Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
MODERATOR NOTE: I've split this topic off of the cartography thread, so as to keep the two discussions separate.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Kinda a fun thought--if accurate maps can be produced with special knowledge/abilities, and the people who have that knowledge/those abilities are largely people (the Boritsis, Azalin, the FoS, the Vistani) who specialize in knowing things others don't, perhaps accurate maps do exist but those who have them do everything in their power to make sure the knowledge doesn't spread. (What if the famed Vistani ability to navigate the Mists was just because they're the only ones with maps?!?
)
Then you could have things like the PCs acquiring a really high-quality map from a Boritsi or a Kargat agent and realizing a) they now have something incredibly rare and useful! b) somebody's gonna want this back...
Then you could have things like the PCs acquiring a really high-quality map from a Boritsi or a Kargat agent and realizing a) they now have something incredibly rare and useful! b) somebody's gonna want this back...
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
For what it's worth, I think we're running into the age-old issue of Ravenloft's inherent contradictions. As DeepShadow aptly pointed out with the Opera House example, the setting is simply unrealistic at its core, no matter how hard we try to patch it. When you add in the game-balance-based economics, forget about it.
Is it relatively easy and affordable to map the core by mortal magic, assuming the Dark Powers don't decide to interfere: yes. Even at 50k, which is a high estimate IMHO, literally dozens of Canon NPCs could afford one if they wanted it. Wish does only make 25k, as alhoon pointed out, but a caster on par with Azalin can cast wish several times a day. I understand if alhoon likes to stick to lower level wizards in his campaign, but not everyone does, and in canon, many of those wizards exist. And many high level NPCs of any class are walking around with a fortune in magic gear, as is appropriate in 3e D&D.
Now, is it thematically appropriate for Ravenloft's wizards to make full use of their abilities? that's another story entirely. Elemental powered trains, everburning streetlamps, etc. All that might make sense looking at the rules. But too far down that path lies Eberron. (No offense, Eberron-fans. But it's a different setting and theme than Ravenloft.) If you want to keep Ravenloft claustrophobic and mysterious, to better emphasize the horror, maybe detailed maps mass produced at 5gp a piece would ruin that flavor, no matter how logically sound the reasoning is.
Is it relatively easy and affordable to map the core by mortal magic, assuming the Dark Powers don't decide to interfere: yes. Even at 50k, which is a high estimate IMHO, literally dozens of Canon NPCs could afford one if they wanted it. Wish does only make 25k, as alhoon pointed out, but a caster on par with Azalin can cast wish several times a day. I understand if alhoon likes to stick to lower level wizards in his campaign, but not everyone does, and in canon, many of those wizards exist. And many high level NPCs of any class are walking around with a fortune in magic gear, as is appropriate in 3e D&D.
Now, is it thematically appropriate for Ravenloft's wizards to make full use of their abilities? that's another story entirely. Elemental powered trains, everburning streetlamps, etc. All that might make sense looking at the rules. But too far down that path lies Eberron. (No offense, Eberron-fans. But it's a different setting and theme than Ravenloft.) If you want to keep Ravenloft claustrophobic and mysterious, to better emphasize the horror, maybe detailed maps mass produced at 5gp a piece would ruin that flavor, no matter how logically sound the reasoning is.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Deepshadow: You come off as kinda hostile.
If those things work in your campaign, be my guest.
Those "strawmen" arguments though, seem quite sound to me. Yes, a flimsy +1 sword costs as much as 8 warhorses. Don't buy it and avoid monsters that have resistance to physical weapons.
5 gp for a map? That wouldn't cover the cost of the ink and the paper actually but if it works for you it's OK.
And no, I don't see any such need for good maps, in a land where the geography actually changes. Yes, Drakov has need for them. However Drakov helps Maloccio abduct and kill vistani so I doupt they would be giving him maps. Not to mention that maps would cut directly on their profits since they make money moving people around. And how many vistani are actually good enough artists to reproduce the map with decent accuracy? Or how many actually realize concepts as "Scale"? How many of those nomads can actually read and write?
Still don't believe me? Try to reproduce a 2' x 2' map by hand. See how long it will take you and how good the result would be. Now try to redraw the map from the copy you made. And not on a thin paper placed on the original. Paper back then was thicker. Also, I doupt Vistani had access to modern-quality measuring tools like accurate rulers and protractors. So, for fairness, try that herculean task, by measuring distances on a stick.
Sounds hard? Try doing that on wagons while you also have to find food and do chores. Yeah, there might be a handful of vistani skilled enough to pull decent copies of hand down original maps. They wouldn't be charging 5gp for those maps though, because the maps would require talent, skill and time.
Also as someone that worked for 4 months to correct the errors of aerophotographs, align and scale them to create an accurate photomosaic that could be used as a map (using GPS of course on the ground), I tell you that no, you can't map an area by flying above it. You'll include big errors there.
You people don't understand how hard it is to make a good map even with today's topography and geodetic instruments. Google-earth map is an actual wonder of our time, it's not something they made by just sticking satelite images together. There's a reason topographers go to universities.
IMC, those good maps cost too much to be considered a bargain. +4 charisma is quite useful to a sorcerer. A map is not. Yes, if you pay 5000 gp you can get a very, very nice and detailed map of the core, because IMC 5000 gp is a lot of money.
I personally agree with Nathan.
Those with the maps have every reason to hoard them, when those maps actually work. You can get them, but they're rare, very expensive and at times dangerous to have.
PS. No, IMC there are no operas in Ravenloft, and I use a core with 2 million people.
On the other hand maybe someone doesn't want to derail his claustophobic, mysterius campaign on how hard it is to find a good map to travel 20 miles to the monastery X, but more or the horror that terrorizes the monks there, driving their leaders slowly to insanity.
So, maybe a detailed map that is passed to the PCs by the terrified lord of the nearby villages that shows where the monastery is accurately is good for the story and flavor, no matter how illogical it is for a detailed, cheap map of a rural area to exist.
So... it comes down to: Whatever is better for the story. Want to make an adventure out of the PCs racing to stop the very rare and expensive map that would allow Drakov's officers to throw a campaign on nearby lands that (although doomed to failure) would cost hundreds of lives? Then maps of that area are extremely rare and expensive and Drakov can't actually order his wizards to fly over the next day and map the area.
Want to make an adventure that the PCs routinely travel from X to Y to Z to A to B without the hassle of "now, let's find a good way to get there" ? Well, then maps are a dime a dozen.
Strange that it was actually Gonzoron that casted doupt on my opinion on maps instead of Deepshadow.
If those things work in your campaign, be my guest.
Those "strawmen" arguments though, seem quite sound to me. Yes, a flimsy +1 sword costs as much as 8 warhorses. Don't buy it and avoid monsters that have resistance to physical weapons.
5 gp for a map? That wouldn't cover the cost of the ink and the paper actually but if it works for you it's OK.
And no, I don't see any such need for good maps, in a land where the geography actually changes. Yes, Drakov has need for them. However Drakov helps Maloccio abduct and kill vistani so I doupt they would be giving him maps. Not to mention that maps would cut directly on their profits since they make money moving people around. And how many vistani are actually good enough artists to reproduce the map with decent accuracy? Or how many actually realize concepts as "Scale"? How many of those nomads can actually read and write?
Still don't believe me? Try to reproduce a 2' x 2' map by hand. See how long it will take you and how good the result would be. Now try to redraw the map from the copy you made. And not on a thin paper placed on the original. Paper back then was thicker. Also, I doupt Vistani had access to modern-quality measuring tools like accurate rulers and protractors. So, for fairness, try that herculean task, by measuring distances on a stick.
Sounds hard? Try doing that on wagons while you also have to find food and do chores. Yeah, there might be a handful of vistani skilled enough to pull decent copies of hand down original maps. They wouldn't be charging 5gp for those maps though, because the maps would require talent, skill and time.
Also as someone that worked for 4 months to correct the errors of aerophotographs, align and scale them to create an accurate photomosaic that could be used as a map (using GPS of course on the ground), I tell you that no, you can't map an area by flying above it. You'll include big errors there.
You people don't understand how hard it is to make a good map even with today's topography and geodetic instruments. Google-earth map is an actual wonder of our time, it's not something they made by just sticking satelite images together. There's a reason topographers go to universities.
IMC, those good maps cost too much to be considered a bargain. +4 charisma is quite useful to a sorcerer. A map is not. Yes, if you pay 5000 gp you can get a very, very nice and detailed map of the core, because IMC 5000 gp is a lot of money.
I personally agree with Nathan.
Those with the maps have every reason to hoard them, when those maps actually work. You can get them, but they're rare, very expensive and at times dangerous to have.
PS. No, IMC there are no operas in Ravenloft, and I use a core with 2 million people.
And to suddenly make a turn:Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: If you want to keep Ravenloft claustrophobic and mysterious, to better emphasize the horror, maybe detailed maps mass produced at 5gp a piece would ruin that flavor, no matter how logically sound the reasoning is.
On the other hand maybe someone doesn't want to derail his claustophobic, mysterius campaign on how hard it is to find a good map to travel 20 miles to the monastery X, but more or the horror that terrorizes the monks there, driving their leaders slowly to insanity.
So, maybe a detailed map that is passed to the PCs by the terrified lord of the nearby villages that shows where the monastery is accurately is good for the story and flavor, no matter how illogical it is for a detailed, cheap map of a rural area to exist.
So... it comes down to: Whatever is better for the story. Want to make an adventure out of the PCs racing to stop the very rare and expensive map that would allow Drakov's officers to throw a campaign on nearby lands that (although doomed to failure) would cost hundreds of lives? Then maps of that area are extremely rare and expensive and Drakov can't actually order his wizards to fly over the next day and map the area.
Want to make an adventure that the PCs routinely travel from X to Y to Z to A to B without the hassle of "now, let's find a good way to get there" ? Well, then maps are a dime a dozen.
Strange that it was actually Gonzoron that casted doupt on my opinion on maps instead of Deepshadow.
Last edited by alhoon on Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:02 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Exactly. Each of us tries to reconcile these in different ways, but there is always room for other reconciliations of the same canon data.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:For what it's worth, I think we're running into the age-old issue of Ravenloft's inherent contradictions. As DeepShadow aptly pointed out with the Opera House example, the setting is simply unrealistic at its core, no matter how hard we try to patch it. When you add in the game-balance-based economics, forget about it.
Note that the 50K is for the magical charts that CREATE the maps. The products themselves would be a fraction of that.Is it relatively easy and affordable to map the core by mortal magic, assuming the Dark Powers don't decide to interfere: yes. Even at 50k, which is a high estimate IMHO, literally dozens of Canon NPCs could afford one if they wanted it.
Ah, but those are easily restricted by the public's resistance to magic. If some wizard wanted to make all the streetlights in Mordentshire into everburning torches, there would probably be an uproar, and the superstitious populace would destroy the things (and possibly the creator). That's a simple way to restrict the path to Dread Eberron.Now, is it thematically appropriate for Ravenloft's wizards to make full use of their abilities? that's another story entirely. Elemental powered trains, everburning streetlamps, etc. All that might make sense looking at the rules.
Accurate maps are hardly the same thing. If a PC has Charts of Certainty, who's going to know if he pulls them out once in a while? If the CoC get copied to make accurate maps, would anyone besides a cartographer know that it took magic to make them? The average peasant would probably not recognize a super-accurate map as a byproduct of sorcery.
Would they? I don't know.If you want to keep Ravenloft claustrophobic and mysterious, to better emphasize the horror, maybe detailed maps mass produced at 5gp a piece would ruin that flavor, no matter how logically sound the reasoning is.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
As I said, the copies will be far but "super-accurate" unless the one making the copy was educated, talented, practiced and with good measuring tools.DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Accurate maps are hardly the same thing. If a PC has Charts of Certainty, who's going to know if he pulls them out once in a while? If the CoC get copied to make accurate maps, would anyone besides a cartographer know that it took magic to make them? The average peasant would probably not recognize a super-accurate map as a byproduct of sorcery.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
I have vague memories of a spell that let you instantly copy pages onto blank paper, but I can't find it in the SRD. wonder if it was a 2e thing, or maybe in the spell compendium or something. If it exists, I wonder if that would work. But, really, all it would take is tracing. As long as you don't roll up the charts, the map stays, and you can take as long as you like to copy it. Once you have one non-magical copy, you can roll up the originals and copy from the copy.
But here's the rub: The description of Charts of Certainty says the map is: "(as detailed as a commercially available one)". So how detailed is a commercially available map of Ravenloft? It's a bit of chicken-and-egg problem, no? If the commercially-available maps are based on Charts of Certainty, and Charts of Certainty's accuracy is based on commercially-available maps... how detailed are they?
But here's the rub: The description of Charts of Certainty says the map is: "(as detailed as a commercially available one)". So how detailed is a commercially available map of Ravenloft? It's a bit of chicken-and-egg problem, no? If the commercially-available maps are based on Charts of Certainty, and Charts of Certainty's accuracy is based on commercially-available maps... how detailed are they?
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
As i ended up with previously: As much as you want them to be.
If you want to focus your story on "what happens once you get there" the answer is "accurate enough". Else I would say as detailed as 17th century maps. For such an item I would bypass the "commercial" quality though and go straight for "2% error" as it is in most maps of 1:50000 which is very accurate. I.e. you get off by 20 meters in a kilometer.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
I figure most of the Core would be mapped reasonly well, but some areas would not get much detail, ie tepest, forlorn, velechor and vebrek and simillar domains. Where as places like nova vaassa, dementlieu mordent, richemulet and borca would be far more detailed. As these lands are large, and economically powerful, not to mention one can find scholars coming from those lands. however the lands that are not truely explored IMO would probaly not get a detailed map. they might no where it is but not much beyond the borders if that, where as most maps would have a clear idea about Borca and what not.
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Something worth considering as well... the "border's" I thought had mist around them and if you went through them you could end up miles away from where you just where. If you were mapping that and the mist's picked you up, then your map would not be very accurate. Guess it depends on whether or not the dark powers allow you to map it or not.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
A common misconception. Most borders appear the same as borders here on earth: invisible. Only darklords who can't pass them even notice them, unless the darklord "closes" his or her borders.Zilfer wrote:Something worth considering as well... the "border's" I thought had mist around them and if you went through them you could end up miles away from where you just where.
The Mists can pick you up whenever the Dark Powers feel like it, border or no border. So yes, if they don't want someone mapping, you ain't mapping.If you were mapping that and the mist's picked you up, then your map would not be very accurate. Guess it depends on whether or not the dark powers allow you to map it or not.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:A common misconception. Most borders appear the same as borders here on earth: invisible. Only darklords who can't pass them even notice them, unless the darklord "closes" his or her borders.Zilfer wrote:Something worth considering as well... the "border's" I thought had mist around them and if you went through them you could end up miles away from where you just where.
The Mists can pick you up whenever the Dark Powers feel like it, border or no border. So yes, if they don't want someone mapping, you ain't mapping.If you were mapping that and the mist's picked you up, then your map would not be very accurate. Guess it depends on whether or not the dark powers allow you to map it or not.
I'll have to reread a bit it seems. Thought it was so, and that you could only get where you wanted to go if the vistani were guiding you through the misty boarder.... o.O'
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
"The Misty Border" is something different than the borders between domains. The Misty Border is the large area of mist surrounding The Core (and other clusters or Islands of Terror). (see map here) You can walk from Sithicus to Valachan to Mordent to Dementlieu to Lamordia to Darkon without ever noticing anything odd at the borders. (Assuming all the darklords in question are in a good mood, and assuming you survive all the other dangers along the way). It's only if you head north from Darkon or south from Valachan/Sithicus/Katakass/Hazlan/Nova Vassa, or east from the Nocturnal Sea, west from the Sea of Sorrows, etc. that you enter that big gray mass at the perimeter of the map. That's the Misty Border. And if you go in there, you'd better have a Vistani with you, or an Ezran Anchorite, or know of a reliable Mistway. If not, it's anyone's guess where you'll end up. (see our FAQ for more on this topic).Zilfer wrote:I'll have to reread a bit it seems. Thought it was so, and that you could only get where you wanted to go if the vistani were guiding you through the misty boarder.... o.O'
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:"The Misty Border" is something different than the borders between domains. The Misty Border is the large area of mist surrounding The Core (and other clusters or Islands of Terror). (see map here) You can walk from Sithicus to Valachan to Mordent to Dementlieu to Lamordia to Darkon without ever noticing anything odd at the borders. (Assuming all the darklords in question are in a good mood, and assuming you survive all the other dangers along the way). It's only if you head north from Darkon or south from Valachan/Sithicus/Katakass/Hazlan/Nova Vassa, or east from the Nocturnal Sea, west from the Sea of Sorrows, etc. that you enter that big gray mass at the perimeter of the map. That's the Misty Border. And if you go in there, you'd better have a Vistani with you, or an Ezran Anchorite, or know of a reliable Mistway. If not, it's anyone's guess where you'll end up. (see our FAQ for more on this topic).Zilfer wrote:I'll have to reread a bit it seems. Thought it was so, and that you could only get where you wanted to go if the vistani were guiding you through the misty boarder.... o.O'
Alright, i'll definately take a look at it.
Btw the qoute in your sig... that from your campaign or is there an offical source for that? Sounds like time travel to me!
-
Garudos Celestar
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 279
- Joined: Sat Jun 10, 2006 1:51 pm
- Location: United States
Re: Mapping Ravenloft [Split from: Drawing a Map]
Madame Eva is a member of the Zarovan tribe of Vistani, who don't exist in linear time (there may be some debate as to whether they can intentionally choose when they're going to exist next).Zilfer wrote:Btw the qoute in your sig... that from your campaign or is there an offical source for that? Sounds like time travel to me!
As far as the mapping issue goes, I would imagine most Ravenloftian maps to be more like subway maps: they'll show you the relationships between places, but won't be accurate in details. Thus, the Old Svalich Road definitely goes from the village of Barovia to Vallaki and then Krezk, in that order (even if people frequently get "lost" along the way), but at best you'll only get a very rough sense of scale, and any two places without a direct line (maintained road, river, etc.) between them will have an even more ambiguous sense of proportion.
Last edited by Garudos Celestar on Wed Dec 14, 2011 3:20 pm, edited 2 times in total.
[i]"I too have begun to wonder about the legendary wisdom of our guardian angel and his pet rock."
~ Evee Beiderbecke[/i]
~ Evee Beiderbecke[/i]
