Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Ah, right. Explained that way, then yes - my understanding of Gothic roleplaying is fundamentally different from yours.

I'm not going to elaborate (there is already a 2007 thread where I debated this issue - I think it might have been the usual "do we kill werewolf cubs?" thread) other than to say I consider the Gothic genre quite compatible with modern roleplaying using a moral-relativist outlook.

The same way I consider medieval themes and settings to be quite compatible with modern roleplaying using a gender-equality viewpoint. Even if, in both cases, the contemporary treatment might have been quite different.


Again, usual "YMMV" disclaimer applies. This sort of discussion usually crops up whenever there's a game mechanic about good or evil, and it usually boils down a subjective comparison of each player's different tastes and outlooks for what works in their games.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

YMMV, indeed! :azalin:

I have no idea what you mean by 'modern roleplaying' , though. Is there some sort of ancient or medieval RPG I should know about? You know that medieval monks didn't really write and design Chronica Feudalis, yes? ;)
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

HuManBing wrote:The same way I consider medieval themes and settings to be quite compatible with modern roleplaying using a gender-equality viewpoint. Even if, in both cases, the contemporary treatment might have been quite different.
For use of my Kaidan setting for the general public, I allow the breaking of gender roles (women as samurai, etc.), the allowance of non-human races: kappa, hengeyokai, tengu, to better accomodate a wider market of PF players. However, when players do not choose to fill such social breaking positions, as a personal preference I maintain the historic mind set. Women are subserviant to men. Non-humans are 'outsiders' to normal human society. Social castes are not pliable - it does not normally allow the movement from one caste to another. If you are not born a samurai, you will never be a samurai.

The only social mobility I generally allow in my Kaidan games, is acquisition of karma, and possible movement to a different social caste after death and reincarnation.

While this doesn't fit your 'modern roleplaying viewpoint', I think for flavor reasons maintaining historic tropes make a better play experience.
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

ewancummins wrote:
HuManBing wrote:
For the record, I agree with you - I don't think Good/Evil really translates well in an RPG, because they tend to view them as objectively provable qualities and I generally view them as highly dependent on your subjective outlook. When I first bought into Third Edition, I tried to sidestep moral alignment as much as possible, but so many spells, magic items, and powers depend on them for their definition. My ruleset change was motivated in part by this: GURPS foregoes alignment and instead focuses on behavioral traits of each person.
I didn't explain well, it seems. :|
You don't agree with me, you only think you do.


Ravenloft is a Gothic, and so it's basically about GOOD vs EVIL. That doesn't mean there are no shades of gray, but that Good and Evil are more than mere subjective viewpoints or relative judgments, they are fundamental parts of the universe. They are part of the order of being (Not that moral order in the real world is merely a subjective matter- it isn't. That's another issue, though). In Ravenloft, Good and Evil are always at work, always affecting the course of events. Even human bodies can be altered by moral forces. That's not a matter of personal judgement.

YMMV, but I think some degree of objective & game mechanical morality is vitally necessary for Ravenloft to work. Even more than most published D&D settings, an alignment system makes sense for Ravenloft. I'm just not sure it needs the added complexity of the Law and Chaos axis.

Yes, but what is good and evil to 10 individuals will be different between those individuals. I mean a criminal almost never thinks they are Evil. Some of the best villians think they are doing the right thing and to them they are 'good and just'.

The system is definitely needed to help ravenloft function but, it's not purely black and white. Grey exists and when you do a grey thing is where it gets all muddied whether it was a evil act or not.
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

Zilfer wrote: Yes, but what is good and evil to 10 individuals will be different between those individuals. I mean a criminal almost never thinks they are Evil. Some of the best villians think they are doing the right thing and to them they are 'good and just'.

The system is definitely needed to help ravenloft function but, it's not purely black and white. Grey exists and when you do a grey thing is where it gets all muddied whether it was a evil act or not.
I see where you are having trouble with this idea. It's not about what the individual thinks is good or evil, it's about what IS good or evil. That's why subjective morality fails so hard in Ravenloft. Most of the Darklords would not be cursed if they were allowed to be their own judges. It doesn't matter what you self-serving justifications you may think up for your actions- if you are doing evil, you are doing evil. As you point out, many of the best villains feel justified-- but they are still villains. Good and evil are not mere matters of opinion in canonical Ravenloft. *


You are 100% correct that there are shades of gray. That's why we have neutral alignments. Those are for characters that are neither strongly good nor strongly evil. Good vs Evil does not have to exclude things like ambiguity, shades of gray, lesser of two evils, etc.

Further, not every questionable or morally dubious act requires a powers check.

Some powers checks are not prompted by evil acts, per se, so much as transgression of certain limits (like raising the dead).

Most powers checks are clearly made for evil actions. Evil actions can lead to damnation as a creature of Ravenloft or a Darklord.



*I don't believe that, at the most fundamental level, they are such in the real world either. That doesn't mean that I claim absolute moral clarity, of course! We are all flawed and fallible human beings.


I think moral relativists often have trouble with games that include objective morality because they have trouble understanding how that works in the real world. This is easily addressed. 1. It's not the real world, it's a game. Don't overthink it. 2.The DM is a little god. He has the final authority on the objective morality/alignment of actions in his campaign. Alignment and powers checks are rules. This is no different than the DM interpreting any other part of the game. Rule Zero always applies. Problems neatly solved, thank you very much.

:)



The usual disclaimer:YMMV, of course. I find that my approach works best for Ravenloft. If you prefer to do things very differently, don't let my ideas stop you.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Five
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 886
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2011 9:59 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Five »

ewancummins: Did you actually mean to paint moral relativists as both delusional and non-creative? Because that's how it read to me, but "delusional" and "non-creative" were not the words that immediately came to my mind.
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."

- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Note: There is an important disclaimer at the bottom of this post, reiterating that I do not mean this as a criticism of ewancummins - especially given his contributions to FoS discussions and his openness to other players' input.


ewancummins wrote:I see where you are having trouble with this idea. It's not about what the individual thinks is good or evil, it's about what IS good or evil. That's why subjective morality fails so hard in Ravenloft.

...

*I don't believe that, at the most fundamental level, they are such in the real world either. That doesn't mean that I claim absolute moral clarity, of course! We are all flawed and fallible human beings.
This explains a lot. When you're speaking from a position where you believe there is an objectively definable Good and objectively definable Evil, then it understandably strikes you as being contrived and artificial to bring moral relativism into a game. After all, you are comfortable with a moral-objectivist viewpoint, and so it's awkward and challenging to depart from that.

Conversely, I am a moral relativist in real life, and I've been one for as long as I can remember. This colors my view of good and evil heavily. For me, the most natural way of role playing is to view the imagined world much as I view this one. So from my standpoint, bringing in objective definitions of Good and Evil feels highly artificial and contrived - in direct contrast to your experience.

The effect that our differences of opinion have on our role playing outlooks can be profound. Consider your next statement:
I think moral relativists often have trouble with games that include objective morality because they have trouble understanding how that works in the real world. This is easily addressed. 1. It's not the real world, it's a game. Don't overthink it. 2.The DM is a little god. He has the final authority on the objective morality/alignment of actions in his campaign. Alignment and powers checks are rules. This is no different than the DM interpreting any other part of the game. Rule Zero always applies. Problems neatly solved, thank you very much.
This is very telling. For you, it's understandably simpler and easier to enforce an objective-morality ruleset in a game, because you actually see the realworld in such terms and so it's very convenient for you to project that into a thought exercise (which is what most RPGs are, to some extent). On the other hand, for players who view real-life morality as subjective, this is anything but simple. It's suddenly an artificial constraint that some designer with a different worldview threw into the game, and effectively tied spells, magic items, psionic powers, and game effects to.

This results in vigorous debate over specific detailed situations, such as this whether Paladins can detect undead and under what circumstances, and whether it's morally reprehensible to kill werewolf young. These debates go on for pages and pages and pages of forum-text; ample evidence, I think, against the supposition that objective alignment is universally easier or simple. Sure, you might simplify early issues of "I want to kill these kobolds, would my deity allow me to do this with a clean conscience?" but depending on the plot arcs, you're also liable to run into player disagreements of morality.

These can't be handwaved away by the GM without an inherent judgment of "I'm sorry, Player A, but I'm ruling that your viewpoint of good and evil is fundamentally wrong".

A less generous way of interpreting this is: "the game runs this way, regardless of your world view, and for the purposes of this game you must abandon your world view and subscribe to somebody else's". In some cases, a player might welcome this challenge, but that's really not a safe assumption to make universally. Many players might be uncomfortable, offended, or simply unable to play-act such a fundamental change in attitude, and there's no reasonable expectation that they do so.

For a more stark example, consider this: "Here is a game setting where women are under-employed, under-represented, and seriously handicapped by a lack of social autonomy or legal agency. If you wish to play this game as a female character, you will not be allowed to enjoy equal social, legal, and financial rights as a male character." Such a game setting might actually have been a realworld situation many times throughout history - in some countries it might even be the current situation. The adjustment a first world citizen of a democratic country would have to make to play this game might be fairly jarring, because it's so different from one's standard experience. Could it be worthwhile and rewarding? Sure, depending on the player's tastes. But can you generalize that for all gamers? Very likely no. There are very likely plenty of gamers, male and female, who would look at that and say "If you can't compromise on that campaign requirement, I'm not going to enjoy it and I'm out."

For you, the game runs more smoothly with objective morality, but that's a function of familiarity rather than universal merit. It doesn't follow necessarily from there that they must be therefore universally simpler and easier for everybody else.

The quote to Rule Zero (often paraphrased as "The GM has the prerogative to override the rules, when they get in the way of fun") overlooks those players and GMs who might actively enjoy a moral-relativist game experience. Perhaps you don't truly believe that these moral-relativists actually exist as people. They do: I'm one of them; I play GURPS with five of them. And a small part of my preference for GURPS over DnD is the game system doesn't make assumptions about objective morality. Instead, it looks specifically at how the character behaves, what they believe, what constrains their actions and why.

It takes all types, and I respect and understand that your gaming style is fully valid and fun for you and your group - and a significant demographic of players besides. But I do want to point out that the solution is not as universally workable as your suggestion indicates.

Moral objectivism is fine, if that's what your group wants. It also seems to be working for a majority of DnD players - and that's fine too. But when a moral relativist looks at the game and ponders some morality changes for their gaming experience, it's a non-starter to suggest they incorporate moral objectivism as a first step. They're already defining their desired experience as one that is not moral-objectivist.

A largely-unrelated anecdote follows, spoilered to mark it as such.
VIEW CONTENT:
It's weird - just as a purely personal coincidence, the last time I read "Problem solved, thank you and good night" at the end of a post was from a South African poster on a video game forum. The topic? How to have a successful marriage. His post had effective read "My wife and I strongly observe traditional gender roles, and I know I have to be a man, and she knows she has to be a woman. We're happy and we'll never get divorced. Problem solved, thank you and good night." At heart, this boils down to: "Here's what worked for me, it's worked very well for me, and I cannot conceive of any reason why it would not work for you or anybody else." Nobody begrudges one instance of happy success, but when that instance is held up as a cure-all across all circumstances, that's when the troubles arise.
Very important disclaimer: I'd also like to point out that ewancummins has reliably and routinely disclaimed his posts with the "YMMV" tag (and moreover, has meant it) which is a very rare courtesy across the internet in general these days. I hope ewancummins and other readers take this response not as criticism against him - but as a contribution to further a discussion that would have been much more difficult without his intellectual generosity, tolerance, and humility.


I echo ewancummins with a YMMV of my own, and likewise hope to emulate his intellectual openness.
Five
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 886
Joined: Fri Nov 11, 2011 9:59 am

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Five »

Just to clarify my position: I'm not criticising ewancummins, just a paragraph that he wrote. And that's not me trying to be funny. I honestly do see a difference between the two. It was a legit question that, truth be told, wasn't even born out of personal insult. Bit of an irk (obviously, given that I posted), but no big deal. The rest I'm content with right now to sit back and read. Interesting topic and points being made...
"A very piteous thing it was to see such a quantity of dead bodies, and such an outpouring of blood - that is, if they had not been enemies of the Christian faith."

- Jean Pierre Sarrasin, "The Memoirs of the Lord of Joinville"
User avatar
Zilfer
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 4231
Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
Gender: Male
Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Zilfer »

I agree with Humanbing in this case, that you can do that. I also agree with Ewan that the DM is God in the game. Final say don't like it I'm sorry but get over it and move on. However that being said, there will be times you don't see eye to eye with a DM and that's usually over Moralities of Characters.

"I'm just playing my character's alignment" is commonly echoed for an excuse through many DM tables. Why? Because the DM and the Player have two different ideas of what an alignemnt actually is/how it acts. Same with good and evil.

I like that Ravenloft has a table set forth of what is evil and what isn't evil, but there are different levels to that. Grave robbing for example from Evil has no check i believe? In some cultures that's taboo to an upmost degree. You don't kill someone who was trying to kill you and then loot their bodies. xD (that's how the criminal's family sues you and wins xD)

I just think the more you think about it the less it makes sense, so generally I try to be fluid on those things.

and of course YMMV as it does from tabletop to tabletop, and from DM to DM. Not trying to change anyone's opinions here, just giving my own and why. :D
There's always something to lose.

Fraternity of Shadows Discord
https://discord.gg/AM6Kp95ekf
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

I'm working on layout for Kaidan's Way of the Samurai, and we've included a paladin archetype called the Yamabushi, who is very much a paladin with some ranger, nature kami and anti-undead influences. The Yamabushi gets Detect Undead, instead of detect good, and loses lay on hands gaining a special smite verus undead beings. The yamabushi tends to be more lightly armored with special fighting skills with both katana and naginata. So Kaidan's paladin bypasses the whole Detect Evil issue of this thread. In Kaidan, yamabushi are most commonly human or tengu, with a special variation of tengu-yamabushi from In the Company of Tengu supplement, with avian light step maneuvers.

Being that Kaidan is an evil cursed realm, the paladins don't have high esteem in Kaidan. Yamabushi are hermetic, ascetic monks and their practices are considered heresy by the state, so yamabushi spend most of their time in high mountain monasteries, hidden in the wilderness away from civilization. Sometimes they come down from the mountains to spread their faith among the poor farming communities near the forest, but do so carefully, with an ever-watchful eye on the authorities who don't take kindly to their mission. Though some yamabushi influence some of the more powerful samurai houses.

One of the pregens for Frozen Wind free adventure (now available as a softcover print book for $9.99 at DrivethruRPG) is a yamabushi paladin.
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

ewancummins wrote:The 'fantasy paladin' as a holy warrior predates D&D. What else is the Red Cross Knight in the Faerie Queene, or the medieval portrayal of Saint George as the dragonslayer?
St. George is actually portrayed more closely to the true paladins of history than anything else. In fact he's not all that different from other military saints, just more popular. Even the tale of his slaying the dragon is of Eastern origin and is based on much older stories dating back to ancient Egypt and Sumeria of other heroes doing much the same. The dragon he slew is more in the vein of Satan as "the great dragon" described in Revelations.

I've never read the Faerie Queene, but it does sound like the first real fantasy paladin. Okay, so Gygax was just a bridge between a faerie (not fairy) tale and pop culture in the idea of the paladin.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by Mortavius »

Funny how topics change...this has gone from a discussion about whether Paladins can detect undead (and the ramifications of only being able to Detect Chaos) to a debate about the moralities of the alignment system in D&D and the historical real-world references about Paladins.
MichaelTumey
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2011 3:23 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by MichaelTumey »

Mortavius wrote:Funny how topics change...this has gone from a discussion about whether Paladins can detect undead (and the ramifications of only being able to Detect Chaos) to a debate about the moralities of the alignment system in D&D and the historical real-world references about Paladins.
But isn't that where paladin discussions always go? No matter where a paladin discussion begins, it almost always ends up as a discussion on alignments. Many people have issues with alignment in game (I don't), and the paladin being a strict alignment based player class is problematic for many.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by ewancummins »

Five, no I didn't mean to imply anything about anyone being 'delusional ' or 'uncreative.' You took it the wrong way, but that's my failure as a writer. I wasn't as clear as I hoped to be, it seems. I simply meant that Ravenloft, being a gothic fantasy, is basically about Good vs Evil. The rules and the setting both seem to me to work best with Good and Evil as real forces, not just relative moral judgements made by individuals. YMMV. It evidently does. I don't think that makes you uncreative. I don't think you are having badwrongfun.

HumanBing may be surprised to learn that I also enjoy RPGs with no mechanics for morality/alignment, objective or otherwise. :diamabel: Many games I like use no alignment rules at all.
Cyberpunk 2020 doesn't need alignment. Neither does Call of Cthulhu. Neither do Boot Hill and Gamma World.


High Priest Mikhal wrote:
ewancummins wrote:The 'fantasy paladin' as a holy warrior predates D&D. What else is the Red Cross Knight in the Faerie Queene, or the medieval portrayal of Saint George as the dragonslayer?
St. George is actually portrayed more closely to the true paladins of history than anything else. In fact he's not all that different from other military saints, just more popular. Even the tale of his slaying the dragon is of Eastern origin and is based on much older stories dating back to ancient Egypt and Sumeria of other heroes doing much the same. The dragon he slew is more in the vein of Satan as "the great dragon" described in Revelations.

I've never read the Faerie Queene, but it does sound like the first real fantasy paladin. Okay, so Gygax was just a bridge between a faerie (not fairy) tale and pop culture in the idea of the paladin.
Speaking of the East, I've been to Mar Garguis in Mosul.
Saint George rules!

I wouldn't be totally surprised if there were a bit of Marduk and Tiamat in the tale, although I'm not aware of any scholarship showing a real link.

D&D took the paladin into video games, to be sure.


D&D is a beast that eats and regurgitates mythology, history, pulp fiction, fairy tales, sci fi, kung fu movies, etc. I mean that in a good way! The game is a crazy, eclectic mix, and has been from the days when Gygax and Arneson were first designing it.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Re: Can Paladins Detect Undead?

Post by HuManBing »

Mortavius wrote:Funny how topics change...this has gone from a discussion about whether Paladins can detect undead (and the ramifications of only being able to Detect Chaos) to a debate about the moralities of the alignment system in D&D and the historical real-world references about Paladins.
This is actually quite typical thread-drift. In most threads that deal with issues of morality (specifically Good vs. Evil), you are almost assuredly going to get a significant debate as to how to interpret the fine points of a given scenario.

And most people have enough variance in their sliding scale of Good vs. Evil that it results in quite a number of different viewpoints. As I mentioned in my post above, the thread about "can you kill werewolf cubs?" generated a very lively debate.
Post Reply