The Saw in Ravenloft

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

A G Thing wrote:Wow... From saw to the justification of retributive acts against wrong doers...

Still there are some questions I wonder how people would answer...

1: Would you kill an innocent to save yourself if it was the only way to guarantee that one of you lives? Would you let them kill you? What if both of you are innocent and it is fate that forces the decision?

If it was only a do or die thing, I would say I'd probably try to kill the other person. I don't know if i'd be happy with myself but at least i'd be alive. Only way i'd let them kill me is if I knew them and respect them alot more. My Girlfriend for example though I doubt she'd kill me so I'd probably have to kill myself to let her live.

2: So to some killing one innocent to save ten is excusable... So what of killing someone guilty of something else? Does a murderer/criminal of heinous crimes become less of a person?

In the eyes of most yes, being a murderer is the quickest way to become tainted in most peoples eyes, but that that just never goes away. "Once a Criminal Always a Criminal" is how the saying goes. There was an old kid movie i used to watch and part of it had an interesting line of thought behind it. The bad guy lost some of his power when he took a life. The qoute from the movie is "To take a life, you also lose a part of yourself." (something very close to that i'm sure) So yes in a way they become less of a person. Do they deserve to live? Eh, depends on the person and crime for me.

3: When is it justified to kill anyone? When they attack you? When you feel threatened? When you have the support of the law?

When you have without a reasonable doubt that letting them live in any form or another will get you killed, or your family killed. That's hard enough to know for sure, but if they are coming at you with any weapon that can take your life your at least able to send the same amount of force right back at them.

4: What confirms the guilt of a person? If guilt can be confirmed then is it not something open to interpretation based on the circumstance or is it just a view of black and white with high stakes that determines morality?

Guilt is dependant on the person, unless your asking can you determine the guilty in court, in which case sometimes it's obvious and other times obscure. Some cases will never be solved save for those who commited the crimes.

5: If a person has the information to save everyone in the world and refuses to talk does torture to recover that info become legitimized for such a circumstance? If so is it only a value of high stakes or could it be to save one person you care for?

Torture should never be an option, if you want to remain "pure" or "moral" Unforunately, a world of black and white does not work perfectly and I would opt for the shade of grey. The person is being selfish, and indirectly harming everyone in the world. They pretty much ARE a murderer if they sit by and do nothing. (all it takes for evil to win is good men do nothing eh?)

6: What level of payback would be sufficient to balance these intangible scales of right and wrong in the world? Excessive payback, eye for an eye, or efficient ending of the situation?

That is hard to define, for it matters on the person who has been wronged, and how vindictive they are. For me sometimes, I can let things go, sometimes I want to inflict as much pain as was inflicted upon me. Other times I might go over board. (mostly talking emotional pain here xD)

7: Who decides what is fair punishment? The victims? An impartial third party? A societal construct on correct punishment?

It wouldn't do to have the victims judge what is fair punishment because their views are sckewed by bais. An impartial third party is usually a good way to go, but the victim definately should at least get a "say" to what they think should be done though quite often it's more than they deserve. I think third parties haven't experienced the crime first hand and thus want to beleive that any such man/woman can be redeemed. (it's my view that is, I judge less harshly of people I don't know xD)

My answers are in the spoiler tag...
VIEW CONTENT:
1: No but I would consider sacrifice of myself or if they wished to they could sacrifice themselves but I would not take their life no matter the stakes to myself. Nothing but me forces me to act and I cannot be forced to act... I may always choose to do nothing and thus I am never robbed of free will...

2: You cannot be forced to kill... Once again sacrifice is the only option here that allows for a moral outcome... A criminal no matter the crime or offense does not become less of a person but they should be watched so they do not become a danger. The moment they become a real and present threat to your life or others in an observable way that requires swift action to stop you have all right to stop them at any level you deem necessary in the most efficient and self protecting manner you can. This never gives you the right to force suffering upon them if a better option is available to you at the time. The moment they are stopped you need not act further nor are you responsible for their welfare if you feel at risk giving aid to them. As for killing to save others if there is no way to opt for self sacrifice and another will not opt to end their life then you cannot excuse killing another if their intentional actions did not place you in such a state. If killing the man who traps you accidentally will save the rest of the group you have murdered him to your convenience even if you justify that it was not completely convenient it still saved you at cost to him with out his consent.

3: The moment they become a real and present threat to your life or others in an observable way that requires swift action to stop you have all right to stop them at any level you deem necessary in the most efficient and self protecting manner you can. This never gives you the right to force suffering upon them if a better option is available to you at the time. The moment they are stopped you need not act further nor are you responsible for their welfare if you feel at risk giving aid to them. The law does not justify the actions of people it only debates the response to the consequences of such actions. A law that says that "no one should have a gun" is debating that guns give rise to opportunities to commit violence but it is so blanket that it implies that all violence with a gun is unwarranted in any circumstance. Thus if only police have guns under the law they are an exception to this law. But once the gun has been shot and killed someone other laws are bought forth and the absolute authority of these laws is derived from the values of the people that administer them. The value of the person is different to those close to them than what someone distant would think. Thus if intelligent life is valued so highly the closer it is to you the measure of whether to end that life by application of the law must always be a divorced one. Divorcing yourself from pain is a comfort, comfort is a gain to your state of mind, thus killing those under the scrutiny of the law for any reason is an act of convenience that is unconscionable. You should restrain those captured and give them the barest minimum of what is needed to maintain their own life in the event of sentences worthy of a life or more prison sentence. Should that act to kill in any way they should simply be granted swift death if they do not surrender and swift death again should the abuse the trust to do so again!

4: Guilt is confirmed upon evidence, witnesses, confessions and full disclosed intentions... Since life is complex a criminal will seldom believe that they were not justified in their actions or at least in the deserving of what ever gain they get from illicit activities. Confessions and full disclosure of intentions in a truthful manner will usually never be 100% full thus we can never be sure. Thus guilt is always to within a reasonable doubt. Confine the guilty but never execute them... In the real world an innocent man may be pardoned but he cannot be resurrected. Executing even one prisoner that is innocent makes all of those who support such laws alive at the time murderers.

5: Torture against a person who is has the info to save the world is justified under the pretense that they by their continued and willful silence will kill everyone else. Torture against one person to save another person is justified in the sense that the same scenario plays out but the stakes are different. Suffice it to say however that torture in either of these situations is not moral unless it is truly the only option and it is done only to the intent to get the info without the actual intention to do permanent harm if you cannot confirm they have the info you need. If they admit to having the info by gloating but do not reveal it then it is moral to torture to get the info doing no permanent damage but blustering and threatening to try and get it. Still the line to where you risk their lives for the info is so precariously thin that should the damage become severe enough and lasting or they must be revived you most likely have gone too far.

6: If immediate action needed then simple death or immobilization to end the threat. If they are alive confinement until guilt or innocence confirmed. If guilty continued confinement with no privileges inherent to societies excesses but neither should they be stripped of humanity or the chance to learn to be better unless they prove unwilling to do such peacefully. Allow them to provide for themselves and learn to interact with others in a more peaceful way. Still do not lighten the responsibility of the prisoner to respect others lives. If they threaten kill or contain them as efficiently as possible and then decide the level of the infraction and continue the confinement.

7: Punishment is based on the understanding of objects and people. Objects are bartered on value hence that value is transferable. Objects thus can be taken from the criminal to replace a set material value of the victim. People as having no value cannot be exchanged nor can quality become an issue other than the excesses that such objects or influences can a bring to a persons experience. Thus no matter the extent a punishing response to a crime should be the same for victims and criminals with no exceptions or stipulations to be allowed. A man who murders twenty if properly restrained should be treated the same as the man who murdered one. Guilt or innocence should be determined for both no matter the length of inquiry as lives value cannot be measured. The living who handle these affairs do not have to do more than determine the innocence or guilt of the accused. They do so out of sacrifice of their time to hold an expected standard of decency commensurate with the indeterminate nature of the value of life.
So yeah go ahead and answer some of these questions for yourself... Maybe add some to the list... They get you thinking on what you really believe in these situations!
Edit: I bolded my responces in the Qoute.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Jack the Reaper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Jul 06, 2009 7:28 am

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Jack the Reaper »

A G Thing, as a doctoral student in the phliosophy of ethics, AND as a qualified jewish rabbi (yes, I know it's surprising), I can only tell you that in order to refer seriously to all those questions, you'll have to do maybe 5 doctor works! And that's just the philosophy - if you want to include the religious outlooks, you'll have to devote an equal amount of time and efforts.

There is simply so much literature about those topics, with so many different theories and viewes, that there's absolutely no chance to give any proper answer in this forum. Better to focus on specific questions, one by one, than try to sum so much philosophy and religion with some short remarks. And remember we have to stay related to Ravenloft topics, and not get too much astray.

If you want another movie which raises strong moral questions, it's "Unthinkable", which deals with one of the cases yoy mentioned, of torturing a terrorist in order to make him reveal the locations of 3 ticking nuke-bombs he hid in 3 american cities. How far will you go? His wife? His children?...
The Reaper's riddle:

"Im ata yachol likro et ze, ata yode'a et ha'emet."

If you can read it, you know the truth.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Zilfer »

^^i will have to check that movie out myself. :D
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
Sorti
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 255
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2005 9:56 am
Location: Ethereal Border

Re: The Saw in Ravenloft

Post by Sorti »

Uh, this is cool! let's enter the fray :)
A G Thing wrote:Still there are some questions I wonder how people would answer...

1: Would you kill an innocent to save yourself if it was the only way to guarantee that one of you lives? Would you let them kill you? What if both of you are innocent and it is fate that forces the decision?
In general I would kill the innocent. The only exception would be if I walue his life more than mine, like the case in which the innocent is one of my children or I am terminally ill; but that doesn't apply to most cases.
A G Thing wrote:2: So to some killing one innocent to save ten is excusable... So what of killing someone guilty of something else? Does a murderer/criminal of heinous crimes become less of a person?
Nobody becomes "less of a person" in any case. Still, we as a society agree on which personal freedoms individuals are granted, and also agree that certain actions can give the society the right to strip you of some of them, for instance by imprisonment. I am strongly against death penalty; torture as a punishment shouldn't even be considered IMHO.
A G Thing wrote:3: When is it justified to kill anyone? When they attack you? When you feel threatened? When you have the support of the law?
When they are trying to kill someone, and only while they're doing so; it's morally justified to kill a person threatening my life with a knife, but if he sees I have a gun and runs away it's not moral to shoot him in the back while he's escaping.
A G Thing wrote:4: What confirms the guilt of a person? If guilt can be confirmed then is it not something open to interpretation based on the circumstance or is it just a view of black and white with high stakes that determines morality?
The guilt must be confirmed by a trained and impartial tribunal deciding only on the base of facts, and up to a certain level of uncertainty, since obviously complete certainty cannot be achieved. The fact that guilty cannot be established at 100% is one reason against death penalty.
A G Thing wrote:5: If a person has the information to save everyone in the world and refuses to talk does torture to recover that info become legitimized for such a circumstance? If so is it only a value of high stakes or could it be to save one person you care for?
Torture is certainly legitimized in that circumstance; a person who would sacrifice 7 billion lives instead of his morality does not have a lot of morality to start with (IMHO, of course). Of course real scenarios will be less black-and-white, since you cannot know with certainty that the person actually has the information and the information will actually save the lives; but any and all actions you take during the day must be decided by the information you have, since we don't possess omniscience.
A G Thing wrote:6: What level of payback would be sufficient to balance these intangible scales of right and wrong in the world? Excessive payback, eye for an eye, or efficient ending of the situation?
There are no "intangible scales" in the world, so the question is vacuous. There are only societies trying to have their components behave in a certain way. The smallest amount of force and punishment that will accomplish that is the right level of payback.
A G Thing wrote:7: Who decides what is fair punishment? The victims? An impartial third party? A societal construct on correct punishment?
As above, a trained and impartial tribunal, having the respect and well being of all human beings as its first aim.
Jack the Reaper wrote:in order to refer seriously to all those questions, you'll have to do maybe 5 doctor works! And that's just the philosophy - if you want to include the religious outlooks, you'll have to devote an equal amount of time and efforts.
Come on Jack, don't be such a killjoy :) this is FUN! Look at all the fun we're having! :D (cit.)
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
Post Reply