Hi,
Been lurking for quite a while...
I need advice.
I have a player playing a Pathfinder Cleric in my game with the Lorekeeper ability.
This means he can touch someone and gets a result of Knowledge skill (nature, I think) 25 telling him what kind of creature he is dealing with.
(I don't have the book in front of me.)
How can I translate this in RL?
Obviously, he now gets a limit a day.
I was thinking of letting the creature get some kind of save to withold info.
Or how to give helpful info without giving everything away?
I don't want to make this a useless ability in RL.
Thoughts?
Thanks in advance!
Patrick
Need Pathfinder advice
-
Jonathan Winters
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 435
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
- Location: Montreal, Quebec
Need Pathfinder advice
Mysteries of Darkon (AKA Miranda Cornelius' Journal)
On hiatus while visiting Ptolus, City by the Spire, new RL-inspired campaign: Madness Rising!
www.bullonir.wikidot.com
On hiatus while visiting Ptolus, City by the Spire, new RL-inspired campaign: Madness Rising!
www.bullonir.wikidot.com
I did wonder reading the playtest material how some of these superpowers got through to the core edition.
Lorekeeper in RL - an idea:
It works fine, but when used on a Dark Lord, directly on the mists if you count the mists as alive or any being that has suffered a powers check, a madness check is required. This won't happen often but when it does it will teach the cleric a valuable lesson, use caution when using lorekeeper in Ravenloft.
Lorekeeper in RL - an idea:
It works fine, but when used on a Dark Lord, directly on the mists if you count the mists as alive or any being that has suffered a powers check, a madness check is required. This won't happen often but when it does it will teach the cleric a valuable lesson, use caution when using lorekeeper in Ravenloft.
[Malice in Wonderland]
SMI2LE
SMI2LE
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
I might limit it to mundane races and subtypes. Or at least allow them the standard saving throw.
To favour the PCs a little more (and not hinder a character too much), I might rule that for creatures with fewer HD than the PC the ability works as written. For creatures of equal level they monster gets a save to avoid revelation, but failure might reveal "something" unknown. For creatures of higher level a successful save reveals wrong information.
For intelligent undead, it would reveal their type in life.
For aberrations, I would have them negatively impacted by contact with an alien intelligence.
For shapechangers, I would have it tell what they're disguised as.
To favour the PCs a little more (and not hinder a character too much), I might rule that for creatures with fewer HD than the PC the ability works as written. For creatures of equal level they monster gets a save to avoid revelation, but failure might reveal "something" unknown. For creatures of higher level a successful save reveals wrong information.
For intelligent undead, it would reveal their type in life.
For aberrations, I would have them negatively impacted by contact with an alien intelligence.
For shapechangers, I would have it tell what they're disguised as.
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
I would suggest the following that isn't punishing the character but makes it harder to break the mysteries and plots:
- The player decides what knowledge check to make. I.e. nature for humans, or werewolves or religion for undead.
- Have him make the roll, whether he made the right choice or not.
- If the player picks wrong type of knowledge, whatever he rolls in the check counts as failure. I.e. "You don't learn anything". That by itself, if the roll is high enough would at least hint the character that the friendly barwoman isn't what she appears to be.
- If the player picks the right skill for the right creature then the DC isn't 25 but 30.
- If the creature in question is undead, darklord, aberration or mad, have the PC make a madness check.
I make this suggestion thinking the limit for this character is about 1/level times per day, right?
Suggestions for Protection measures for creatures against this power:
Make the power something that is somewhat known in RL, not so unique or special so that creatures may expect it from powerful clerics.
- Nondetection foils it. Or at least demands a save.
- Drinking a special herbal tea from a plant that grows around the town the werewolf opperates makes him immune to this power (and spells like detect shapechanger etc).
- If nothing else is available or at hand... the creature avoids physical contact with people unless he/she/it has to.
- The player decides what knowledge check to make. I.e. nature for humans, or werewolves or religion for undead.
- Have him make the roll, whether he made the right choice or not.
- If the player picks wrong type of knowledge, whatever he rolls in the check counts as failure. I.e. "You don't learn anything". That by itself, if the roll is high enough would at least hint the character that the friendly barwoman isn't what she appears to be.
- If the player picks the right skill for the right creature then the DC isn't 25 but 30.
- If the creature in question is undead, darklord, aberration or mad, have the PC make a madness check.
I make this suggestion thinking the limit for this character is about 1/level times per day, right?
Suggestions for Protection measures for creatures against this power:
Make the power something that is somewhat known in RL, not so unique or special so that creatures may expect it from powerful clerics.
- Nondetection foils it. Or at least demands a save.
- Drinking a special herbal tea from a plant that grows around the town the werewolf opperates makes him immune to this power (and spells like detect shapechanger etc).
- If nothing else is available or at hand... the creature avoids physical contact with people unless he/she/it has to.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
In any mechanical discussion it's really important to know what you're talking about, and I made a serious error not looking up the ability before posting last night.
Here's the actual ability here or here.
Text:
The knowledge check is related to the monster, so that varies.
Notice the phrase "as if you made the appropriate Knowledge skill check". Look up those rules here or here and you'll find:
For common creatures, the DC drops so they know three pieces of info, while for "rare" monsters (left to DM fiat) the DC raises so they'd only learn one piece of info.
So if it's a rare creature that has a CR of the cleric's level+5 (or more) the ability reveals nothing.
The 4e mentality has hit me hard, so I tend to favour players a little more than I used to. So I'd like to keep an ability like this as useful as possible. So I'd recommend not telling the player what knowledge check. They can also learn of all its abilities and weaknesses, including those gained from classes or currently memorized spells.
An important change might be to describe the abilities descriptively without using game terms.
Because it is Ravenloft I would rule that there are very few "common" monsters (if any) and many more "rare" monsters who are considered legend or have stories so full of misinformation or myth that it is difficult to tell fact from fiction.
I would allow intelligent monsters/creatures a saving throw, with success meaning they chose the abilities revealed. Failure means you ask the PC what kind of ability they would like to know. Again, touching an aberration or mindless undead would result in a madness check or saving throw to avoid being dazzled/dazed.
Because of the above setting limits, I would NOT limit it to a number of times per day. And, I would rule that any "rare" monster the PCs have fought and defeated before defaults to the regular DC (10+CR instead of 15+CR).
In combat I might be a little more lenient than I would during an investigation story. The ability does require "a successful touch attack" meaning the player is replacing their standard action (aka their attack) to learn about their foe. And is also in melee range. They're taking a big risk to learn something, and that should be rewarded.
Here's the actual ability here or here.
Text:
It doesn't reveal the creature's type, the name of the monster, etc. Just their powers and weaknesses.Lore Keeper (Sp): You can touch a creature to learn about its abilities and weaknesses. With a successful touch attack, you gain information as if you made the appropriate Knowledge skill check with a result equal to 15 + your cleric level + your Wisdom modifier.
The knowledge check is related to the monster, so that varies.
Notice the phrase "as if you made the appropriate Knowledge skill check". Look up those rules here or here and you'll find:
Success does NOT mean the player is going to just know everything about the monster, only one to three abilities. Really, the way the ability is set-up, a level 1 cleric is considered to have rolled a DC 20 check (15 +1 + 4). For a CR 1 critter the knowledge check is DC 11, so they beat the DC by 9 for two pieces of information. A 2nd Level cleric is considered to have rolled a 21 but a CR creature raises the DC to 12. This stays constant.Success: you recall 1 piece of useful information + 1 piece of useful information for each 5 points over the DC
Failure: you don't recall any information about the monster
For common creatures, the DC drops so they know three pieces of info, while for "rare" monsters (left to DM fiat) the DC raises so they'd only learn one piece of info.
So if it's a rare creature that has a CR of the cleric's level+5 (or more) the ability reveals nothing.
The 4e mentality has hit me hard, so I tend to favour players a little more than I used to. So I'd like to keep an ability like this as useful as possible. So I'd recommend not telling the player what knowledge check. They can also learn of all its abilities and weaknesses, including those gained from classes or currently memorized spells.
An important change might be to describe the abilities descriptively without using game terms.
Because it is Ravenloft I would rule that there are very few "common" monsters (if any) and many more "rare" monsters who are considered legend or have stories so full of misinformation or myth that it is difficult to tell fact from fiction.
I would allow intelligent monsters/creatures a saving throw, with success meaning they chose the abilities revealed. Failure means you ask the PC what kind of ability they would like to know. Again, touching an aberration or mindless undead would result in a madness check or saving throw to avoid being dazzled/dazed.
Because of the above setting limits, I would NOT limit it to a number of times per day. And, I would rule that any "rare" monster the PCs have fought and defeated before defaults to the regular DC (10+CR instead of 15+CR).
In combat I might be a little more lenient than I would during an investigation story. The ability does require "a successful touch attack" meaning the player is replacing their standard action (aka their attack) to learn about their foe. And is also in melee range. They're taking a big risk to learn something, and that should be rewarded.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Good work Jester and excellent advice. The PRD is an invaluable resource.
Jonathan, here's a bit more of what the PRD says about using knowledge skill checks to identify monsters and their powers (bolding mine):
Jonathan, here's a bit more of what the PRD says about using knowledge skill checks to identify monsters and their powers (bolding mine):
Note that the DCs vary by monster CR.In many cases, you can use this skill to identify monsters and their special powers or vulnerabilities. In general, the DC of such a check equals 10 + the monster’s CR. For common monsters, such as goblins, the DC of this check equals 5 + the monster’s CR. For particularly rare monsters, such as the tarrasque, the DC of this check equals 15 + the monster’s CR or more. A successful check allows you to remember a bit of useful information about that monster. For every 5 points by which your check result exceeds the DC, you recall another piece of useful information.
-
Jonathan Winters
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 435
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2004 8:23 pm
- Location: Montreal, Quebec
Thanks to everyone,
I'm gonna go digest this. It looks like the player and myself had misread the ability a little.
AND, I really don't want to restrict the PC too much with this ability, but a RL-twist was needed!
I'll get back to you all!
Patrick
I'm gonna go digest this. It looks like the player and myself had misread the ability a little.
AND, I really don't want to restrict the PC too much with this ability, but a RL-twist was needed!
I'll get back to you all!
Patrick
Mysteries of Darkon (AKA Miranda Cornelius' Journal)
On hiatus while visiting Ptolus, City by the Spire, new RL-inspired campaign: Madness Rising!
www.bullonir.wikidot.com
On hiatus while visiting Ptolus, City by the Spire, new RL-inspired campaign: Madness Rising!
www.bullonir.wikidot.com

