Asymmetric warfare - what to do when you're the weaker side
Kobolds are light, they can walk over disguised pit traps without setting them off. Use that to their advantage!
Also, take a leaf out of the Viet Cong's strategy book: use burrows and tunnels that their enemies are too large to comfortably fit through. Doors should never be bigger than they need to be. If you combine several unpleasant factors, it can turn a pursuit into a standstill - say the kobolds have a tunnel entrance that's underwater. Only way in for a human is to crawl in... and when you're crawling, you can't dodge incoming attacks or (even better) cave-ins. Touch attacks are easy in that situation - imagine that a kobold jumps down on the hapless PC's shoulders (touch attack or grapple) and then produces a knife to cut their throat. Even if it doesn't work, all they have to do is pin the PC's nose below water for long enough and the problem takes care of itself.
As far as pandas go, consider that they have thick fur. This makes them automatically less vulnerable to anything that needs direct skin contact to work - thistles, thorns, even stinging insects. A panda may get beehives on loan from its natural allies, the grizzly bears, and hang them around its lair. PCs trip over and free the bees. The panda is smiling - they can't sting it through the thick fur. Also because pandas' mouths are shaped in a way that they can't stop smiling.
Also, take a leaf out of the Viet Cong's strategy book: use burrows and tunnels that their enemies are too large to comfortably fit through. Doors should never be bigger than they need to be. If you combine several unpleasant factors, it can turn a pursuit into a standstill - say the kobolds have a tunnel entrance that's underwater. Only way in for a human is to crawl in... and when you're crawling, you can't dodge incoming attacks or (even better) cave-ins. Touch attacks are easy in that situation - imagine that a kobold jumps down on the hapless PC's shoulders (touch attack or grapple) and then produces a knife to cut their throat. Even if it doesn't work, all they have to do is pin the PC's nose below water for long enough and the problem takes care of itself.
As far as pandas go, consider that they have thick fur. This makes them automatically less vulnerable to anything that needs direct skin contact to work - thistles, thorns, even stinging insects. A panda may get beehives on loan from its natural allies, the grizzly bears, and hang them around its lair. PCs trip over and free the bees. The panda is smiling - they can't sting it through the thick fur. Also because pandas' mouths are shaped in a way that they can't stop smiling.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
That I haven't thought. A kobold grappling though is redicusly easy for a PC even with a -2 or even -4 from being in that tunnel. So, I'll go with death pits in that tunnel.HuManBing wrote: If you combine several unpleasant factors, it can turn a pursuit into a standstill - say the kobolds have a tunnel entrance that's underwater. Only way in for a human is to crawl in... and when you're crawling, you can't dodge incoming attacks or (even better) cave-ins. Touch attacks are easy in that situation - imagine that a kobold jumps down on the hapless PC's shoulders (touch attack or grapple) and then produces a knife to cut their throat. Even if it doesn't work, all they have to do is pin the PC's nose below water for long enough and the problem takes care of itself.
Why should a kobold drop itself when it can drop with a couple of budies a spherical stone that weights 100 lbs down the hole on the PC?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Well, the human is a) underwater, b) constricted, and c) prone. I'd say you're looking at more than just a -4 (which comes to a -20%) penalty. Possibly something to the order of -10 total. Of course, this is assuming your campaign has the rules mechanics to make this sort of realism work. If you're playing a cinematic campaign, it's possible that a PC could just shrug this off effortlessly.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I go for more rule oriented resolutions.
Also, the PC in your example isn't prone, just constricted and underwater. By the rules I play, prone supercedes constricted, doesn't add up. So it's -4.
If you go for realistic rules in a fantasy game, the first thing you need is to drop the hit point system. Then you need to change d20 with 2d10 so the chars roll far more towards the average.
Of course, once I have tried these, my players didn't like them.
If you go for realistic rules in a fantasy game, the first thing you need is to drop the hit point system. Then you need to change d20 with 2d10 so the chars roll far more towards the average.
Of course, once I have tried these, my players didn't like them.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
I typed out a very long post in response but decided to edit it. It came off as very exasperated, which wasn't my intention.
Two points:
1. "Are the PCs prone?": as mentioned above, "Doors should never be bigger than they need to be", which means height as well as width. So a human going through that will be prone, if it's underwater and the kobolds only need to swim through it. We're not even talking about a kobold's height - the opening will be the size of a kobold's shoulder girth. PCs will have to get horizontal to get through that. Apologies if this wasn't clear.
2. "Realism": this thread is intended to bring about non-system-specific examples of asymmetric fighting, drawn from realworld examples and my own low-level study of military history. These ideas work in reality. If your choice of game rules does not support them, then I would say that's a failing of your game rules, not the examples. You know what my solution would be in that situation...
3. Man-on-man winking action. I'm not entirely sure how to respond to your flirtatious and mildly flattering display of affection, so I shall merely mirror the gesture and hope everything turns out okay.
Here we go:
Also, here is a panda with guns.

Two points:
1. "Are the PCs prone?": as mentioned above, "Doors should never be bigger than they need to be", which means height as well as width. So a human going through that will be prone, if it's underwater and the kobolds only need to swim through it. We're not even talking about a kobold's height - the opening will be the size of a kobold's shoulder girth. PCs will have to get horizontal to get through that. Apologies if this wasn't clear.
2. "Realism": this thread is intended to bring about non-system-specific examples of asymmetric fighting, drawn from realworld examples and my own low-level study of military history. These ideas work in reality. If your choice of game rules does not support them, then I would say that's a failing of your game rules, not the examples. You know what my solution would be in that situation...
3. Man-on-man winking action. I'm not entirely sure how to respond to your flirtatious and mildly flattering display of affection, so I shall merely mirror the gesture and hope everything turns out okay.
Here we go:
Also, here is a panda with guns.

Last edited by HuManBing on Tue Feb 09, 2010 9:34 pm, edited 2 times in total.
- Scipion_Emilien
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 246
- Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:54 pm
This thread remember a principle that I readed somewhere that apply to biological evolution and warfare:
If you can't move (or are slow), you need to be big enough to face what's coming to you.
From what I saw in this thread, it seem to be many application of this.
From what I have seen, asymetrical warfare seem to appeal to 3 main concept:
- The "big" factor. Youre capacity to be able to take hit.
- Your mobility. You re capacity to strike where you want when you want, and possibly avoid the opponent. Mobility give you the initiative.
- Your firepower. Pretty self-explanatory. But I would argue that this one is less important in the middle age and classical warfare since the technology is usually more or less the same from one side or another. And you didn't have the capacity to anihilate the opponent main force (even if technologically on par with you) by being the first to strike. (Important in modern warfare as shown in the six-day war.)
Usually, you can't have all those 3 at the same time. You have to do trade off.
The full plate is in my opinion a good example of this. or rather, a counter-example that show the rule. The full plate is a relatively heavy and bulky armor. You gain a lot of protection, but at the cost of mobility (not only the weight of the armor slow you, but it increased the speed to which you become fatigued, which can be a crucial factor on a medieval battlefield).
What made the full plate such an interesting armor for it's time? The horse. The horse was giving the knight his mobility and helping on the fatigue front.
For the main infantry, even your heavy one, the full plate was a poor choice. There is of course the issue of cost, a big shield cost less than a full plate armor. But there too the fact that your infantry will be in formation (which help minimize the exposure to the ennemy) and will need to walk and perhaps run alot. And since the infantry don't have a horse for their mobility, they need an armor that allow them to move a little.
There is other way to be "bigger" than your opponent than the armor if you are not mobile. A good fortification do this job well by minimising your exposure to the ennemy and allowing you to maximise the firepower you have by forcing the ennemy in engaging you in small unit.
After all, if you are 200 against 1000, in open field you have 2 men against 10, in a fortification, you can have 20 men against many groups of 10.
As for mobility, as mentionned earlier, in the middle age, horses were the main factor of mobility. But others factors can help. The Sherwood forest of Robin Hood show that knowledge of the terrain is a crucial factor too.
If I remember right, the muslim embush the 4th crusade in a valley in the Taurus because they knew the terrain better than the crusader. And some say the byzantine scout let them in a trap. Which show the importance of the scouting too.
Then you needed to remember the point of asymetrical warfare. Which is not necessarly to get a surrendering from the ennemy, but to show to the ennemy that your resolve is enough that you are ready to be a real pain in the ass until he agree to your goal. The case of Irland, and more recently Irak and Afghanistan show this. The goal of the insurgency was and is to make the occupation of the country more costly than what you gain by staying here.
Another thing I like to keep in mind in such situation, even if this time it come from engineering rather than warfare is how to measure a risk factor.
In that field, the risk factor is measured by: damages dealt * probability of occurence.
Usually, when you are in front of a state or an organized military, you need to spread out your force. While it reduce the damage you can deal to the ennemy, it make it easier for logistical purpose. But it too is an application of this. If an organized military pinned you down, you are dead. The damage that can be done is really high, so to diminish the risk factor, you need to reduce the probability of occurence, even at the cost of firepower.
Now how to translate this in a fantasy world? Let say you are under the rulership of a tyrant and are sponsoring in uprising in the far reached of his realms. (Well you can do it in the core of his realms, but then it would be really hard since he has a lot more support for his regime and the center is usually easier to maintain than the periphery)
The first thing you need as a resistant leader is mobility. You need to ensure that those thugs of the tyrants don't get you. An horse and some knowledge of the terrain will do the trick. But in a fantasy world, you have an even broader scope. You have all those fantasy animal, flying ones are particularly great since they allow you to scout the ennemy movement and give great mobility. Then you needed some spy to know what is going on.
But you particularly need magic. Magic allow you to move faster, spy on your ennemy, and more importantly, avoid the ennemy to spy on you.
Second, firepower. This is the point that is the most different with the medieval world. Magic can allow you to unleash rapidly on unsuspecting ennemy a great deal of damage. D&D (pre-4e) evocation magic is particularly brutal at this since your casters can unleash their daily allotement of spell (or at least their higher lvl spell if they don't have the time to cast them all) to great effect an then withdraw.
Now, on the side of the tyrant, he need to be "bigger". This can be done with his of course numerous legion of mindless minion. But this can be done with fortification too.
This lead to the question of the importance of fortification in a fantasy world and how poliorcetic has developped. There is two option to this:
1-Magic is so powerful in firepower that it can blow easily foritification. if this happen, the tyrant will probably have many small fortifications. Those fortification will be spread on the territory to have a projection of force everywhere, but will remain small to minimize the loss if one is blow by an ennemy. It is even probable that the troops will have the order to leave the fortification before being surrounded since they don't really have an hoped that a siege will a least slow down the ennemy. Which would make the lost of this men pointless. Better to have them be put to use in a fight later with the rest of your army. An army in open field is thus better in this kind of fight since the ennemy must spread his magical firepower on a greater surface.
2-Magic has been incorporated into the building of the fortress and present a danger as great as a catapult to a fortification. In this case, you will have a big fortification that control an area. That fortification will be difficult to take and can slow down an attack, perhaps for years. Which will give the Kingdown time to react to the news of the invasion. If you are a resistant leader, you re better to just avoid it and strike elsewhere. Unless of course you do a kind of "commando mission" with a precise objective in the fortress (like kidnapping the ruler daughter in the hope of convincing her to marry you or assassinating a key figure).
Personnally, I prefer number 2 than 1 because number 2 give me a feeling of being in a medieval time. Number 1 make the thing so brutal that I have the impression of playing modern warfare 2 with airstrike, chopper and nade that kill me randomly. Sadly for me, D&D seem to be more on the side of number 2 than 1. I usually play at low-lvl and consider that fortification construction included hard-earned lesson against magic user to make my game tend more toward 2 than 1.
Now as a side note, I want to stress out the importance of magic in a fantasy world. Magic is akind to technology in the real worl, to win, you need to possess it, or at least know it's effects enough so as to know how to minimize the detrimental effect of having your opponent possessing such an advantage. (Like the Zulu against the britannics. Even if the Zulu didn't have gunpowder, they learned the range and lethality of such a weapon and were using cover to approach britains lines. They were even able to bolster their troops in front of casualty due to gunfire because it was no longer a "magic" thing for them)
If you can't move (or are slow), you need to be big enough to face what's coming to you.
From what I saw in this thread, it seem to be many application of this.
From what I have seen, asymetrical warfare seem to appeal to 3 main concept:
- The "big" factor. Youre capacity to be able to take hit.
- Your mobility. You re capacity to strike where you want when you want, and possibly avoid the opponent. Mobility give you the initiative.
- Your firepower. Pretty self-explanatory. But I would argue that this one is less important in the middle age and classical warfare since the technology is usually more or less the same from one side or another. And you didn't have the capacity to anihilate the opponent main force (even if technologically on par with you) by being the first to strike. (Important in modern warfare as shown in the six-day war.)
Usually, you can't have all those 3 at the same time. You have to do trade off.
The full plate is in my opinion a good example of this. or rather, a counter-example that show the rule. The full plate is a relatively heavy and bulky armor. You gain a lot of protection, but at the cost of mobility (not only the weight of the armor slow you, but it increased the speed to which you become fatigued, which can be a crucial factor on a medieval battlefield).
What made the full plate such an interesting armor for it's time? The horse. The horse was giving the knight his mobility and helping on the fatigue front.
For the main infantry, even your heavy one, the full plate was a poor choice. There is of course the issue of cost, a big shield cost less than a full plate armor. But there too the fact that your infantry will be in formation (which help minimize the exposure to the ennemy) and will need to walk and perhaps run alot. And since the infantry don't have a horse for their mobility, they need an armor that allow them to move a little.
There is other way to be "bigger" than your opponent than the armor if you are not mobile. A good fortification do this job well by minimising your exposure to the ennemy and allowing you to maximise the firepower you have by forcing the ennemy in engaging you in small unit.
After all, if you are 200 against 1000, in open field you have 2 men against 10, in a fortification, you can have 20 men against many groups of 10.
As for mobility, as mentionned earlier, in the middle age, horses were the main factor of mobility. But others factors can help. The Sherwood forest of Robin Hood show that knowledge of the terrain is a crucial factor too.
If I remember right, the muslim embush the 4th crusade in a valley in the Taurus because they knew the terrain better than the crusader. And some say the byzantine scout let them in a trap. Which show the importance of the scouting too.
Then you needed to remember the point of asymetrical warfare. Which is not necessarly to get a surrendering from the ennemy, but to show to the ennemy that your resolve is enough that you are ready to be a real pain in the ass until he agree to your goal. The case of Irland, and more recently Irak and Afghanistan show this. The goal of the insurgency was and is to make the occupation of the country more costly than what you gain by staying here.
Another thing I like to keep in mind in such situation, even if this time it come from engineering rather than warfare is how to measure a risk factor.
In that field, the risk factor is measured by: damages dealt * probability of occurence.
Usually, when you are in front of a state or an organized military, you need to spread out your force. While it reduce the damage you can deal to the ennemy, it make it easier for logistical purpose. But it too is an application of this. If an organized military pinned you down, you are dead. The damage that can be done is really high, so to diminish the risk factor, you need to reduce the probability of occurence, even at the cost of firepower.
Now how to translate this in a fantasy world? Let say you are under the rulership of a tyrant and are sponsoring in uprising in the far reached of his realms. (Well you can do it in the core of his realms, but then it would be really hard since he has a lot more support for his regime and the center is usually easier to maintain than the periphery)
The first thing you need as a resistant leader is mobility. You need to ensure that those thugs of the tyrants don't get you. An horse and some knowledge of the terrain will do the trick. But in a fantasy world, you have an even broader scope. You have all those fantasy animal, flying ones are particularly great since they allow you to scout the ennemy movement and give great mobility. Then you needed some spy to know what is going on.
But you particularly need magic. Magic allow you to move faster, spy on your ennemy, and more importantly, avoid the ennemy to spy on you.
Second, firepower. This is the point that is the most different with the medieval world. Magic can allow you to unleash rapidly on unsuspecting ennemy a great deal of damage. D&D (pre-4e) evocation magic is particularly brutal at this since your casters can unleash their daily allotement of spell (or at least their higher lvl spell if they don't have the time to cast them all) to great effect an then withdraw.
Now, on the side of the tyrant, he need to be "bigger". This can be done with his of course numerous legion of mindless minion. But this can be done with fortification too.
This lead to the question of the importance of fortification in a fantasy world and how poliorcetic has developped. There is two option to this:
1-Magic is so powerful in firepower that it can blow easily foritification. if this happen, the tyrant will probably have many small fortifications. Those fortification will be spread on the territory to have a projection of force everywhere, but will remain small to minimize the loss if one is blow by an ennemy. It is even probable that the troops will have the order to leave the fortification before being surrounded since they don't really have an hoped that a siege will a least slow down the ennemy. Which would make the lost of this men pointless. Better to have them be put to use in a fight later with the rest of your army. An army in open field is thus better in this kind of fight since the ennemy must spread his magical firepower on a greater surface.
2-Magic has been incorporated into the building of the fortress and present a danger as great as a catapult to a fortification. In this case, you will have a big fortification that control an area. That fortification will be difficult to take and can slow down an attack, perhaps for years. Which will give the Kingdown time to react to the news of the invasion. If you are a resistant leader, you re better to just avoid it and strike elsewhere. Unless of course you do a kind of "commando mission" with a precise objective in the fortress (like kidnapping the ruler daughter in the hope of convincing her to marry you or assassinating a key figure).
Personnally, I prefer number 2 than 1 because number 2 give me a feeling of being in a medieval time. Number 1 make the thing so brutal that I have the impression of playing modern warfare 2 with airstrike, chopper and nade that kill me randomly. Sadly for me, D&D seem to be more on the side of number 2 than 1. I usually play at low-lvl and consider that fortification construction included hard-earned lesson against magic user to make my game tend more toward 2 than 1.
Now as a side note, I want to stress out the importance of magic in a fantasy world. Magic is akind to technology in the real worl, to win, you need to possess it, or at least know it's effects enough so as to know how to minimize the detrimental effect of having your opponent possessing such an advantage. (Like the Zulu against the britannics. Even if the Zulu didn't have gunpowder, they learned the range and lethality of such a weapon and were using cover to approach britains lines. They were even able to bolster their troops in front of casualty due to gunfire because it was no longer a "magic" thing for them)
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
For a mathematical representation of what you are talking about, look at Lanchester's Laws. Unfortunately, most RPG rules are meant to contradict these laws, by allowing a small force (the PC's) to beat a larger one (the Forces of Darkness). Still, the strategies one can derive from Lanchester's Laws are still sound: divide and conquer, manpower is more important than equipment, etc.
Very useful when calculating battle sims.
Very useful when calculating battle sims.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
On a somewhat more tactical-level, chemical weapons are an impressive equalizer.
Poisons are the most basic chemical weapon, and are pretty ancient as an idea. The earliest mention of poisoned weapons is in the myths of Hercules, what with the hydra, so the idea has been around for a while. The right poisons can debilitate and defeat even very powerful foes, and poisons require minimal industrial or technological base. Quite the opposite, if anything, primitive tribes such as your stereotypical lizardfolk or goblins would have a much better knowledge of which plants and animals are toxic then folks living in the big city.
I believe Sun Tzu argued for using smoke and fire as a chemical weapon as well. If you've got the enemy trapped (not hard if they're in a cave system, say), then it's pretty easy to smoke them out. Even basic, regular smoke is toxic, and certain plants when burned create a really toxic gas. Mustard seeds, anyone?
Poisons are the most basic chemical weapon, and are pretty ancient as an idea. The earliest mention of poisoned weapons is in the myths of Hercules, what with the hydra, so the idea has been around for a while. The right poisons can debilitate and defeat even very powerful foes, and poisons require minimal industrial or technological base. Quite the opposite, if anything, primitive tribes such as your stereotypical lizardfolk or goblins would have a much better knowledge of which plants and animals are toxic then folks living in the big city.
I believe Sun Tzu argued for using smoke and fire as a chemical weapon as well. If you've got the enemy trapped (not hard if they're in a cave system, say), then it's pretty easy to smoke them out. Even basic, regular smoke is toxic, and certain plants when burned create a really toxic gas. Mustard seeds, anyone?
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
I thought about poison too.
Or get the help of technology: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hwacha to increase your fire power
... or create major distractions that doesn't hinder you (hot pepper smoke while you wear googles and masks.
Or get the help of technology: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hwacha to increase your fire power
... or create major distractions that doesn't hinder you (hot pepper smoke while you wear googles and masks.
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
As part of last century's first genocide, Ottoman troops built a fire at the entrance of a cave where Armenian refugees had taken shelter. The fire sucked out the oxygen and poured in smoke and carbon dioxide, gassing to death the refugees and prefiguring even more monsterous crimes to come.
The cure for what ails you
Propaganda, False Flag and Terrorism. Turn the overwhelming force into a pen of confused, backstabbing sheep.
The attackers of your beloved caves have returned to their safe little inn in their safe little town with its safe little guards. Regroup your Kobold allies and swear vengeance...
The town may be safe, but the farms are not. In the dark of the moon, go steal some babies for a morale-raising midnight meal. Steal some less tender children too, and kill them. In one palm place a bit of Elven jewelry, obviously ripped from the attackers...
Do you have a Shaman or Witchdoctor in the group? Use him to Charm some still-living children on another midnight raid. Treat those little ones with respect and courtesy at all times-invite them out for midnight mischief and such. In 2nd Ed rules Charms can be made to last for months, not so much in 3rd-but youngsters can be lied to more easily than the adults. Do NOT abuse or eat your new pals and be on your best behavior-these kids are your eyes and ears in the enemy camp. If you have enough young sympathizers you have a surprisingly effective Fifth Column-you could even send them on 'secret missions' (minor theft, spying, messages etc). Keep the mission 'fun' and of a non-lethal nature. If your young spy is caught, the names you have given him (Flopsy, Spot, Piggy, Not Me) will lead the adults to believe the child to be indulging in harmless games.
If and when the children have outlived their usefulness, kill them-horribly. Mutilate them. Remove the tongues and place a tiny scroll inside. Written on the scroll in flowing Elvish script is a single word-TRAITOR.
On the outskirts of the towns begin your 'retaliation'. Set shoddy 'traps' that fail half of the time and are never lethal. Carve long, rambling laments in Kobold on trees...it's pretty obvious that you've been broken and neutered as a threat by now, right? Just keep fed and mobile for now and swallow your pride-you're in this for the long haul.
Still got some Spellcasters? Charm up another 'Play Group' of young kids. Dress them up in outfits like yours.Give them toy weapons. Use illusions to emulate their happy faces. Near dusk, use this group of squealing mock-fighters to run past the gatekeepers and into the city...
Did you fail? Run. If you have played this out properly, the guards have just murdered some children thinking them to be 'monsters'. There will be a LOT of backlash on this one, maybe a reconsideration of the whole "kill the worthless Kobolds" deal. If any kids survive, they'll tearfully confess to 'playing' with the 'poor lonely Kobolds' who "weren't doing any harm and showed us how to catch squirrels and, and," etc.
For maximum effect, sneak as close to the town as is safe and leave little shrines in honor of your 'friends' for the next fortnight or so.
And if your plan DIDN'T fail...you made it into the city. If any of the kids know the layout of the town, use them. Have them spy out places to buy what you need and some good hideouts. Once that's done, KILL them. Butcher the biggest for provender but leave no trace of the body. As for the others-shove arrows of Elvish make into the killing wounds. It's pretty obvious that the poor things were 'playing Kobold' and some damned trigger-happy ELF didn't take a second look, right?
Lay low. Steal what you need but don't be flashy or too greedy-spells help here. When the time is right, sabotage everything you can within a few nights. Use attacks that are obviously Kobold-your best traps, most fiendish ambushes, mutilate the bodies, poison the well with offal (or maybe Zinc aka 'cobalt'
). Do NOT get caught. Be invisible if you can-if not, use Illusions to give yourself Elvish stature. Wear oversized shoes too. On the second or third act of sabotage, 'accidentally' leave part of a message behind in flowing Elvish script. The phrase "and once the idiots think those pathetic Kobolds are responsible, we can begin to" should be legible on the fragment.
If rumors haven't started by now, lay low, map out details of the town in detail and sneak out when it's quiet-hopefully you've found a secret egress by now for latter visits. But if the town begins wondering about those Elvish folk-time to step it up. Kidnap infants from their cradles and replace them with puppets, dolls or crudely-carved logs. This is a fine time to replenish your larder of course, but make sure some of them are found-with Elvish symbols smeared or carved in soft skin, laying piteously dead in a ceremonial circle of some kind...leave while you can and let the recriminations peak while you return home.
Has everything gone well so far? Allies at each other's throats, no Kobold caught and blamed yet? Now comes the hard part. One of you has to die. Only a few commanders-and the victim, who must be willing-can know this part of the plan. The Victim doesn't have to be capable or valuable, just willing-he WILL die. Arm him with killing runes, slow poison, multiple means of dying. Near dawn, this unarmed, undisguised Kobold will approach the gate holding a single scroll. He will probably get shot down (unless, y'know, that Kid Massacre thing...). If he is not shot then he kneels before the first guard he sees and hands over the scroll. If the timing is correct (or the means of death can be triggered remotely) your Victim should expire before any true discussions(or interrogations) can begin.
So what's on the scroll? A call for Truce. A rambling, semi-coherent (remember, you want them to believe you are wretched and pathetic) appeal begging relief from the Elvish Atrocities upon your people. Surely some common ground can be reached, could you please talk to your Elven Allies (after all they don't seem nearly as rabid as the ones in the Outer Woods)? Although we have heard rumors that the Gentle Ones may have turned on you as well....
And so on. Get creative.
Watch the anthill boil-watch the red ones start to fight with the black ones. Smile, and plot some more, rebuild forces during the respites if possible, and keep painting yourselves as victims and turning allies against allies. They will become paranoid and waste their superior might chasing ghosts and each other while you and yours wax-and if the other Demi-humans actually declare war against those turban wear...er those pointy-eared Elves for a bit, then maybe you can get some raiding and hunting land out of it for a while!
The attackers of your beloved caves have returned to their safe little inn in their safe little town with its safe little guards. Regroup your Kobold allies and swear vengeance...
The town may be safe, but the farms are not. In the dark of the moon, go steal some babies for a morale-raising midnight meal. Steal some less tender children too, and kill them. In one palm place a bit of Elven jewelry, obviously ripped from the attackers...
Do you have a Shaman or Witchdoctor in the group? Use him to Charm some still-living children on another midnight raid. Treat those little ones with respect and courtesy at all times-invite them out for midnight mischief and such. In 2nd Ed rules Charms can be made to last for months, not so much in 3rd-but youngsters can be lied to more easily than the adults. Do NOT abuse or eat your new pals and be on your best behavior-these kids are your eyes and ears in the enemy camp. If you have enough young sympathizers you have a surprisingly effective Fifth Column-you could even send them on 'secret missions' (minor theft, spying, messages etc). Keep the mission 'fun' and of a non-lethal nature. If your young spy is caught, the names you have given him (Flopsy, Spot, Piggy, Not Me) will lead the adults to believe the child to be indulging in harmless games.
If and when the children have outlived their usefulness, kill them-horribly. Mutilate them. Remove the tongues and place a tiny scroll inside. Written on the scroll in flowing Elvish script is a single word-TRAITOR.
On the outskirts of the towns begin your 'retaliation'. Set shoddy 'traps' that fail half of the time and are never lethal. Carve long, rambling laments in Kobold on trees...it's pretty obvious that you've been broken and neutered as a threat by now, right? Just keep fed and mobile for now and swallow your pride-you're in this for the long haul.
Still got some Spellcasters? Charm up another 'Play Group' of young kids. Dress them up in outfits like yours.Give them toy weapons. Use illusions to emulate their happy faces. Near dusk, use this group of squealing mock-fighters to run past the gatekeepers and into the city...
Did you fail? Run. If you have played this out properly, the guards have just murdered some children thinking them to be 'monsters'. There will be a LOT of backlash on this one, maybe a reconsideration of the whole "kill the worthless Kobolds" deal. If any kids survive, they'll tearfully confess to 'playing' with the 'poor lonely Kobolds' who "weren't doing any harm and showed us how to catch squirrels and, and," etc.
And if your plan DIDN'T fail...you made it into the city. If any of the kids know the layout of the town, use them. Have them spy out places to buy what you need and some good hideouts. Once that's done, KILL them. Butcher the biggest for provender but leave no trace of the body. As for the others-shove arrows of Elvish make into the killing wounds. It's pretty obvious that the poor things were 'playing Kobold' and some damned trigger-happy ELF didn't take a second look, right?
Lay low. Steal what you need but don't be flashy or too greedy-spells help here. When the time is right, sabotage everything you can within a few nights. Use attacks that are obviously Kobold-your best traps, most fiendish ambushes, mutilate the bodies, poison the well with offal (or maybe Zinc aka 'cobalt'
If rumors haven't started by now, lay low, map out details of the town in detail and sneak out when it's quiet-hopefully you've found a secret egress by now for latter visits. But if the town begins wondering about those Elvish folk-time to step it up. Kidnap infants from their cradles and replace them with puppets, dolls or crudely-carved logs. This is a fine time to replenish your larder of course, but make sure some of them are found-with Elvish symbols smeared or carved in soft skin, laying piteously dead in a ceremonial circle of some kind...leave while you can and let the recriminations peak while you return home.
Has everything gone well so far? Allies at each other's throats, no Kobold caught and blamed yet? Now comes the hard part. One of you has to die. Only a few commanders-and the victim, who must be willing-can know this part of the plan. The Victim doesn't have to be capable or valuable, just willing-he WILL die. Arm him with killing runes, slow poison, multiple means of dying. Near dawn, this unarmed, undisguised Kobold will approach the gate holding a single scroll. He will probably get shot down (unless, y'know, that Kid Massacre thing...). If he is not shot then he kneels before the first guard he sees and hands over the scroll. If the timing is correct (or the means of death can be triggered remotely) your Victim should expire before any true discussions(or interrogations) can begin.
So what's on the scroll? A call for Truce. A rambling, semi-coherent (remember, you want them to believe you are wretched and pathetic) appeal begging relief from the Elvish Atrocities upon your people. Surely some common ground can be reached, could you please talk to your Elven Allies (after all they don't seem nearly as rabid as the ones in the Outer Woods)? Although we have heard rumors that the Gentle Ones may have turned on you as well....
And so on. Get creative.
Watch the anthill boil-watch the red ones start to fight with the black ones. Smile, and plot some more, rebuild forces during the respites if possible, and keep painting yourselves as victims and turning allies against allies. They will become paranoid and waste their superior might chasing ghosts and each other while you and yours wax-and if the other Demi-humans actually declare war against those turban wear...er those pointy-eared Elves for a bit, then maybe you can get some raiding and hunting land out of it for a while!
"And did she ever come out?"
"Not Yet".
"Not Yet".
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Remind me to never upset you, Order.

Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Further military analysis concerning the Monochromatic Army's surprise invasion of the frozen wastes.
Recon forces: Lightweight, mobile forces capable of covering large areas in short time and reporting back. Also capable of carrying key ordnance to enemy hardpoints in sacrificial attacks. Marine: penguins (must remain near surface), Land: dalmatians (keen sense of smell, but genetically poor sense of hearing), Sky: arctic terns (superior sentry abilities in warning calls).
Engagement forces: Medium-to-heavyweight units capable of sustained combat. Marine: orcas (killer whales, capable of lightning strikes and coordinated tactics in three-dimensions underwater - however, known to beach themselves if deployed too close to shorelines). Land: polar bears (where mobility is less important than field strength, e.g. bottlenecks, advantageous-terrain engagements) zebras, where climatic conditions allow (close formation melee fighting coupled with excellent speed).
Special operations forces: Pandas (diplomatic demeanor allows for superior infiltrative abilities, coupled with climbing skills and six-fingered hands for operation of delicate instruments). Ospreys provide transport capabilities (though limited by range and capacity to 300g). Snow leopards serve as alpine scouts and camouflage skirmishing forces (preferably above treelines). Skunks for deployment in deniable chemical-warfare engagements outside the Geneva treaty structure.
Information provided here is meant for summation purposes only and may not represent the latest state of intelligence.
Recon forces: Lightweight, mobile forces capable of covering large areas in short time and reporting back. Also capable of carrying key ordnance to enemy hardpoints in sacrificial attacks. Marine: penguins (must remain near surface), Land: dalmatians (keen sense of smell, but genetically poor sense of hearing), Sky: arctic terns (superior sentry abilities in warning calls).
Engagement forces: Medium-to-heavyweight units capable of sustained combat. Marine: orcas (killer whales, capable of lightning strikes and coordinated tactics in three-dimensions underwater - however, known to beach themselves if deployed too close to shorelines). Land: polar bears (where mobility is less important than field strength, e.g. bottlenecks, advantageous-terrain engagements) zebras, where climatic conditions allow (close formation melee fighting coupled with excellent speed).
Special operations forces: Pandas (diplomatic demeanor allows for superior infiltrative abilities, coupled with climbing skills and six-fingered hands for operation of delicate instruments). Ospreys provide transport capabilities (though limited by range and capacity to 300g). Snow leopards serve as alpine scouts and camouflage skirmishing forces (preferably above treelines). Skunks for deployment in deniable chemical-warfare engagements outside the Geneva treaty structure.
Information provided here is meant for summation purposes only and may not represent the latest state of intelligence.

