Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

It is a strange day when the youngest member of a gaming group is the grognard that wants to stick with 2nd Edition. But hey, at least I have a potential gaming group, and they like 4e. So I am now going about and converting Ravenloft to the system. I've looked through some other conversions, and none of them really did what I wanted them to, so I decided to just take 2nd edition and try to convert it mechanically as simply as possible. My conversions aren't quite done yet, but I wanted to share what I've got done so far. In segments, of course. To prolong the life of this thread arbitrarily. And to ease the amount of reading in one go.

One thing that made Ravenloft converting to 4e difficult in my eyes was the ability to be anything from anywhere. I wanted a way to put everything that is playable INTO the setting, yet in a logical way with mechanics to back it up. I love love Backgrounds, I think it is a clever little bonus, and it ties in with how Domains gave PCs regional benefits and restrictions. So I decided to replicate it, as well as to do some postulating. So I've done up the Region Backgrounds and Restrictions for the vast majority of Domains in my campaign (I've added my Farelle from Quoth the Raven as well as Whal from the BoS series), as well as an overall write-up and some explanations as I go. Take a look:

Ravenloft Region Backgrounds:
STANDARD SETTING
Races: Human, Deva, Changeling, Elf*, Kalashtar**, Half-Elf, Dwarf, Gnome, Halfling, Half-Orc (Caliban), Region specific
Other: Drow***
*Elves: Eladrin and Elves are both "elves", just from different regions. Think of them as a more classical “wood elf” and “high elf” comparison.
**Kalashtar: These are the Abber Nomads, and are playable
***Drow: It is up to a DM if Drow should be playable. It is in my humble opinion that Drow are not the same as the denizens of the Shadow Rift any longer, and thematically do not mesh with the world of Ravenloft any longer.

Power Sources: By Region, Shadow****
**** The Shadow power source is the stuff of mists and darkness, and is applicable in all cases to all races in all realms, as it’s requirements are to surrender a small part of your soul to the Dark Powers themselves. It is the only power source that is available in all domains.

BY REGION
LAMORDIA
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Warforged
Benefit: Arcana is class skill, +2 Arcana

DEMENTLIEU
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane, Psionic
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: Diplomacy is class skill, +2 Diplomacy

DARKON
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane, Psionic, Primal
Region Specific Race: Revenant, Goliath, Elves
Benefit: +2 to fear checks from Undead

FALKOVNIA
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: +1 to fear, horror, and madness checks and saving throws when bloodied

TEPEST
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: No elves or Gnomes
Benefit: +3 to all knowledge checks on Monsters

MORDENT
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Primal, Arcane, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Shifters
Benefit: +2 to fear checks from Insubstantial creatures

VALACHAN
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane, Primal
Region Specific Race: Shifters
Benefit: Nature is a class skill, +2 Nature

FARELLE
Sources allowed: Martial, Psionic, Primal
Region Specific Race: Goliath, Genasi, Gnoll, Shadar-kai, Warforged
Benefit: One bonus language, Streetwise is a class skill, +2 Streetwise

RICHEMULOT
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine
Region Specific Race: Shifters
Benefit: Diplomacy is class skill, +2 Diplomacy

SITHICUS
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: Only Eladrin and Halfling
Benefit: Bonus skill Arcana. +2 Arcana

INVIDIA
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Shifters
Benefit: Choose a creature type. +1 Damage to all enemies of that type

BORCA
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: Resist Poison 1. Resist Poison 2 @ 11th. Resist Poison 3 @ 21st.

BAROVIA (Barovian)
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: Revenant
Benefit: +3 to creature knowledge checks

BAROVIA (Gundarkite)
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: Only Shadar-Kai
Benefit: Diplomacy is a class skill, +2 Diplomacy

KARTAKASS
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Primal, Divine
Region Specific Race: Shifters, Gnolls
Benefit: Ghost Sound as an encounter power

HAZLAN (Mulan)
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Genasi, Goliath, Warforged
Benefit: One bonus skill

HAZLAN (Rashemi)
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine
Region Specific Race: Genasi, Goliath, Warforged
Benefit: One bonus skill: Athletics or Endurance, +2 to Athletics and Endurance

NOVA VASSA
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: Nature is class skill, +2 Nature

VECHOR
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane (Sorcerer only), Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Genasi, Wilden
Benefit: Arcane is a class skill, +2 Arcane

BLUTSPUR
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Githzerai only
Benefit: Stealth is a class skill, +2 Stealth

G’HENNA
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Shadar-Kai, Gnoll
Benefit: Region is a bonus skill. +2 Religion.

KALIDNAY
Sources allowed: Martial, Psionic, Primal
Region Specific Race: Goliath, Thri-kreen, Mul
Benefit: Four death saves instead of three.

NOSOS
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane, Psionic
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: Endurance is a class skill. +3 Endurance.

SOURAGNE
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Wilden
Benefit: Streetwise is a class skill, +2 Streetwise

VOROSTOKOV
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal
Region Specific Race: Goliath, Shifter
Benefit: Resist Cold 2. Resist Cold 3 @ 11th. Resist Cold 5 @ 21st.

HAR’AKIR
Sources allowed: Martial
Region Specific Race: N/A
Benefit: Resist Fire 2. Resist Fire 3 @ 11th. Resist Fire 5 @ 21st.

PHARAZIA (City Dwellers)
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine
Region Specific Race: Genasi
Benefit: One bonus skill from the knowledge category

PHARAZIA (Nomads)
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Genasi
Benefit: +1 Speed

SEBUA
Sources allowed: Only Barbarians
Region Specific Race: Only Halflings
Benefit: +1 to Athletics, Acrobatics and +2 to Endurance

CAVITIUS
Sources allowed: Martial
Region Specific Race: Revenant
Benefit: Resist Negative 1. Resist Negative 2 @ 11th. Resist Negative 3 @ 21st.

TOVAG
Sources allowed: Martial, Arcane, Divine, Primal
Region Specific Race: Revenant
Benefit: Stealth is a class skill, +2 Stealth

PARIDON
Sources allowed: Martial
Region Specific Race: No Changelings*
Benefit: Bonus skill Streetwise or Diplomacy, +1 to Streetwise, Stealth and Diplomacy
* I know, I know, it seems like they fit in the BEST here. Well, I look at Hour of the Knife, and see how all the Doppelgangers are in Sodo's pocket or plotting with him, and it makes me think that they are all unplayable in this land. That's my thought process, anyway.

NIGHTMARE LANDS
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race: Only Kalashtar
Benefit: +1 to saving throws against slowed, immobilized, and restrained, +1 Endurance

WHAL
Sources allowed: Martial, Primal
Region Specific Race: Goliath
Benefit: Swim speed of Speed -2.

WILDLANDS
Sources allowed: Martial, Divine, Arcane, Primal, Psionic
Region Specific Race*: Dragonborn**, Kenku, Bullywug, Gnoll, Minotaur, Thri-kreen
Benefit: Nature as a bonus skill. One bonus language.
* The mists have played perhaps the cruelest trick of them all on the creatures of the Wildlands … live as intelligent animals in their own land, or travel the world as a man-thing. They will never be animals, and never be man, but stuck in between, as Broken Ones.
** Dragonborn: Much like Drow, Dragonborn do not mesh well with Ravenloft as a setting. Yet they exist mechanically, so they should be represented SOMEWHERE. Just be wary what elemental breath powers you allow your Dragonborn to take. A suggestion I would give is to reskin the Dragonborn as Ape-Men, and change their “breath weapon” into a “mind assault” that does psychic typed damage. Barring that, poison at least makes sense in the context of “real animals turning into Broken One style animal men."

I have revamped and made my Fear Check system as well as Horror Checks, and I will shamelessly steal Jester's Madness checks, as I like the sanity points idea a lot and he did a lot of good work there. So yeah, Fear and Horror are coming.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Deewun wrote:I love love Backgrounds, I think it is a clever little bonus, and it ties in with how Domains gave PCs regional benefits and restrictions. So I decided to replicate it, as well as to do some postulating. So I've done up the Region Backgrounds and Restrictions for the vast majority of Domains in my campaign (I've added my Farelle from Quoth the Raven as well as Whal from the BoS series), as well as an overall write-up and some explanations as I go.

I like backgrounds. The big change from a unique little bonus to a discreet skill bonus does make my backgrounds a little overpowered and heavy.
I do prefer themes. If I had more 4e energy I might attempt a few of those, but my creative focus is very Pathfinder focused these days.
Deewun wrote:I have revamped and made my Fear Check system as well as Horror Checks, and I will shamelessly steal Jester's Madness checks, as I like the sanity points idea a lot and he did a lot of good work there. So yeah, Fear and Horror are coming.
Glad you liked my Madness system. I'm curious to see where you take the Fear and Horror systems. I worked hard on mine and should be able to offer feedback.
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

Thanks Jester, it is appreciated! If you didn't do the first conversion, I would have given up entirely. But being able to see one persons approach allowed me to have the mindset to get 4e to work with Ravenloft how I wanted it to.

I just finished Fear, Horror, and Powers checks. I want to go through Jester's Madness and check to make sure there are no fiddly bits that I need to convert to work better with my three new sets of rules. But I'll put up my Fear rules probably tomorrow. Early spoiler: Absolutely NOTHING like Jester's mechanically.
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

That's actually a very impressive list of backgrounds. :)

I do have one thing, though (see Barovia, Lamordia, Nova Vaasa, etc.): usually, when a skill is given for a background, the Character Builder allows a character to choose if either the skill is to be trained or to have a +2 bonus for it. My recommendation is to have two skills for skill-based background benefits, so the appropriate bonus or training could be chosen.
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

Hmmm ... you are probably right. I'll go through and add another skill to some of those that are skill based. I was using the Scales of War Backgrounds as my template, so I really should pump these just a tad.

Time for some FEAR CHECKS SUCKA! (Now with a once over fix from myself and the great Jester, who prompted me to do this in the first place. Boom boom pow!)


FEAR CHECKS:
A fear check is an attack against a player’s will defense. Make a check in combat when:

– A non-minion monster uses a power with the keyword “fear” for the first time in an encounter
– A monster bloodies a player in one hit
– All party members that attack a single monster and miss in a single round
– A monster is at least 2 size categories larger than the largest party member
– If the player triggers an unseen trap
– If the player is the last PC in positive hit points
– If a player rolls a natural one on an attack roll

Do not make checks out of combat, allow your players to roleplay the situation. For better or for worse. Overconfidence breeds fear checks in combat, remember that.

When a fear check is triggered, you roll the following attack:
1d20 + level of the encounter or the monster/trap (whichever is higher) +2 to hit the player’s Will Defense
If the Fear check misses, then there are no effects. If the DM rolled a natural 1, then the player gains an immediate action point them may use until the end of their next turn. If the DM rolled a natural 20, then just like an attack, the Fear check hits automatically. If the Fear check hits, roll on the following chart to determine what effect afflicts the player:

1 - Fumble: The character drops all items in their hands.
2 - Gape: Immobilized until end of the player’s next turn.
3 - Dazed: Dazed, save ends.
4 - Flight: The character is pushed their movement speed and drops prone, save ends.
5 - Stagger: Stunned, save ends.
6 - Faint: The character drops prone and is helpless, save ends.
7 - Horror: Roll on the Horror chart, ignoring "no effect" and "roll on the fear chart".
8 - Madness: Lose 1d6 Sanity points. If that drops sanity to zero, the character develops a Madness

In a day or two, Horror Checks.
Last edited by Deewun on Fri Sep 02, 2011 11:17 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Deewun wrote: PARIDON
Sources allowed: Martial
Region Specific Race: No Changelings*
Benefit: Bonus skill Streetwise or Diplomacy, +1 to Streetwise, Stealth and Diplomacy
* I know, I know, it seems like they fit in the BEST here. Well, I look at Hour of the Knife, and see how all the Doppelgangers are in Sodo's pocket or plotting with him, and it makes me think that they are all unplayable in this land. That's my thought process, anyway.
Take a look at the Van Richten Society: Dopplegangers Report in our Library. It's not canon, but it's very well done, IMHO (and it predates my time in the FoS, so I'm not tooting my own horn. I had nothing to do with it. :) ) It casts changelings as the dread doppelganger version of calibans. They are not accepted among the dopps, usually killed at birth, and in the rare cases they survive, tend to live in hiding with other (human derived) calibans. Personally, I like it, but YMMV.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

4E changelings can actually work well within Ravenloft beyond Paridon. It's all a matter of tweaking their origins: they could very well be the changelings that VRG Shadow Fey present them to be. Once a changeling eventually finds out it's not human after all, for example--well, there's a nice origin right there.

Of course, I base the idea on both this:

Image

And this:

Image
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

Oh, I completely agree. That's why I put them as a baseline can be from anywhere style race with Humans, Gnomes, Dwarves, etc. I like that style of Changeling, the Crib Swappers and Changeling the Lost, and have always used that as the background idea for where the race came from. The Paridon choice was to help make that realm feel unique mechanically through these backgrounds, and the explanation that all changelings in Paridon are too focused on Sodo and the political battles, much like in the established Hour of the Knife and the good ole Shadow of the Knife adventures, where PCs are replaced and no one knows, is a good explanation for why Changelings aren't playable from that realm.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Jester of the FoS »

I’m going to be mean here, because 4e is rigidly balanced and has a lot of moving parts. You need to really know the system to write for the system.

Firstly, I think your math is a little off.
At “d20 + ½ level of monster or encounter” it will miss a lot. Now, this might be your intent, as it means low-level characters will be much, much more likely to be hit, which reflects the idea that high level and high power characters are harder to scare. But powerful monsters and terrifying new threats should always be scary.

Here’s the breakdown:
d20 + ½ is pretty much equivalent to a character’s base defence (10 + ½ level). So the DM would need a “10” to hit. However, every character in the game has a stat boost to every defence. 4e is really dump-stat heavy, with 2-3 stats just not being needed. You need your primary stat (chosen by class), secondary stat (chosen by build) and everything else goes into a stats in the third defence. The only exception are the few builds with two stats in the same defence, but those are rare by design. Every PC should have a 12 or 14 in a Will defence stat.
This means that instead of a 10+ you need a 12+ to hit (13+ if the stat is secondary and 14-15+ if the stat is primary).

This only scales up. The base number (10 + 1/2 ) keeps pace with the inherent advancement, but other increases (the stat boosts every 4 levels, the +1 boost every tier) mean the number increases. Hitting a mid-Paragon tier hero (three stat boosts) with a Will secondary stat requires a 15 or 16.

Now, all this takes is base stats and not neck slot items, which increase a character’s Will defence by 1 every 5 or so levels. The math of the edition says every character has a +2 neck slot item by level 10 and +6 above level 25. So the mid-Paragon character in the above example now requires an 18 to hit (or possibly even a 19 or 20).
Even if you’re ignoring magic items, this will come-up because of inherent bonuses (in the Character Builder now, as well as the DMG2 and Dark Sun book).

Compare this to how often monsters hit, which is level + 2 (IIRC). This might be a better baseline.

Okay, nitty gritty now:
A fear check is an attack against a player’s will defense. Make a check in combat when:
– A monster targets a character with a power that has the keyword “fear” for the first time in an encounter
Just targeting? Not attacking with it? What about doubles of monsters with fear effects? I can imagine waves of frightening minions wrecking havoc.
– If the character is caught unaware by a trap
Could also read: the players trigger a trap. Are traps really frightening?
– If a player rolls a natural one
Any natural “1” or only on a d20?
1d20 + 1/2 level of the encounter or the monster/trap (whichever is higher) rounded down against the character's Will Defense.
You don’t need to specify that it’s rounded down. One of the first rules specified in the PHB is that you always round down.
This formula will affect a character who has the lowest possible score in their Will Defense 50% of the time, with most players having a much higher defense against Fear. But no one is immune, and there will always be a 5% chance of failing a Fear Check.
Lowest would be an 8 and 10, so a Will of 10. Assuming an even level encounter that would be a 55% chance of success. I did warn I was being nit-picky.
If the player passes the Fear check (i.e. the attack doesn’t surpass his Will Defense) then there are no effects.
This is awkward. The player isn’t “passing” because they’re passive. The attack is failing. And a Fear check (really a Fear attack) doesn’t need to surpass, it needs to match or surpass. But you don’t need to say that, if we’re running the game we know if something succeeds or fails.
If the player passes critically (the DM rolls a natural 1) then that character gain a free action point they may use until the end of their next turn.
This is a little awkward. There’s no other benefits in the game awarded to a player when an attacker rolls a “1”. And calling it a critical seems odd. If the player was rolling a “fear save” maybe, but it feels weird to have the DM roll then tell the player that they crit and gain an extra action point. Which is a pretty huge bonus.
And what happens when the DM rolls a “20”?
If the player fails, though, then a nasty effect will take place. Roll 1d10 and refer to the following chart to determine what effect afflicts the character:
I hate having to consult charts to resolve mechanics. It feels very 1e. It stops the game while the DM hunts for his chart.
1. No effect
This is odd. After all that nothing happens…
2. Fumble: The character drops all items in their hands and slides 1 square away from the triggering effect.
“Triggering effect” seems weird, since most of the time it’s going to be a creature. This is nastier than it sounds because the next turn the character has to move 1 square back (move action) and pick-up their stuff (2 minor actions). That’s their turn, ending-up back where they were at the beginning of their previous turn. And an evil DM might easily move a monster overtop their weapons, disarming the player.
I might just have them drop items they’re holding, that way they can pick-up and still consider attacking.
3. Gape: The character is Immobilized and Dazed until end of the player’s next turn.
Immobilized and dazed? If they’re not in melee or a ranged character they might as well be stunned.
I’d pick one (daze or immobilize) and dump the other.
5. Fight: The character must use an at-will attack power each turn, save ends.
What happens if they don’t?
6. Flight: The character must move their movement speed away from the triggering effect, fall prone and is immobilized, save ends.
Technically, they’re immobilized right away. So they can’t move their speed. Does the save end the prone or the immobilized or both?
A better effect might be pushed a few squares and unable to move closer. Fits better than immobilized.
7. Stagger: The character is Stunned, save ends.
Having played for a while, I really hate stuns. If I had the time and energy I’d remove it from most of my monsters and content. And “save ends” hurts, since you can roll poorly and be out an entire combat. So much worse than #3 which is just a round.
8. Faint: The character drops prone and is helpless, save ends.
Welcome to coup de grace-ville, population: you. I hope you enjoy your stay, it will be short.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Jester of the FoS »

(In case you were curious, in the thread with my 4e rules I did a little designer commentary explaining some of my reasoning and thoughts:
http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... lit=Jester)
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

Jester of the FoS wrote:I’m going to be mean here, because 4e is rigidly balanced and has a lot of moving parts. You need to really know the system to write for the system.
No, no, I need the editting and wording help. I've been away from 4e for a while, so relearning the wording is necessary. I appreciate all the help.
Firstly, I think your math is a little off.
At “d20 + ½ level of monster or encounter” it will miss a lot. Now, this might be your intent, as it means low-level characters will be much, much more likely to be hit, which reflects the idea that high level and high power characters are harder to scare. But powerful monsters and terrifying new threats should always be scary.

Here’s the breakdown:
d20 + ½ is pretty much equivalent to a character’s base defence (10 + ½ level). So the DM would need a “10” to hit. However, every character in the game has a stat boost to every defence. 4e is really dump-stat heavy, with 2-3 stats just not being needed. You need your primary stat (chosen by class), secondary stat (chosen by build) and everything else goes into a stats in the third defence. The only exception are the few builds with two stats in the same defence, but those are rare by design. Every PC should have a 12 or 14 in a Will defence stat.
This means that instead of a 10+ you need a 12+ to hit (13+ if the stat is secondary and 14-15+ if the stat is primary).
Crap, you're right. Neck slots were totally forgotten. I'll rework the math.
Compare this to how often monsters hit, which is level + 2 (IIRC). This might be a better baseline.
Bazinga, thank ya.
Just targeting? Not attacking with it? What about doubles of monsters with fear effects? I can imagine waves of frightening minions wrecking havoc.
All good points, and needing some rewording. Stuck in Magic the Gathering mode. "Attacking with" or "using" is much better wording, and I'll add non-minion, as you are right, and minions being fearful seems counter intuitive to minion design.
Could also read: the players trigger a trap. Are traps really frightening?
This is a hold over from 2nd, which I actually really like, and why I included it. Traps are now parts of encounters, so I figure they should be included. And when thinking like a movie or novel, a trap out of nowhere can be incredibly terrifying even for a seasoned hero. And again, wording problems fixed!
Any natural “1” or only on a d20?
Needed clarification. Natural one on an attack roll
I did warn I was being nit-picky.
Nit-picky is very necessary, and I greatly appreciate it.
This is awkward. The player isn’t “passing” because they’re passive. The attack is failing. And a Fear check (really a Fear attack) doesn’t need to surpass, it needs to match or surpass. But you don’t need to say that, if we’re running the game we know if something succeeds or fails.
Wording fixed. I was writing this from the perspective of "no one knows what I'm talking about" but that was all entirely unnecessary, and has been removed.
This is a little awkward. There’s no other benefits in the game awarded to a player when an attacker rolls a “1”. And calling it a critical seems odd. If the player was rolling a “fear save” maybe, but it feels weird to have the DM roll then tell the player that they crit and gain an extra action point. Which is a pretty huge bonus.
And what happens when the DM rolls a “20”?
You make a good point. Without saving throws as we knew them, it is not really the same wording. I'll work on a way to better express what I'm meaning to say there.
I hate having to consult charts to resolve mechanics. It feels very 1e. It stops the game while the DM hunts for his chart.
I love charts, ha. So this is more than likely a "mileage may very" thing, as for me, a list of 10 is index card size and easily accessible for me as a DM, especially since I'll know what the encounter is as I built it to begin with, making the "hunting" a non-factor.
This is odd. After all that nothing happens…
Another hold over that I liked. Even in the worst case when a character succumbs to fear, they can still nut up and swallow it down for no effect. And all that is really just two die rolls, just like an attack roll and damage.
“Triggering effect” seems weird, since most of the time it’s going to be a creature. This is nastier than it sounds because the next turn the character has to move 1 square back (move action) and pick-up their stuff (2 minor actions). That’s their turn, ending-up back where they were at the beginning of their previous turn. And an evil DM might easily move a monster overtop their weapons, disarming the player.
I might just have them drop items they’re holding, that way they can pick-up and still consider attacking.
Perfectly worded, and you are very right, it was much too powerful for so low on the chart. One of those cases I kept adding to it because I thought it was too weak, but in doing so I greatly increased the power.
Immobilized and dazed? If they’re not in melee or a ranged character they might as well be stunned.
Agreed now that you point it out. Same problem as above, and changed to immobilized alone.
What happens if they don’t?
That is a very good point. Going to have to find for a similar thing happening on a monster power (I'm sure it exists somewhere) and use their wording.

Edit: Crap, there is really no good way to make this work in 4e. Which means I should just remove it in totality. I'll also remove the "no effect" as you are right, it is pretty pointless and merely gums up the works.
Technically, they’re immobilized right away. So they can’t move their speed. Does the save end the prone or the immobilized or both?
A better effect might be pushed a few squares and unable to move closer. Fits better than immobilized.
Good points all around. The prone was the save ends part, and I'll reword to reflect that, and the push instead of "move" is a much better wording.
Having played for a while, I really hate stuns. If I had the time and energy I’d remove it from most of my monsters and content. And “save ends” hurts, since you can roll poorly and be out an entire combat. So much worse than #3 which is just a round.
While it is very true that stunned save ends is powerful because you can roll poorly, it can also (and this happened a lot in my experience) be worthless as the player immediately saves it anyway. And it is supposed to be worse than 3, just like 7 damage is worse than 3 damage. That was my hope anyway, to tier the effects.
Welcome to coup de grace-ville, population: you. I hope you enjoy your stay, it will be short.
It is painful, yes, but I find 4e to be very much ... well, uber god-beasts comes to mind. It is a punch to the kidneys, and rightfully so I feel.

I really appreciate the once-over, Jester! It has greatly helped on a lot of fronts, and I look forward to getting more nit-picky feedback on Horror checks and Powers Checks, when I get the Powers Checks worked out (I'm close, just got some fiddly bits).
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

I keep on forgetting if "save ends" happens at the beginning of a turn or at the end of it; I usually attempt it at the beginning, so there's at least a chance for some sort of simulated immunity.

Meanwhile, for madness checks I use the cards in the "Gloomwrought" accessory. But I also make sure to create new ones as well. :)
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Deewun wrote:
What happens if they don’t?
That is a very good point. Going to have to find for a similar thing happening on a monster power (I'm sure it exists somewhere) and use their wording.

Edit: Crap, there is really no good way to make this work in 4e. Which means I should just remove it in totality. I'll also remove the "no effect" as you are right, it is pretty pointless and merely gums up the works.
"Fight" could work if you slip in a penalty or clarify. "You fight heedlessly and without finess. You can only make At-Will attacks and grant combat advantage (save ends)." This keeps the player from dropping Encounter and Daily powers (small ouch) but lets them fight. But also has a penalty, which has an effect for classes that would have been fighting and just using At-wills anyway.
Deewun wrote:1 - Fumble: The character drops all items in their hands.
I think "drops all held items" flows a little better.
Deewun wrote:3 - Dazed: Dazed, save ends.
This should be "Dazed (save ends)". Minor stylistic nitpicking.
Deewun wrote:4 - Flight: The character is pushed their movement speed and drops prone, save ends.
This should specify the number of squares, otherwise a slowed character won't move far. Subtle rule interaction. And again prone (save ends).
Deewun wrote:5 - Stagger: Stunned, save ends.
see above
Deewun wrote:6 - Faint: The character drops prone and is helpless, save ends.
The "unconcious" conditon could also work. I think you might be able to refer to it as "asleep" which has additional rules which would work (can be woken by allies or when take damage). I'll have to double check that.
User avatar
Deewun
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 282
Joined: Sat Sep 09, 2006 1:06 pm
Location: GA
Contact:

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Deewun »

Save Ends is end of turn I'm pretty sure, Dion.

And yeah, I'll fix all those fiddly wordings. Good call.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Deewun's 4e Ravenloft Conversion

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Dion of the Fraternity wrote:I keep on forgetting if "save ends" happens at the beginning of a turn or at the end of it; I usually attempt it at the beginning, so there's at least a chance for some sort of simulated immunity.

Meanwhile, for madness checks I use the cards in the "Gloomwrought" accessory. But I also make sure to create new ones as well. :)
In 4e you always save at the end of your turn. Some races and classes have special abilities that let them save earlier.
Post Reply