Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

DeepShadow of FoS wrote:*sigh* I guess I knew that. Oh well.

I guess my real problem is with the replacement of detect evil with detect chaos. I've never seen that ability used in my games to any sort of useful end.

How about any of you? How do paladins in your games use detect (evil) chaos to accomplish their missions?

I've only ever seen one paladin in 3E Ravenloft. He wasn't in the game very long, but I seem to recall he did detect some chaotic aligned foes, yes.

Paladins aren't neutral good or chaotic good, they are lawful good. Detect chaos helps them keep tabs on the opponents of law and order. Of course, a wise paladin realizes that not all chaotic types are evil, and so he exercises mercy and restraint as appropriate.

I harbor some doubts as to whether the nine point alignment system is desirable in Ravenloft. I think the whole thing could be replaced with a simple, tripartite good/neutral/evil arrangement. .Alignment cannot be detected by any direct means (there are no working no detect evil spells/class abilities). Indirect clues are possible; some special people can recognize a sinkhole of evil as a warp in reality, and if you trick the villain into picking up a holy sword his hand may be burned, etc.. Law and chaos subtypes disappear. Gothics are about Good versus Evil, and the Morcockian stuff may be a bit off the mark.
YMMV
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Jester of the FoS »

High Priest Mikhal wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:I'm thinking of giving paladins the ability to detect environmental evil as an always-on ability. They can just sense sinkholes of evil, and places of corruption. Kinda a "this place is strong with the Dark Side" sixth sense.
That would be more thematically proper and doesn't violate the RAW. Of course there aren't really rules for positive ethereal resonance so blackguards would need a case-by-case ruling on whether or not they detect the "good" equivalent of Sinkholes of Evil (detecting consecrated and hallowed places with their Detect (Good) Law ability fits).
That works nicely, I like the idea of knowing you're in a hallowed or desecrated area.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Jester of the FoS »

ewancummins wrote:
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:*sigh* I guess I knew that. Oh well.

I guess my real problem is with the replacement of detect evil with detect chaos. I've never seen that ability used in my games to any sort of useful end.

How about any of you? How do paladins in your games use detect (evil) chaos to accomplish their missions?

I've only ever seen one paladin in 3E Ravenloft. He wasn't in the game very long, but I seem to recall he did detect some chaotic aligned foes, yes.

Paladins aren't neutral good or chaotic good, they are lawful good. Detect chaos helps them keep tabs on the opponents of law and order. Of course, a wise paladin realizes that not all chaotic types are evil, and so he exercises mercy and restraint as appropriate.

I harbor some doubts as to whether the nine point alignment system is desirable in Ravenloft. I think the whole thing could be replaced with a simple, tripartite good/neutral/evil arrangement. .Alignment cannot be detected by any direct means (there are no working no detect evil spells/class abilities). Indirect clues are possible; some special people can recognize a sinkhole of evil as a warp in reality, and if you trick the villain into picking up a holy sword his hand may be burned, etc.. Law and chaos subtypes disappear. Gothics are about Good versus Evil, and the Morcockian stuff may be a bit off the mark.
YMMV
I like the Law/Chaos spectrum. In my next Ravenloft game I'm just breaking it up so you pick up to two of Good or Evil and Law or Chaos and then choose your order.
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Mortavius »

I'm probably mistaken here, but I thought that Paladins could detect the pressence of evil outsiders (ala Demons & Devils), not Detect Chaos? That makes more sense to me; Paladins are LG, and Demons (at least) are CE, detecting ones opposition and all that.

Also, the way Outsiders warp the fabric of reality, it makes thematic sense that a Paladin could detect them.

There are so many undead in Ravenloft, they've permeated the environment. They're harder to locate (and this is also reflected in the Will save they get).

Granted, a Paladin with the above ability probably wouldn't use it often, considering the rarity of Outsiders, but I think they may use it just as much as Detect Chaos, and to me, the ability to detect evil outsiders makes more sense than Chaos, even if Chaos opposes their Lawful alignment.
User avatar
brilliantlight
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1003
Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 8:02 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by brilliantlight »

Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Also detect chaos just isn't really useful.... ever? (Except maybe when crafting a Mystick Cage?)

Ooh... you're chaotic! so... you're Skeletor or Robin Hood. This helps me how?
I agree, I always have seen it as useless.
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

ewancummins wrote:I've only ever seen one paladin in 3E Ravenloft. He wasn't in the game very long, but I seem to recall he did detect some chaotic aligned foes, yes.

Paladins aren't neutral good or chaotic good, they are lawful good. Detect chaos helps them keep tabs on the opponents of law and order. Of course, a wise paladin realizes that not all chaotic types are evil, and so he exercises mercy and restraint as appropriate.

I harbor some doubts as to whether the nine point alignment system is desirable in Ravenloft. I think the whole thing could be replaced with a simple, tripartite good/neutral/evil arrangement. .Alignment cannot be detected by any direct means (there are no working no detect evil spells/class abilities). Indirect clues are possible; some special people can recognize a sinkhole of evil as a warp in reality, and if you trick the villain into picking up a holy sword his hand may be burned, etc.. Law and chaos subtypes disappear. Gothics are about Good versus Evil, and the Morcockian stuff may be a bit off the mark.
YMMV
In Unearthed Arcana there are rules for CG, LE, and CE paladins (champions of freedom, tyrrany, and slaughter, respectively). There's also the Holy Avenger PrC in Complete Divine that is very paladin-like, even allowing ex-paladin levels to augment features. More options for heroes and villains.

I have to disagree on the nine point alignment being undesirable, at least in my games. It's a foil for those paladins who, unaware that good and evil really do exist, fall prey to moral certainty and fall from grace when hubris blinds them. That ethical alignment can be detected, but not moral, leads to ignorance and arrogance. That amplifies the moral quandries paladins face; their trusty detect evil ability doesn't work as normal, so they have to learn to read people and trust their instincts. Just as paladins in other worlds shouldn't slaughter someone just because they register as evil, in Ravenloft they're denied even that certainty and must instead face the tough realities of what it means to be a paladin without any shortcuts. That makes for excellent role-playing.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
The Lesser Evil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1552
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by The Lesser Evil »

ewancummins wrote:In RAW Ravenloft, paladins detect chaos, not evil. Chaos is not the same as evil in the AD&D/3E /PF nine point alignment system.

I would rule that CE (and also CN or CG)undead do not detect as 'extra chaotic.'

The restrictions on his detection abilities are there for the same reason several cleric (and a few wizrobe) divination spells are modified; so that the players have to work a bit harder to discover who/what/where the baddies really are.
Well, according to the rules, detect chaos functions just like detect evil, save that it detects chaotic creatures instead of evil ones. So RAW seems to say that it undead would show up as "Extra Chaotic". As far as the utility of detect chaos, well it can ferret out chaotic people who are claiming to be lawful (such as the servants of a chaotic evil god trying to infiltrate the clergy of a lawful good one, for example.)

As somebody else mentioned, paladins in Ravenloft can also detect evil outsiders. Perhaps, if one were to change up the ability, it would be that paladins could detect only really unnatural evil, such as outsiders with the evil subtype or environmental evils like sinkholes or phantasmagoria, as has already been suggested. Most mundane or low-grade supernatural evils might not register.
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

The Lesser Evil wrote:So RAW seems to say that it undead would show up as "Extra Chaotic".
I guess this is the assumption under scrutiny. In older editions of DnD, undead were almost uniformly chaotic evil, and if that still holds in your campaign, then a "detect chaos" power for a PC means it's useful in detecting undead too.

It's been a while since I've looked at 3.5 ed so I don't know the RAW for that. But conceptually this may give a problem with mindless servitor undead, which may lack the necessary mental functions to show up as any ethical alignment apart from neutral.

The ultimate question is: how do you want to treat your undead? Do you want the paladin to be able to magically ferret out the mook undead, while giving more important self-willed undead (the vampire lord, the ancient dead priest, etc.) a fair chance at escaping detection?

A few possibilities:

1. Self-willed undead have an alignment, and it might not be chaotic. Azalin is a good example of this - by RAW, he's lawful.
2. Mindless undead either have no alignment, or show up as neutral. This proofs them against detection.
3. Mindless undead have whatever alignment their controller has (because the controller dominates them mentally). This could open them up to detection if the controller is also chaotic.
4. The detection may not be 100% accurate either. Highly intelligent self-willed undead (and possibly even their controlled mooks!) may get an opposed roll to resist detection. They may be able to "feign mindlessness" or "feign lawfulness" if they're aware of the threat and want to spend time bypassing it.

Just some ideas. Not all of these will work for everybody and not all of them are even mutually compatible with each other. They also almost certainly break the RAW... but I really don't feel too bad about that at all.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

High Priest Mikhal wrote:
ewancummins wrote:I've only ever seen one paladin in 3E Ravenloft. He wasn't in the game very long, but I seem to recall he did detect some chaotic aligned foes, yes.

Paladins aren't neutral good or chaotic good, they are lawful good. Detect chaos helps them keep tabs on the opponents of law and order. Of course, a wise paladin realizes that not all chaotic types are evil, and so he exercises mercy and restraint as appropriate.

I harbor some doubts as to whether the nine point alignment system is desirable in Ravenloft. I think the whole thing could be replaced with a simple, tripartite good/neutral/evil arrangement. .Alignment cannot be detected by any direct means (there are no working no detect evil spells/class abilities). Indirect clues are possible; some special people can recognize a sinkhole of evil as a warp in reality, and if you trick the villain into picking up a holy sword his hand may be burned, etc.. Law and chaos subtypes disappear. Gothics are about Good versus Evil, and the Morcockian stuff may be a bit off the mark.
YMMV
In Unearthed Arcana there are rules for CG, LE, and CE paladins (champions of freedom, tyrrany, and slaughter, respectively). There's also the Holy Avenger PrC in Complete Divine that is very paladin-like, even allowing ex-paladin levels to augment features. More options for heroes and villains.

I have to disagree on the nine point alignment being undesirable, at least in my games. It's a foil for those paladins who, unaware that good and evil really do exist, fall prey to moral certainty and fall from grace when hubris blinds them. That ethical alignment can be detected, but not moral, leads to ignorance and arrogance. That amplifies the moral quandries paladins face; their trusty detect evil ability doesn't work as normal, so they have to learn to read people and trust their instincts. Just as paladins in other worlds shouldn't slaughter someone just because they register as evil, in Ravenloft they're denied even that certainty and must instead face the tough realities of what it means to be a paladin without any shortcuts. That makes for excellent role-playing.

Also I really believe the paladin's alignment should depend on the god he/she serves. I worked it out with my DM that I am a Lawful Neutral Paladin. For I think a god of Death would be quite neutral in matters, except when it comes to necromancers, and Undead. Those are like the unforgivable crimes to my paladin. XD

Ravenloft would be an interesting setting for him to be thrown into, but unforunately, I am the Ravenloft DM so I doubt the land of mists will sweep him up any time soon. I know the setting would drive him to hunt monsters that i'm sure of, and in my head he kind of fits the setting, maybe i'll find a PbP one of these days to throw him in here.... was in one of them but i fell off the map for awhile so *shrugs*

Anyways, yeah there's a few paladin's that don't follow the always Lawful Good.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

I'm in the 'paladins are always LG' camp, but I don't mind other classes of 'holy warriors' with different alignments.

That's definitely a YMMV area, of course.

Zilfer, have you checked out the 'A Plethora of Paladins' article in Dragon? You might like it. It is written for AD&D 1E, but I believe it was updated for 3E in the Dragon Compendium. (I'm not sure which edition you use).

The original article may be found in Dragon magazine # 106.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

ewancummins wrote:I'm in the 'paladins are always LG' camp, but I don't mind other classes of 'holy warriors' with different alignments.

That's definitely a YMMV area, of course.

Zilfer, have you checked out the 'A Plethora of Paladins' article in Dragon? You might like it. It is written for AD&D 1E, but I believe it was updated for 3E in the Dragon Compendium. (I'm not sure which edition you use).

The original article may be found in Dragon magazine # 106.
I've always felt there could be a class called Templar, that works as a paladin on non-LG alignments with options such as Smite Chaos, etc. However, I agree with Ewancummins - paladins are always LG, and while there are other possible holy warriors out there with other alignments, they aren't called paladins (as they are a specifically Lawful Good divine martial class and not just a holy warrior concept.)
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

ewancummins wrote:I'm in the 'paladins are always LG' camp, but I don't mind other classes of 'holy warriors' with different alignments.

That's definitely a YMMV area, of course.

Zilfer, have you checked out the 'A Plethora of Paladins' article in Dragon? You might like it. It is written for AD&D 1E, but I believe it was updated for 3E in the Dragon Compendium. (I'm not sure which edition you use).

The original article may be found in Dragon magazine # 106.

I'll have to see if I can find it anywhere online or something. I play 3.0/3.5. We try to stick mostly 3.5 but we have some house rules of our own we play by like i think any other table.

I'm ok with you not wanting to call other "holy warriors" paladins, but that is what they are to other faiths. A Paladin may follow laws that aren't 'just' in the eyes of another religion is how i can see the moral alignment being anywhere from Lawful Good/Lawful Neutral/Lawful Evil.

Outside of those alignments it's much harder to justify being a "paladin" anymore, though I guess if a society is chaotic enough. Bad Alignments, the more you think about them the more they don't make sense! xD

Anyways I will definately try to take a look, I think I may have stumbled across what you were talking about. I think they had a different type of "paladin" for each alignment in that dragon book or something like that.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

MichaelTumey wrote:
ewancummins wrote:I'm in the 'paladins are always LG' camp, but I don't mind other classes of 'holy warriors' with different alignments.

That's definitely a YMMV area, of course.

Zilfer, have you checked out the 'A Plethora of Paladins' article in Dragon? You might like it. It is written for AD&D 1E, but I believe it was updated for 3E in the Dragon Compendium. (I'm not sure which edition you use).

The original article may be found in Dragon magazine # 106.
I've always felt there could be a class called Templar, that works as a paladin on non-LG alignments with options such as Smite Chaos, etc. However, I agree with Ewancummins - paladins are always LG, and while there are other possible holy warriors out there with other alignments, they aren't called paladins (as they are a specifically Lawful Good divine martial class and not just a holy warrior concept.)

I got a curious question for you, two not to get off topic.

What can you show me historyically that is a paladin? I mean when you say paladin what instantly pops into mind?

For most people (in Washington State out of all my friends) it's a Templar Knight from the Crusades Era. I'd like to point out that these Templar are far from Lawful Good. xD

(not to start a war or anything just curious of your oppinions :D)


Edit: Oh and I appologize for the double post!
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Zilfer wrote:when you say paladin what instantly pops into mind?
Oddly enough, I looked this up. The etymology apparently comes from Sanskrit or Hindi, one of the languages in the Indian subcontinent, and meant some sort of divinely appointed person there.

I seem to recall it was a similar thing to the term "avatar", which is also a Sanskrit word meaning a divine embodiment.

The current understanding seems to be more towards a European knight in shining armor though.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

I can answer this one with certainty.

The word 'paladin' comes from palatinus , or officer of the palace . In the Matter of France, Charlemagne’s noble champions are referred to as paladins; Count Roland, Ogier the Dane, Oliver, etc. These stories are only partly based on real people and places- they are mostly fantasy (Much like the stories of Arthur and the Round table).


http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=paladin


The literary cycle around Charlemagne’s paladins was formed by- and helped to form- the Western Christian ideal of chivalry.

This is also true of the Matter of Britain, of course.


Poul Anderson liked the old stories of Charlemagne’s paladins so much that he incorporated elements of these stories into his fantasy novel,. Three Hearts and Three Lions.
Guess what's on the Appendix N reading list? Yup, Gygax loved the classics. :)

So, when Zilfer writes about the historical Templars, he's missing the literary inspiration of the paladin class. It's based on the historical/literary/religious ideal, not the historical reality.


Of course, Zilfer should interpret the class however he likes. I'm just explaining the historical, linguistic, literary, and religious roots of the paladin class in D&D. Nothing in my post should be construed as saying that alternate interpretations are 'wrongbadfun.'
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Post Reply