When the Darkest of Lords gives his opinion on something being gamerspeak, wise players take heed of the Darkest One's warning more and quibble less. The Darkest of Lords has no objection to an OOC reference to the precise quality of the items purchased, but "high quality" or "very well made" are better for an in-character comment than are words denoting a specific game benefit.sageaqua wrote:Onyx will join Benji for tea. "Well Benji now that you have been made the leader of this pack. What would you like for us to do in the near future? What are your goals? And why did we run?"
ooc: I threat the books as the local ranting system. ( levels are the local black belt system ) ( ranks - required for pristages class training is your competence in a field ) And I use the books terms as game speak: tenth level is most likely Lord class but how is that helpful to speak in those terms when you are substituting words to reflect this info. Calling something masterwork says the item was well made and suitable for enchantment. That's what Onyx is looking for both in his bells and his chainmail. The intent is clear and understood. Masterpiece is something else entirely. As someone that has in fact created a masterpiece in school and offered a huge some of money for it. I know they are always remarkable pieces. So those terms are not interchangeable - but we need to use a common language or we are not going to be able to give clear messages. The books provide the terms to do that.
The Darkening
-
whalejudge
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
- Location: Davis, CA
Emma is sitting in her room at the inn, back facing John at first. His apology causes her to frown and she turns to look at him. "I accept your apology, John. I understand how you're feeling... I am not accustomed to anything that we've been doing. I am no adventurer or fighter. I am a simple healer with little to no knowledge of the world around me." Emma releases a short sigh, "But I want to be something more. I can't continue living my life locked away... and so while I don't know everything that I am doing, I will continue to press on. I know i'm not anyone you should be taking advice from, but I suggest you do the same. No matter how far we may travel, Indis cannot be lost. The love you two feel for one another is something that distance cannot break and I have faith that you two will be united once again."
As John continued, Emma silenced herself and paid mind to both his words and the item that he held. Emma looked at it curiously, having never been given a gift before in that manner. John's words, so heartfelt and thought out caused Emma's face to brighten up significantly. After he handed her the gift, she pulled back the cloth to reveal the well crafted heavy mace. Even without having much experience with weapons, Emma could tell that it had been expensive. "You didn't have to spend your gold on me..." She said quietly, taken back that John would go through such an effort on her behalf. "Surely you'll allow me to repay you?" She looked up at him, smiling warmly.
As John continued, Emma silenced herself and paid mind to both his words and the item that he held. Emma looked at it curiously, having never been given a gift before in that manner. John's words, so heartfelt and thought out caused Emma's face to brighten up significantly. After he handed her the gift, she pulled back the cloth to reveal the well crafted heavy mace. Even without having much experience with weapons, Emma could tell that it had been expensive. "You didn't have to spend your gold on me..." She said quietly, taken back that John would go through such an effort on her behalf. "Surely you'll allow me to repay you?" She looked up at him, smiling warmly.
Last edited by Emma on Wed Feb 03, 2010 6:30 pm, edited 4 times in total.
After talking with Benji Onyx seeks out the local healers. He needs his noise reset and to have his injuries treated. Onyx heads up stairs to talk to Emma. He knocks. "Emma, I'm sorry. I did what I thought I needed to to protect Ingrid. I'm sorry things worked out so badly." He hopes Emma heard him but he heads down stairs to get some help.
-
John Merino
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 188
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
- Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
- Contact:
John smiled at his sister. It's really nothing... I just... as you said, you're not really a fighter. So... I'm sorry it's not anything nicer or more... I don't know, in line? with who you are, but there you have it. And it didn't really cost much at all! John lied, Just something I found while looking for other things more suited to my... practice. The Art, some call it, though I find denying the utilitarian value of magic is somewhat degrading to the magical forces... once again John blushed a little, thinking to himself, "She doesn't care about magic!"Emma wrote:As John continued, Emma silenced herself and paid mind to both his words and the item that he held. Emma looked at it curiously, having never been given a gift before in that manner. John's words, so heartfelt and thought out caused Emma's face to brighten up significantly. After he handed her the gift, she pulled back the cloth to reveal the well crafted heavy mace. Even without having much experience with weapons, Emma could tell that it had been expensive. "You didn't have to spend your gold on me..." She said quietly, taken back that John would go through such an effort on her behalf. "Surely you'll allow me to repay you?" She looked up at him, smiling warmly.
Last edited by John Merino on Thu Feb 04, 2010 3:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
whalejudge
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
- Location: Davis, CA
-
Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 55
- Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 12:55 pm
-
Benjiman/Vin/Bhorg
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 55
- Joined: Thu Nov 26, 2009 12:55 pm
OOC, more discussion on discussing,
In my non-darkest opinion (because I prefer to make light of things), I think that the specific case of masterwork isn't a problem.. mainly because it is both built with fine materials and by a master's hand, it is a master's work.whalejudge wrote: When the Darkest of Lords gives his opinion on something being gamerspeak, wise players take heed of the Darkest One's warning more and quibble less. The Darkest of Lords has no objection to an OOC reference to the precise quality of the items purchased, but "high quality" or "very well made" are better for an in-character comment than are words denoting a specific game benefit.
I've more annoyance with referring to things by 'plus'es, 'levels' or 'classes'. No world is that rigidly institutional and organized. Of course there are certain ways of weighting the merit of people and describing their skill.. for instance "John has been seen to prepare and cast spells of the complexity of glitter dust three times in a day!". Though this is difficult with fighting ability, "Benjiman savagely beat the leader of the Falkovians and then started through his guards." It is hard to tell how hard that is.. but then again, what is a fighter's 'level' but a reputation generated by deeds and stories. As for classes, we tend to describe people by the kind of person they are and what kind of thing they do. Ingrid is a clock-maker, John a scholar wizard, Emma a healing priest, Onyx a fire-headed fighter, and Benji is clearly just a madman.
I also include the general morality system and references to people as g/n/e & c/n/l, but I've already written papers on that issue (ethics class).
-
John Merino
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 188
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
- Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
- Contact:
OOC: Next time we meet I'll need a copy of the DMG, but under "Crafting magic items" it's quite clear that I do not need to meet the pre-requisites for crafting a magic item by myself... having an item or another spellcaster cast the spell for me is acceptable.whalejudge wrote:The Darkest of Lords Speaks:
Scroll creation does not work in that fashion. You can only scribe a scroll of a spell YOU know. See Scribe Scroll feat, page 99, PHB.
The relevant section is here, specifically, "Most of the time, they take the form of spells that must be known by the item’s creator (although access through another magic item or spellcaster is allowed)." Having access by another spellcaster is specifically allowed in the DMG.
Edit: Also don't forget that John's class is officially "None."
-
whalejudge
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
- Location: Davis, CA
Which is true for staves, rods, wondrous items, rings, arms, and armor. It is not true for potions, for scrolls, and for wands, all of which specifically replicate a spell and which item creation feats specifically require the creator of the item to know the spell in question. Check the specific sections of the DMG on creating scrolls, potions, and wands as well as the Scribe Scroll, Brew Potion, and Craft Wands feats in the PHB.John Merino wrote:OOC: Next time we meet I'll need a copy of the DMG, but under "Crafting magic items" it's quite clear that I do not need to meet the pre-requisites for crafting a magic item by myself... having an item or another spellcaster cast the spell for me is acceptable.whalejudge wrote:The Darkest of Lords Speaks:
Scroll creation does not work in that fashion. You can only scribe a scroll of a spell YOU know. See Scribe Scroll feat, page 99, PHB.
The relevant section is here, specifically, "Most of the time, they take the form of spells that must be known by the item’s creator (although access through another magic item or spellcaster is allowed)." Having access by another spellcaster is specifically allowed in the DMG.Edit: Also don't forget that John's class is officially "None."
-
whalejudge
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 222
- Joined: Tue May 12, 2009 12:32 am
- Location: Davis, CA
Emma set the heavy mace on her bedroll and gave her brother a hug in thanks. "It's wonderful, John. I really like it." While Emma wasn't quite sure she believed him about the cost, she decided to let it drop. She would just have to find something to repay him! Before Emma could continue her conversation with John, she heard someone calling out from outside the door. It didn't take her long before she recognised the voice as Onyx. "Excuse me for just a moment.." She said quietly. Emma makes her way to the door and opens it in time to see Onyx leaving. With a frown, she responds. "I'm not sure I accept your apology just yet, though I cannot leave you in the shape you're in. Come inside and i'll fix you up."
-
John Merino
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 188
- Joined: Fri Oct 30, 2009 3:03 am
- Location: A WIZARD DID IT!
- Contact:
"Are you sure? I don't want to intruded." Onyx goes into her room to let her treat his injuries reluctantly. His estimation of her commitment to healing improves, but he says nothing about it. "I see that you also bought a high quality weapon. Looks good to me. I put in an order for some custom chain mail, myself and these silver bells. They sound really nice together. They remind me of birds singing."
ooc: Emma looking at his injures would realize he was nearly dead, he was cut up that badly. Onyx say's nothing about it though. His broken noise is however making it hard for him to breath.
ooc: Emma looking at his injures would realize he was nearly dead, he was cut up that badly. Onyx say's nothing about it though. His broken noise is however making it hard for him to breath.
At the door, Emma responds to her brother. "It was perfect just as it was. You shouldn't be so hard on yourself." Returning her attention to Onyx, she looks him over and then motions for him to come inside. "You're not intruding, Onyx. I invited you in." She waits for him to followed her direction and then directs him to a chair to sit. Although they fled together with the party, Emma hadn't paid the tall, red headed man much attention. This was the first time she was able to get a good look at his injuries and she suddenly felt guilty for leaving him uncured for so long. Placing a hand on his shoulder and holding her holy symbol with the other, waving it over his wounds, Emma prays quietly to heal him. When she is finished, she pulls back her hand and sets her pendent down. "The mace was a gift from John."
OOC: If Rian allows healing to be done over the boards, Emma is going to cast cure moderate. I rolled and got: 7 + 1 + 3 + 1 for a total of = 12 healing. How is Onyx looking after this healing?
OOC: If Rian allows healing to be done over the boards, Emma is going to cast cure moderate. I rolled and got: 7 + 1 + 3 + 1 for a total of = 12 healing. How is Onyx looking after this healing?
