An interesting event has occured in my game so here goes. We started our game in Barovia, its my first ravenloft campaign and one of the PCs created a vampire which i allowed but she is playing much more chaotic evil than i expected. I ran the premade adventure, child of the house that i got here as our second mini adventure with a bit of renaming characters and changed the setting and a few details to fit in Barovia rather than darkon. Anyways she coerced the mother who i named Fiona, into killing the innkeeper in exchange for rescuing her children, she accepted but had really no intention of actually doing it. They went and completed the adventure rescuing the children and when the deed had not been done, Dawn into the house and turned Fiona into a vampire. Which she did get corruption points for. When the party found out they didnt know by whom, they went to the local cult of the morninglord and them and several of their hunters went to put Fiona to rest but Dawn had her moved so she may rise without being slaughtered in her sleep. They went out hunting for the vampire and decided not to kill her once they found her because she had already risen and did not seem very evil. More alone, lost and scared. Fiona decided to listen to Dawn because she was the only one who had answers and was protecting her from one of our more lawful members from killing her. They had forgotten about the hunters of the morninglord who had gone with them and they ended up catching up with them later in the woods while they were leaving town about six hunters and some dogs. The hunters were not leaving without putting Fiona to rest as if it were some religious conviction, so the party decided to slaughter the entire group so that Fiona can live and they cannot go and tell anyone else of their deeds. Shortly after the massacre the bard decided that they were right and Fiona needed to die so he tried to convince the party of it and they would not go along with it so he tried to kill her anyways when the party beat him into submission (and wow that was hard to avoid pvp combat). The party opted to keep Fiona around a little while longer until Dawn can teach her not to have a bloodbath whenever she is hungry and control herself, and the lawful stupid bard opted to leave the party and reroll their characters.
Anyways those are the events that took place. I have 2 of my players who think that this merits the dark powers noticing so much so they even asked me if i would so i was asking you guys at what point in this should i have a powers check and should it be done on an individual basis or collectively for the party.
On a side note I am using jesters guide for 4e ravenloft as a sort of backbone for rules on corruption and such i am kind of worried that it might progress too quickly seeing as how easy corruption is to gain, i looked back on 3e and they didnt even use points just stages of corruption based on a percentile dice rather than a d20 usually with a chance as low as 1% and as high as 10% but you immediately go to the next stage until you can redeem yourself if you can. I was considering using these lower points but ive only played a few sessions with jesters version actually in play. The system is still compatible but would have to use paths appropriate for 4e
Need help with an event in my campaign.
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Need help with an event in my campaign.
I would definitely call for 3 powers checks here. 1 for Dawn's bargain with Fiona. Convincing an innocent to agree to become a murderer. A Sin of Violence and Betrayal. Would be an atrocity if Fiona actually committed the murder. Then 1 for Dawn turning Fiona into a vampire. An Atrocity of Violence and Black Magic. Then 1 for the whole party for killing the hunters of the Morninglord. An Atrocity of Violence and possibly Blasphemy (definitely Blasphemy if any of the part are Morninglord worshippers).
But putting that aside, the greater problem seems to be that you and your players seem to want different things from this campaign (and also your players don't seem to agree among themselves either.) You're going to have to decide if a loose cannon vampire really belongs in your party, and you may have to sit down with the players and discuss whether they want to be the good guys or the bad guys. If this is the kind of character Dawn is, and the other PCs don't go along with it, there will be PvP issues. If they do go along with it, this won't be the last set of Powers Checks you'll have to make.
I haven't played with Jester's rules myself, but they seem pretty solid. They are only progress too quickly if your party goes around slaying vampire hunters and protecting and creating vampires.
But putting that aside, the greater problem seems to be that you and your players seem to want different things from this campaign (and also your players don't seem to agree among themselves either.) You're going to have to decide if a loose cannon vampire really belongs in your party, and you may have to sit down with the players and discuss whether they want to be the good guys or the bad guys. If this is the kind of character Dawn is, and the other PCs don't go along with it, there will be PvP issues. If they do go along with it, this won't be the last set of Powers Checks you'll have to make.
I haven't played with Jester's rules myself, but they seem pretty solid. They are only progress too quickly if your party goes around slaying vampire hunters and protecting and creating vampires.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Need help with an event in my campaign.
The problem of PvP almost came up in our session yesterday when a DM changed someone's alignment to CE when he gave me a back that sucks you in and takes all your stuff. He knew it did that, (i did out of character but in character i didn't so i opened it) Well we have 2 paladin's in the room one decided to detect evil down the way and... well now the paladin's want to arrest or kill him. So I convince them to arrest him and figure it out after we are out of the dungeon. A cleric stands in their way with his god supposed to help the defenseless. So I had to hold person the Cleric in order for them to arrest the evil mage and cleric mentioned he'd just try and break him free so we tied him up. XD
It can be hard to avoid a PvP based on what character's think sometimes. xD
In Ravenloft such choices can quickly become muddled up because real life isn't black and white while a gaming system can definately try to be.
The slaughter of the Morninglord could definately be a powers check, and turning, and convincing a woman to murder someone...
There's also a possible one for beating the bard into submission, act of violence against him, or it could be the opposite way though since his target's a vampire i think that % is a 0% for Evil things. Unless you concider the vampire girl not a problem.
Question... how does dawn get around? o.O'
It can be hard to avoid a PvP based on what character's think sometimes. xD
In Ravenloft such choices can quickly become muddled up because real life isn't black and white while a gaming system can definately try to be.
The slaughter of the Morninglord could definately be a powers check, and turning, and convincing a woman to murder someone...
There's also a possible one for beating the bard into submission, act of violence against him, or it could be the opposite way though since his target's a vampire i think that % is a 0% for Evil things. Unless you concider the vampire girl not a problem.
Question... how does dawn get around? o.O'
Re: Need help with an event in my campaign.
Usually wearing a big heavy cloak in the daytime. Which is what her class says she can do, honestly i think its stupid to be able to do that. Thanks for the input on that Gonzoron, i think definitely might give some points out for the slaughter of the hunters and for Dawn because of what she did in particular. It is hard having this whole grey area for points since not much is black and white. The actual vampire girl who they were protecting right now, she has only taken 1 life so far and it was in self defense. She is scared and kind of helpless not actually evil despite being a vampire.
I calculated with jesters thing, probably for killing the hunters would be a violation, being a bit nice because of the circumstances it went down, so 1d4 for failing the check, +3d4 for its severity and +3d4 for 6 victims put them at +6d4 corruption roll. It seems like for that one event being unlucky can bring you from 0-24 in 1 shot, and would can actually send dawn over the edge into the final stage. So would this rate of progression for the party's actions be good for the campaign? it seems to be happening awful fast. The roll i actually did for Dawn puts her at 20 points for what she has done so far including slaughter of the hunters. In the 3e method of doing it, murder is a 3% chance and im not sure if this stacks on itsellf for multiple counts. Murdering 6 people would i increase chance to 18%? But yeah input on the systems in practice or theory would be nice. I am leaning towards using the one in the 4e conversion guide with the points instead.
The first option is to go with Jesters idea for it which seems to be working pretty well so far but i dont know how jumping up 2 or 3 stages in 1 incident but could also do it 3e style and roll percentile where on a failure they are automatically bumped up to next corruption level instead of keeping track of points. Lower chance of success but penalties are incurred immediately rather than having to accumulate points. So instead of having a 25% chance of being noticed it would be more between 1-10% depending on the severity of the crime. 10% being the most atrocious without committing an act of ultimate darkness. But you jump straight to the next stage if you fail the percentile roll. Its in ravenloft campaign setting 3.5 or ravenloft players handbook 3.5. Both are the same book anyways.
I calculated with jesters thing, probably for killing the hunters would be a violation, being a bit nice because of the circumstances it went down, so 1d4 for failing the check, +3d4 for its severity and +3d4 for 6 victims put them at +6d4 corruption roll. It seems like for that one event being unlucky can bring you from 0-24 in 1 shot, and would can actually send dawn over the edge into the final stage. So would this rate of progression for the party's actions be good for the campaign? it seems to be happening awful fast. The roll i actually did for Dawn puts her at 20 points for what she has done so far including slaughter of the hunters. In the 3e method of doing it, murder is a 3% chance and im not sure if this stacks on itsellf for multiple counts. Murdering 6 people would i increase chance to 18%? But yeah input on the systems in practice or theory would be nice. I am leaning towards using the one in the 4e conversion guide with the points instead.
The first option is to go with Jesters idea for it which seems to be working pretty well so far but i dont know how jumping up 2 or 3 stages in 1 incident but could also do it 3e style and roll percentile where on a failure they are automatically bumped up to next corruption level instead of keeping track of points. Lower chance of success but penalties are incurred immediately rather than having to accumulate points. So instead of having a 25% chance of being noticed it would be more between 1-10% depending on the severity of the crime. 10% being the most atrocious without committing an act of ultimate darkness. But you jump straight to the next stage if you fail the percentile roll. Its in ravenloft campaign setting 3.5 or ravenloft players handbook 3.5. Both are the same book anyways.
- Zilfer
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4231
- Joined: Wed Apr 20, 2011 8:14 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: WA (Land of lots of trees)
- Contact:
Re: Need help with an event in my campaign.
Just a big heavy cloak? o.O' I could see if you said the mist kept out most of the sunlight on cloudy days and she had a cloak on never really showing too much skin but i think i'd still slap on some negatives during her day rolls. Anyways, yeah definately hand something out, that whole situation was pretty evilish.

