A snippet from my GURPS campaign. The PCs are dealing with complex social issues that cannot be easily solved with the sword. As a GM my usual modus operandi is to give them two or three clear choices, but to let them come up with their own if they want to.
Background:
A matriarchy is in turmoil. The heir apparent princess has upped and left, and taken a significant number of men with her in revolt. The queen is distraught at losing her child. As the months pass, a series of policy failures occurs. Key routine business is not being done by the queen. Grain harvests are mismanaged, water and irrigation is not well maintained. Also, a particularly nasty form of mutilation is occurring, sanctioned by the queen, and inflicted on all females passing through a certain age to prevent "future mistakes". The PCs witness one such session, presided by a modern doctor, and all are seriously disturbed by it. They accuse the doctor of betraying his Hippocratic oath. He responds that he makes the procedure clean, safe, and relatively painless - without him, the matriarchy would do it with a jagged rock and flame cauterization.
The root cause:
The heir apparent princess is actually an intersex individual (probably caused by consanguinous ancestry: the queen has some male concubines who are her close blood relatives). When the princess was a young child, she appeared to be female, although she was genetically male. After puberty, the hormonal changes were enough to give her masculine traits like facial hair and broad shoulders. A personal examination resulted in her being declared a male. She left the city in protest at losing her birthright and essentially becoming a second-class citizen like the rest of the men.
Her mother and other concerned noblewomen began the ritual mutilations of girls to make sure they didn't "turn into men" overnight.
The problem:
The PCs catch up with the Heir, who is now fully embracing the intersex nature of their birth, and who has three trusted lieutenants. The PCs can choose which ones to side with and which ones to oppose.
1. Madasamba is a wise, older man who left the city protesting gender inequality. He wanted to leave his weapons and gear as a bequest to his son, but lacking legal status, he was blocked by the boy's mother, who refused to let her son enter a dangerous trade. Madasamba lost custody of his son and joined the Heir to try to force the matriarchy to recognize men legally. He is skilled in warcraft but has a strong sense of social justice. Madasamba does not want to overthrow the queen, but would do so if pressed, so long as the succeeding regime treats its citizens equally.
2. Chebwundu is a scheming, devious man who left the city because he thought he could get power, fame, and status as a rebel. He is skilled in hypocrisy and political maneuverings, and incidentally possesses various poisons, diseases, and immunities from his time as a tanner. He could be talked into overthrowing the queen if he was then able to join the ruling caste, although he believes she is too powerful to overthrow yet (he would happily wait for the city's situation to decay if that would improve his chances). He has no particular interest in gender equality as long as he can be the ruler. Chebwundu is quick to see any underhanded way of manipulating people and situations to a given end. The only person he is unlikely to turn on is the Heir - possibly because the Heir is politically valuable, and possibly because the Heir has taken him as a lover.
3. Sasema is a young woman who left the city because of its stultifying boredom. The daughter of a noblewoman, Sasema refused to be a good girl and sit and study songs and poems. Instead, she longs for adventure and wishes to see the world. Idealistic and naive, she believes that change is inherently better than stasis and tradition. She has no personal hatred for the queen, but she does believe the matriarchy is untenable and it will eventually have to change. She is unconcerned with gender equality, being of the favored gender, but she finds herself taking well to combat - traditionally a low-ranked male role. To preserve her new hobby, she would just as happily continue roughing it as rebels indefinitely, or turn back and overthrow the matriarchy. She also would never betray the Heir, who has taken her as a lover as well.
Back in town, the Heir had a younger sister: the Next. The Next is too young to rule, but understands that her prospects have improved now that the elder sister is disenfranchised. For the moment, she loves her mother the queen, and she has good memories of the Heir as a pleasant sister. However, the longer the power vacuum continues, the more likely the noblewomen will be to "weaponize" the Next and turn her against her ailing mother and her rebel sister. The Next is also nervous about the apparent gender change of her sibling - if the Heir is now male, does that mean the Heir and the Next are expected to marry?
Over about four months of play, my PCs have solved several of the issues involved and they're still working on others.
The very first issue that got them involved in the first place (unnecessary surgeries performed on young women) unfortunately still has not been solved. Some cultural things you can't change overnight.
Your ideas for moral ambiguity!
Re: Your ideas for moral ambiguity!
Maybe this doesn't really fit here, but... read for yourselves.
I once mastered the "Best of Both Worlds" adventure from CotN:The Created by our revered Mr. Mangrum. I did change it a bit to fit into my campaign and to my PCs; and I wanted the PCs to leave the domain after that adventure, so I disregarded the "recurrence" section. Furthermore, I wanted my PCs to solve that adventure and get rid of Gestalt once and for all.
Well, they solved the riddles around Gestalt. They even saved Dr Couture from it, and various others. But anytime they came near to destroy the creature, they just blundered and nearly got themselves killed. They even fell down stairs or from roofs; it was unbelievable what crap they rolled. (And that from a group that annoyed me terribly by riding silently through a forest, although armored with chain and plate!)
I made up one last chance: the golem presented itself to them, saying that the paladin of the group should kill it before it commits even more crimes. I thought this would be only a moral dilemma; it wasn't.
Imagine Gestalt, a human flesh golem, with exposed breast, waiting for the coup de grâce, by an experienced paladin. The paladin raises her sword, stabs...
and misses. (That wasn't even an attack roll, just an (modified to be easy) AG check.)
Ok. The paladin raises her sword again. And... misses again. And again.
On this point, I very nearly had Gestalt walk away, muttering to itself "well, I'll find me a cutpurse to kill me, they can't be worse than this...", but on fifth try, the paladin finally succeeded.
I once mastered the "Best of Both Worlds" adventure from CotN:The Created by our revered Mr. Mangrum. I did change it a bit to fit into my campaign and to my PCs; and I wanted the PCs to leave the domain after that adventure, so I disregarded the "recurrence" section. Furthermore, I wanted my PCs to solve that adventure and get rid of Gestalt once and for all.
Well, they solved the riddles around Gestalt. They even saved Dr Couture from it, and various others. But anytime they came near to destroy the creature, they just blundered and nearly got themselves killed. They even fell down stairs or from roofs; it was unbelievable what crap they rolled. (And that from a group that annoyed me terribly by riding silently through a forest, although armored with chain and plate!)
I made up one last chance: the golem presented itself to them, saying that the paladin of the group should kill it before it commits even more crimes. I thought this would be only a moral dilemma; it wasn't.
Imagine Gestalt, a human flesh golem, with exposed breast, waiting for the coup de grâce, by an experienced paladin. The paladin raises her sword, stabs...
and misses. (That wasn't even an attack roll, just an (modified to be easy) AG check.)
Ok. The paladin raises her sword again. And... misses again. And again.
On this point, I very nearly had Gestalt walk away, muttering to itself "well, I'll find me a cutpurse to kill me, they can't be worse than this...", but on fifth try, the paladin finally succeeded.
Morn came and went – and came, and brought no day
– George Gordon, Darkness
– George Gordon, Darkness
Re: Your ideas for moral ambiguity!
Moral Ambiguity on a smaller scale - A little snippet of trouble from a nWoD game.
The Setup:
A little changeling - essentially a former human turned part fey - happened to run into a pair of mafia mooks helping their boss out with an insidious plan. One of the mooks happened to be having pangs of guilt over a woman he'd killed over the course of it. The fey, preferring to avoid violent conflict when she could, decided to try and scare him off so the party wouldn't have to fight him. Unfortunately or fortunately, she went too far when calling him out on his crimes. The mook, who already had some mental health issues (which the fey didn't know about), was confronted with something clearly supernatural, and had a complete breakdown. He decided the fey was an angel sent to him to change his ways.
The first mook made good on this perceived expectation and has completely turned his life around, doing his best to make up for his former crimes. He still thinks the fey is an angel, and quite literally worships the ground she walks on. The changeling has never outright said she was an angel, but hasn't exactly corrected him either. In fact, she's developed a heavy interest in religious literature, and started manifesting typically "angelic" powers, which are implicitly leading him on.
-Is it right to base a man's life on a lie by omission, especially when it involves posing as such a holy being? Or should he be told the truth, even if it shatters his faith and steers him back into the darkness? Do his former crimes make it more 'right' to utterly deceive him?
The second mook wound up under the changeling's wing through a series of wacky misadventures. Unlike the first mook, this man has his head more tightly screwed on his shoulders. Also unlike the first mook, he is not sorry one bit for anything he's done - and if he was, he'd never admit it to anyone. But he knows a good deal when he sees it, and has agreed completely to the fey's terms, which has involved him giving up crime. He now devotes most his working hours to charity and community service. He's even gone so far as to enter a supernatural contract to that effect, though it also rewards him rather nicely for keeping to the terms.
-The man is unrepentant, but he's a strong ally and is doing good for the community. The first mook seems more sympathetic than the second, but can he be discriminated against when they're both guilty of the same crimes? Does the fact he's being paid undo the good he's doing?
The real conundrum: Both these men are career criminals, guilty of multiple murders and other very ugly crimes, like human trafficking. Both of these men have now turned their lives around and are doing good, even trying to defend people from dangerous monsters. But neither of them have ever paid for their crimes. If they are allowed to stay free, does it send the message that punishment is arbitrary, and you can get away with anything so long as people sympathize? If they are not, does it send the message that repentance doesn't matter, that there's no point in turning back from evil, because you cannot be forgiven?
-The changeling has done her best to hide their identities, but what if they were found? If one of their former victims came seeking vengeance, would it be right to defend either of them? If the police came seeking them, would it be justifiable not to turn them in? Can mercy take the place of justice? Can either of these men be trusted? Does the outcome of the situation determine whether the changeling was wrong or right to spare them?
The Setup:
A little changeling - essentially a former human turned part fey - happened to run into a pair of mafia mooks helping their boss out with an insidious plan. One of the mooks happened to be having pangs of guilt over a woman he'd killed over the course of it. The fey, preferring to avoid violent conflict when she could, decided to try and scare him off so the party wouldn't have to fight him. Unfortunately or fortunately, she went too far when calling him out on his crimes. The mook, who already had some mental health issues (which the fey didn't know about), was confronted with something clearly supernatural, and had a complete breakdown. He decided the fey was an angel sent to him to change his ways.
The first mook made good on this perceived expectation and has completely turned his life around, doing his best to make up for his former crimes. He still thinks the fey is an angel, and quite literally worships the ground she walks on. The changeling has never outright said she was an angel, but hasn't exactly corrected him either. In fact, she's developed a heavy interest in religious literature, and started manifesting typically "angelic" powers, which are implicitly leading him on.
-Is it right to base a man's life on a lie by omission, especially when it involves posing as such a holy being? Or should he be told the truth, even if it shatters his faith and steers him back into the darkness? Do his former crimes make it more 'right' to utterly deceive him?
The second mook wound up under the changeling's wing through a series of wacky misadventures. Unlike the first mook, this man has his head more tightly screwed on his shoulders. Also unlike the first mook, he is not sorry one bit for anything he's done - and if he was, he'd never admit it to anyone. But he knows a good deal when he sees it, and has agreed completely to the fey's terms, which has involved him giving up crime. He now devotes most his working hours to charity and community service. He's even gone so far as to enter a supernatural contract to that effect, though it also rewards him rather nicely for keeping to the terms.
-The man is unrepentant, but he's a strong ally and is doing good for the community. The first mook seems more sympathetic than the second, but can he be discriminated against when they're both guilty of the same crimes? Does the fact he's being paid undo the good he's doing?
The real conundrum: Both these men are career criminals, guilty of multiple murders and other very ugly crimes, like human trafficking. Both of these men have now turned their lives around and are doing good, even trying to defend people from dangerous monsters. But neither of them have ever paid for their crimes. If they are allowed to stay free, does it send the message that punishment is arbitrary, and you can get away with anything so long as people sympathize? If they are not, does it send the message that repentance doesn't matter, that there's no point in turning back from evil, because you cannot be forgiven?
-The changeling has done her best to hide their identities, but what if they were found? If one of their former victims came seeking vengeance, would it be right to defend either of them? If the police came seeking them, would it be justifiable not to turn them in? Can mercy take the place of justice? Can either of these men be trusted? Does the outcome of the situation determine whether the changeling was wrong or right to spare them?
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."


