The Saw in Ravenloft

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Rock of the Fraternity
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 6844
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Rock of the Fraternity »

But the people who are executed by the state are - nowadays, in the west - killed in a swift, relatively humane manner. Heck, they could probably do it even quicker by poisoning their last meal with something very swift-acting, if not for the requirement that the execution must be seen to happen.
Welcome to my webcomic, Sarcantasy.
You can read it here:

Comicfury; Webtoon

Come drop by and leave a comment; you'll make my day.
User avatar
Jack the Reaper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Jul 06, 2009 7:28 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Jack the Reaper »

Rock wrote:But the people who are executed by the state are - nowadays, in the west - killed in a swift, relatively humane manner. Heck, they could probably do it even quicker by poisoning their last meal with something very swift-acting, if not for the requirement that the execution must be seen to happen.
Right, but sometimes one feels it is simply not enough. Would such a swift, painless death be all what people like Hitler, Jigsaw, Hannibal Lecter or Vlad Drakov deserve? I don't think so (unless you trust Hell to complete the rest of the job after you deliver them there). Eye for an eye, wound for a wound, and torture for a torture - that's the rule I identify with.
The Reaper's riddle:

"Im ata yachol likro et ze, ata yode'a et ha'emet."

If you can read it, you know the truth.
User avatar
The Lesser Evil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1552
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by The Lesser Evil »

Jack the Reaper wrote:
Rock wrote:But the people who are executed by the state are - nowadays, in the west - killed in a swift, relatively humane manner. Heck, they could probably do it even quicker by poisoning their last meal with something very swift-acting, if not for the requirement that the execution must be seen to happen.
Right, but sometimes one feels it is simply not enough. Would such a swift, painless death be all what people like Hitler, Jigsaw, Hannibal Lecter or Vlad Drakov deserve? I don't think so (unless you trust Hell to complete the rest of the job after you deliver them there). Eye for an eye, wound for a wound, and torture for a torture - that's the rule I identify with.
We may have to agree to disagree here, but the attitude of simply not enough to me seems like one of excess, even in the guise of justice. Justice is different from revenge or vengeance because it is more or less impartial. Vengeance is not. You are right that people must be held accountable for their crimes, however, holding people accountable is not the same as the relativity of one upping their crimes back onto them. Who would benefit from raping a rapist? What benefit is there to be gained from torturing a torturer?

Dark avengers may be "heroic" in a sense that they may be more so than their opposition. However, that relativity does not make them good people. As for eye for an eye, Hammurabi wrote that it should be the absolute most that should be applied, not the least.
User avatar
Jack the Reaper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Jul 06, 2009 7:28 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Jack the Reaper »

The Lesser Evil wrote: You are right that people must be held accountable for their crimes, however, holding people accountable is not the same as the relativity of one upping their crimes back onto them. Who would benefit from raping a rapist? What benefit is there to be gained from torturing a torturer?
By speaking about benefit, you put the question again in terms of utilitarianism. But justice, IMO at least, is not only about benefits and utility - it is just something that has to be done. An act of evil taints the world in some metaphysical sense, and only proper retribution can erase this taint and bring the world back to balance - even if nobody benefits from it, or even knows about it.

To use an example from one of my philosophy lessons, a world in which Hitler died in a terrible, long agony from some wasting disease
is a better world than the one in which he just shoot himself in the head - even if in both cases he was alone in his bunker and nobody knew about his demise. Why is it better so? Can't say too much - it's just how the world is, that's all.

But as you said, we don't have to agree about it.
The Reaper's riddle:

"Im ata yachol likro et ze, ata yode'a et ha'emet."

If you can read it, you know the truth.
User avatar
Rock of the Fraternity
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 6844
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Rock of the Fraternity »

The world is not better if an evildoer suffers a prolonged, gruesome death, rather than dying quickly. It is just a world where there exists a chance that someone enjoys the evildoer's suffering.

And when good people enjoy the suffering of even their enemies, that goodness is damaged. For the rest of their lives, there will be at least a seed of doubt as to their own goodness when they think back to the day that they did as their enemy had done.
Welcome to my webcomic, Sarcantasy.
You can read it here:

Comicfury; Webtoon

Come drop by and leave a comment; you'll make my day.
User avatar
The Lesser Evil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1552
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by The Lesser Evil »

Jack the Reaper wrote:
The Lesser Evil wrote: You are right that people must be held accountable for their crimes, however, holding people accountable is not the same as the relativity of one upping their crimes back onto them. Who would benefit from raping a rapist? What benefit is there to be gained from torturing a torturer?
By speaking about benefit, you put the question again in terms of utilitarianism. But justice, IMO at least, is not only about benefits and utility - it is just something that has to be done. An act of evil taints the world in some metaphysical sense, and only proper retribution can erase this taint and bring the world back to balance - even if nobody benefits from it, or even knows about it.

To use an example from one of my philosophy lessons, a world in which Hitler died in a terrible, long agony from some wasting disease
is a better world than the one in which he just shoot himself in the head - even if in both cases he was alone in his bunker and nobody knew about his demise. Why is it better so? Can't say too much - it's just how the world is, that's all.

But as you said, we don't have to agree about it.
Though I might not agree with what you are suggesting, I am interested in hearing your view of how inflicting suffering beyond death wipes out the taint of the injustice or makes the world a better place. The crime is still on the record, the criminal is not changed, the victims still suffer or are dead. I only see it darkening or weighing heavily on the mind and soul of those who inflict the punishment. If you are arguing from a cosmic point of view, I trust that a higher power beyond man will address any imbalances that haven't been addressed by bringing heinous to trial, execution, and/or life sentences after the offender's death. However, I'm of the opinion that two wrongs don't make a right. But I'm always willing to hear different perspectives on justice and the like.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

Jack the Reaper wrote:
The Lesser Evil wrote: You are right that people must be held accountable for their crimes, however, holding people accountable is not the same as the relativity of one upping their crimes back onto them. Who would benefit from raping a rapist? What benefit is there to be gained from torturing a torturer?
By speaking about benefit, you put the question again in terms of utilitarianism. But justice, IMO at least, is not only about benefits and utility - it is just something that has to be done. An act of evil taints the world in some metaphysical sense, and only proper retribution can erase this taint and bring the world back to balance - even if nobody benefits from it, or even knows about it.

To use an example from one of my philosophy lessons, a world in which Hitler died in a terrible, long agony from some wasting disease
is a better world than the one in which he just shoot himself in the head - even if in both cases he was alone in his bunker and nobody knew about his demise. Why is it better so? Can't say too much - it's just how the world is, that's all.

But as you said, we don't have to agree about it.

I agree with Jack the Reaper here, there's quite a bit someone would want to do to someone who has commited such atroisities. We would wish much ill will upon people such as Hitler.

Though to the question what does it benefit? I'm not saying rapists should be raped, though i do think something equally horrible should happen to them. What benefit do we get from the current method?

I mean most victims/friends/family of the victims are not 100% satisfied with just seeing someone go to jail. A lot of people think it's letting them off easy. Everyone has their own oppinion as to what should be done.

The thing that does come out of such revenge is usually satisfaction. Though they have a common cliche that revenge will never fill the hole that your left with. (I think it fills it part way :P)

Such a way is definately, a darker and smaller road to walk.

(see's new post)

I'm not sure Jack the Reaper meant that the revenge would take place outside of the law. Merely suggesting that the law could possibly take it further.

As I mentioned before I don't think either way brings a full catharsis, but who's to say one way is better than another?

To each his own.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Jack the Reaper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Jul 06, 2009 7:28 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Jack the Reaper »

I'm afraid it would be difficult to me to discuss this philosophical topic lengthly in english, which is not my first language; but you can read the following article about the theory of punishment in the online Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/punishment/

I will only say that there are two main views about justice and punishment (and also about morality in general) - the utalitarian or consequentionalist view, and the retributive or deontolgical view. The first is based on considerations of benefits and favorable results, and the second believes in perfect duties and obligations, which exist independently of their outcomes (e.g you shall not kill an innocent, even if it will save the life of 10 other innocents). Both attitudes have strong intuitions and arguments in their favor, and the debate will probably last forever.

When it comes specifically to punishment, I can say that my rather-retributive approach has to do with my wider theological and cosmological beliefs. It is based on biblical concepts, such as "So you shall not pollute the land in which you are; for blood pollutes the land and no expiation can be made for the land for the blood that is shed on it, except by the blood of him who shed it" (Book of Numbers, 35, 33). I also feels that it is intuitively right. It might be a difference between jewish and christian outlooks.
The Reaper's riddle:

"Im ata yachol likro et ze, ata yode'a et ha'emet."

If you can read it, you know the truth.
User avatar
Rock of the Fraternity
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 6844
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Rock of the Fraternity »

"An eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth leaves us all toothless and blind."
Welcome to my webcomic, Sarcantasy.
You can read it here:

Comicfury; Webtoon

Come drop by and leave a comment; you'll make my day.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

^unless you take more then just an eye and a tooth.... There comes a point where you can't take what was taken from you.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
The Lesser Evil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1552
Joined: Sat Apr 03, 2004 3:17 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by The Lesser Evil »

Zilfer wrote: I agree with Jack the Reaper here, there's quite a bit someone would want to do to someone who has commited such atroisities. We would wish much ill will upon people such as Hitler.

Though to the question what does it benefit? I'm not saying rapists should be raped, though i do think something equally horrible should happen to them. What benefit do we get from the current method?

I mean most victims/friends/family of the victims are not 100% satisfied with just seeing someone go to jail. A lot of people think it's letting them off easy. Everyone has their own oppinion as to what should be done.

The thing that does come out of such revenge is usually satisfaction. Though they have a common cliche that revenge will never fill the hole that your left with. (I think it fills it part way :P)
Some of what you says rings true, concern for the feelings of the victims is another concern we must take into here. It would be an interesting study to see how far victims would want to go in seeing punishment done.

As for famous heinous criminals, I may be weak of stomach here, but I couldn't imagine personally getting joy out of inflicting or even watching the torture of the worst of offenders. I don't want them to be tortured; I just want them dispensed with. Any more seems to me to stray away from the path of justice into the realm of indulgence.

I don't agree that watching somebody being tortured will help anybody achieve any sort of satisfaction beyond the most fleeting kind. To reach a sense of closure with something means coming to a sense of peace with the world, including those who have wronged you. Instigating needless suffering upon others muddies this process, as you must spend the rest of your life justifying it. Furthermore, to the victims of a crime, I'd imagine there will never be any equivocation. So indulging in torture or other punishments beyond death seems to be trying to satisfy a hunger that will never (can never) be fulfilled.

I don't begrudge people for having these feelings of unsatisfaction against those who have wronged them. However, I don't think it is right to act on them beyond justice and into vengeance, nor that pursuing an avenue of revenge will ultimately lead to a life of peace and recovery for the victims.
Jack the Reaper wrote:I'm afraid it would be difficult to me to discuss this philosophical topic lengthly in english, which is not my first language; but you can read the following article about the theory of punishment in the online Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/punishment/

I will only say that there are two main views about justice and punishment (and also about morality in general) - the utalitarian or consequentionalist view, and the retributive or deontolgical view. The first is based on considerations of benefits and favorable results, and the second believes in perfect duties and obligations, which exist independently of their outcomes (e.g you shall not kill an innocent, even if it will save the life of 10 other innocents). Both attitudes have strong intuitions and arguments in their favor, and the debate will probably last forever.

When it comes specifically to punishment, I can say that my rather-retributive approach has to do with my wider theological and cosmological beliefs. It is based on biblical concepts, such as "So you shall not pollute the land in which you are; for blood pollutes the land and no expiation can be made for the land for the blood that is shed on it, except by the blood of him who shed it" (Book of Numbers, 35, 33). I also feels that it is intuitively right. It might be a difference between jewish and christian outlooks.
I see, thank you for providing some context. So If I understand correctly, your perspective comes from a duty to set things right, such that scale is evened beyond what it might end up for the individual participants. if this is so, then to a certain extent I agree. We as people have certain obligations and duties we must fulfill, regardless of what likely outcomes might be most beneficial to us. Therefore, some acts are inherently evil, regardless of the intent or aims behind them (the aforementioned murder of one innocent to save many, for example).

To me, every person has a purpose or duty to try to help his fellow man, and attempt to ensure that good is promoted rather than evil; this to me goes beyond simply correcting evils or righting wrongs. It also behooves every person not to engage in acts that are inherently evil, which for me includes torture and the like. And if a person indulges in these evils, are they not polluting the land themselves? In the quote above, is not the shedding of the offender's blood satisfied with the offender's death?

Ironic given my screenname here :wink: , but I also believe in the duty not to commit certain acts in order to address other acts. In this case, from my perspective, torturing somebody is never excusable, regardless of the context, much like murdering one innocent to saving many. Because one act is inherently unjustifiable, it cannot be retributive to mirror it, and going so far to duplicate or equivocate certain acts to me seems to stray into the realm of indulgent revenge and away from righteous duties.

I feel like your perspective has some validity to it, but I disagree in how far it is just and dutiful to pursue that avenue. Death and/or incarceration of the guilty seem to me to fulfill those duties without breaking others that require the refrain from inherently undesirable acts.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

Indeed, though I may wish torcher upon such people, or ill will I really doubt i'd watch such a thing take place. Or if i was a victim, I don't think i'd watch, i'd be the one opting to do the torchering.

Now these are just base human emotions that edge on an animalistic side (or i seem to think so at least). I would having never been in such a grave situation probably have a scewed view of what i think someone in such a situation would feel. I can say however when hearing stories about bad people and then ending up in a fate that "suites them" whether it's torcher dying in a horrible way or some other. I get a sort of 'grim satsifcation' out of knowing they got what they deserved. (at least in my eyes, obviously there's people who believe all life is sacred.) I can understand both views, but it doesn't change the way i feel inwardly about it.

I do indeed agree it would be interesting to see how far someone would go to torcher in the name of "justice" or vengence if they knew there was no restrictions and they wouldn't get 'caught' in a manner of speaking. It would also be interesting to see how many people have the balls to actually do it. I may say that's how i feel, but I am curious if I would act upon that feeling. :D

To the point where you don't think people would get the satsification, I can tell you with reassurance that while YOU personally may not feel this way, there are people in the world that will get this. I get it on some level or another, now whether this is normal or how do i put this.... Not sure the exact word i'm looking for here so i'm going to say slightly insane, or an altered form of mind. Is up to question. Maybe there's something wrong with people that think this way? or visa versa. We'll never know because most oppinions are never exactly the same.

Believe there is a saying, ask a 100 people about _________(insert topic) and you'll receive a 100 different answers.

In conclusion, I do agree that we shouldn't go past the boundries of the Law for Justice. That doesn't mean however that I or other people think that they shouldn't be punished more.

I think most people when seeking some sort of "payback" want to inflict 'double' the amount of pain inflicted on them. It then might become a game of "knuckles".
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Rock of the Fraternity
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 6844
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Rock of the Fraternity »

People are going to want to inflict misery upon those who have hurt them, hurt their loved ones, or offended their sensibilities beyond their tolerance to endure, and they are going to want to heap misery on them to twice or thrice or a hundredfold the amount they have suffered, be it directly or vicariously. I know this and understand it.

But it is not right and it is not wise. If an evil stands before you and it can not be redeemed in any way, then yes, it must be cut down. You cut it down quickly, before it has a chance to spread. Because if you wield the same tools that the thing that hurt you so has used, then the evil is spreading. You will be forever tainted by the knowledge that you, yourself, are capable of inflicting torment on another, just like the one who hurt you.

You may speak of justification and satisfaction, but that is a very dangerous line of reasoning. The one who inflicted the first hurt probably felt perfectly justified in doing so, and most likely derived great satisfaction from it. Yes, yes, I know, he or she is a monster who hurt you, blighted your soul. But there is a difference beteen cutting such a thing out of this world, and letting it become your example in the way you remove it.
Justification and satisfaction are nebulous concepts, if you give them a hard look. Justice should be hard and clearly-defined, or it becomes a tool to slick talkers and double-dealers.
Welcome to my webcomic, Sarcantasy.
You can read it here:

Comicfury; Webtoon

Come drop by and leave a comment; you'll make my day.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

Rock wrote:People are going to want to inflict misery upon those who have hurt them, hurt their loved ones, or offended their sensibilities beyond their tolerance to endure, and they are going to want to heap misery on them to twice or thrice or a hundredfold the amount they have suffered, be it directly or vicariously. I know this and understand it.

But it is not right and it is not wise. If an evil stands before you and it can not be redeemed in any way, then yes, it must be cut down. You cut it down quickly, before it has a chance to spread. Because if you wield the same tools that the thing that hurt you so has used, then the evil is spreading. You will be forever tainted by the knowledge that you, yourself, are capable of inflicting torment on another, just like the one who hurt you.

You may speak of justification and satisfaction, but that is a very dangerous line of reasoning. The one who inflicted the first hurt probably felt perfectly justified in doing so, and most likely derived great satisfaction from it. Yes, yes, I know, he or she is a monster who hurt you, blighted your soul. But there is a difference beteen cutting such a thing out of this world, and letting it become your example in the way you remove it.
Justification and satisfaction are nebulous concepts, if you give them a hard look. Justice should be hard and clearly-defined, or it becomes a tool to slick talkers and double-dealers.

Heh, "Justice" now is still at full of "slick talkers, and double dealers."

There are so many cases that the criminal wins it's rediculous. Man falls through roof of house he was scaling for a window and is trapped in garage with no way out because it's locked for 3 days. He sues and wins.

>.> and indeed I agree it would be wiped out clean but the problem is most evil isn't ousted quick and efficently. Hell the Green river killer bargained his way to life in prison and out of the death penalty by using the locations of where he buried or got rid of bodies. He has about 100 women killed up here in washington and they STILL don't think he's revealed everything. My oppinion is they should just put a bullet between the guy's head. Unforunately, they kept him alive to help sooth the families so they could actually have a body to bury.

I don't think you become tainted with the knowledge that you have the capability to do this to another person. Most people are aware of it on one level or another.

I'll conclude with that I believe we hold a very similiar view that yes doing such evil to evil does not make it better for the world.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by A G Thing »

Wow... From saw to the justification of retributive acts against wrong doers...

Still there are some questions I wonder how people would answer...

1: Would you kill an innocent to save yourself if it was the only way to guarantee that one of you lives? Would you let them kill you? What if both of you are innocent and it is fate that forces the decision?

2: So to some killing one innocent to save ten is excusable... So what of killing someone guilty of something else? Does a murderer/criminal of heinous crimes become less of a person?

3: When is it justified to kill anyone? When they attack you? When you feel threatened? When you have the support of the law?

4: What confirms the guilt of a person? If guilt can be confirmed then is it not something open to interpretation based on the circumstance or is it just a view of black and white with high stakes that determines morality?

5: If a person has the information to save everyone in the world and refuses to talk does torture to recover that info become legitimized for such a circumstance? If so is it only a value of high stakes or could it be to save one person you care for?

6: What level of payback would be sufficient to balance these intangible scales of right and wrong in the world? Excessive payback, eye for an eye, or efficient ending of the situation?

7: Who decides what is fair punishment? The victims? An impartial third party? A societal construct on correct punishment?

My answers are in the spoiler tag...
VIEW CONTENT:
1: No but I would consider sacrifice of myself or if they wished to they could sacrifice themselves but I would not take their life no matter the stakes to myself. Nothing but me forces me to act and I cannot be forced to act... I may always choose to do nothing and thus I am never robbed of free will...

2: You cannot be forced to kill... Once again sacrifice is the only option here that allows for a moral outcome... A criminal no matter the crime or offense does not become less of a person but they should be watched so they do not become a danger. The moment they become a real and present threat to your life or others in an observable way that requires swift action to stop you have all right to stop them at any level you deem necessary in the most efficient and self protecting manner you can. This never gives you the right to force suffering upon them if a better option is available to you at the time. The moment they are stopped you need not act further nor are you responsible for their welfare if you feel at risk giving aid to them. As for killing to save others if there is no way to opt for self sacrifice and another will not opt to end their life then you cannot excuse killing another if their intentional actions did not place you in such a state. If killing the man who traps you accidentally will save the rest of the group you have murdered him to your convenience even if you justify that it was not completely convenient it still saved you at cost to him with out his consent.

3: The moment they become a real and present threat to your life or others in an observable way that requires swift action to stop you have all right to stop them at any level you deem necessary in the most efficient and self protecting manner you can. This never gives you the right to force suffering upon them if a better option is available to you at the time. The moment they are stopped you need not act further nor are you responsible for their welfare if you feel at risk giving aid to them. The law does not justify the actions of people it only debates the response to the consequences of such actions. A law that says that "no one should have a gun" is debating that guns give rise to opportunities to commit violence but it is so blanket that it implies that all violence with a gun is unwarranted in any circumstance. Thus if only police have guns under the law they are an exception to this law. But once the gun has been shot and killed someone other laws are bought forth and the absolute authority of these laws is derived from the values of the people that administer them. The value of the person is different to those close to them than what someone distant would think. Thus if intelligent life is valued so highly the closer it is to you the measure of whether to end that life by application of the law must always be a divorced one. Divorcing yourself from pain is a comfort, comfort is a gain to your state of mind, thus killing those under the scrutiny of the law for any reason is an act of convenience that is unconscionable. You should restrain those captured and give them the barest minimum of what is needed to maintain their own life in the event of sentences worthy of a life or more prison sentence. Should that act to kill in any way they should simply be granted swift death if they do not surrender and swift death again should the abuse the trust to do so again!

4: Guilt is confirmed upon evidence, witnesses, confessions and full disclosed intentions... Since life is complex a criminal will seldom believe that they were not justified in their actions or at least in the deserving of what ever gain they get from illicit activities. Confessions and full disclosure of intentions in a truthful manner will usually never be 100% full thus we can never be sure. Thus guilt is always to within a reasonable doubt. Confine the guilty but never execute them... In the real world an innocent man may be pardoned but he cannot be resurrected. Executing even one prisoner that is innocent makes all of those who support such laws alive at the time murderers.

5: Torture against a person who is has the info to save the world is justified under the pretense that they by their continued and willful silence will kill everyone else. Torture against one person to save another person is justified in the sense that the same scenario plays out but the stakes are different. Suffice it to say however that torture in either of these situations is not moral unless it is truly the only option and it is done only to the intent to get the info without the actual intention to do permanent harm if you cannot confirm they have the info you need. If they admit to having the info by gloating but do not reveal it then it is moral to torture to get the info doing no permanent damage but blustering and threatening to try and get it. Still the line to where you risk their lives for the info is so precariously thin that should the damage become severe enough and lasting or they must be revived you most likely have gone too far.

6: If immediate action needed then simple death or immobilization to end the threat. If they are alive confinement until guilt or innocence confirmed. If guilty continued confinement with no privileges inherent to societies excesses but neither should they be stripped of humanity or the chance to learn to be better unless they prove unwilling to do such peacefully. Allow them to provide for themselves and learn to interact with others in a more peaceful way. Still do not lighten the responsibility of the prisoner to respect others lives. If they threaten kill or contain them as efficiently as possible and then decide the level of the infraction and continue the confinement.

7: Punishment is based on the understanding of objects and people. Objects are bartered on value hence that value is transferable. Objects thus can be taken from the criminal to replace a set material value of the victim. People as having no value cannot be exchanged nor can quality become an issue other than the excesses that such objects or influences can a bring to a persons experience. Thus no matter the extent a punishing response to a crime should be the same for victims and criminals with no exceptions or stipulations to be allowed. A man who murders twenty if properly restrained should be treated the same as the man who murdered one. Guilt or innocence should be determined for both no matter the length of inquiry as lives value cannot be measured. The living who handle these affairs do not have to do more than determine the innocence or guilt of the accused. They do so out of sacrifice of their time to hold an expected standard of decency commensurate with the indeterminate nature of the value of life.
So yeah go ahead and answer some of these questions for yourself... Maybe add some to the list... They get you thinking on what you really believe in these situations!
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
Post Reply