Legion of Dread: Ass Kicking in Ravenloft
-
Lost Heretic
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Feb 15, 2007 9:22 pm
- Location: La Nouvelle Angleterre
Legion of Dread: Ass Kicking in Ravenloft
So, I'm really pumped for the Castle Ravenloft board game. Really, really excited - it's not out, I don't know the rules, and I'm trying to plan a campaign.
So, here's my question - how can a dungeon hack'n'slash work in the Ravenloft setting? What if I want my characters to begin by tearing through Strahd's castle, defeating some of his lieutenants, and then moving on to another domain. How can you maintain a horror setting with such powerful characters?
I've got a few ideas - playing up survival horror with the characters facing hordes of enemies (this is supported by the board game, apparently) and including a number of fights they "cannot win." Well, fights that they are unlikely to win.
What kind of tips do you guys have?
So, here's my question - how can a dungeon hack'n'slash work in the Ravenloft setting? What if I want my characters to begin by tearing through Strahd's castle, defeating some of his lieutenants, and then moving on to another domain. How can you maintain a horror setting with such powerful characters?
I've got a few ideas - playing up survival horror with the characters facing hordes of enemies (this is supported by the board game, apparently) and including a number of fights they "cannot win." Well, fights that they are unlikely to win.
What kind of tips do you guys have?
Darker Days Radio - The World of Darkness Podcast
Well, here are a few tricks I use.
First off, no matter how powerful you are, you can still be scared. If you get into the power=invincibility mindset, you've already lost. You're the DM, there is always a bigger trump card for you to play; get outwitted by a rules lawyer on one encounter? Write down what went wrong and watch for that trick again-you've got all night, after all.
Everything has a history. This doesn't just include the player characters. Who are the goblins guarding Strahd's murder hole? Do those zombies he's using have family? Are they a family, cursed to play out their last meal before Strahd twisted them to unliving service? I liked the look on my PC's face when he realized he was fighting a little girl that wanted to tear his face off and play dress up with it, and I dug my PCs getting legitimately righteous when they realized just what the goblins were doing to honor Bane.
Think in four dimensions. Everything has a reason for being the way it is, and those reasons are tools you can tap to further immerse the players in your game. Even the crunchiest dice slinger might get a little rp-minded if you take the time to offer him or her incentive, both through personal attention, the occasional reward, and just having a rich world for your PCs to explore.
But back to the power rift. Even the best fighter is going to blink when his kid sister's life is at stake, the coldest wizard is going to feel it when he has to fight the animated remains of people he couldn't keep from becoming monster chow. Make sure your players know that if they fail, they won't be the only ones suffering; don't be sadistic with this, naturally, (While I'm at it, unwinnable fights always feel like a cheap trick to me. They have their place but shouldn't be common.) but if the PCs make a clearly selfish decision, well, they made the choice for you. Dungeons just aren't generic caves where bad things wait, they should be the most dangerous places in the world, where heroes and madmen challenge Things that can make the gods themselves tremble.
With fear, its all about the sale; the meekest monster can be horrific if played the right way. You've just got to give them a soul.
First off, no matter how powerful you are, you can still be scared. If you get into the power=invincibility mindset, you've already lost. You're the DM, there is always a bigger trump card for you to play; get outwitted by a rules lawyer on one encounter? Write down what went wrong and watch for that trick again-you've got all night, after all.
Everything has a history. This doesn't just include the player characters. Who are the goblins guarding Strahd's murder hole? Do those zombies he's using have family? Are they a family, cursed to play out their last meal before Strahd twisted them to unliving service? I liked the look on my PC's face when he realized he was fighting a little girl that wanted to tear his face off and play dress up with it, and I dug my PCs getting legitimately righteous when they realized just what the goblins were doing to honor Bane.
Think in four dimensions. Everything has a reason for being the way it is, and those reasons are tools you can tap to further immerse the players in your game. Even the crunchiest dice slinger might get a little rp-minded if you take the time to offer him or her incentive, both through personal attention, the occasional reward, and just having a rich world for your PCs to explore.
But back to the power rift. Even the best fighter is going to blink when his kid sister's life is at stake, the coldest wizard is going to feel it when he has to fight the animated remains of people he couldn't keep from becoming monster chow. Make sure your players know that if they fail, they won't be the only ones suffering; don't be sadistic with this, naturally, (While I'm at it, unwinnable fights always feel like a cheap trick to me. They have their place but shouldn't be common.) but if the PCs make a clearly selfish decision, well, they made the choice for you. Dungeons just aren't generic caves where bad things wait, they should be the most dangerous places in the world, where heroes and madmen challenge Things that can make the gods themselves tremble.
With fear, its all about the sale; the meekest monster can be horrific if played the right way. You've just got to give them a soul.
"Is there anything keeping us from checking that place out tonight?" Besides sanity, naturally.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
You can also play up the menace of Strahd himself -- even if the PCs never actually fight or even see him -- simply by making it clear that he's smart. He's running the show, watching them all along, and he's hitting them over and over, with minions or traps that specifically target their weaknesses or test and expend their strengths. He's bleeding off their resources, setting them up for something monumentally nasty, and doing so via such an unpredictable variety of encounters that they can't begin to guess what the grand finale might be. He's not the Level Boss waiting at the end of the dungeon, he's the evil genuis playing Xanatos Speed Chess against the patsies who've walked right into his lair, and are always exactly where he wants them.
A politely-worded note, left in plain sight on the windowsill while they're in the middle of a battle they didn't even know Strahd was watching from outside, can work wonders. Especially if he critiques their fighting tactics or advises the cleric that she'd better project her faith with a little more confidence in future: the next time she has to repel the undead, it won't be so easy.
A politely-worded note, left in plain sight on the windowsill while they're in the middle of a battle they didn't even know Strahd was watching from outside, can work wonders. Especially if he critiques their fighting tactics or advises the cleric that she'd better project her faith with a little more confidence in future: the next time she has to repel the undead, it won't be so easy.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Have I told you lately that I love you, DocBeard?DocBeard wrote:I liked the look on my PC's face when he realized he was fighting a little girl that wanted to tear his face off and play dress up with it,
I agree completely that hack'n'slash dungeon crawls can have a place in RL. Heck, it goes all the way back to the beginning with I6/House of Strahd/Expedition to Castle RL. If the atmosphere is there, and (as Doc said) the story is there behind the crawl, it works.
I've done the "expedition to the abandoned Guardian monastery, now inhabited by a vassalich, racing the crazed clockwork man for the MacGuffin artifact" and the "exploration of the mad genius' ever-shifting sentient warehouse" in my campaign.
I've done the hoard of zombies in the rain thing too, but even though the players never found the reason, I made sure I had a reason in mind. (they were camping in a Terg ruin reportedly used as a Gundarakite rebel hideout, and when they triggered his wards on the place, Strahd sent the zombies to wipe out the "rebels")
Of course a typical haunted house is nothing but a flavorful dungeon.
Other classic Ravenloft "dungeons" are ruined castles, monster-infested sewers, expansive catacombs, ornate crypts, anicent jungle ziggurats and desert pyramids, caves in the moors and swamps, etc.
(BTW, latest word on the boardgame is that there won't be any campaign rules, at least at first. (maybe released later online after playtesting) each play will be independent. )
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
I can always use more praise and adulation, Gonzo.
For my part, I really dig that living warehouse idea. The adventure should climax in the heroes having to fight the evil living building as it decides they needed to die.
For my part, I really dig that living warehouse idea. The adventure should climax in the heroes having to fight the evil living building as it decides they needed to die.
"Is there anything keeping us from checking that place out tonight?" Besides sanity, naturally.
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Amen!! This is why so many people think "epic" doesn't mesh with Ravenloft. I don't care how powerful a character is, there will always be a bigger, meaner, stronger foe out there. And I don't care how powerful you are, like DocBeard said anyone can be scared. There are things that even epic characters (or at least their players) just can't handle: child monsters, major depravity in action, things that hit below the belt in the emotional sense. It's a dirty trick and I recommend not using it unless absolutely necessary since it's both easy to seriously offend and can ruin the game (and friendships) if taken too far, but it can humble players who've gotten too obnoxious. Just because the characters can shrug off even the most horrific sights doesn't mean the players can. Figuring out what makes the players squirm--and how far is too far--is something a Ravenloft DM should know anyway if only to make their campaigns horrific to their unique players. Not everyone is scared by the same things.DocBeard wrote:If you get into the power=invincibility mindset, you've already lost.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Nice, though I went the other way with it. The warehouse asked my resident tinkerer PC to "complete it" (thereby sucking all of Ravenloft into the plane of Mechanus). He almost agreed...DocBeard wrote:For my part, I really dig that living warehouse idea. The adventure should climax in the heroes having to fight the evil living building as it decides they needed to die.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
-
Lost Heretic
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 132
- Joined: Thu Feb 15, 2007 9:22 pm
- Location: La Nouvelle Angleterre
Keep up the awesome advice guys!
Right now I'm playing around with making story into a modified version of I6, followed by I10. However, I'm struggling to make this something more than just a tour of the Core, as the characters battle Strahd in Barovia and then chase after him in Mordent.
I guess a good way to solve this might be to include some powerful motives and interesting allies. I'm kind of interested in working Lord Soth into this story...
Anyway, here's another idea - how can morality be worked into this? I've found that the alignment system doesn't connect for many players - is there an alternate system that you would recommend? Perhaps the New World of Darkness Virtue/Vice? How could this be worked into a board game turned into an extended campaign?
Right now I'm playing around with making story into a modified version of I6, followed by I10. However, I'm struggling to make this something more than just a tour of the Core, as the characters battle Strahd in Barovia and then chase after him in Mordent.
I guess a good way to solve this might be to include some powerful motives and interesting allies. I'm kind of interested in working Lord Soth into this story...
Anyway, here's another idea - how can morality be worked into this? I've found that the alignment system doesn't connect for many players - is there an alternate system that you would recommend? Perhaps the New World of Darkness Virtue/Vice? How could this be worked into a board game turned into an extended campaign?
Darker Days Radio - The World of Darkness Podcast
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Unless you're using something like the action point system sometimes used in 3e (Eberron uses it, but Unearthed Arcana has all the rules for action points), Virtue and Vice don't translate well mechanically to D&D. As a role-playing element it could be used to add flavor to individual characters, but again I'm not sure how to translate it into D&D morality. Once more I refer you to UA, this time for alternatives to standard alignment rules.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
Honestly? I think alignment works well enough for what players would LIKE to think of themselves as; that said, if you really want philosophical basics, you'll have to sweat it out for a few adventures and see how they react to certain situations.
"Is there anything keeping us from checking that place out tonight?" Besides sanity, naturally.
- Lovecraftforever
- Criminal Mastermind

- Posts: 110
- Joined: Thu Apr 08, 2010 7:31 pm
- Location: Pittsburgh
