Pow Check Question?!?!?! Help!!!

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Pow Check Question?!?!?! Help!!!

Post by A G Thing »

I apologize for the long winded post but this is bugging the heck outta me and I need some sort of advice on some key points.

Okay... I got a fairly new group of players that while not yet the best or sharpest roleplayers yet, they are showing promise with experience and great interest in the game of D&D, and yet they are close to 10 yr's younger than me and are teenage boys one and all... So after a few warm up games in homebrew I decided to start them in Ravenloft and I have been running simple stories and games that I ran before so I can get something truly good together... :)

Still that being said I ran into a problem in the current game in how to handle this fairly large Powers Check one of them caused as he was roleplaying his rather callous racist Sithican Elf. His main goal in the game is gathering enough power and experience to gain vengeance against Azreal Dak so he is not a shining hero. He is however traveling with a Paladin and a Monk so if he strays too far the others might conflict with him.

But here's how it happened

He broke off alone as others in the group were gathering info/recovering and was hunting one of the Bogeymen, namely Miss C... He spotted her leading one child away from a group of children when he ran up and confronted her with bow drawn threatening her. She sort of surrendered but when several of the children in the park turned and I clearly described their dazed and controlled looks on their faces. (I tend to make the Bogeymen a little more powerful but they are mostly the same!!!) Well they walk toward him and he threatens Miss C with an arrow so she protests her innocence all the while the children in dead tones of voice start calling him a meany and grabbing him or moving in his path as he decides to rush her. Once he is grappled he struggles to get out as he see's her run toward the waiting wagon. He says he wishes to knock the children out and I tell him that while they are holding him they are perhaps not doing anything under their own power or doing significant harm. He says his character would not care as he has no concern for such inferior races offspring, and he is still minimizing the harm. So I tell him if he thinks his character would than it is up to him.

Now I have no problem with this so far... He wrote a background and his character is Lawful Neutral though from other actions I think he should have been Chaotic Neutral but that is not important. I knew full well this could happen and just wanted to see how far this roleplay would carry.

It is that he swung at the first few of the children doing non lethal but when it became desperate his character said to heck with it and swung full force so he might get a shot off to delay her. The children with only 4 hp who he had only knocked out before were lucky compared to the ones dropped to -4, -7 & -8 with well placed strikes. Horrified towns people managed to save these children and he managed to delay the Bogeymen till the guard arrived. The townspeople were scared by the crazy elf and the few that commented did not help his arguements, which only made him more frustrated as their virtual invisibility and ability to lie kept him from an easy solution. So he could only persuade the already distrusting guardsmen by lying repeatedly in order to get them held for questioning, thus he was just rapping at the powers checks gates. He even through good roles and solid reasoning convinced them to take her candy pouch so he could examine it, but in truth though it never came to light, when he got a chance he was going to use poison on it to make a false conviction on them. He could not convince the guards that the child was not Mr and Miss C.s child either, and the little boy did not talk except to confirm the story but he felt the child would be watched by the guard...
This led to tragedy for the child, the guards men and a much more dramatic showdown later on. Nine people died in the Bogeymens efforts to escape, and their confinement was a direct result of his lies. He however could not be held accountable for their non belief as he did warn them of the danger.

---------------------------

He had no proof of the Bogeyman Miss C. identity before he started threatening her except her matching the story but as these are how you have to fight these types of villains I can perhaps see waving the threats of violence part of the check. She matched so closely and he did not fire until she ran so it was not so bad of an act.

It is the assault and considering the targets were children I am considering bumping them all up to Grievous. 3 knocked unconscious in restraint is unless I decide different just Unprovoked Assault as they were controlled and just restraining.

Lastly the lies (and their were multiple!) are many but mostly toward the same goal so I think I will just increase the percent to 2%... I am unsure if I should include some guilt in the death of so many others as partly his fault, especially since he let them be for a long while but he was dealing with multiple Bogeymen at the same time. But planning to frame someone even if guilty was another lie and he was going to betray what trust his reputation had earned him among the guard. If it could have been found out it would have been a major betrayal...

So

Assault Unprovoked x3 is 9%
Assault Grievous x3 is only 16% but if the last 3 are also AGr too then it is 32% :shock:
Lying is 2%
And the Lie + the planned but never executed betrayal due only to circumstance would have been 10% minimum...

In total it is either 35% or it is 44% :shock:

Does this sound right? Am I fair in judging this? I have not rolled the percents yet and the next game has a little time before it comes round.

Also does anyone have any ideas on what the curse/boon should be for such? I have thought since it was motivated by racism I would perhaps start adding traits of other races, but also increase his elven traits... This way even if he is an Elf on the inside and maybe even a superior elf internally, he is not an Elf outside and his OR will reflect that. Eventually the track would make him a Caliban, but start to give him bonuses to disguise as other races, but from here I am starting to lose the train of thought...

Help!!! :?
Last edited by A G Thing on Thu Dec 31, 2009 4:01 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

I'm not an expert on powers checks, but I'd always assumed that you roll them all separately. They don't stack up like that, so it would just be a bunch of powers checks at around 5-6%. [This may make the resulting percentage seem low, but even cold blooded murder is a decently low percent chance of failing... when it's not a AoUD, that is.]

Also, I don't think you can make someone roll a powers check for something they planned to do. Even if they only didn't do it because of circumstance, it still didn't happen.

You'll have to make the call on what the assaults are. However, by the strict intent behind what was written for Grievous Assault - viciously beating the children with the intent to do lasting harm - I would say it's only Unprovoked. [Technically, he was provoked, but it sounds like the children couldn't really do any harm to him.]
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

I'd say that you are being a bit harsh.

I would not give a powers check for any non-lethal assault on the kids.It wasn't unprovoked, after all. It was a course of action that might have saved those kids' lives.

I would count the lethal force attacks as assault: grievous against strangers [2% each}. The PC seems to have understood that the kids were mind-controlled, but he used lethal force on them, anyway. That's where it strays in powers check territory for me. He showed no regard for their lives, even if his intent wasn't to kill them.

Lying should only provoke powers checks if it directly causes the hearer to come to harm, and the liar intended harm/endangerment. That doesn't seem to be the case , here. He was trying to stop the monsters, not help them get more victims. I would say no powers checks for his lies and fabrications. I'm not sure that I have clearly understood what it is he lied about, or the cicrumstances. That part was a bit confusing, AG.

I would give no powers check for any planned actions, because that's not how the checks work. You actually have to act, not just think or plan.

I roll all checks seperately. You are the DM, so you should handle it as you like! This is all just my advice, the way I'd handle it.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Post by Ryan Naylor »

I think you're being harsh too.

Isabella is right, as well: you roll them all separately.

I wouldn't make checks for knocking the children out, since the PCs was really trying to help them/protect innocents at the time.

I would make a check for using lethal force on them (one, for the assaults generally, not one each, since the crime is the same). I'm in two minds about whether it's grevious assault or not (it probably is). Because they're children, I'd say roll against the "good NPCs" column, not the "neutral NPCs" column.

I wouldn't make a check for the lie, since it wasn't malicious.

So you end up only making 1 check.

Doesn't sound like LN behaviour either.
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

Oh I knew posting the total percent would do that but I for some reason thought the number was impressive.
I would of course roll them separate for each act but I guess I just assumed you people had psychic powers and realized I was shocked at the amounts totaled and was not house ruling powers checks... Also adding the words "this fairly large Powers Check" was not my best move to avoid such confusion either... Stupid stupid me!!! :x :oops:

My bad!!! Won't happen again!!! Sorry!!! :oops:


As for his lies I guess reconsidering the circumstances they were minor and in a way even though they were not true they could have fit the creatures methods in a fashion. He accused them of being drug peddlers, and poison sellers and trying to addict the children. Mostly it was a lack of credibility and the monsters abilities to lie and deceive the guard that prevented them from being arrested and hung as it was a serious crime he was accusing them of, and he was ready to claim that his own drugs and poison were what little he was able to find of theirs. Still he did do good with the lie in delaying them.

As for being too harsh, I guess I can see what you are saying on these points. I tend to look at things perhaps too much in the sense of black and white in some instances, especially when powers checks are involved I worry I will screw things up. I mean lying against someone you cannot prove is guilty and planning to forge evidence is wrong even if it fails. I can usually see good and evil quite clearly even by Ravenloft standards, but I perhaps did not balance the events from the characters point of view quite well this time. I kept placing moral standards into it that were more my own as I guess I can be a bit of a Paladin or Innocent in how I see wrong and right. :P

Still the reason for the post is that I knew something was wrong in my reasoning for the time being which is why I brought it here and your comments gave a more clear scope to my thoughts... I think I over thought the whole thing and then talked myself into judging it badly from this overly critical view. Not to mention I confused the heck out of you from the numbers and made myself look incredibly green as a Ravenloft DM!

So I am thinking this is the case...

Assault Grievous: three checks at 4% - As Isabella pointed out I should decide and listening to what ewancummins stated it seems right and fair that he should have a chance for failure for each such offense but taking a cue from Ryan Naylor I am going to split the difference as children should be treated gentler even if strangers by increasing the percent, but only taking the first succeeded powers check if any. He has a greater chance somewhat in failing but he can still only fail once.

Lies: He did not actually turn anyone to violence and he was trying to get them delayed but could have gotten them lynched and would not have cared. The only reason some of the lies such as the drugs/poisoning and such did not stick is his own questionable character and the villains lies. Still inconsequential I guess so no check... But man is he pushing for an alignment change!

Planned Act Of Lie/Betrayal: No check! I really never should have posted the possible powers check as it was just confusing to the people trying to help me. I once more am just marveling at the shocking level of possible evil in his actions... Still if not for the events that made it unnecessary it would have been evil of him if it had happened!

So thanks guys and ghouls it helps a bunch and you may have saved his character from a mostly undeserved painstaking early decent into Darklordship! :)

Of note: There really were Dark Powers on this check! :twisted: :D
Post Reply