Power checks for an excecutioner?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
Post Reply
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by cure »

To what extent would an executioner who is concerned with doing his job well, keeping the axe edge sharp and all that, be power check worthy?

Would it make a difference if he was employed in Mordent (where guilt and innocence matter to the authorities), Lamordia (where due process matters to the authorities), or Dementlieu (where Dominic arranges judgements of guilt and innocence as best advance his agenda).

Part of the question is where killing becomes murder. For the Dark Powers, this surely isn't simply a legalistic matter.
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Nathan of the FoS
Fiendish Enforcer
Fiendish Enforcer
Posts: 5247
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
Location: San Francisco CA

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by Nathan of the FoS »

I know you're familiar with my Unified Theory of Powers Checks, having extensively proof-tested it ;), so it will come as no surprise that I would be in favor of giving a long-time professional executioner no more than one or two failed Powers checks if all he does is stick to his job. (Maaaaybe three if it's somewhere where torture is part of the job description). I don't think the Dark Powers get too hot and bothered by people performing according to official job descriptions and cultural norms, but it certainly makes sense that Jack Ketch and his fellow-headsmen should be a little...off.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by HuManBing »

Edit: You probably want to go with Nathan's Unified Theory first.


The best philosophical and legalist minds of educated modern societies have gone back and forth on this issue. Like abortion, the death penalty is one of those modern ethical/moral issues that everybody will have some sort of opinion about, and there is a wide variety of opinions along a spectrum.

Specific to Ravenloft, I'd say it's a serious case of GM discretion. (And a good GM should give the players plenty of pointers as well, either in-character or straight-out as the GM's voice.) Players are likely to feel cheated if the GM portrayed an adventure as a consequence-free combat exercise (such as repulsing and killing several brutal Talons from Falkovnia) but then suddenly starts forcing the PCs to roll DP checks.

Here are a few philosophical viewpoints to get you started. Whichever you choose, make sure your PCs are on board with them first!

1. Sentences as reformative. You sentence a criminal to rehabilitate them into society. A thief may be required to perform some service to their community, or to their victims. Applied to youths, this can be an effective way of instilling closeness and therefore sympathy with the victim they formerly wronged. Execution does not fall into this category, except in religions or philosophies where an after-death continuation of experience is accepted doctrine. Then, it might be a case of "freeing the spirit from the criminal flesh to seek absolution" or something similar. In many cultures, from feudal Japan to ancient Rome, self-execution was seen as an honorable means of redemption, for much this reason. Both Japanese and Romans also had "second men" who would administer a killing blow if the primary penitent failed to kill himself quickly. This "second man" role would effectively be an executioner - albeit with the strong sanction of society (and the victim!) behind their actions.

2. Sentences as sequestration. You punish a criminal to sequester that criminal from committing the crime again. Jails are an obvious example of this, but usually don't result in death. A strict utilitarian society might view execution as this too - you remove the criminal so they can't cause any more trouble. This is more likely to be the philosophy behind non-violent means of ending a life, such as administration of a lethal injection or a comfortive oral poison. A lethal injection (especially one done without observers) is unlikely to have the same shock value as a beheading or torture, but it does clearly remove a convict from ever being able to commit the crime again.

4. Sentences as public example. The sentence is intended to be public, and to arouse a strong emotion in the viewers. This may be to imbue the public with a sense of justice being done, vengeance delivered, or (more cynically) to strike fear into the public at the manner of the execution. Death by shooting squad, while clearly unpleasant and somewhat bloody, is still a far cry from the gory spectacles of other forms of execution - and is generally not regarded as torture (though it may fall under the legalist definition of "cruel and unusual punishment", terms drawn from the US Constitution). Death by torture, mutilation, or lethal deprivation are far more exemplary in their roles, showing the public what happens if you transgress. Torture involves causing physical or emotional pain to the condemned until they are killed - and some methods of execution can be quite speedy but still horrifically painful (the medieval practice of sawing is one). Mutilation often accompanies torture, but may be separate - the Chinese traditionally considered one's body to be the sacred gift of one's parents and ancestors - thus, beheading was reserved only for the most grievous crimes, as it involved striking the head from the body and defiling the gift of one's ancestors. Although the condemned would likely have limited and very brief suffering, the social calumny of the execution style was a potent message to onlookers. Finally, deprivation could be an effective means of deterrence - gibbets could hardly be described as violent, but they could certainly be called cruel, as the condemned wastes away from dehydration and hunger, open to the stares and jeers of onlookers.


How severe the DP check is for any of these executions would also depend on your view of morality or ethics in Ravenloft. Are they absolute? ("Taking a human life is wrong no matter what conditions exist.") Or are they relative? ("Taking a human life can be justified if it prevents a greater evil/if it's socially acceptable/if it's done with the consent of the victim/if you are not human and you normally consume them nutritionally.") The old grave-robbing entry in 2E rules danced around this issue, introducing the question of whether all PCs should be judged on the trope of a "mummy's curse" (specified as a Har'Akiri social norm).

Whatever you choose, you'll probably find it easier going if you're consistent in its application, and clear to your PCs about where the milestones lie.

Personally, I'm inclined towards a reading that the actor's subjective state of mind also influences the outcome. Thus, if a person specifically believes that the situation obviates the action, then they're unlikely to attract the DP's attention. The corollary to this is that everybody, even the Dark Lords, must at some point have realized that what they were doing is wrong. To me, this has the beneficial effect of showing that all the Dark Lords likely had a moment of "Do I REALLY want to do this?", and then they made their damning decision.

The downside of this is you can have a theoretical morally bankrupt person who performs horrific acts, but indefinitely escapes culpability through virtue of not knowing what they've done is wrong. This is especially the case for maniacs, mentally deficient people, dumb animals, and children. This may be dissatisfying to your players. On the other hand, it would explain the relatively human-centric selection of Dark Lords - the DPs tend to punish those individuals who have a morality system relatively close to humans... whereas non-anthropomorphic things like Shadow Dragons are not judged on that criteria.
User avatar
Manofevil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by Manofevil »

The players state of m,ind may also be a factor. If the character realizes he has no choice and does this thing but feels like he's soiled himself or damned himself, then a powers check is hardly warranted. If on the other hand he does so in a heated moment or even a frenzy of rage (DIE YOU B#$%$%^& PIECE OF S^%#!!! DIE! DIE! DIE! DIE!) Then a powers check would definitely be in order.
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!

So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by Jester of the FoS »

As others have said, it depends on the executioner.

If he's a butcher that fell on hard times and this was the only job he could get then no. If he was the victim of violence and crime, and took the job to personally send as many criminals to the afterlife then likely yes.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by HuManBing »

Manofevil wrote:The players state of m,ind may also be a factor. If the character realizes he has no choice and does this thing but feels like he's soiled himself or damned himself, then a powers check is hardly warranted. If on the other hand he does so in a heated moment or even a frenzy of rage (DIE YOU B#$%$%^& PIECE OF S^%#!!! DIE! DIE! DIE! DIE!) Then a powers check would definitely be in order.
This makes sense. It's interesting you should say that, because the last few paragraphs of my post takes the exact opposite view: the DPs punish those who carry some semblance of guilt around with them.

So in my system, a complete psychopath would actually get away with it scot-free. The same would go for a dumb animal that can't tell the difference between right and wrong, and also for a child who did not have the mental faculties to do so.


It comes down to a difference of whether you judge based on an absolute, objective scale ("The DPs are watching to see if you do something they don't like, then they'll punish you... even if you don't realize you're doing something bad"), or whether you judge based on an internal, subjective scale ("The DPs are watching to see if YOU, the actor, understand that what you're doing is bad... and you go ahead and do it anyway").

The former view is much simpler, and the standard 1st ed. DnD rules favoring objectively observable alignments and moral systems supports it. Go out and whack the orcs, kill the evil wizard, and take their stuff - because they're "evil" and so that makes it okay.

The latter view is much more complex, but it's been adopted by many modern legal systems. Most crimes, for example, require mens rea (loosely translated as "the intent to do evil") in order to be punished. If I cut you open with a knife, my intent is very important: am I a murderer trying to kill you? Or am I a physician trying to dig out an arrow from your guts? Or - indeed - am I a child or a mentally disabled adult, who does not understand that what he's doing is harmful to another?

Both views definitely work for a campaign, but they are mutually incompatible, so you'll have to choose one. And it's a good idea to choose it early and make it clear to your players, otherwise when the DP check hammer comes down, you'll find arguments a-plenty about which moral system "everybody thought we were using".
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Re: Power checks for an excecutioner?

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

HuManBing wrote:The latter view is much more complex, but it's been adopted by many modern legal systems. Most crimes, for example, require mens rea (loosely translated as "the intent to do evil")
Forgive me, but this term comes up so infrequently that I must take the opportunity to link to the funniest mens rea joke of all time:
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Post Reply