DocBeard wrote:Eerie? Seriously? Its me going "No" and "No" in a louder 'voice'.
It's text. It lacks intonation, and therefore is subject to misinterpretation, especially when there is so little to interpret.
Anyway, sure. I think its a bad idea. "Jerk learns new perspective by walking a mile in someone else's shoes." is a classic trope, but in my experience the only story that ever did something decent with 'lol you're a chick!' is Ranma 1/2, which always made sure to establish that Ranma was the same person, man or woman.
I'd agree, except I don't think they are trying to teach him a lesson. At least talking with my players, none of them expects Drakov to learn anything. They are trying to destroy him, starting with disassociating him from his power base.
What does your game benefit from the forced transformation of a villain into a grandmother? If it changes the way he thinks, then we get into "Women are innately more empathetic and less evil than men.", and if it doesn't, then Drakov remains Drakov, if a bit embarrassed.
My game uses reputation points for political attacks. Humiliation is damaging to Drakov just as much as knocking off hit points. More so, because Drakov's political might exceeds his physical prowess.
Consider: while Drakov is laying low and trying to get his life back, others see this as their chance to move in and take over. Vlad II might make a move backed by the vampyr, or the gang of dopps backed by Sodo, or Marcos Vedarrek backed by the Frat and Radiant Tower. The conspirators might move too slowly and only tip their hand as Drakov regains the throne, or they might get on the ball and actually sabotage Drakov's efforts. In the first case, Drakov cleans house when he comes back into power, and removes what was formerly an asset. In the second, the nation may split, forcing people to pick sides.
Either would be a win for my players.
Neither is precisely a masterstroke for a secret society struggling to overthrow a tyrant.
It doesn't need to be a masterstroke; it's not going to happen in a vacuum. Killing Drakov isn't a masterstroke either, as long as the successors are as bad or worse. At this point, the obvious successor would be VDII, who has all of his father's vices without his father's military discipline. As one of my players pointed out, this option removes the corpse that would cue a normal succession; it leaves the throne unoccupied and in question, which gives them a better shot at real change.
If anything, the whole plot sounds like something out of "The Wotch" which is, if you are not familiar with it, a comic strip where a young witch solves all her problems by turning men into women and mentally conditioning them to enjoy it, or just not question the whole thing. She even forgets about a few people she's changed, later discovering that their families and friends miss them and are looking for them. From this she learns the important lesson, "Cover your tracks better. But don't worry! Everyone's much happier this way!"
I can see why you might think that, if you thought that they were trying to change Drakov into a better person. They aren't. They are trying to change him into a corpse, but the current political situation suggests they ought to make a detour on the way to deads-ville. This seemed to them a viable detour.
Its...trying for funny, I guess, but ultimately it just sort of manages to insult both genders for a story point that's not very effective.
Again, it
wasn't trying for funny. Ironic, maybe, but the
actual goal was political unrest.
A better way, off the top of my head, to have Drakov have a change of heart would be to have his daughter be the child to finally overthrow him, even if only for a brief time.
That's likely to happen, but I doubt it will change his heart, except in the most literal sense.
The successful coup and ambitious leadership style would remind Drakov of his own glory days; I think the idea of a "mad tyrant" in his twilight years trying to establish some kind of non-hateful relationship with the only child of his who isn't psychotic is a more interesting twist than, "Hey! I'm a chick! Suddenly all of my beliefs are on their ear!".
I don't think either would change Drakov in the slightest. Sadly, I think that's what Kara is holding out for when it comes to the prospect of assassination, but that dream is finally dying.
I mean, if it works for you, more power to you man. Just doesn't do anything for me.
I can see why, with the whole "teaching him a lesson" thing. What do you think of the prospect as a political maneuver, as stated above?