Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by HuManBing »

The events in the Middle East - specifically in Egypt and Tunisia, where the old regimes have departed - got me thinking about how something might play out in Ravenloft.

Looking at the huge groundswell of public energy and hope in Egypt and Tunisia, I can only imagine a similar echo in Czechoslovakia, Hungary, East Germany, and other Soviet satellite states at the end of the Cold War. The population started off filled with purpose and hope and determination, and they overthrew their previous masters.

Years later, some of them have truly changed into free societies, while others have regressed to strongmen and autocrats of old. The passion and revolutionary fire of the people was evident in all cases at the start... but only time could tell whether their great gamble would bring them the freedom they desired - or just another dictatorship in disguise.

In this thread, discuss whether you think Ravenloft campaigns could feature large-scale social movements.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

The obvious places to play with this, off the top of my head are Falkovnia, Nidala, and Gundarak. I suppose the threat of revolt exists in any of the despot domains, but less so in the "benevolent" despotisms like Barovia and Darkon. In my campaign, the Falkovnian and Nidalan rebellions have both been featured, though neither has "won" yet. But both are possible, and what fills the power vacuum is the question in both places. Gondegal has proven his failure to rule back in Arabel, but maybe things would be different with the older and wiser Gondegal. Red Wolf has no rulership experience, though it would tough to be worse than Elena and Drakov, no?

But there's no guarantee the rebel leader will become the eventual ruler in any rebellion. Maybe another ruler would rise from within the ranks of the deposed regime. A priestess of Belenus, Guardian of Morals, or Falkfuhrer or Talon who does the requisite mea culpas and distances him/herself from the old ruler by joining the rebellion might rise to power instead.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by HuManBing »

Revolt in Darkon: post-Grim Harvest

In Ravenloft, there is already an excellent canon example of an overthrow. In Darkon, after the Grim Harvest, Azalin vanished utterly and the Kargat and barons suddenly found themselves leaderless. Without the surpassing power of their leader, the enforcers found themselves unable to contain the masses and in some cases they became the hunted, lynched at the hands of the same citizens they once oppressed.

However, this potentially rich campaign backdrop is not mentioned in much official canon.

Only one campaign adventure (Necropolis, in the Grim Harvest set), and one sourcebook (Domains of Dread, 2nd ed) actually focus on the interregnum period and they already extrapolate a significant time after Azalin's departure, with demilords stalking the land. Later editions have restored Azalin to the throne. Although I consider his restoration to be an excellent step stylistically, I feel that a canny DM could make a great campaign out of the first few hours, days, weeks, and months after Darkon threw off its dark master.

Storming the symbols of the old regime - days immediately afterwards
VIEW CONTENT:
According to canon, one major problem is that Il Aluk becomes a dead city, and it slays any living creature that enters via the Shroud. Stylistically, this has been likened to something similar to an atomic blast or similarly apocalyptic: it makes for great drama, but only at a distance. It's quite hard to host a campaign there. Thus, we're deprived the familiar scenes of demonstrators outside the seat of power: the general citizenry wouldn't go near Il Aluk.

Castle Avernus is another possible symbolic stronghold, although the traps and guardians there are so deadly that citizens would likely be slaughtered en masse if they attempted to storm it. Additionally, Azalin himself appeared to be a fairly aloof ruler, and the average layman probably wouldn't have much personal reason to raid his castle - more likely, they'd be aching for a fight with the Kargat and corrupt barons who have mistreated them more frequently in the past. (Much like the average Moscovite citizens left Gorbachev and the Soviet politicians alone, but raided the KGB headquarters.)

According to canon, Azalin's most powerful ally, Ebb the Shadow Dragon, made her way out of Avernus and went to lair in Mount Nyid to the south. Her departure from Avernus is interesting - the Gazetteer implies that she left out of grief at losing her powerful friend, but it could be possible that she was driven away by force. Certainly, although she has little to fear from a mob of commoners, she might think twice about staying if some of Azalin's more powerful lieutenants decided to secure his castle for themselves...

The Gazetteers do make mention of Darkonian commoners raiding Kargat stations in some cities. Karg is the center of operations for the secret police, and it's easy to imagine a furious mob gathering to erase this symbol of oppression. In Egypt, the secret police succeeded in shredding most of their documents and relocating their staff before the protesters gained access to their headquarters. In East Germany, they did not, and miles and miles of shelves of secret documents and files were suddenly made available to the public, often with chilling evidence of friends turned informants, and miserable fates of missing family members.
A disorderly succession - weeks afterwards
VIEW CONTENT:
A handful of demilords inherited some of the domain's power, but few of them seem to seek political influence. Galf Kloggin headed a ragtag bandit group in the Forest of Shadows, Yako Vormoff sought access to his phylactery in Avernus, Glennis McFadden wanders the Boglands, Damon Skragg captained a ship near Martira Bay, Beryl Silvertress headed the Kargat in Corvia.

With Il Aluk inaccessible, the barons also would lack a clear unifying point to demonstrate their supremacy. Of the remaining cities, Martira Bay is the most populous and cosmopolitan. Any de facto national leadership would likely congregate there. Martira Bay is also the home of Tavelia, a Kargat officer who founds a false religion (almost in a neat echo of Azalin's own experiments with the Eternal Order).

The remaining barons might declare some limited degree of independence, although those geographically closest to Falkovnia and possibly Nova Vaasa might not. The threat of foreign invasion or influence could dissuade them from turning their backs on the monarchy, decapitated though it might be.
Pulling down the pillars - winners and losers among the societal structures
VIEW CONTENT:
The Kargat's power base takes a precipitous tumble, any way you look at it. Without the authority of Azalin behind their actions, people may dare to hope for vengeance. Some Kargat may even perpetuate the myth that Azalin is still alive. Others may try to embrace the facts with their own skew: a few human-seeming Kargat might even try to win some political currency by "outing" Azalin as a lich. (Some of the declassified Egyptian secret police files are similarly suspected to be decoys or misdirections - one even suggests rather fancifully that Mubarak's son sponsored terrorist acts after unsuccessfully approaching Israel with an arms deal.) One potentially interesting viewpoint could be that of the "virtuous policeman" - the PCs find a Kargat officer who is still fully human and who wishes for order and stability without the tyranny. Or it could be equally fun to join the rioting crowds... a creative DM could come up with all sorts of terrible secrets to air out when they storm the Kargat headquarters.

The Eternal Order loses out in the long run too, according to the 3rd edition canon. Supposedly this is because the priesthood takes the hardline stance of the Requiem as punishment for failures of the followers, and the followers respond by abandoning the Order. However, church policy can be slow in forming... a DM who wants to keep the Order influential for a while even after the collapse could easily say the leaders don't formulate their suicidal announcement until months or years afterwards. Some Order outposts may still be quite popular - after all, the false religion did have some tenets of comfort amidst the doom and gloom. Some folk are bound to find its consistent message reassuring while everything changes around them. Others could collapse spectacularly, especially as the previous privileges they took for granted come crashing down around them. One gimmick that I worked into Eternal Order routines was a staged "extermination" of undead attacks - staged, because Azalin (or another hidden necromancer) was actually collaborating with the Order, and the undead under their command would "flee" from the performing Order priests, thus ensuring public gratitude. If this falsehood ever becomes public knowledge, proof will be key and the Order strongholds nearest would feel the fire first.

The Barons might initially see some gains early on, as their taxes and levies are no longer subject to Azalin's tributation. However, the absence of a strong ruler now means that Barons act singly instead of federally. Barons could waste vast sums now squabbling internally among themselves, while navigating a tortuous path among the Kargat and Eternal Order. Most noteworthy among the barons is Reldkasen of Martira Bay, who seems to conduct herself more as an Italian city-state powerbroker than a medieval baroness (and who remains baroness in 3rd ed., with Azalin's approval). Reldkasen ultimately presides over the largest remaining city in Darkon, but which is also home to such powerful monsters as Kazandra, Styrix, and Tavelia.

The Overseer Cult under Tavelia truly comes into its power when Azalin is absent. Indeed, Tavelia's story forms one of the main plotlines in the unreleased Death Undaunted (adventure about restoring Azalin to power). Tavelia likely would have some insights as to how Azalin engineered the Eternal Order as an artificial religion, and she'd be canny enough to apply them in forming her own religion - making sure to avoid the failings of the Order's teachings. By the time of Death Undaunted, her religion is likely quite influential in the wealthy city of Martira Bay at least. Maybe she teaches a creed whereby church officers give spiritual counselling to wealthy members in exchange for large donations, in order to cleanse their souls of the taint of the Requiem.


Revolution is underway in Darkon - so much hope and optimism... And to think that in ten short years, things will have fallen to the state where Azalin's return will be a welcome sign.
User avatar
The Giamarga
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2313
Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
Location: wandering

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by The Giamarga »

How about a french revolution pastiche set in Dementlieu and/or Richemulot ? Guillotines anyone?
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by HuManBing »

The Giamarga wrote:How about a french revolution pastiche set in Dementlieu and/or Richemulot ? Guillotines anyone?
That could definitely work! Part of the beauty of that setup is that Dementlieu at least is a pretty factional society on the surface, so you could definitely have several different political cliques forming and then scrambling for power.

Richemulot I'm not so sure (I honestly am not too familiar with the domain) - the canon seems to suggest that the Reniers have everything pretty much locked down. But if something came along with an immunity to disease and contagion, then they'd have to hop about looking for an alternative way of keeping power.



The events unfolding in Libya strike me as being a good illustration of what might happen in some place like Falkovnia. The rebels might make early dramatic gains, leading to a firm sense of destiny and inevitable victory... but it's only because the central rulership is slowly marshalling its forces and making sure they're led by reliable cronies. When the old regime strikes back, it does so with full force. Suddenly the rebels aren't having it so easily, and they'll have to dig in and make the most of their asymmetric advantages of mobility, terrain familiarity, and (hopefully) popular support to overcome the extreme difference in firepower.

Although it's hard to imagine the kobolds gaining much popular support, they could join forces with Ebb or Gloom, which would give them an instant tank/air force! And Gondegal could be the humane face of the revolution, with the swordplay and battle savvy to match even the best of Drakov's men. Meanwhile, Drakov still has the loyalty of the top ruling families, as he is directly responsible for their status, wealth, and military power.
User avatar
Zettaijin
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 670
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
Gender: Male
Location: Himeji, Japan

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by Zettaijin »

There are those who'd say that neo-liberalism and the various forms of corporate domination over various aspects of human existence in numerous post-industrial countries is merely a more insidious, and much more efficient form of dictatorship. Possibly one where humans actively desire and seek out subjugation.

Save for some manner of working anarchist commune (which can only work if somehow all members agree on every aspect of their collective life, otherwise you'll get bickering anarchist think tanks disagreeing vocally on what to do when members disagree), we are all living under different degrees of dictatorship. And really, the myth of the all powerful ruler is just that, a myth. Every all powerful ruler needs help. If the supreme leader has no support from his generals, from the economic leaders, from the populace even, said ruler will fall - eventually.

Scenarios involving political change can certainly be very inspiring. It's all very comic-booky, and contemporary media outlets of neo-liberal, post-industrial powers have been pumping out tons of easily digestible narratives about good liberators triumphing over despots, dictators, and freedom haters. It's a prime fantasy scenario with very clear-cut good guys and bad guys. Some are content in just propping up a benevolent dictator, others more ambitious try to impose contemporary political ideals on past eras.

I mean really, is a "good king" really possible? Or are we just aiming for "not as bad as the one before" monarch-wise?

I believe it could be interesting to have players involved in a particularly important and successful revolution only to find that, in the end, they're just changing who's on top and who's at the bottom.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by HuManBing »

Zettaijin wrote:I believe it could be interesting to have players involved in a particularly important and successful revolution only to find that, in the end, they're just changing who's on top and who's at the bottom.
Yes! This, in my opinion, is one of the most tragic and compelling narratives of the Communist revolution. (And Napoleon's French Revolution before that.) You may strive and sweat and spill your own blood in pursuit of social justice and equality... but in the end, you risk watching everything you've worked for turn into something monstrous and oppressive.
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by cure »

Go to the Mistipedia and read my stuff on Hazlik, the Church of the Lawgiver and especially its head. The head of the Church of the Lawgiver is aiming at the invasion and decapitation of Hazlan, justified by the very schism that he is attempting to percipate between the Hazlani Chruch its master back in Kantora.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Zettaijin
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 670
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 2:30 am
Gender: Male
Location: Himeji, Japan

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by Zettaijin »

HuManBing wrote:
Zettaijin wrote:I believe it could be interesting to have players involved in a particularly important and successful revolution only to find that, in the end, they're just changing who's on top and who's at the bottom.
Yes! This, in my opinion, is one of the most tragic and compelling narratives of the Communist revolution. (And Napoleon's French Revolution before that.) You may strive and sweat and spill your own blood in pursuit of social justice and equality... but in the end, you risk watching everything you've worked for turn into something monstrous and oppressive.
I'd say that's the tragedy of all revolutions. But what I'm interested in is what would players aim for if they were to, say, overthrow Drakov. Notions of anarchism, socialism, or even libertarian ideals are a bit unusual in a world of dark powers and swirling mists. When some can call forth thunder and lightning with the mere uttering of a prayer or cleave a man in half with a mighty swing of their broadsword while others can do little more than a splendid job of milking a cow, social equity is difficult to imagine.

In this case, I think stuff like Watchmen, The Boys, and other superhero myth deconstructing comics might be an apt source of inspiration, rather than history books.

And even if we assume that no one will ever ask themselves "What can we do when people wield fire from the heavens and magical sentient weapons?" we still have the question of "Who can rule Falkovnia? How will they rule it? How can we be sure we won't be in this mess again in 5 years?"

There is no U.N., and despots are actively encouraged by "entities" whose power far eclipse those of mortals.

Will players accept a brutal, but not AS brutal ruler? What happens if Falkovnia gets split into various autonomous kingdoms? Wouldn't that make certain neighbours a little more ambitious? Heck, some of these kingdoms could band together to kill off the rest and split the land.

Could players actually side with Drakov simply because he's a stabilizing force?

Remember, the northern core's economy revolves heavily around Falkovnian grain being cheap and plentiful. Northern political powers are wary of Drakov, yet is it really better to plunge the domain into chaos?

Much like North America funding brutal dictators in South America or turning a blind eye to middle eastern madness, it could be an interesting twist to add "non-evil" political powers who support an "evil" one for the sake of their own people's survival.
User avatar
The Lesser Evil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1552
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by The Lesser Evil »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:The obvious places to play with this, off the top of my head are Falkovnia, Nidala, and Gundarak. I suppose the threat of revolt exists in any of the despot domains, but less so in the "benevolent" despotisms like Barovia and Darkon. In my campaign, the Falkovnian and Nidalan rebellions have both been featured, though neither has "won" yet. But both are possible, and what fills the power vacuum is the question in both places. Gondegal has proven his failure to rule back in Arabel, but maybe things would be different with the older and wiser Gondegal. Red Wolf has no rulership experience, though it would tough to be worse than Elena and Drakov, no?

But there's no guarantee the rebel leader will become the eventual ruler in any rebellion. Maybe another ruler would rise from within the ranks of the deposed regime. A priestess of Belenus, Guardian of Morals, or Falkfuhrer or Talon who does the requisite mea culpas and distances him/herself from the old ruler by joining the rebellion might rise to power instead.
Actually, since a good portion of Gundarak got swallowed up by Barovia in the Grand Conjunction, isn't there already an ethnic insurrection of sorts going on there? Seems I recall the shadow of a deity Erlin (as well as the Gundarkite conception of the Mornlinglord as a freedom loving deity) fanning the flames of revolution. The Effigy dread golem from one of the Book of S's (can't recall which) is a nice twist on hate become animate.

I'd take a similar note from the medieval legend of the golem and surmise that oppressed groups and minorities could affect some unexpected resistance in the form of dread constructs. Scarecrows/straw golems seem particularly fitting here.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Ravenloft campaigns featuring revolt and regime change

Post by HuManBing »

A powerful link on this topic. The Great Dictator, Charlie Chaplin.

Post Reply