Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

Yes, the paladins that pop to mind are Charlemagne's paladins.

I've already said, I can see the justification of a Templar class, being a holy warrior that is not Lawful Good, however, a paladin is not a templar. The legend of the paladin preceeds templars by almost 500 years. Templar legend begins in the crusades, and then the driving out the Moors from Spain, and the birth of the Inquisition.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

MichaelTumey wrote:Yes, the paladins that pop to mind are Charlemagne's paladins.

I've already said, I can see the justification of a Templar class, being a holy warrior that is not Lawful Good, however, a paladin is not a templar. The legend of the paladin preceeds templars by almost 500 years. Templar legend begins in the crusades, and then the driving out the Moors from Spain, and the birth of the Inquisition.

To be fair, the historical Templars got a bad rap from a greedy French king who wanted their wealth and a weak pope who didn't stick up for them. There's really no evidence they were heretics, idolaters, sodomites, or any of that. The trials were rigged.


There's also the fact that crusading to free the Holy Land was what most medieval Western Christians would have considered "LAFWUL GOOD" behavior. You can't expect medievals to hold 'modern' politically correct attitudes about these things (Heck, I think the Crusades began as an essentially justified defensive reaction, and I'm not even baptized). The Muslims were the Bad Guys, and had attacked the eastern and southern regions of Christendom many times. The Templars and other crusading orders were defending Christendom.

Did it look different on the other end of a crusader's sword? Sure- but does anyone seriously think that the AD&D alignment system is a good way of understanding the real world?
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

^Indeed.

Though, trying to make a system that works 100% of the time for something like morals is quite silly as well, since from different religions/creeds/countries something may seem evil/chaotic compared to how the social norm is there.

Guess i'll have to look up on these a bit more. :D

Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

ewancummins wrote:Sure- but does anyone seriously think that the AD&D alignment system is a good way of understanding the real world?
I've always wondered about that. To their credit, the 3.0 books about Good and Evil (Book of Exalted Deeds and Book of Vile Darkness) came with a hefty warning that it takes some maturity to deal with the concepts inside and it's not meant to be a treatise on realworld morality. At heart, DnD started off as a tactical wargame and its later incarnations did present various enemy races whose sole purpose was supposed to be cannonfodder for the heroes (kobolds, orcs, goblins, etc.).

Ravenloft's Black Box (or it could have been the Forbidden Lore boxed set, I can't remember) also acknowledges the difficulty in judging something objectively in moral terms. The main example I can recall is grave robbing - is it a morally bad act? Do you go by the motives of the grave robber or the deceased occupant? Do you go by the current cultural norms or the cultural norms of the interring culture? etc.

I think it's really interesting that one of the longest threads in the Fraternity forums was dealing with the moral question of whether it's morally acceptable for a Lawful Good PC to kill the juvenile offspring of a werewolf. This generated a large amount of discussion, with alignment and how it reflects realworld morality.

For the record, I agree with you - I don't think Good/Evil really translates well in an RPG, because they tend to view them as objectively provable qualities and I generally view them as highly dependent on your subjective outlook. When I first bought into Third Edition, I tried to sidestep moral alignment as much as possible, but so many spells, magic items, and powers depend on them for their definition. My ruleset change was motivated in part by this: GURPS foregoes alignment and instead focuses on behavioral traits of each person.

I've taken some steps towards bringing Dark Powers checks in line with this viewpoint too.

Paladin question: Back on track, another possible change to paladins would be to allow them to detect dangerous or malicious intent directed against them instead of evil. This is less dependent on an objective judgment of Good vs. Evil and more dependent on specific conscious attitude. This could also help the party out in a much more specific way than just detecting evil. (After all, plenty of situations exist where an "evil" person might want to help the PCs, or "good" person might want to harm or obstruct them.) This would translate into a divine "danger sense" where their deity is helping look out for them, without getting into the question of whether NPC X is evil.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

That is piercely why a game i was playing in grinded to a hault as I argued about morality/alignment in the DnD game saying what was lawful to one person isn't lawful to another. Good and evil is a point of view, I may be a super tight christian and think working on a sunday or doing anything but praying is evil/forbidden. Needless to say the DM didn't agree with my application of alignment though he offered no counter argument. As always GM is god while the session is going. (not that it mattered it was more of a random spree of the moment conversation/arguement)

I have let people I play with know, that they should check with their DM before playing "Lawful Good" or a Paladin because if you don't make sure you and your DM are on the same page you might run into troubles.

As of right now, I have a DM that again allowed me to play a paladin outside that Lawful Good restriction, since I worshiped Kelemvor. He changed my powers around a bit and since I even have an Orc follower who calls me all sorts of random names from Bonesword, to Deathstealer, to LifeSavior. (comes up with them all the time xD) Anyways back on topic to what HMB said...

That sounds reasonable enough but if you put it back on the subject of Undead, i think most undead would want to harm you no? at least the lesser undead would probably want to eat ya.

So it could work that way, and still be useful.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

Zilfer wrote:Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
Charlemagne is Charles the Great, Charles the Hammer, Charles Martel, the King of the Franks and the First Holy Roman Emperor. Basically he and his paladins went around on religious wars on a 'convert to Christianity or die!' expedition. He converted the Germans (Saxons) to Christianity (among other countries, into what became the Holy Roman Empire.) He removed the Lombards from being in charge of Italy, and returned much control of the Italian province to the pope. Charles essentially 'created Western Europe'.

He brought the chaos that was Europe since the fall of the Roman Empire into a controlled Catholic state.

Charlemagne's 12 Peers are the paladins of his realm, including Roland (Song of Roland). They recovered lost Christian artifacts stolen by the Moors in Spain and fought against the Moors (Sarecens) in an attempt to make Spain entirely Catholic.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

sounds like he was a busy man.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
Five
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 886
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2011 9:59 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Five »

MichaelTumey wrote:
Zilfer wrote:Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
Charlemagne is Charles the Great, Charles the Hammer, Charles Martel, the King of the Franks and the First Holy Roman Emperor. Basically he and his paladins went around on religious wars on a 'convert to Christianity or die!' expedition. He converted the Germans (Saxons) to Christianity (among other countries, into what became the Holy Roman Empire.) He removed the Lombards from being in charge of Italy, and returned much control of the Italian province to the pope. Charles essentially 'created Western Europe'.

He brought the chaos that was Europe since the fall of the Roman Empire into a controlled Catholic state.

Charlemagne's 12 Peers are the paladins of his realm, including Roland (Song of Roland). They recovered lost Christian artifacts stolen by the Moors in Spain and fought against the Moors (Sarecens) in an attempt to make Spain entirely Catholic.
Conversely, Charlemagne (his coronation) could also be considered to be an essential (puppet) cornerstone of the to-be Holy Roman Empire, or more to the point, the papacy's groundwork for establishing/solidifying ecclesiastical jurisdiction over the laity. Charlemagne's recorded life and deeds (his battles against the so-called "pagans") would then be called on almost three hundred years later in part to justify the right of christians (through the papacy's direction of course) to destroy those that would be considered "hostile" towards God and/or Christendom in general. Of course this repeated Christian rhetoric would later be known as the Crusades.

A tool for the church, for better and for worse. Depends on your faith I spose.

PC Paladins beware. How well do you -really- know your role in your service to your faith?

As to paladins detecting undead, we always used the paladin's ability to detect the presence of evil as a multi-tiered thing. Lower levels was just that, the ability to detect evil monsters and characters. But with exposure came experience, or, an increased sensitivity to what it was that they were feeling. So basically, if a paladin didn't combat a whole lot of undead, then they'd get a vague hit: evil lurking. But a paladin crusted with gravesoil would read their hit as detailed deja-vu...but only if they felt that same feeling before (survived a matched encounter). A new encounter (creature type) would mean a new obviously unfamiliar feeling, regardless of level. Intelligent undead were always vague hits, as were other sentient creatures. The uniqueness of their evil (constantly changing, or abstract applications of) is more than enough of a 'mask' to throw the holy hound off of any specific track.

As to alignment, these days I now tend to view the paladin as Lawful __ (god's equivalent). A paladin (to me and my homebrew) is the posterchild and very militant extension of any given religious organization. And soldiers aren't really known for their individuality. Therefore, they should be of alignment with its idealized version of its god/dogma. I mean, why would a selfish god reward a selfless individual? Or vice versa? The "good" in the paladin's lawfulness (to their faith), should read as "ideal (from the faith's POV)", not neccessarily as "moral good". "Detection of evil" therefore is really "detection of evil intent/harm". But homebrew aside, see above.
Last edited by Five on Wed Mar 07, 2012 9:11 pm, edited 3 times in total.
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."

- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
User avatar
Nathan of the FoS
Fiendish Enforcer
Fiendish Enforcer
Posts: 5247
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
Location: San Francisco CA

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Nathan of the FoS »

MichaelTumey wrote:
Zilfer wrote:Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
Charlemagne is Charles the Great, Charles the Hammer, Charles Martel, the King of the Franks and the First Holy Roman Emperor.
Actually, Charles Martel/Charles the Hammer, Prince of the Franks, is the grandfather of Charlemagne (Charles the Great, King of the Franks and the first Holy Roman Emperor). Between them (son of Martel, father of Magne) is Pepin the Short, so-called because he is often overlooked.

...Well, OK, that's not why they call him that. He was just not very tall. :P ;)
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Zilfer wrote:[Back] to what HMB said... [paladins detect malicious intent rather than "evil"]

That sounds reasonable enough but if you put it back on the subject of Undead, i think most undead would want to harm you no? at least the lesser undead would probably want to eat ya.

So it could work that way, and still be useful.
Exactly, that's pretty much the intended function.

Lesser undead usually lack the mental ability to desire anything except harm upon living PCs, so they'd almost constantly trigger a PC's danger sense. A self-willed undead might be smart enough to see other ways of dealing with them without actively wanting to harm them. NPCs like the Kargat and Strahd would very likely want to deal with the PCs peaceably first and only resort to violence if all else had failed.

This would protect the "VIP" NPC undead while allowing the mindless mook undead to be easily detected. Whatever works for your campaign.
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

Ironically it's D&D that we have to thank for the idea of the paladin as a holy warrior. Gary Gygax was the first to design the fantasy paladin and it's since spread to other games (Quest For Glory being my favorite, though WoW and other video/tabletop RPGs have run with the idea). We also have him to thank for blackguards (anti-paladins). It's off topic, but would a paladin of tyranny or slaughter gain the bonuses for ex-paladin levels if he became a blackguard? I don't think it works based on the reasoning of ex-paladin powers, but that just my opinion.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

MichaelTumey wrote:
Zilfer wrote:Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
Charlemagne is Charles the Great, Charles the Hammer, Charles Martel, the King of the Franks and the First Holy Roman Emperor. Basically he and his paladins went around on religious wars on a 'convert to Christianity or die!' expedition. He converted the Germans (Saxons) to Christianity (among other countries, into what became the Holy Roman Empire.) He removed the Lombards from being in charge of Italy, and returned much control of the Italian province to the pope. Charles essentially 'created Western Europe'.

He brought the chaos that was Europe since the fall of the Roman Empire into a controlled Catholic state.

Charlemagne's 12 Peers are the paladins of his realm, including Roland (Song of Roland). They recovered lost Christian artifacts stolen by the Moors in Spain and fought against the Moors (Sarecens) in an attempt to make Spain entirely Catholic.

Charles Martel was not Charles the Great/Charlemagne. He was Charles the Great's grandfather.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

Nathan of the FoS wrote:
MichaelTumey wrote:
Zilfer wrote:Edit: I'd never heard of Charleman so that's probably why me, and most people think european knights when someone says paladin. Anyone know what these knights of Charleman did that was so awesome? o.O'
Charlemagne is Charles the Great, Charles the Hammer, Charles Martel, the King of the Franks and the First Holy Roman Emperor.
Actually, Charles Martel/Charles the Hammer, Prince of the Franks, is the grandfather of Charlemagne (Charles the Great, King of the Franks and the first Holy Roman Emperor). Between them (son of Martel, father of Magne) is Pepin the Short, so-called because he is often overlooked.

...Well, OK, that's not why they call him that. He was just not very tall. :P ;)
Right.


Charlemagne= Carolus Magnus (in Latin) = 'Charles the Great'
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

High Priest Mikhal wrote:Ironically it's D&D that we have to thank for the idea of the paladin as a holy warrior. Gary Gygax was the first to design the fantasy paladin and it's since spread to other games (Quest For Glory being my favorite, though WoW and other video/tabletop RPGs have run with the idea). We also have him to thank for blackguards (anti-paladins). It's off topic, but would a paladin of tyranny or slaughter gain the bonuses for ex-paladin levels if he became a blackguard? I don't think it works based on the reasoning of ex-paladin powers, but that just my opinion.
The 'fantasy paladin' as a holy warrior predates D&D. What else is the Red Cross Knight in the Faerie Queene, or the medieval portrayal of Saint George as the dragonslayer?


For something close to the present, and with the word paladin used explicitly, check out Three Hearts and Three Lions. Gygax listed the book as inspirational material in Appendix N. Read it, and the links are pretty clear.


Here is a direct quotation from the novel.
Quite likely he was one of the Chosen, like Carl or Arthur or their greatest paladins. I do not mean a saint, but a warrior whom God has given more than common gifts and then put under a more than common burden.
I won't spoil it by telling more, but anyone who knows D&D and reads this novel will instantly recognize several things that influenced Gygax.


D&D has certainly popularized and modified fantasy elements from older sources, of course. It's also had a huge impact on video games.
Last edited by ewancummins on Fri Mar 09, 2012 1:01 am, edited 2 times in total.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

HuManBing wrote:
For the record, I agree with you - I don't think Good/Evil really translates well in an RPG, because they tend to view them as objectively provable qualities and I generally view them as highly dependent on your subjective outlook. When I first bought into Third Edition, I tried to sidestep moral alignment as much as possible, but so many spells, magic items, and powers depend on them for their definition. My ruleset change was motivated in part by this: GURPS foregoes alignment and instead focuses on behavioral traits of each person.
I didn't explain well, it seems. :|
You don't agree with me, you only think you do.


Ravenloft is a Gothic, and so it's basically about GOOD vs EVIL. That doesn't mean there are no shades of gray, but that Good and Evil are more than mere subjective viewpoints or relative judgments, they are fundamental parts of the universe. They are part of the order of being (Not that moral order in the real world is merely a subjective matter- it isn't. That's another issue, though). In Ravenloft, Good and Evil are always at work, always affecting the course of events. Even human bodies can be altered by moral forces. That's not a matter of personal judgement.

YMMV, but I think some degree of objective & game mechanical morality is vitally necessary for Ravenloft to work. Even more than most published D&D settings, an alignment system makes sense for Ravenloft. I'm just not sure it needs the added complexity of the Law and Chaos axis.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Post Reply