Out of nigh pure curiosity, imagine that you were going to stat up a butcher. He has been a butcher all his life and is moderately successful at it. He not only chops up animals into nice pieces, but also slaughters them, with cows and horses being the largest creatures in which he deals.
What class would you give him? What level would you assign him in that class? What feats would you give him? As for skills, maxing out Profession (butcher) would be a given. But what else? What weapons would you make him handy with?
Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
The cure for what ails you
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Re: Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
Sounds like an expert to me, if that's all he does. Possibly you could justify a level of warrior if he's also a member of the local militia.
Killing livestock as a butcher shouldn't provide any experience points, as they're generally restrained and helpless to fight back. Maybe let him acquire a level of expert for every decade he's been practicing his craft, earned through role-playing challenges like negotiating purchases, dealing with irate customers, or training apprentices.
For weapons, a medieval-style butcher would be familiar with several kinds of knives, heavy hammers, cleavers, meathooks, and hatchets.
He should definitely have a few skill ranks in Handle Animal, possibly a few in Use Rope, and perhaps a single rank in Heal for dealing with slips of the knife. Appraise might be useful if he buys livestock for sale rather than slaughtering what others bring him, and perhaps Sense Motive to make sure he's not being ripped off. A Craft skill that makes use of the inedible parts of an animal, such as candle-making from tallow, might allow him an appropriate sideline to his business, particularly if he lives in a town too small to have a chandler.
For feats, skill-enhancers would work, and possibly Power Attack if he's strong enough and his work includes large animals like cattle and horses. (They'd be restrained, so no problem taking a big hit penalty.) Possibly Endurance would help if he has to subdue animals himself, and doesn't want to get knocked out by a struggling steer's flank slamming into him.
Killing livestock as a butcher shouldn't provide any experience points, as they're generally restrained and helpless to fight back. Maybe let him acquire a level of expert for every decade he's been practicing his craft, earned through role-playing challenges like negotiating purchases, dealing with irate customers, or training apprentices.
For weapons, a medieval-style butcher would be familiar with several kinds of knives, heavy hammers, cleavers, meathooks, and hatchets.
He should definitely have a few skill ranks in Handle Animal, possibly a few in Use Rope, and perhaps a single rank in Heal for dealing with slips of the knife. Appraise might be useful if he buys livestock for sale rather than slaughtering what others bring him, and perhaps Sense Motive to make sure he's not being ripped off. A Craft skill that makes use of the inedible parts of an animal, such as candle-making from tallow, might allow him an appropriate sideline to his business, particularly if he lives in a town too small to have a chandler.
For feats, skill-enhancers would work, and possibly Power Attack if he's strong enough and his work includes large animals like cattle and horses. (They'd be restrained, so no problem taking a big hit penalty.) Possibly Endurance would help if he has to subdue animals himself, and doesn't want to get knocked out by a struggling steer's flank slamming into him.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- Dion of the Fraternity
- Lurker Maximus

- Posts: 1092
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
- Location: Baguio City, Philippines
- Contact:
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
Both great answers! Roti covered 3e. Dion covered 4e.
Here, I'll take 2e:
0-level human with a cleaver. (use handaxe stats).

Here, I'll take 2e:
0-level human with a cleaver. (use handaxe stats).
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Strahdsbuddy
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 605
- Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: A Finger Lake
Re: Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
And I'll take the bastardized Pathfinder version. I statted up the NPCs from I-10 in 3.5/Pathfinder speak. SIlas Archer was listed as Fighter8 in the Original 1st edition, I changed that co COM-8, which will account for the differences. This seems like a lot of levels in retrospect, but there was certainly an effort to make some NPCs stand out, so I left it alone. Feats: Skill Focus: Profession, Iron Will (to deal with all that death), Tough (same premise, including intestinal fortitude), Skill Focuse: Knowledge, Athletic (kind of a tack-on, I admit)
Skills were: Profession: Butcher +13, Knowledge: Local History +10, Handle Animal +4, Climb +4, Craft:Brewer +5. My climb and craft were tack-ons again, and I think Rotipher's craft works much better. Overall I think her ideas trump mine, but I wanted to show them for the sake of completeness.
8th Level commoners should be rare, but not unknown. Mordentshire probably shouldn't have a dozen of them though.
Skills were: Profession: Butcher +13, Knowledge: Local History +10, Handle Animal +4, Climb +4, Craft:Brewer +5. My climb and craft were tack-ons again, and I think Rotipher's craft works much better. Overall I think her ideas trump mine, but I wanted to show them for the sake of completeness.
8th Level commoners should be rare, but not unknown. Mordentshire probably shouldn't have a dozen of them though.
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
- The Lesser Evil
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1552
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am
Re: Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
Depending on how macabre/experimental he got with his butchering and if you do pathfinder, you might consider the vivisectionist archetype for the alchemist (in the Ultimate Magic book if i recall correctly). That's how I wrote up my version of Frantizek Markov.
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Re: Class, level of a long-standing butcher?
I find that a bit to slow...Rotipher wrote:Killing livestock as a butcher shouldn't provide any experience points, as they're generally restrained and helpless to fight back. Maybe let him acquire a level of expert for every decade he's been practicing his craft, earned through role-playing challenges like negotiating purchases, dealing with irate customers, or training apprentices.
Did you check out the ENworld NPC class threads by MavrickWeirdo that i linked to in my NPC classes rant here? No butchers there but plenty of interesting NPCs-over-a-lifetime.
MavrickWeirdo's premise was "you learn something new everyday", and thus his formula was this:
Other's have proposed that a year of getting by should be a CR1 encounter which yields a similar if a bit slower advancement scale and tops out at CL8, as CR1 encounters don't bring any more XP then.NPC’s over a lifetime
My preference is 1exp/day for NPC's, 365 exp/year
so for humans
age 15 is level 1
age 18 is level 2
age 24 is level 3
age 32 is level 4
age 35 is “middle age” –1 S, D, & Co; +1 I, W, & Ch
age 43 is level 5
age 53 is “old age” –2 S, D, & Co; +1 I, W, & Ch
age 57 is level 6
age 70 is “venerable” –3 S, D, & Co; +1 I, W, & Ch
age 73 is level 7
age 92 is level 8
So the butcher would probably be level 4 to 6 (depending on his age) if nothing very exceptional happened to him in his life. He could be a Commoner or an Expert, depending on how well-rounded his education was. A small town's butcher would probably be a commoner, while in a big city a resident butcher would be more likely to have expert levels. Both would have the same profession butcher skill rank at the same levels. The Expert would be proficient with more of his tools as weapons, the Commoner only with one.
See also the Commoner vs Expert thread for the interesting comparisons of specialized commoners and experts.

