done (along with the authorities). It’s going to be a CR 2 encounter that they will remember.

Open display of monstrous powers is mostly frowned upon in Ravenloft and for a good reason: you don’t want to attract the attentions of the Darklord.

I don’t have the stats for the crawling claw handy but I am sure that they can slip past a guard or at the very least keep the characters on their toes several nights in succession and make their move when sleep deprivation sets in. again use of several low CR creatures works best as distraction and scenario complication carriers.
Nature offers the sick and dying.
We offer the best we have.
That's why the Gods prefer our sacrifices!
Post Reply