OK, so non-supernatural fighting threats:
- serial killer
- bandits
- pirates
- wild beasts loose in town
- drunks
- duelists
- innocent townsfolk driven mad by ergot
- corrupt police
- barbarian raiders
- a lost platoon of soldiers, not knowing the war is over
- koalas
Help for lull in story
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Help for lull in story
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Re: Help for lull in story
Personally, I'd play out the stereotype of a frontier settlement: bunch of rugged individuals looking to start over (each with their own reasons, some legit some criminal) but all thrown into the same pot for better an for worse. And when you have a small colony coexisting on the fringe of society like that, then elbow space is not only inevitable but oftentimes necessary. Tempers WILL flare from time to time, especially when alcohol is fueled by hard luck.
Maybe the local merchant's supply run got pinched en route and the effect has everybody on edge. No axe handles slows the loggers down, which causes the carpenter's crew to idle, which in turn puts people either out in the cold (wagon beds, tents etc) or into overcrowded makeshift public housing. Maybe the public house ran dry and the lack of escape (downtime, whatever you want to call it)has everybody on edge. The result is a brewing mob-like mentality. One sour look and its cracked teeth and bloody mouths.
Not to mention that sometimes one just has to mark his or her territory in a world so small as a frontier town. Personal reputation is a truly sacred thing, especially amongst people looking to re-establish themselves from their former lives Pushovers now have the chance to push, criminals can find whatever god they need to help stay clear of the past, etc. A new start for all. Game terms, a potential re-alignment centre. Y'know?
So, with the basics said, it's no problem to exchange slurs, fists, teeth and pleasantries in a place such as that. I like to think of frontier settlements like a large family: fisticuffs will happen from time to time, but due to the clan mentality of coexistence, all feuds will eventually settle themselves. Sure, some grudges will be made, sides will be taken, but all will fall under the pretext of social politeness in the least. None of which can't truly be settled, given a two party inclination to do so.
Hell, sometimes the strongest relationships develop after a good exchange of blood, sweat and tears, so I'd embrace whatever the players want to do. Just tally the names and actions and over time the colony will become almost entirely 'PCs' as opposed to 'NPCs'.
In short, pit job crew against job crew (I assume the PCs are there in such a capacity) and go from there. The results of any physical conflict can easily be written off as frustration (due to circumstances such as mentioned earlier), but in the end when the town prospers everybody prospers. And if things are getting particularly out of control, then rig it that the PCs shift jobs to that of their foes of the moment...that should be an interesting change of pace. Or, if the player's row got right out of hand then just throw in a situation that forces the town to band together. Bandits. Subversion tactics played out by or even just emanating from an underground faction (two sides like the town the way it is, above and beyond their personal feud). Anything that threatens to undo that renewed sense of self and or accomplishment. After all, there's only one name on the welcome sign, yeah?
A few random and quick thoughts.
Maybe the local merchant's supply run got pinched en route and the effect has everybody on edge. No axe handles slows the loggers down, which causes the carpenter's crew to idle, which in turn puts people either out in the cold (wagon beds, tents etc) or into overcrowded makeshift public housing. Maybe the public house ran dry and the lack of escape (downtime, whatever you want to call it)has everybody on edge. The result is a brewing mob-like mentality. One sour look and its cracked teeth and bloody mouths.
Not to mention that sometimes one just has to mark his or her territory in a world so small as a frontier town. Personal reputation is a truly sacred thing, especially amongst people looking to re-establish themselves from their former lives Pushovers now have the chance to push, criminals can find whatever god they need to help stay clear of the past, etc. A new start for all. Game terms, a potential re-alignment centre. Y'know?
So, with the basics said, it's no problem to exchange slurs, fists, teeth and pleasantries in a place such as that. I like to think of frontier settlements like a large family: fisticuffs will happen from time to time, but due to the clan mentality of coexistence, all feuds will eventually settle themselves. Sure, some grudges will be made, sides will be taken, but all will fall under the pretext of social politeness in the least. None of which can't truly be settled, given a two party inclination to do so.
Hell, sometimes the strongest relationships develop after a good exchange of blood, sweat and tears, so I'd embrace whatever the players want to do. Just tally the names and actions and over time the colony will become almost entirely 'PCs' as opposed to 'NPCs'.
In short, pit job crew against job crew (I assume the PCs are there in such a capacity) and go from there. The results of any physical conflict can easily be written off as frustration (due to circumstances such as mentioned earlier), but in the end when the town prospers everybody prospers. And if things are getting particularly out of control, then rig it that the PCs shift jobs to that of their foes of the moment...that should be an interesting change of pace. Or, if the player's row got right out of hand then just throw in a situation that forces the town to band together. Bandits. Subversion tactics played out by or even just emanating from an underground faction (two sides like the town the way it is, above and beyond their personal feud). Anything that threatens to undo that renewed sense of self and or accomplishment. After all, there's only one name on the welcome sign, yeah?
A few random and quick thoughts.
Last edited by Five on Wed Jan 04, 2012 9:04 pm, edited 2 times in total.
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
- DilisnyaRevenge
- Agent of the Fraternity

- Posts: 70
- Joined: Mon Nov 03, 2008 4:17 pm
Re: Help for lull in story
At the moment you have a frontier town, no magic, but you want some combat for the next session... It may seem odd to say this, but you might want to look to westerns for inspiration.
Maybe you could just have some troublemakers/bandits wander into town (by road or by sea) and steal/pick fights/etc. until the PCs chase them out of town. Or maybe the someone's daughter/cattle/shipment goes missing and the PCs are part of a posse to track them down? A bit more of a darker way to accomplish the same thing could have the last survivor of family slaughtered by bandits staggers into town and collapse. The PCs go hunting to track down his killers. The beauty of the "posse" is that you can have some of the important NPCs go with them and they can still be learning about the local politics while out on the combat missions.
Maybe you could just have some troublemakers/bandits wander into town (by road or by sea) and steal/pick fights/etc. until the PCs chase them out of town. Or maybe the someone's daughter/cattle/shipment goes missing and the PCs are part of a posse to track them down? A bit more of a darker way to accomplish the same thing could have the last survivor of family slaughtered by bandits staggers into town and collapse. The PCs go hunting to track down his killers. The beauty of the "posse" is that you can have some of the important NPCs go with them and they can still be learning about the local politics while out on the combat missions.
- The Lesser Evil
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1552
- Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am
Re: Help for lull in story
Hmm, so it sounds like what you're wanting is some kind of physical conflict (as opposed to a social conflict) that doesn't involve the supernatural. Hrmmm... what about some tension inducing physical conflicts that don't involve physical violence but still involve action? Like...
-natural disasters (floods, for example)
-exploration (climbing around old, decaying houses- that have built in 'traps' such as rotten floors you can fall through, or maybe fishing out an old body or treasure chest buried in a lake- using the drowning rules for this one)
-contests of skill (shooting/archery competitions, jousting, drunken bar brawls, wrestling competitions, etc)
-natural disasters (floods, for example)
-exploration (climbing around old, decaying houses- that have built in 'traps' such as rotten floors you can fall through, or maybe fishing out an old body or treasure chest buried in a lake- using the drowning rules for this one)
-contests of skill (shooting/archery competitions, jousting, drunken bar brawls, wrestling competitions, etc)
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Re: Help for lull in story
Don't forget the potential for conflict with mundane animals, either. Not necessarily just combat -- sure, there might be a rabid dog to hunt down or a predator killing sheep, but that gets old fast -- but ordinary work with livestock and pests as well. Imagine having to chase down a magpie that's stolen the diamond earring of the mayor's wife, or rounding up a herd of feral horses and breaking them to the saddle using a variant of the grappling rules instead of just a Handle Animal check.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Re: Help for lull in story
For a great example of Rotipher's second idea, check out All the pretty horses, by Cormac McCarthy. Great book!
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Re: Help for lull in story
I've started a thread about the reputation combat I was talking about. Will be adding more.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
Re: Help for lull in story
...Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:OK, so non-supernatural fighting threats:
- koalas
ಠ_ಠ
I see what's happening. The outback is being overrun by bears! Stephen Colbert was right!
